48 ms·
Go after Apple next. They're the worst of the lot. Apple is destroying the notion of computing freedom by locking up all their computing devices. You shouldn't
by echelon 6y ago
Go after Apple next. They're the worst of the lot.
Apple is destroying the notion of computing freedom by locking up all their computing devices. You shouldn't be able to sell a computer or phone and prohibit what runs on it. These aren't game consoles sold at a loss with tons of competition - these are the gateways to digital lives and international business.
And what the hell business do any of these three companies have doing movie/tv production? (Four companies, if you count Amazon.) They wouldn't even allow studios to own theaters, and yet we allow these four monopolies to own payments infrastructure, communication, entertainment, devices.
What the fuck? Are we just going to let them soak up the entire economy?
It's absurd and it has to stop.
Break up all four. Microsoft is doing better than ever post-DOJ, and the intervention led to Apple, Google, and Facebook ascendency. (Microsoft had to pay Apple!) The intervention created wealth and opportunity. It required Microsoft to innovate more - and look where they are now!
Make Apple pay Epic and all the companies it hurts on the App Store. Don't let them have a say what you can and can't run on your device, how you install software, or how you make repairs or upgrades. And don't let them limit which browsers you can install, either!
Tell Google they can't do Chrome and AMP anymore, and threaten to pull AdSense into a separate company.
Make Facebook open up its chat protocol and provide rich data export and interoperability tools.
Split Amazon and AWS. Make them stop bundling services and selling their own products. Fine them for fakes.
My absolute dream would be for the DOJ to make Google and Apple collaborate on a cross-platform native app API and treat it as a first class citizen. Doubly so if web/WASM can make those API calls. Visiting Netflix.com should give me first-class native streaming, casting, and screen sharing.
Technology belongs to us, not the giants.
Edit: Apple enablers downvoting. Y'all need to rethink what's going on and have a serious change of heart. I'm not a heretic calling for more freedom and you're not in a puritanical sect defending a blameless entity. This company has trillions of dollars and they don't need you to defend them. You don't need this company to protect you and everyone else - don't blindly trust them while they erode the world around us.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoApple is pretty ridiculous for what they've been doing. The M1 is pretty cool but jesus christ not only did it take them 2 years to fess up going "sorry we got caught that our keyboards were trash..." but they KEPT SELLING THEM! For the cost of an Apple product, that's downright unacceptable. Those should've been recalled on the spot. But oh no, Apple cant have a recall. Gimme a break. They only care about their consumers with endless pockets.
- gentleman11 6y agoA bad keyboard doesn’t really justify an antitrust suit... even if we all did want the amazing 2012 keyboards back
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoNo and I'm sorry I came of pretty hot headed there.
- mschuster91 6y ago> It required Microsoft to innovate more - and look where they are now! Arguably things went seriously downhill with Windows 8 and culminated in the horror that is W10: ads everywhere, invasive tracking that can't be made to shut up for good, extremely ugly redesign.
- edgyquant 6y ago> extremely ugly redesign I’ll never get how people can argue that older versions of Windows are more aesthetically pleasing than windows 10. I don’t use Windows (and haven’t since XP) but even I think 10 looks better than, say, Windows 7s fat task bar. Although I can actually say with a straight face I think most default Linux DEs look better than Windows for the first time in my life.
- mschuster91 6y agoI have always turned off all that redesign nonsense in XP and 7. There's a reason that the Win95 look is so iconic and "timeless": it's clear, consistent and simple. Windows 10 is a fucking hot mess, made worse by the fact that Microsoft for whatever dumb reason wanted the same UI on mobile and desktop, and the result was the worst possible outcome.
- philliphaydon 6y agoI only use Windows for gaming, or old .NET Framework projects. But man Windows 10 is SOOOOOOO much more visually appealing than any other version of windows to date. And better visually than most linux distros. And I really don't know what this 'ads everywhere' crap people keep talking about.
