13 ms·
How I read books: a guide on how to learn
- cgriswald 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Read_a_Book https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Read_a_Book There are plenty of useful things to learn from others to expand and supplement your approach to reading, but for a total understanding of having a relationship with a book/author, Adler can’t be beat.
- rimliu 6y agoI've made a mistake and bought this one. Did not finish. Very boring and now useful information.
- cryoshon 6y agoi'm a huge proponent of this book. it's not just about "reading books" so much as how you should approach any piece of prose information. it's life-changing.
- loughnane 6y agoI second this. Huge productivity boost in my reading.
- Denzhadanov 6y agoThank you for the recommendation! Will add that to the list
- lmilcin 6y agoMy process: - If I find the book is very daunting but also very valuable, I read it multiple times from start till end. First time without stopping for reading references, then another pass for researching topics, references, etc. and then finally once more to read everything again with the newly acquired knowledge to find some things that I may have missed, things that I might have understood incorrectly and to improve retention. - I always keep notebook close by to note anything that comes to my mind. Some things are triggered by reading the book and some things are completely unrelated. I write them down so that they don't distract me from reading. - I have special place in my office where I put a book so that it is visible to me whatever I do. It serves as a constant reminder to get it finished. - When I was young I learned to speed read. When I grew up little more I unlearned. It impairs comprehension.
- purplecats 6y ago> I have special place in my office where I put a book so that it is visible to me whatever I do. It serves as a constant reminder to get it finished. Tangential but I do this with everything. I like very high levels of organization (blame my aspergers) and thus I found that my motivation to hide unnecessary things from view is pretty high. High enough that I place things in view as a reminder to get them done. An extra laptop on my desk -> I need to transfer the remaining files into my new laptop so that I can finally remove it from view. Book on my desk? Needs to be finished. Sticky note on my island? need to order groceries before I can remove it. I'd turned minimalism into a lifestyle/todo list. Same with the digital world.
- Denzhadanov 6y agoGreat point. James Clear was talking about organizing an environment around us that would encourage certain behaviours.
- brg 6y agoOne piece of advice I’ve found valuable is to write in books. On successive reference it has surprised me what I had thought first time through, and it doesn’t take me out of the book to make the note. It did take a while to get over the feeling of sacrilege of the book, but it has been useful.
- cgriswald 6y agoLet me first second (heh) your point about writing in books. In addition to it being a useful reference, it also aids me in the following two ways: First, I am far more likely to remember what I have written than what I read. So it's a great device for helping to cement the material in your mind. Second, it helps overcome a sort of inertia I have where if I'm not reading a book, there's a hurdle to picking it back up. If there's a note in the book sort of summarizing where I'm at, it not only removes that hurdle, but I have the subjective feeling that I'm back into it with a running start, rather than having to turn back a few pages to get back up to speed. > It did take a while to get over the feeling of sacrilege of the book, but it has been useful. I believe there's a section in Adler about this, and reading that passage was enough for me. I won't quote or paraphrase, because I'm not sure I'll represent their statements correctly, but I think that's the source of where I'm at with this now. And the change in my perspective was very rapid. My new perspective on this wasn't to see books as less sacred, but to understand that in order to honor that sacredness, I had to consume this book in a deeper, more meaningful way, and form a real relationship with the book in a way that's probably impossible without writing in the book. Not to be too cheesy, but there was also a bit of an "Aha!" moment for me watching Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. With regard to spoilers, the "half-blood prince" (HBP) had a real relationship with that book. It's positively scribbled in, and it made the book better presumably for HBP, but also for Potter who ends up possessing the book.
- randomNumber7 6y agoMy process: - Read the book from start till end - From time to time, I lay the book aside and think about what I just read People learn differently and I personally don't need notes nor fancy color maps like the author. Having an external brain like the author has the downside that you can't set things in context (same as wikipedia). For me the key to learning is this "aha" moment. Once I understand something I remember it for a very long time.
- gauchojs 6y agoI'm probably missing number 2. Its only half a joke - I really don't reflect on stuff I read very frequently.
- randomNumber7 6y agoI think it depends on the text. When I read something complicated I have to reflect a lot. On the other hand it's pointless to reflect on something you already know, understand or simply agree with...
