14 ms·
My fucking Google Home can't even figure out how to play the auto playlist "My Likes" on YouTube Music. Previously, I could say "Play my Thumbs Up" and it coul
by renewiltord 6y ago
My fucking Google Home can't even figure out how to play the auto playlist "My Likes" on YouTube Music.
Previously, I could say "Play my Thumbs Up" and it could do so on Google Play Music.
It keeps playing a song called "My Likes". Jesus fucking Christ, Google. If I say "Play my My Likes playlist" something random happens.
Do these guys even use their product? I'm just glad this album didn't come out before the forced migration.
EDIT: Okay, I went to verify it and this has to be the best instance of massive PEBKAC plus some UX donkeyness. The auto playlist is called "Your Likes" so I can get the Assistant to do the right thing by telling her to play her likes (Ok Google, play your likes). What the fuck man. But fine. At least I got it working.
I've suffered with this for months and now I find a solution in the few minutes after posting this.
- dylan604 6y agoThink of the assistants as young children. As a reference, someone I know spent some time in Miami with his wife and 2 young kids. After some time, the young son told his dad that he wanted to go back to "yourhammy". The dad eventually decoded "yourhammy" was the kid's interpretation of Miami as My-hammy. Your Likes => My Likes reminded me of that story.
- notRobot 6y agoYou shouldn't have to treat a Smart assistant like a child.
- twicetwice 6y agoChildren are really really smart—just not yet as smart as adults.
- ajmurmann 6y agoI think children are probably at least as smart as adults, but are missing assumed context on almost everything. Maybe the same is the real problem with smart assistance?
- dylan604 6y agoThis is what I was thinking. If you stop a second to think about it from their perspective, it can make more sense. (I know in 2020 it is unheard of to think about something from a different point of view than one's own.) Even real-life human beings in the assistant role get things wrong as they interpret the original request not as intended.
- renewiltord 6y agoI believe current evidence is that children grow both intelligence and knowledge into adolescence. After that, it's mostly knowledge. i.e. both compute and data grows for quite some duration, then it's mostly data.
- codetrotter 6y agoIn that case maybe the assistants should be more like children and like ask questions? Relatedly, I wonder if these assistants “filter bubble” you like search does. Like, learning what types of things you are looking for and grouping you with other similar people.
- mosselman 6y agoYou shouldn’t take everything so seriously.
- wittjeff 6y agoRegressions in language understanding are common when children are acquiring deeper understanding of the rules of that language. For example a kid may start saying 'letted' for the past-tense of 'let', even if they had used it correctly before.
- renewiltord 6y agoThat is a great story. Honestly, I do intend to treat smart assistants that way. I can accept that they're imperfect and that they're tools that only work in certain ways. I can figure out a way to either make them be useful to me or abandon them if the way is too hard. I'm not asking for perfection. The thing is predictability, though, and maybe handling the common use cases. It gets frustrating when they get worse. Kids, on the other hand, only get better at understanding you (though perhaps also better at frustrating you on purpose). To put it simply, I'm happy to make myself perform incantations. I'll say "Ok Google, grooblepuff the bonkman" to get the thing to do the thing. This whole thing has made me understand why wizards and sorcerers chant Accio! and Sectumsempra! and shit like that because if they just said "Bring me my firebolt" no one knows how the AI that runs magic in the world would interpret that. And you know someone who feels this strongly about the product is pretty bought into it. Like, if I didn't use it so much, I wouldn't be complaining this much.
- germinalphrase 6y agoYouTube music has been a really mixed bag. Disappointed by the forced transition.
- renewiltord 6y agoIt really has. Google Play Music integrated so well with everything. YT Music has the massive advantage that there is so much more music on YouTube but damn, the integration is shambolic.
- baskire 6y agoThe forced transition was the final nail in the coffin to de-google myself. Even Gmail, can’t trust that it won’t be deprecated in the future.
- StavrosK 6y agoYeah but Gmail is one of the easiest things to leave (if you have your own domain). There are high-quality alternatives and moving is a half hour of work. Leaving YouTube is nigh impossible.