- themacguffinman 6y agoIt's hard to miss the fact that Windows 10 pre-installs Candy Crush and your start menu looks like this: https://www.howtogeek.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/ximg_57c4d873d5ed3.png.pagespeed.gp+jp+jw+pj+ws+js+rj+rp+rw+ri+cp+md.ic.4287m6BUAs.png https://www.howtogeek.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/ximg_57... From https://www.howtogeek.com/269331/how-to-disable-all-of-windows-10s-built-in-advertising/ https://www.howtogeek.com/269331/how-to-disable-all-of-windo...
- zamalek 6y ago> Apple enablers downvoting. It's a comically bad idea to talk against Apple around here, but the guidelines are clear: don't talk about downvotes. If you have good points corrective votes will happen. That being said, while Apple is strongly anti-consumer (in everything except for privacy), Facebook is orders of magnitude worse in more regards than merely celebrating choice. Definitely a great second contender, but the world would be genyinely better place without Facebook.
- humanrebar 6y ago> If you have good points corrective votes will happen. I've seen corrective votes happen, but I wouldn't be so categorical in saying all votes are well reasoned and reward cogent argument.
- op03 6y agoThe Law of Pointless Reward systems states - Any random reward system produces community. If the community has no shared goal or purpose, the random outcomes the reward system produces will be tolerated.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoAnd just so GP understands—I felt the need to downvote their comment explicitly because of that line at the end.
- urda 6y agoHonestly I did the same here. It completely undermines their argument and turns their comment into a whine-fest. I don't need to be told how to "think" about things and how I should allow more and more government into my life by some random internet commenter who's upset over downvotes (especially not from one who's not even associated with SV at all and has little to stand on).
- echelon 6y agoI'm speaking for your freedom, whether you accept that or not. > especially not from one who's not even associated with SV at all and has little to stand on Please don't gate keep tech. Not everybody lives in the valley.
- danvoell 6y agoAlso for Amazon, Walmart, CVS, Costco... Disallow white label products. They just learn about products, copy, undercut then crush them due to distribution. Its anti-competition and demotivates new advances.
- dleslie 6y agoNo way; generic products are a boon to affordability. You'll see a hell of a fight if you try to take "No Name" from Canadians.
- texasbigdata 6y agoWhich one is worse? Costco shelfing it followed by a generic replacement once the consolidated volume is high enough to achieve a crazy margin profile, Walmart using the bill of materials to alter the product in a way that achieves a particular customer goal (like all-in cost) or Amazon paying nothing but requesting meeting after meeting and demo after demo ahead of a potential acquisition and (maybe sometimes maybe never) stealing your idea basically full bore and competing with you?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- reaperducer 6y agoEdit: Apple enablers downvoting. You're probably being downvoted because you posted an off-topic rant. The topic is Facebook. Going all, "But what about Apple!" is deflection at best.
- gentleman11 6y agoThe wider topic is antitrust, and that is part of the wider problem of “big tech companies are eating the world.” Its on-topic in a broad sense in my opinion
- mishftw 6y agoYes, while OP did sort of rant I think it adds value to the greater discussion and highlights Facebook's peers
- dleslie 6y agoA bit of _as a game developer_ here: Game consoles shouldn't be special. If the NES and Genesis hadn't had their locks broken then we wouldn't have been graced with some of the greatest entries in their catalogue. Consumers won because anti-consumer digital locks were broken.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoCan you give more context? Were there locks on consoles and now there aren't? I'm not aware of this.
- artificialLimbs 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIC_(Nintendo) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIC_(Nintendo)
- dleslie 6y agoThere were locks then and there continues to be locks, stronger locks, nowadays. IIRC, Codemasters and others discovered the magic numbers necessary to include in the header of the NES cart in order for it to boot, and went on to release unlicensed games; like Micro Machines. I'm hazy on the NES-specifics. EA reverse engineered the Genesis development kit and released their games in their own carts in large part because they refused Sega's licensing terms; in retrospect, it's similar to Epic/Apple today. Sega eventually caved. An old Game Informer article about EA and the Genesis: https://bluetoad.com/publication/?i=73272&article_id=773681 https://bluetoad.com/publication/?i=73272&article_id=773681
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIt's not even particularly that the locks are stronger now from a technical perspective, as that when the NES was current, DMCA 1201 didn't exist. It's a terrible piece of legislation whose primary effect is to be harmful to competition.
