4 ms·
Ultimately, automation is good because it means more goods and/or services to more people. More goods and services means that society as a whole can support mor
by dragontamer 6y ago
Ultimately, automation is good because it means more goods and/or services to more people. More goods and services means that society as a whole can support more people.
A lot of American life is tied down to your job however. That seems to be the problem: health care is tied to your job, retirement benefits are often tied to your job (401k or pension), etc. etc. One can argue that its the overemphasis of your job that's the problem... not the grossly improved productivity due to inventions.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoIndeed. Provide robust safety nets and universal healthcare and we can proceed with Automating All The Things with wild abandon. Until then, based on the automation you’re building and deploying into the marketplace, you’re relegating subsets of workers to possible long term or permanent unemployment, despair, and possibly death (people die without health insurance, which many can’t get without an employer or holding on until they’re eligible for Medicare at 65, in the US). At some point, we have to move past the concept of jobs as the measure.
- chii 6y ago> Provide robust safety nets and universal healthcare and the question becomes "who" does the providing? In the US, the going mentality is 'user pays' (which leads to insurance, which leads to insurance company dealing with healthcare provider, which leads to employers providing good insurance as a side benefit to compensation). The US populous can't easily change their mentality to "society pays". Therefore, this is where the issue should be tackled.
- tuatoru 6y agoIf housing, healthcare, education, clothing, and food were free, and I still had income, I could spend it on fitness trainers, life coaches, interior designers, personal shoppers, performance artists, geanealogists, ... There are a lot of potential mass-market service industries that don't exist because all the benefits of productivity growth (and slightly more than all, now) go to the top 0.1%. There are still plenty of potential jobs - jobs that we will never have because of inequality. And we should keep the eusocial aspects of jobs in mind. They provide life structure, self respect, and respectability in the eyes of others as well as a means of subsistence. Edit: I would love to live in a world where tens of thousands of people have "street party organizer" as their job.
- frockington1 6y agoRetirement is not at all tied to your job, IRAs exist for this reason. Obamacare was supposed to address the health insurance tie to employment, however all that seems to have done so far is increase costs
- ako 6y agoCorrelation does not imply causation - is there any proof that obamacare is the cause of the increases in costs, or would that have happened anyways?
- frockington1 6y agoIn 2012 Obama promised premiums would go down, my main point was that health insurance is theoretically no longer tied to employment. (note: I am aware that in practice it is not so simple as Obamacare plans are a small fortune)
- lotsofpulp 6y agoACA would have caused insurance prices to rise no matter what since healthcare spending would have risen since more people are getting healthcare since the law required insurers to cover everyone. People that complain about ACA increasing prices are complaining about having to pay more since more people are getting healthcare. ACA also requires younger people to pay disproportionately more than older people. Health insurance premiums did go down from infinity to somewhere between $400 per month and $1,200 per month for people who previously couldn’t buy it.
- biggermike 6y agoIt's very rare to have direct proof of the effect of an economic/regulatory intervention, but luckily, in this case, we do. We've had a decade a survey data that indicates exactly what the effect the ACA had on employer provided healthcare was. See here for one such example: https://pnhp.org/news/impact-of-aca-on-employers-and-their-employees/ https://pnhp.org/news/impact-of-aca-on-employers-and-their-e... Some relevant highlights: * More than one-third of organizations now have increased out-of-pocket limits, in-network deductibles and/or participants’ share of premium costs in response to ACA. More than one in five organizations have increased copayments or coinsurance for primary care, increased participants’ share of prescription drug costs and/or increased the employee proportion of dependent coverage cost. * The excise tax on high-cost group health plans (a.k.a. Cadillac tax) is considered the top ACA cost driver beyond 2015. Since 2011, a steadily increasing percentage of organizations has taken action to avoid triggering the excise tax — a trend likely to continue. More than one in ten organizations already have adopted changes to prevent them from triggering the tax, 21% are working on changes and 28% plan to act sometime prior to 2018. Only one-quarter said changes were not necessary either because they have no high-cost plans (23%) or because they plan to pay the tax (2%). That being said, the year following the passage of the ACA saw a large anomalous spike in employer healthcare costs that wasn't present in Medicaid/Medicare. It's almost undeniable that this was due to the ACA.