- pnathan 6y agoI pay for G Suite, it works well. If I have to migrate, I will, but it'd be very upsetting. Music-wise, I have completely transitioned to Alexa and Amazon Music. The interface is worse, but they seem to be more stable. I just wish I could upload my own music and have Alexa connect to Bandcamp.
- moron4hire 6y agoI have 5 Google Home devices (one Max, two regulars, and two minis) and I'm dreading the day Google Home shows up on killedbygoogle.com.
- baskire 6y agoGoogle home was already killed. It’s now the google nest home mini.
- cbhl 6y agoApparently the new brand for speakers and displays with Google Assistant is now "Nest" -- as far as I can tell the Nest Mini and Nest Hub are the same hardware (?) as the Google Home Mini and the Google Home Hub. (And the "Nest Audio" is the new version of what was the original "Google Home".)
- colejohnson66 6y agoIf you view the “Nest” brand as a thermostat brand, it doesn’t make sense. But if you view it as a “smart home” brand, it makes sense. However, rebranding to a different product name never makes much sense. It just confuses the public.
- cgb223 6y agoMy Google Assistant (on Sonos) will somehow always play the wrong version of the song. Ask for War Pigs? Here’s the live version Ask for a Come Sail Away? Here’s a terrible cover Ask for Magic Stick? Here’s an instrumental I swear it just picks the version of the song that pays the least royalties and plays that instead of the right one...
- grenoire 6y ago>pays the least royalties This is a very interesting theory, I don't know if this was revealed somehow but considering how consistently terrible the guesses are on assistant devices... I wouldn't be surprised.
- Ansil849 6y agoWhy would a live version of a song pay less royalties than the studio version? Similarly for the instrumental version. The only one that seems like it would pay less royalties is maybe the cover, if the cover band has a weaker royalty rate with the provider. I think the far more likely explanation is just that these home assistant products suck.
- iforgotpassword 6y agoBut how do you mess that up? Let an intern code that shit up? Assuming the voice recognition part worked perfectly: 1) query song database for input 2) play result that is most popular (most plays by manual selection in eg desktop client etc) The only tricky part is to determine whether the query is an artist or a title but again in most cases this will be solved by checking popularity. What's a plausible explanation that they mess this up so badly?
- blacksmith_tb 6y agoMy assumption has always been that Alexa, Assistant etc. just have really naive sorting of results - if I search on Spotify, the song results for 'War Pigs' are returned with the album version second, but I know that's what I meant.
- Zelphyr 6y agoI coined "Brogdon's Law" (probably not original to me by any stretch) several years ago: The answer to any technical problem will present itself within 30 seconds (sometimes minutes) of asking "Hey, can you take a look at this?"
- will_pseudonym 6y agohttps://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law Cunningham's Law states "the best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer." The concept is named after Ward Cunningham, father of the wiki. According to Steven McGeady, the law's author, Wikipedia may be the most well-known demonstration of this law. Cunningham's Law can be considered the Internet equivalent of the French saying "prêcher le faux pour savoir le vrai" (preach the falsehood to know the truth). Sherlock Holmes has been known to use the principle at times (for example, in The Sign of the Four.)
- silentsea90 6y agoFascinating! How does Sherlock use it? Or put differently, you are completely wrong about Sherlock using it in Sign of the Four. Prove me wrong! ;)
- greggturkington 6y ago"If you go to a Linux forum and ask for help fixing your WiFi driver, everyone will ignore you." "If, instead, you say 'Linux sucks, you can't even get a f*&$ing WiFi driver working!' thousands of people will solve the problem for you."
- will_pseudonym 6y agoIt's not until just now that I realized the irony inherent in my reply. What the person I was replying to did was to "post the wrong answer", and I was uncontrollably impelled to enact the very phenomenon I was describing, completely unaware I was doing so. Whether unintentional or not, it has put a huge smile on my face.
- 6y ago
- browniefed 6y agoI had the exact annoyance and figured it out. If you say "OK Google play my likes on youtube music" it will play `Your likes`. If you forget the `on youtube music` part even if your default player is set to Youtube music it will play the `my likes` song.
- renewiltord 6y agoI thought the same but it literally doesn't work for me. Just tried it. It plays something random. I tried it on my phone to see what it was doing and it picked "my supermix" once and the song "my likes" the next time.