- tenebrisalietum 6y ago> IIRC, Codemasters and others discovered the magic numbers necessary to include in the header of the NES cart in order for it to boot > I'm hazy on the NES-specifics. I'll fill you in. The ROM on NES carts doesn't have a header (the ROM files floating around on the Internet do but those aren't part of the cartridge data) - the NES has no firmware or OS. What it is is that the NES console, along with each cart, has a chip called a CIC that was only available from Nintendo, and only if you were a paid licensee. The CIC in the console resets the console constantly unless it handshakes with the CIC on the cartridge. There were ways to disable the chip; some things I've read say having something on the cart send a voltage spike would disable it. I think Tengen reverse engineered it and developed a compatible chip, they got sued. As far as the Sega Genesis, I do know a later revision of the Genesis motherboard had a boot ROM and also required the cart to write ASCII 'SEGA' to some I/O ports, otherwise the video chip would not work. The idea was that copying this without authorization was a trademark infringement, but I think a later lawsuit made that tactic legally worthless. Arcade boards of the 80's and early 90's have some interesting schemes. A number of Capcom games have decryption keys in a RAM that's powered by a 'suicide battery' and if the battery ever dies or is tampered with, the keys are gone and the board stops working.
- Dig1t 6y agoWhy litigate in the case of Apple? There is so much competition, Apple is not a monopoly in any market by any stretch of the imagination. There is a very easy solution to the problem, don't like the computer/phone? Buy a different one! I totally agree its really stupid to go to such great lengths to lock down devices like they do, but at the same time it really doesn't hurt anyone because anyone who doesn't like it can just buy one of the million (vastly less expensive) alternatives.
- gentleman11 6y agoNetwork effects are a real thing. You could switch to the Ubuntu OS if you wanted to, but there’s no developer ecosystem to provide the apps you use daily
- pbourke 6y agoExcept that modulo very specialized software, those apps exist or they are consumable as web apps from nearly any OS.
- OpieCunningham 6y agoThat’s a shame, I guess? Ubuntu exists though, so if you want definitive control, you can have it. If you want Brand X commercial software that only runs on Mac, you can have that too. I don’t see why Apple should be required to facilitate both.
- zepto 6y agoExcept that there actually is software for the things you do every day on Ubuntu (and Linux in general).
- Consultant32452 6y agoThe network effect is the problem here. There's no Linux app that lets me connect to my network of friends and family using the Facetime protocol, which they are all on. Oh I can video chat, for sure, with the nobody else I know who is willing to migrate to a new chat software.
- xvector 6y agoSince when do you have a right to computing freedom? Why don’t you buy from Purism instead? Sorry, but I can’t get behind such a draconian government takeover of private corporations. No one is forcing you to buy an iPhone. Support free products with your wallet instead of demanding that a the government coerce a private entity to make your arbitrary wishes and desires real.
- manigandham 6y agoConsumers should come first before massive corporations. It's why we have regulations in the first place. A world controlled by a few giant conglomerates that own all of your data while providing the illusion of choice of "just don't buy it" is not a good outcome.
- xvector 6y ago> Consumers should come first before massive corporations And yet corporations don’t exist to do your particular bidding and make your desires real. Unless a corporation is doing something illegal, you have no right to tell them what to do and what to make. Apple could, for all intents and purposes, sell useless slabs of aluminum. Your demands to have the government coerce them into creating open APIs would be just as outrageous in this scenario. Finally, giving the government this much power is shortsighted at best. Has the Trump administration not shown you the extremes the government can go to? The TikTok debacle after Trump’s Tulsa rally was ruined by it, calls to repeal Section 230, etc. The government is not your friend and it never will be. There will always come a time when it will abuse its powers to the greatest extent possible. Unless corporations are actively and illegally harming consumers, I don’t see why your proposal is necessary. Consider supporting companies that further your ideals with your own wallet rather than telling other companies what to do.
- zepto 6y agoSupport such companies or actually work on projects that further them. The idea that the government is going to create an open software utopia is hard to understand.