- allie1 6y agoI've taken quite a few things from Ryan Holiday's approach to reading: https://ryanholiday.net/the-notecard-system-the-key-for-remembering-organizing-and-using-everything-you-read/ https://ryanholiday.net/the-notecard-system-the-key-for-reme... https://ryanholiday.net/read-to-lead-how-to-digest-books-above-your-level/ https://ryanholiday.net/read-to-lead-how-to-digest-books-abo... I also go through all notes on a subject [from other books I've read] when reading a new book to see how my new view of the whole subject might change given the new information.
- 0x008 6y agoI tend to only write stuff down I learned from reading the book, then later turn these notes into flash cards. I feel the stuff that is obvious to me shouldn’t be written down, even if my notes then lack a certain completeness or are incomprehensible for anyone but me. I rather have notes of bits and pieces and tie them to the already existing neurological connections I have about the subject instead of trying to reorder everything in a coherent hierarchical sense. I feel trying to make a perfect summary of a topic is something that is not really useful to a single person from a learning perspective. Yea you can not easily turn your notes into a blog post, but you train your brain and that is more rewarding in the long run, I think. Also, yeah, Zettelkasten.
- kungito 6y agoSometimes I wonder how I would turn out if I did organized people stuff like this. What bothers me is these life advices always feel like bullshit. Like, check this guy out. He has his own website with a title "Den Zhadanov\nTechnology. Productivity. Inspiration.". This is life coaching 101. He writes about how burning man didn't change his life and has pictures of books on beaches. How does one take this person seriously? Can someone read this crap and think "Yeah, I find this guy to be honest and want to take his opinion seriously." I get that he's a Forbes 30 under 30 but personally it all smells way more like hustle than some profound knowledge.
- quickthrower2 6y agoYeah I had a skim of the submitted page only and this stuff is common sense to anyone who has studied to get good grades from age 14 onwards. However this sort of article might be useful to someone who struggled at high school and wants to give learning another shot.
- faceplanted 6y agoHonestly, as one of those people who never studied or even did homework and basically got grades entirely a linear function of my interest in listening to the class without making any notes, I've thought for a while that I should just look up how organized, hard working people actually do anything, because it's predictably come back to bite me in that I now can't really teach myself anything unless it's in lecture format and provides summaries because any notes I take are useless. Also I have like zero time-management ability and I don't even know how people get it.
- jamesholden 6y agoThis ^ Also, as someone else mentioned, use your own brain to think about how this particular method would work for you. Hell try it. Doesn't mean it works for everyone, or that someone else doesn't have another better method. But this is our area of interest as 'hackers' and hacking learning might be the format which better appeals to someone over another.
- mluts 6y ago> Instead of reading 100 books, it’s better to find one that really changes your life. You can't know whether book will change your life or not until you read it. If you treat every book too seriously you just waste your time and kill the pleasure of reading. Everyone should master skimming and their ability to regulate "depth of understanding" based on perceived value.
- rootsofallevil 6y ago> If you treat every book too seriously you just waste your time and kill the pleasure of reading. I gave up on reading non-fiction seriously as I realized that I started to skew non-fiction books due to taking them too seriously. I, now, learn at lot less from each book but I do take pleasure in reading so it's an overall win. Furthermore, I can always look deeper into a book if I get really interested into
- meghdeepr 6y agoAlan Kay said that you need to read bad books to know a good book. You need the context to know what makes something good and thus no reading is truly wasted.
- sharker8 6y agoThen there's the category "so bad it's good". "Three Cups of Tea" is The Room for books. It is a trifecta of sorts: poorly written, nonfiction, and partially falsified and debunked.
- venamresm__ 6y agoAm I alone in thinking this reduces the essence of books as work instead of as leisure. Where you are more focused on extracting something of "value" out of it then to actually enjoy it. It doesn't have to be this reductionist and utilitarian. Maybe that explains the rise in companies that will summarize long books in 15min, or the rise of the small single rotating idea books.
- tartoran 6y agoIt really depends on the books you’re reading. Doing this on fiction/literature will kill that pace the author wanted you to have but if you’re some literary critic or something, taking notes while reading may be useful for you
- ParadiseEclipse 6y agoAlmost everything posted on the Internet is just an ad in one form or another
- hue3 6y agoThis is the "most true" thing I read today.