- the-dude 6y agoDid you try please? or tangential for me?
- renewiltord 6y agoHaha, I'm scared it'll say "I'm afraid I can't do that, Rene" and break the illusion of who the master is and who the slave is.
- the-dude 6y agoI would expect it to ask you to take out the trash first.
- untog 6y agoIt feels like a trope to even say it but it amazes me how badly Google have handled the transition from Google Play Music to YT Music. For me YT Music is an inferior experience in every single way.
- david_allison 6y agoYT Music isn't yet supported in my country. Inferior is much better than "we'll delete your music library on an undisclosed date in December".
- silentsea90 6y agoI dislike it too, but I can't put a finger on why YTMusic sucks compared to Google Play music. Mind sharing your reasons?
- untog 6y agoOne big annoyance for me is that every song I play now shows up in my YouTube history. For me, watching videos on YT and listening to music are activities I do in two very different contexts, mixing them together in a list serves no purpose and makes it a lot more difficult to navigate. And on mobile GPM had a very simple functionality: a playlist containing all the songs you've downloaded offline. To the best of my knowledge YTM has no such thing, just a playlist _it makes for you_ of offline songs.
- novia 6y agoWhen Google Play started a "radio station" based on a song, the songs that came after were changed on each iteration based on your likes/dislikes. Maybe they just shuffled the same list each time, but it kept it feeling fresh. When you ask YouTube Music to play a song, the same set of songs will always come after. Not very good for similar song discovery.
- robotnikman 6y agoOne major annoyance for me: No shuffle playlist option in the Android Auto interface, you have to pick up your phone and do it from there. Also, the shuffle button only shuffles the current songs in queue, not the playlist your currently listening too like Spotify and GP Music do.
- puranjay 6y agoGoogle Play Music was so trash but I stuck with it because I had too many tracks sent by friends/my own on it (which Google Play would randomly delete altogether at times). When they forced the transition to YouTube music, I gave up the service for good.
- reaperducer 6y agoIt keeps playing a song called "My Likes" Meanwhile, here in Siri Land... Me: Hey, Siri, add "tomatoes" to my Groceries list. Siri: OK, Reapreducer. Which list should I add it to? Me: Groceries. Siri: OK, Reapreducer. Which list should I add it to? Me: Groceries. Siri: OK, Reapreducer. Which list should I add it to? Me: Groceries. Siri: OK, Reapreducer. Which list should I add it to? Me: Groceries. Siri: OK, Reapreducer. Which list should I add it to? Me: Cancel. I've gone back to paper grocery lists. They Just Work™.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoI don’t use Siri for much, and I certainly don’t have it always listening. But I did hack out a useful Shortcut to record my blood pressure and heart rate to Apple Health. I say, “Add blood pressure <pause> 120 over 80 plus 60.” Then I use the shortcut to parse the string on the / and +, and record it to Health. The hard part was finding delimiters that Siri would consistently record as a single character. That and realizing I needed a manual review step to make sure Siri didn’t happily pump garbage into my logs.
- pimlottc 6y agoThat sounds useful. What’s the third number, BPM?
- Hnrobert42 6y agoRight. My blood pressure cuff records systolic, diastolic, and beats per minute. Apple health lets you record all three of those measures.
- masklinn 6y agoI've been wondering whether I should re-enable siri and give it an other shot. I use the todos app for that and from time to time it would be convenient to do it handsfree. I see that I still have no reason to bother, it's going to frustrate me more than anything else (especially with how downhill voiceover has gone in 12).
- gorkish 6y agoThis is my experience with any 'smart assistant' product that is or ever has been. It's always frustrating but never particularly hard to find the special incantation that will invoke it to do the thing that you want it to. Overall though it's simply not worth the effort which is probably why I end up using these overwhelmingly complex devices only for their most mundane functions like timers and getting the weather. Trying for anything moderately complex, and I might as well be asking the dog to do it for me.
- renewiltord 6y agoThat's the worst thing. It used to work well for me.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoAll technology is becoming more and more this way for me.
- isaacimagine 6y agoSame. It's been getting less smart over time.