- zepto 6y ago“My absolute dream would be for the DOJ to make Google and Apple collaborate on a cross-platform native app API and treat it as a first class citizen. Doubly so if web/WASM can make those API calls.” You want a government mandated software platform? Regardless of whether any of your criticisms have merit, putting the government in charge of API design seems like a questionable suggestion to say the least. Also, all these breakups you are suggesting are anti-consumer. Your assumption is that somehow ‘competition’ would produce better products than we currently have, but history doesn’t support that idea. Without vertical integration you just end up with inefficient consortia attempting to solve problems by committee and political jockeying. That’s what enabled Apple to overtake WinTel in the first place. The way to unseat Apple isn’t to use the government to force us back in time. It’s to recognize the needs they aren’t satisfying and actually contribute to meeting them.
- echelon 6y ago> You want a government mandated software platform? Sure. I like that cars all have government mandated turn signals and brake lights too. Computing is an essential freedom and we can't let these companies turn it into "special sauce" that only they control. The fact that they're this close to doing it is both scary and a shame. We have a chance to get back on the right path, and we should do it. It's not like an industry and academia consortium wouldn't step in to help build the standard. The W3C got us pretty damn far. > The way to unseat Apple isn’t to use the government to force us back in time. It’s to recognize the needs they aren’t satisfying and actually contribute to meeting them. How do you compete with a $2T giant that can easily clone you or lock you out? They've created a "hardware + software + services" megalopoly that does nearly everything. Email, photos, video editing, movies, music, devices, health tracking. When businesses do compete (take SONOS, for instance), Apple comes along and builds their own. Owing to deep integration and ecosystem forces, the competitors aren't able to escape the growth/funding gravity well. Apple is Thanos, and they're snapping freedom and competition out of existence.
- zepto 6y agoThe inability of industry and academia (and the w3c) to create standards is what created the opportunity that enabled Apple to succeed. If standards had been the solution, Apple wouldn’t have been able to differentiate themselves. Turn signals are a great example of why this idea is dead on arrival. They have been around for close to a century and the government mandated them 50 years ago. If you want the US computing industry to move at that speed, the government will make that happen for you. We just aren’t at the stage in computing where innovation is over and we can afford to force everyone to adhere to a government mandated design.
- newfeatureok 6y agoWhat's so special about computers? Should car manufacturers be forced to use interoperable wheels, lights and other proprietary components? Maybe so. Take a basic 36V drill, companies such as Black and Decker and Dewalt use different methods to lock the battery onto the accessory. Should the government also mandate these are interoperable? The list goes on - construction tools, consumer electronics, appliances, etc. To what extent should the government force industries to do things? By the way, I personally would love if the answer to the questions above were yes, but I wonder how successful the government would be in pursing these things.
- echelon 6y ago> By the way, I personally would love if the answer to the questions above were yes I was about to say... :) Remember when cell phones all used proprietary adapters and you had to buy expensive chargers if you lost yours? This is one of the great things governments can do to protect us. (I think we owe Europe for that one.) If your solution to creating margin is being anti-competitive / anti-consumer, there's something fundamentally wrong.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s not actually anti-consumer to create products that people want.
- echelon 6y ago> It’s not actually anti-consumer to create products that people want. Big tobacco. And that's a great analogy. And just like tobacco might be something the consumer wants, it's bad for the broader system. Apple is creating negative externalities that ripple across our industry, all the while bringing smiles to consumers that don't know about the cost.
- zepto 6y agoTobacco is clearly not analogy by your own argument, since tobacco harms the user. Are you claiming Apple harms its users? Apple creates fewer negative externalities than any of their competitors. This is well documented. I don’t see how this analogy works.
- Lammy 6y agoMy assumption is that any US lawsuits against US tech companies are just song-and-dance to maintain US technological hegemony worldwide while also looking like we're doing something.
- CameronNemo 6y agoI don't know if it is quite so meaningless. But I doubt the US government is going to do something to give us more power over our technology. The Feds successfully threatened to shut down an entire social network this year. They don't want to lose that power. They do care about mass media and how people discover information, however. They will take action to make sure the wrong information is not being shared widely.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> My absolute dream would be for the DOJ to make Google and Apple collaborate on a cross-platform native app API and treat it as a first class citizen. No. This is exactly what they should not be doing, because it requires detailed ongoing precision regulatory work. The government is not a scalpel, it's a sledgehammer. It can easily say that the same company can't make both third party app stores and operating systems, or both video search/recommendations and video hosting. It's a clear enough line, it isn't mired in technical details, you swing the sledgehammer at the fault line between the two markets and break them apart. Then you go home.
