5 ms·
A broken clock is right twice a day. It's rare that someone is cartoonish levels of incompetent.
by bobthepanda 6y ago
A broken clock is right twice a day. It's rare that someone is cartoonish levels of incompetent.
- shoulderfake 6y agoIts not incompetence, its corruption
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoAjit Pai is extremely competent, except he enacts policies that you do not agree with. Listening to an interview with him, I could feel myself thinking that he had a ton of valid points about the FCC and industry as a whole. And before I get called a shill, I disagree with many of his policies and am glad hes leaving the post.
- TheOperator 6y agoYeah I've been exposed to Pai and the man certainly is more erudite than myself. My view on network neutrality at this point is the companies pushing for those laws were always more of a monopolizing threat than the ISPs ever were. Netflix and Google loved network neutrality because it saved them lots of cash and they ended up getting an "internet fast lane" Comcast couldn't dream of by installing a massive CDN across the globe. It seemed like policy that was supported mostly because it was pro-consumer and because honestly the ISPs are getting lots of taxpayer money.
- enragedcacti 6y ago> It seemed like policy that was supported mostly because it was pro-consumer and because honestly the ISPs are getting lots of taxpayer money. Am I getting wooshed or are these both great reasons to support this policy and thus oppose Ajit Pai?
- x3n0ph3n3 6y agoIt's almost as if there are good arguments on _both_ sides of the debate!
- cultus 6y agoWhat are the benefits of abandoning net neutrality if you are not an ISP?
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoIn my personal case: I'd much rather be able to buy special-purpose cellular plans with limited/restricted capabilities. I'd really like to see more $5-10/mo. device plans that offer connectivity that isn't artificially speed-throttled to dialup speeds. For instance, for the computer in my car. If every single mobile network plan is legally required to support Netflix 4K and YouTube streaming, that's not workable from a business standpoint. And that's exactly Google and Netflix's goal: Require everything support their modern reincarnation of the boob tube.
- ashtonbaker 6y agoThat doesn't make much sense to me - if the issue from an ISPs perspective is data volume, then why not just put a cap on data and remain content-agnostic? Doesn't that address the issue in a much more direct way? For example, if there is no data cap, but only a block on netflix.com, it seems that you could get around that using a VPN or something anyway.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoI'd be perfectly fine with fully metered data plans at high speed: However, the same group of people who support net neutrality complain that data caps are also unfair. Notice that "unlimited data" is once again, however inaccurate as it is, nearly the only way to buy wireless service in 2020. I feel a very small group of companies are pushing an incredibly wasteful business model, because they aren't the ones paying for all of the waste. Google, Netflix, Spotify, etc. would rather you wirelessly stream content that makes... a lot more sense to store locally. And they're pushing things like streaming 4K... even when the cost/benefit of streaming 4K to a phone is questionable at best. We're all paying for the extreme network contention of 90% of available bandwidth going to these very wasteful business models. It's pretty unsurprising ISPs would like to charge extra for them, either towards consumers or the streaming providers themselves.
- zackees 6y agoNet neutrality never regulated Google/Facebook or the other social media tech giants. It only regulated the ISP which have never posed any threat to free on the internet. Net neutrality was only about shoving the costs of the internet infrastructure to the consumer. Net neutrality died, and all of the doom and gloom we were told would happened never materialized.
- mundo 6y ago> In 2017, Pai voted with his fellow Republican commissioners to remove rules that prohibited internet providers from blocking or slowing traffic to particular sites and offering higher speed “lanes” at higher prices. Many major internet providers have not yet taken advantage of that rule change, however. It seems likely that this is because they consider the looser regulations likely to be overturned in Biden's presidency, not because they don't actually want to make changes they spent millions lobbying for the right to make.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> Netflix and Google loved network neutrality because it saved them lots of cash and they ended up getting an "internet fast lane" Comcast couldn't dream of by installing a massive CDN across the globe. Comcast could easily install CDN servers if they wanted. And everything related to Netflix and peering was ridiculous. Charging because the traffic is unbalanced, even though it's the ISP's customers requesting the data? What, they'd peer for free if netflix clients uploaded 5mbps of random data so that uplink and downlink are perfectly matched? So sure, Netflix and Google are a monopolistic threat in other areas. But when it comes to ISPs getting into conflicts, it's almost always the ISPs in the wrong.
- brnt 6y agoHe's a good demonstration of why experts without ethics are problematic.
- hungrygs 6y agoCome on, Ajit Pai was regulatory capture at its worst. Now, as he always planned, he gets to go somewhere and collect his millions per year already furtively promised, until the next Republican administration.
- masonic 6y agoPai was originally nominated to be FCC commissioner in 2011 by President Obama during his first term.
- mlindner 6y agoThere's been little out of the FCC that's been supremely bad. People have a completely irrational hatred about this and talking to them is almost impossible. "Vitriol" is an accurate definition of what occurred.
- jtms 6y agoI agree with you, having a rational conversation about NN and the FCC is sometimes difficult here. It seems like people just downvote anything they simply don't agree with. Your comment is a perfectly valid observation, yet people actively try to downvote it away and silence your point of view. My gut tells me that NN is probably a mostly beneficial regulation to have in place, but I have heard some very well reasoned arguments against it that seem more substantial and less reductive than "incompetency" or "corruption".
- schnevets 6y agoPeople have differing opinions on NN and net privacy, but the FCC's inability to make any progress on robocalls over 4 years in office screams incompetence to me. I know blocking automated calls is an audacious challenge (and one that other HNers understand better), but the lack of action on any front has made the phone a less useful method of communication, has harmed legitimate businesses, and probably impacted COVID contract tracing efforts. So fuck Ajit Pai, not just for compromising ideals that the internet was built upon, but for failing at his fundamental responsibilities and failing to protect Americans.
- colejohnson66 6y agoSTIR/SHAKEN was, in essence, signed into law (as the TRACED Act) just about a year ago in December 2019. The FCC approved the mandate March 31 this year with a deadline of implementation June 30, 2021 (2022 for smaller carriers). So to say he’s done nothing is very not true. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STIR/SHAKEN https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STIR/SHAKEN
- dredmorbius 6y agoRobocalls have been a notable concern dating to 2008: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=robocalls https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=robocall...
- souprock 6y agoThat would be 8 years prior to Ajit Pai. If it makes him incompetent, it also makes his predecessor incompetent. The fact that STIR/SHAKEN required a new law should be a big hint that the FCC Chairman didn't have the power to fix the issue.
- dredmorbius 6y agoIt means that the problem was highly evident by the time Pai arrived. Taking four years to build political concensis on a decade-old problem sufficient to result in STIR/SHAKEN, dependent or not on Congress, isn't a laudable achievement.
- TylerE 6y agoNot so rare amongst Trump appointees: See Betsy DeVos, Rick Acott, etc
- KorematsuFred 6y ago> It's rare that someone is cartoonish levels of incompetent. reply This sort of non-evidence based gaslighting it becoming depressingly common on HN these days. Ajit Pai has been a very competent individuals for the objectives he has been working for. One of the few in Trump admin who has skirted all controversies, done a good job quietly and delivered a good result despite so many people who earn their bread and butter from internet abusing him. ( I have even seen memes making fun of his skin color and face shape). You disagree with his policies does not mean he is incompetent.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoHis thinking that the will and advantage of the few (his telecom bros) over the many (your average American with internet) and doing away with net neutrality makes him extremely incompetent in my opinion. He's a civil servant to the interests of the people of the USA not AT&T, Comcast, and Spectrum stock holders.