3 ms·
In order to produce a personalized anti-cancer RNA vaccine, you need to a) do a biopsy of the tumor and some healthy tissue, which is fairly cheap, b) do gene
by inglor_cz 6y ago
In order to produce a personalized anti-cancer RNA vaccine, you need to
a) do a biopsy of the tumor and some healthy tissue, which is fairly cheap,
b) do genetic analysis of those samples to find the differences. This used to be prohibitively expensive, but now is fairly cheap too, the price went down six (!) orders of magnitude since 2000,
c) ask specialized software to find the optimal protein set to express. This software can be used for all the patients around, so cost of development will be split among them,
d) synthetize the correct messenger RNA and embed it in lipid nanoparticles. Not cheap, but not prohibitively expensive either, this is basically a biological equivalent of a printing job,
e) check the resulting drug and send it to the clinic where the patient is treated.
This all together is a much more straightforward and automatized process than extracting tumor-invading lymphocytes from a patient and babying them in vitro with a lot of attention from human scientists and use of fairly expensive reagents. The price tag for this process per se should be at least two orders of magnitude lower.
Then you must add the original development and testing costs, amortized equipment cost and profit. This is where the total price tag may balloon.
- sleepydog 6y agoIf a parent and child develop the same cancer, is it any more likely that the same (mRNA) drug will work for both of them? Or do cancer cells mutate so much that they're unrecognizable between patients? It would have interesting implications if in the future a family could invest in a bank of mrna molecules for their future generations. A new form of wealth.
- abiogenesis 6y agoI guess you should still perform steps (a), (b), and possibly (d) unless they develop it at the same time.
- Aeolun 6y agoIf the total course of treatment is closer to $40000 or $4000 then it doesn’t seem unreasonable for insurance to cover it.
- throwaway201103 6y agoIf the cost is $4,000 it is almost below the level that insurance is even necessary (if you're on a high-deductible plan with an HSA, you'd be out-of-pocket for it). That's less than the cost of a 10 year old car. If it's $40,000 yeah -- still that's on par with the cost of an ER visit for a traumatic injury and a couple of days as an in-patient, exactly the sort of thing you have insurance for.