- ltbarcly3 6y agoArticles like this should start with at least some reason we should think the author is actually in a position to give advice on this subject. Reading a bunch of popular bestseller self help books doesn't actually teach you anything, even if you read 5000 of them.
- sdevonoes 6y ago> Reading a bunch of popular bestseller self help books doesn't actually teach you anything, even if you read 5000 of them. Agree. Your time in life is finite, so one should read only the good stuff (and yes, objectively, some books are better than others).
- matthewh806 6y ago> Agree. Your time in life is finite, so one should read only the good stuff (and yes, objectively, some books are better than others). Wow, what a way to look at things... if life is finite why waste all of your time reading books someone else deems to be be "objectively" better than others? Just read whatever the hell appeals to you and forget about the official "deemed worthy" cannon.
- ltbarcly3 6y agoI think I partly agree, reading anything is probably better than the alternatives if you want to do something to improve yourself. However, you could also try, yourself, to make an educated guess or research what you might read to decide, for yourself, whether you consider it 'worthwhile' to spend your time on. You are setting up a false choice between 'read whatever you feel like without thinking about it at all' and 'only read what they tell you is worth reading', which aren't even choices among the same set of alternatives!
- Denzhadanov 6y agoThanks for the feedback. It's simple - I realised that having a better system to read and learn is needed, and I did research and created a system for myself. During this process, I decided to share as my friends and colleagues are interested in this topics. It got picked up by HN. So no advice were given and you don't have to take it. But I'm also always happy to learn from others.
- AntiImperialist 6y agoI took the other route and decided to read 100 books in a year. Did that for 3 years. They were mostly top rated or highly popular or highly recommended non-fiction books of all time, including the one pictured in the article. Most books are highly overrated. They usually take some useful ideas, usually what author perceived was useful to them, and add things to them to make it sound useful to their target readers, which may or may not make sense... enough to fill the length of a book. Are some books life changing? Sure! But some can change how you think to your detriment because the information in books is not optimized to your life situation. So, overall, if you're not reading any, you're not missing out. The problem is you won't believe it until you actually do go ahead and read them. How the books are marketed and sold, it makes you feel that you are missing some vital information that will change your life... you purchase it and think one day you'll read it and conquer all obstacles (or realize that "the obstacle is the way" by reading Ryan Holiday). Well, nothing like that will happen. But again, to actually know that for yourself, you'll have to read them. So, I can explain how I did it. If you are obsessive-compulsive like me and are single without kids and without much of a social life like I was, you may be able to do it too. This is what I did: - Create a goal in Goodreads and obsessively track progress (which page are you in) every time you read a part of the book - If some book is easily distracting, find the audiobook... and listen to the audiobook at high speed while reading the physical or digital copy. If audiobook version doesn't exist, find a drm-free digital copy (Library Genesis is your friend) and let Google Books or PocketBook read it at high speed for you - Buy good quality noise-cancelling headphones and listen to books all the time... commuting, driving, working out, cleaning, cooking, whenever you can do it. - If you get stuck with a book, start another one. Keep doing that. Don't set goals to read specific books. That will halt you. Just move on to the next one. You can always come back and continue. - It's OK to read 3 whole books cover to cover on a Sunday. - It's OK to read at night when you can't sleep. It might help you sleep. I managed to fall sleep in a micro bus in Thailand when I was reading 48 Laws of Power (yes, it is that boring). Again, it's not worth it... but if you feel like you're missing something, do it and find out for yourself.
- adflux 6y ago>- It's OK to read at night when you can't sleep. I do this, but with the same book series. Have read them for what must be 10 times in a row now. They put me to sleep in minutes. I never stare at the ceiling for this single reason. One unfortunate side effect is that if I start reading in a bus or train, I get sleepy now.
- timeeater 6y agoHas anybody used the flash card feature of the Kindle readers to good effect? I keep wanting to use them, but I only occasionally remember to highlight things in the books I read.