- echelon 6y ago> The government is not a scalpel, it's a sledgehammer. It can easily say that the same company can't make both third party app stores and operating systems, or both video search/recommendations and video hosting. It's a clear enough line, it isn't mired in technical details, you swing the sledgehammer at the fault line between the two markets and break them apart. Then you go home. This works. Let's do it.
- rmrfstar 6y agoIt sounds nice, Glass-Steagall for tech. Worked in finance for a long time. But I think that technology is going to make it easy to work around structural separation. Facebook derives its power from building dossiers on billions of people. They are intelligent motivated people. I don't think that pushing different activities into different orgs is going to do anything to limit that power. Their surveillance business model is what needs to go. Will society collapse if we shift from behavioral to contextual advertising? I doubt it.
- formercoder 6y agoMy feelings during every GDPR training.
- dismantlethesun 6y agoI think you're right. However, the op said it was their "dream". It's okay to have a dream be infeasible in real life. My dream government functions as a scalpel, dynamically reacting to situations faster than any one person can think and creating outcomes better than any capitalist market. However, history has shown this to be infeasible so it will always remain a dream.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoIt comes down to power. Studios don't own theatres because they aren't powerful enough to lobby for that, but if were more profitable for studios and theatres to be vertically integrated (spoiler alert: it would), then you'd bet it'd happen. Maybe Disney will take the lead on that one. Look, I don't like it either, but common people have statistically insignificant impact on whether or not legislation is passed. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig&t=60 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig&t=60
- toast0 6y agoStudios don't own theatres because they lost an anti-trust case last century (United States v Paramount Pictures) and have been prohibited from owning theaters since, although the DOJ moved to end that last year, and it's now in a two year sunset period. Well, maybe, only the studios listed in the original consent decree were strictly prohibited, but nobody else did it, because they would risk being added, and lose their investment in theaters.
- chrismcb 6y agoHuh? Studios are probably the most powerful lobbyist on the planet, otherwise mickey mouse would be out of copyright. And we shoukdnt have the dmca fiasco.
- chrismcb 6y agoWhy?you last a lot of things that you think sous be done, but don't give any reason. Why is it absurd? Why does it have to stop?
- af16090 6y ago> They wouldn't even allow studios to own theaters The DOJ recently convinced a federal judge to terminate the consent decrees that prevented studios from owning theaters: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/federal-court-terminates-paramount-consent-decrees https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/federal-court-terminates-para...
- ericmay 6y ago> Make Apple pay Epic and all the companies it hurts on the App Store. Don’t make me barf. This is stupid. I hate to be so, well, blunt, but you can’t be hurt by an App Store, maybe if you don’t like it you can create your own? Apple (and they aren’t unique in this - Wal-Mart, Amazon, Steam, Epic, Nintendo, you name it) created a place for people to sell products. Without that creation, that market doesn’t exist. I’d you want to “punish” Apple then sure they can pay the developers and then all the developers can pay back all the profits they made on top of iOS.
- koyote 6y ago> maybe if you don’t like it you can create your own But that's the point. You can't. Imagine Wal-Mart sold fridges and forced you to buy every item you put into that fridge at Wal-Mart. And maybe that Xbox you bought at Wal-Mart required you to buy (and pay for) your Xbox live pass through Wal-Mart.
- ericmay 6y agoYep. I also can’t create a Wal-Mart, or an AirBnB, or Netflix, or Disney. So what? Why do I have to pay Microsoft to play via Xbox Live? Why can’t I set up my own online service to play games on their hardware?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eropple 6y agoPaying for Xbox Live in order to access games with matchmaking/sometimes dedicated servers on Microsoft resources and services (because that's what you're paying for)? Sure! But somebody who wants to play a game with non-platform crossplay, like Rocket League or something like Power Rangers: Battle for the Grid, absolutely should not have to pay for Xbox Live, and I don't see why that would be controversial.