- deaddodo 6y agoThis is the same way I feel about Google Maps. Especially with the new streamlined/cards UI. Everything is objectively worse and I can't even force it to act like it used to. Actual, useful functionality has just been lopped off.
- erikerikson 6y agoAnd Google Search.
- Causality1 6y agoYep. Google has been getting progressively worse at recognizing my words over the past two years. It's also started randomly capitalizing words that aren't proper nouns and seemingly has a blacklist of words that it clearly recognizes as speech but refuses to type such as "o'clock".
- duxup 6y agoOutside of setting a timer, I've kinda given up on voice commands. My tolerance for mistakes for simple commands that work sometimes / are the right command ... but don't work is ultra low. Like how is it my Android phone will default to just googling "exact valid voice command letter for letter" (it's used in a commercial for cripes sake!) ... and not somehow notice that?
- rriepe 6y agoMy experience with every personal assistant is the same. I start using it. I have two or three commands I do regularly. One of the commands stops working. I stop using it forever.
- the_af 6y agoMost "Ok Google" assistance feels like a gimmick to me, but here's something very simple I'd love to have working: I watch a lot of YouTube on my phone when cooking, I even built a cardboard stand for my phone for this reason. What I want is for YT to respond to these voice commands: - Pause video. - Play video. - Rewind 10 seconds. - Skip the (expletive) ad <-- ok, I can understand why this one might not work. Sadly, this doesn't work. And it's the only voice assistance I really need :(
- heavyset_go 6y agoI hooked up Kalliope[1] to Home Assistant to do exactly this, except for the ad skipping voice command. [1] https://github.com/kalliope-project/kalliope https://github.com/kalliope-project/kalliope
- kore 6y agoI've been playing around with a Nest Hub Max, and with that you can pause/play a video by holding your hand like a stop sign in front of it. Kind of gimmicky, but occasionally useful. Was also curious about your use cases on the phone (aside from ad skip), and they actually worked for me. I'm using a pixel 4, though wouldn't think that'd make a difference.
- crtasm 6y ago> Skip the (expletive) ad OK Google, install Newpipe.apk
- drivebycomment 6y ago"Hey Google pause/unpause youtube" and "Hey Google skip/rewind 30 seconds on youtube" work on my android phone. So I don't know why you say it doesn't work.
- the_af 6y agoThey don't in mine. What Android version do you have? What phone model? Mine is a Galaxy S8.
- visarga 6y agoIf you take a look at recent neural net papers for dialogue and question answering you'll see amazing things. It is really mind boggling they don't improve the commercial product, maybe it's still too expensive to run for the general public. Similarly, they say English language Search is powered by Transformers. But when I want to perform searches it often switches the intent to something wrong. It's a blunt tool, not a precision instrument.
- woodgrainz 6y agoFor those uninitiated, PEBKAC = problem exists between keyboard and chair, aka user error.
- throwaway889900 6y agoAlso: ID10T error, Layer 8 issue, etc.
- _underfl0w_ 6y agoThe OSI reference "Layer 8 issue" is a new one to me. That's a good one!
- fullstop 6y agoI have endless frustrations with Google Assistant / Google Now / Whatever they call it now. A few examples: 1. I have my phone set up to trust bluetooth in my car and unlock my phone. I get in the car and say "okay google, open spotify" -- this is so that it will continue playing what I was listening to before I left work. "Okay", she says, and then tells me that she can't do that because my screen is locked. Sometimes this works, and sometimes it does not. 2. When I had Google Play Music it reliably would play random sub-par covers of songs rather than the original, even when I specified the artist. 3. Sometimes it decides to rely on screen input instead of audio controls. I can't do that while I'm driving. 4. It sometimes ends voice input too early or does voice input inconsistently. I've sent messages to my wife saying "I'm on my way home exclamation point" instead of "I'm on my way home!" 5. Commands which have worked for months suddenly stop working. 6. Sometimes my screen stays on, forever, after asking to play music. (OnePlus 7T, Android 10). This does not always happen. 7. Google: "Here's your message, send it?" Me: Yes Google: Sits there for a moment and pops up the results for "Yes" in the assistant. My biggest gripe isn't what it can and can not do. It is the inconsistency that drives me up the wall. I am not a heavy user and most of my requests are because I wish for it to be hands-free in a car with bluetooth audio. I'm sure that this is a harder problem to solve than just me interacting with the phone, but it is a common use case.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y agoI don't even bother trying to use any sort of voice commands while in a car unless I'm stopped and the radio is off. Road noise makes voice recognition an impossible task.