- CraigJPerry 6y ago>> Instead of reading 100 books, it’s better to find one that really changes your life This is just flat out wrong for non-fiction. This is not a good way to use books or any research material, except perhaps meta-analysis’ but even then with caution. It doesn’t matter how many 5 star reviews it has, or who wrote it. You will be far better served by reading many writers on the topic and using your learning from each to compare and contrast between the materials and arrive at a deeper understanding. For example, there are thousands of books with a theme that could be written as “how i got rich”. Every single one of these books tells the version of the story the author would like you to believe rather than the actual truth because the simple fact is the author themselves, despite living that life, may not actually know the truth of the matter themselves. Plus some actively seek to deceive.
- unklefolk 6y agoPlus there is a great deal to learn out there that is not instructional and can't be captured by a single book. Reading good fiction, biographies etc opens your horizons, builds human understanding and empathy. It is more subtle than the "10 habits of successful people" style books but more valuable in my opinion.
- dhikapow 6y agoI believe the author's point is that there are just too many books out there. Book reviews and ratings saves you time by helping you avoid the bad ones to begin with. In that case good star reviews does matter. The reviews helps you avoid those books that you mention in your example. Though I agree that reading widely does help, it makes sense to focus your limited time to read and use sources that have been thoroughly reviewed by other people
- hue3 6y agoIf that's the author's intended point, he should have written it in a way that makes it clear.
- arendtio 6y agoWhat the author means, is that many people read a lot of books, but don't internalize and adapt their actions accordingly in a truly meaningful way (count me in). So his argument is, to better take one good book and truly learn from it and change yourself than read a hundred books and forget 90% of what you read, let alone to change your actions. That said, I agree with you that having more sources of information reduces the risk of falling to the misconceptions of one or a few authors.
- playpause 6y ago> Disclaimer: I’ve spend hours researching this topic and simplifying things for you.It gets a bit nerdy, but if you apply these techniques -> your life can change. Is that meant ironically? It leaves a bad taste if not.
- hue3 6y agoExactly! Also, his saying he spent “hours” researching something is a strong giveaway he’s not very familiar with, well, researching and putting an idea forward. Everyone who wrote anything worth reading has also spent hours (often in the three-digit mark) researching it. If he thinks his article is anything special because he spent a few hours doing research for it, I’m not sure I can take it seriously.
- hacym 6y agoThe numerous errors in the writing don’t help things much, either.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jkingsbery 6y agoWhile I think there are some merits to this approach, I think some caution is also needed. There are numerous times where I've read a lot of material quickly, not really mastering it but making a mental note of where to find that later. It's easy enough to go back and look up facts, reference material, or techniques for solving a particular kind of problem later, you don't need that to change your life. Another other problem is: it's hard to know what books will change your life. For me, Fermat's Enigma (https://www.amazon.com/Fermats-Enigma-Greatest-Mathematical-Problem/dp/0385493622 https://www.amazon.com/Fermats-Enigma-Greatest-Mathematical-...) and The Last Lecture (https://www.amazon.com/Last-Lecture-Randy-Pausch/dp/1401323251 https://www.amazon.com/Last-Lecture-Randy-Pausch/dp/14013232...) were both life changers, but it would have been hard to know that going in to reading them. Still another problem is that there are multiple ways at getting repetition. One approach is to read one book really intently. Another approach though is to consume similar related media over a period of time. If you listen to a weekly podcast (like EconTalk, for one example), very often similar themes come up over and over again. Or you can read several books by one author, or a group of related authors. Finally, and maybe this is a more minor point, the post's author mentions taking down great quotes. One thing I've realized from my reading is that great quotes sometimes help summarize and understand the flow, but pretty often they don't. One of the nice thing about reading on the Kindle app on a phone is that there are multiple colors for highlighting, and I find it helps to highlight differently for "this is an awesome quote" vs. "this sentence is important in following the structure of the argument."
- a_c 6y agoJust chill man. Read whatever the way interests you. You will enjoy the process, or even learn a thing or two as a bonus.
- hue3 6y agoBut if people did this, how would they brag about reading pseudoscience on books about productivity? How would they come online and tell everyone they read the latest life-hack book and that made them a millionaire? Hell, how would they write such B.S. articles trying to teach something every 15yo knows?
- Denzhadanov 6y agoThere was no intention to give advice or teach anyone, I'm not an expert in this field. I needed a system to learn better (often times I forget great concepts from books), so I did my research and created a system for myself, and decided to share with friends and all those who might find this helpful.