- ericmay 6y ago
- JimDabell 6y ago> Go after Apple next. They're the worst of the lot. Really? Facebook has contributed to ethnic cleansing in places where Facebook has such a dominant position that it is practically synonymous with the Internet. Facebook’s responses to this have been slow and lack oversight, with Facebook themselves saying they failed. - https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebook-genocide.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo... - https://www.reuters.com/article/us-myanmar-rohingya-facebook-idUSKCN1GO2PN https://www.reuters.com/article/us-myanmar-rohingya-facebook... - https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-46105934 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-46105934 - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/feb/07/facebook-myanmar-genocide-violence-hate-speech https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/feb/07/facebook-... How on earth can you arrive at the conclusion that Apple are the “worst of the lot” because they won’t let you run the software you want and they are getting involved in movie/tv production? Those are quite literally first world problems compared with the harm Facebook does.
- spunker540 6y agoBut people were accessing Facebook on Google and Apple devices — so who’s to blame really?
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoIt's completely absurd to suggest that Apple should be moderating what users post to facebook.
- spunker540 6y agoIs it? Apple controls the keyboard and camera. Why only prevent terrorism or child pornography at the app-level when you can stop it at the os level?
- tsjq 6y agoGood points indeed, albeit a tad hard language for this forum. Definitely upvoting this
- Reedx 6y agoBreaking up tech companies would be using a 20th century tool on a 21st century problem. Andrew Yang had a better idea. Put a VAT on big tech and use that to fund UBI. https://www.yang2020.com/policies/value-added-tax/ https://www.yang2020.com/policies/value-added-tax/
- Apocryphon 6y agoWhy not try both?
- fakedang 6y agoIt makes perfect sense. Tech enjoys massive benefits from scalability and from eating up competition. It's easy to use both - break them up, then tax the shit out of them so that they can't grow into leviathans as fast.
- butterisgood 6y agoYou seem confused. Go use Linux or something. There is plenty of choice.
- rudolph9 6y agoThe problem is Apple actually makes quality products. I personal don’t buy Apple products anymore for the reasons you have listed, and am transitioning from my iPhone 7 to my newly purchased pine phone. However, from both the standpoint of an engineer and a consumer I’m continually impressed by the quality of the products Apple makes. Not as impressed as I was when I got my first Mac in 2007 bu despite conducting the same shady business practices that have landed others in hot water, as long as Apple makes quality products I doubt any antitrust “changes” will be more than symbolic in-practice. I’m all for putting pressure on them with antitrust lawsuits but ultimately consumers are who will drive meaningful change
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"What the fuck? Are we just going to let them soak up the entire economy?" Looks that way. No leadership to stop it.
- helloycombinat 6y agoSorry mate but this is fucking stupid. Facebook ruining lives is way worse then apple not letting you run apps And 99% of software is absolute crap anyway I rather have an open source console ($300) or phone ($400) so I have one specific hardware to test against that most people can afford and have anything spec higher conform to the lower one so people don't have to test dozens and dozens of hardware (friend told me his company has 20+ android phones that they MUST test against because they all glitchy)
- 1270018080 6y agoAmazon being able to undercut the entire retail market while peddling counterfeits is abhorrent. It isn't even financially possible to compete with them given barriers to entry considering their retail operates at a loss while AWS subsidizes them.
- tabob 6y agoThe nature of the apple ecosystem is a boon to consumers, not a hinderance. I don't really give a #$!@$ about your profits as an iPhone developer. I care that google isn't sniffing all of my personal data, that I don't get viruses or phished, and that my phone just works. Compare Apple to PCs. Windows is, has been, and always will be a security sh*tshow. Linux isn't interesting enough to scammers to be a security target yet, but it sure is ugly and chaotic. Apple just works for me. By forcing Apple to be open, you're trying to both turn it into Linux by taking away the quality and usability of the apps available, and into Windows by .. making it a security shitshow. Nobody has ever given me a real argument as to how Apple harms consumers in the iPhone. The only argument seems to be that app developers want a free ride. They want full access to do whatever they want, consumers be damned, without paying into the infrastructure which made their market available. (techno-libertarianism strikes again?)