- Throwaway1771 6y agoNeed better car, or add dynamat to your old car's doors. Or, possibly different tires. This is an unusual problem - sounds annoying in general!
- craftinator 6y ago> 5. Commands which have worked for months suddenly stop working. This is my biggest gripe. Whatever magic voodoo ML they use is inconsistent, and it's not clear what level of abstraction this inconsistency is happening in. What I want is the reliability of Google Assistant's speech to text parsing, combined with a firm, customizable interface. Something like If This Then That, where there are some default commands with a clear reliable command pattern: "send message to George Orwell, we live in your book", and commands can be added.
- mdoms 6y agoThey recently renamed "Your Mix" to "My Mix" but not "Your Likes", apparently.
- SpaceRaccoon 6y ago> Do these guys even use their product? I get the impression that many Google employees do not use the products they work on.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoDude if this is an issue that evokes such rage you might want to think about how good you have it.
- renewiltord 6y agoHaha, I've lived a life that ranges from lacking toilets to living for free in beautiful apartments owned by movie stars. Trust me, I know my life is great. But the way I see it is that any Google Assistant PM is going to see this for what it is: someone who is angry because they love not because they hate.
- bsanr2 6y agoThe assistant has gotten markedly worse at finding music since the home devices came out a few years ago. Songs I used to be able to find by describing vaguely it can now no longer find at all, and it gives me random indie artists for songs I actually know the title og unless I literally spell it out (and even then, it often fails). Woe be to you whose desired song only exists as a Youtube (but not Youtube Music) video. Something behind the scenes has changed, and it's just another reason never to trust Google to maintain their services.
- faebi 6y agoI still don‘t know how to start play youtube music using siri on an iPhone. I also couldn‘t figure out play music . It‘s truly badly integrated.
- Narretz 6y agoReminds me of this voice command skecth I've watched recently (careful, loud): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4n-GAd33jew https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4n-GAd33jew Especially, since the problem wasn't the voice command in your case.
- codetrotter 6y ago> Do these guys even use their product? This is a question that I too ask myself daily with a lot of the software that I deal with and depend on.
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoPerhaps they do use it but they know exactly what to say to get it working.
- kiliancs 6y agoI always enjoy Alexa making a comment out of the blue because some word in a conversation sounded a lot like "Alexa", apparently.
- free2OSS 6y agoYeah that's what got me to get rid of my Alexa. Now only Google can hear my every word via cellphone and Nest. And look how incompetent Google is. I don't even get creepy suggestions on ads since I deleted facebook.
- SamBam 6y agoCome back home from work, I frequently say "Ok Google, text Mary 'home in 10'", only to be told that it can't do that because it doesn't have a "Home" number for "Mary." I have to re-do it with "Ok Google, text Mary 'I'll be home in 10'", and growl a lot on the inside.
- freedomben 6y agothe google assistant is getting objectively worse and stupider. It worked better a couple years ago. The thing I hate the most about these opaque, closed box systems is the absolute dependence I have on them. I can't just freeze the version of software I'm running that is working. Nearly every app I have that works great, will at some point stop working and regress. Almost universally that is true. I despise the new era we're in where the user has zero control over what is running on their hardware.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 01100011 6y agoGiven how they killed off Google Play Music and foisted YouTube Music on us, I have to conclude that Google hates music and wants to do everything they can to ruin the listening experience. It's as if no one involved in product design has even a passing interest in music.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoWhen cancelling my YouTube Premium subscription one of the exit survey questions for "reason for cancellation" was "Unhappy with the YouTube Music App." So clearly there's some awareness of the unpopularity of YTM out there. However while it specifically asked about the app, whereas the real problem is the whole YTM service/experience on all platforms -- in particular the web app. Hopefully the cancellations and the survey results percolate to the right people.