- yawz 6y agoOn how to read books I trust and like the classic called How To Read A Book [0]. The rest, these articles, etc. always feel too fluffy and contrived. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Read_a_Book https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Read_a_Book
- abc_lisper 6y agoNot to make light of authors efforts, but the book “How to read a book” is much better, and more thoroughly thought about on the topic
- troughway 6y agoMore and more I feel like some submissions are here to nerd-snipe the HN crowd into a furor.
- arendtio 6y agoI find it funny that the author chose 'Thinking, Fast and Slow' as the title image as that is one of the books I read and I am 100% certain there is so much more to learn from that book than what I have learned. How do I know? After reading said book, I read a few other books and some of them actually cited 'Thinking, Fast and Slow' and applied some of the concepts in new contexts and sometimes I thought 'Wow, I didn't realize the implications when I read the original book'. So I think it is actually a book that is well worth to be actively read, but currently I still find myself struggling to keep integrating the lessons from 'How to make friends and influence people' into my everyday actions.
- jyriand 6y agoMy problem with all these systems for reading books is that it starts to feel like a work I have to do, instead of enjoyment. I just want to read a book in my leisure time and not fill out templates in my notebook/app, constantly worrying that I might have missed some key idea.
- colechristensen 6y agoWell you get more out of books when you do something to interact with them more than a linear stream of text. These sort of "self-improvement-hack" BS systems are good for the kind of people they appeal to, but you don't need a form to fill out or some regiment. Likewise not every piece of text deserves the same attention. Some things don't need to be read at all, some things skimmed, some read through once, some with a bit of reflection, some with extreme studying over years. Just the exercise of doing something regarding the text. Keeping notes in the margin, discussing it with someone, writing a review of the material in long form or in bullet points, keeping track of questions you have, etc. all enhances what you get out of a book. You might resent it as a chore, so you just figure out what works best for you, maybe it's nothing, but trying something different from time to time can't hurt. My advice is to keep a pencil at hand when you're reading to take a note, underline a passage, or if you don't like writing in the margins, a notebook to the side to highlight things you think are important, things you think are questionable, questions it raises in you, etc. After that, share it. When you read a section, explain it to your partner, your cat, an internet stranger, to yourself in your notebook, etc.
- Sigmoid 6y agoJust read the book lmao
- yaoxx151 6y agoWhile I like the strategy in general, I want to challenge the first point "Have a clear WHY I’m reading this book". I think reading books is like exercise, it doesn't matter which part of muscle it trains, as long as you keep doing it, it'll improve your health overall. I find that the best part of reading books for me comes mostly from the unconscious influence--often after I read a book, I can't tell you what I remember specifically and how it would improve my life. But if I'm lucky, one day the idea will come to my mind at the right time. I find myself dislike the mindset of having a purpose on reading. For me, the meaty part of reading is the process of searching, not the results. And you can guess that I dislike reading self-help books. I don't think we can change our behaviors by reading a book. knowing something is easy, practice is hard. Interestingly, the author mentions he's reading Daniel Kahneman's Thinking, Fast and Slow. In a talk[1], Daniel says "This is not really a self-help book. And of course it's very easy for me to say because I've been studying it. Not only I've read the book, I wrote it. Didn't improve my thinking at all." [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MgQutgSwY88&feature=youtu.be&t=4392 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MgQutgSwY88&feature=youtu.be...
- Denzhadanov 6y agoGreat point! The reason behind my "Why" is that I would like to pick a book and read it as it might improve my thinking and help me make a better decision. For example, I want to become a better manager and leader, and so I research which books might help me. And "Radical Candor" was the book I picked, and it did change the way I manage my team, improved my relationships, etc. However, letting go of why and structure is important too, and I can see how "searching" works for you. Thanks for the comment
- marek22 6y agoHey, I read at an average pace.About 20 books a month. Some are read in 3-4 hours, and some you won't read in a week. Sometimes I think that if there were no books, I probably would have shot myself. Working at the factory, I am the only one who sits with a book during a break - they consider me somehow strange and I look into their eyes and see such melancholy that I am grateful that I have such a hobby here https://pdfmania.com/adventure/57-peter-pan.html https://pdfmania.com/adventure/57-peter-pan.html
- bvrlt 6y agoIt's kind of sad that his list only contains self-help book, and not a single novel, nor any classics.