- shadowtree 6y agoThat's why magic spells use this weird language - to prevent accidents. Wonder if these AI assistants will lead to the development of a new language. Exterminatum Horix Abracadabra (Siri, play something nice).
- dorkwood 6y agoI'm still surprised these things have become so ubiquitous. I remember thinking "these things will never catch on", but they caught on massively in spite of their flaws. I guess the ability to do an action without requiring hands is such a powerful draw that it outweighs all the pain that comes with it.
- dan_quixote 6y agoIt's great if you have young kids. Your hands are always full and you're always in need of a distraction. That said, I end up frustrated with Alexa more often than satisfied.
- 725686 6y agoSo not much has changed since Apple's Newton: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6qxixgQJ4M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6qxixgQJ4M
- capableweb 6y agoRealisticly, how many of the people working on Google Voice, Siri and Alexa do you think try to use their own service as much as possible day to day? Because just like you, I think it's evident they simply don't. They build for others, not for themselves, and they miss the point 50% of the time. What we need are people building interfaces for themselves, not people building interface they think are good for others.
- tfehring 6y agoConversely, I've been pleasantly surprised at how well voice recognition works with weird song/album titles nowadays. "Hey Siri, play 'Zombie by the Cranberries by Andrew Jackson Jihad' by AJJ on Spotify" works exactly as intended.
- mcguire 6y agoAbout 16 years ago, I worked in the IBM Solutions Experience Lab (with the smart kitchen and living room and stuff). One thing I did was to set up the "smart car" simulator, which connected with IBM's cloud stuff at the time, including their voice recognition. I'm testing this diddly-bob and say, "Turn on headlights." The simulacar honks its horn. Loudly. Unfortunately, there was a tour going through the lab at the time. Some VPs from some company got to watch me honk the horn and then bang my head against the desk. In the last 16 years, the state of the art has not advanced, as far as recognizing my speech goes. It still don't work.
- m-ee 6y agoThis sounds like something from Better Off Ted
- JosephRedfern 6y agoIt's taken me 10+ attempts to get Google Home to wake me up to a radio station on weekday mornings. Even with the alarm supposedly set, it works maybe 30% of the time, so I end up setting alarms elsewhere too. I'm astonished at how badly it works compared to Alexa, but sadly, Alexa no longer supports alarms via BBC Sounds, so it's not an option for me.
- binarymax 6y agoIt's probably obvious that the only way these services would get improved is if they actually made money. Alexa is constantly being improved since it's a vector for revenue. Siri and Google Home and Cortana are tinker toys for engineering and R&D.
- waterside81 6y agoReminds me of the scene from The Simpsons: When Bart, Lisa , Maggie and Marge were at the Mt. Useful Visitors Center, Bart went to a statue of Smokey the Bear. Smokey said "Only WHO can prevent forest fires ?" Bart then pressed the You button and Smokey said "You pressed you, referring to me, that is incorrect. The correct answer is you."
- lostlogin 6y ago> The auto playlist is called "Your Likes" This used to really irritate me. Microsoft called folders things like “my pictures”. The awkward personalisation seemed so gross (I used a Mac). However Spotify’s “Your likes” is even worse, it sounds more like big brother giving me temporary access. I’m not sure how I ended up fixating on this.
- sriku 6y ago"AI" (quoting since we aren't there yet) will have to deal with what Melanie Mitchell calls "the long tail problem" before we'll accept it as AI - https://youtu.be/NMUqvhuDZtQ https://youtu.be/NMUqvhuDZtQ . While she gives instances such as "how is an autonomous vehicle supposed to distinguish between a flock of birds on the road versus a small snowman versus a kid versus a rock versus a small animal.. all of which would warrant different responses, if the system can only respond if it has seen this stuff in training before." (paraphrasing) .. and she brings up the example of Teslas getting confused by salt lines laid prior to snow season. (I'm in India, so I wouldn't know such things were done either.) With natural language and speech interfaces, we face such long tail problems too .. like the Burger King ad triggering a whopper lookup via "ok google".[1] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/12/business/burger-king-tv-ad-google-home.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/12/business/burger-king-tv-a...