8 ms·
RNA vaccines have a huge potential in treating cancer as well. Basically, you can whip up a personalized vaccine which wakes the immune system up to the fact th
by inglor_cz 6y ago
RNA vaccines have a huge potential in treating cancer as well. Basically, you can whip up a personalized vaccine which wakes the immune system up to the fact that it has a growing tumor on its hands.
So far, the success rate is very far from 100 per cent, but the therapy sometimes works even in patients with severe late stage metastatized cancer and, in all likelihood, we will learn how to use it better in coming years.
This progress could save way more lives down the line than just those at risk with Covid.
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-03072-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-03072-8
- hprotagonist 6y agoif mRNA works in anything close to a general case, i’m beginning to think that it might be as fundamentally transformative as the move from sulfa drugs to antibiotics was.
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoI do not know if you aware or not, but there is a similar to mRNA vaccines, yet different (actually, almost mirror reflection of what mRNA vaccine is) invention called antisense drugs. Those are actually already used as antivirals.
- wxnx 6y agoAntisense drugs are the same biological material, but have a very different mechanism of effect. Specifically, mRNA vaccines require an immune response to be effective. The mRNA (vaccine) encodes a viral protein, and the host (human) immune system still has to learn to respond to that protein. Antisense drugs are much simpler, with no immune response required. The mRNA (the drug) itself simply binds to the target mRNA.
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoI know all that. Besides, one pedantic point - antisense are not the same to typical mRNA, they have thiophosphate group instead of normal phosphate in their backbone, or some other tweak to make them bind mRNA permanently.
- papa_bear 6y agoSome of us don't know, so the extra detail is appreciated :) Interesting re: the thiophosphate group. It sounds like it just floods your body with some mRNAs complementary to the viral mRNA that blocks it from getting turned into proteins by your cells' ribosomes?
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoYes, pretty much; almost like NOPing out code in binary patches. However double check about the thiophosphates. I might be wrong. It is either Morpholinos are blockers and thios are promoting destruction of the mRNA or the opposite.
- philsnow 6y ago> Antisense drugs are much simpler, with no immune response required. The mRNA (the drug) itself simply binds to the target mRNA. Does that make them a class of "cures" rather than "immunizations"? If I get infected with the same thing a year later, will I need another dose of the antisense drug?
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoYes, they are "cures". Yes, you will.
- abiogenesis 6y agoIs it correct to say that an mRNA based vaccine wouldn't work for that virus anyway if you can get infected with the same thing a year later?
- ineedasername 6y agoVaccines have a shelf life in your body. It's good to get a titer every once in a while to make sure you don't need a booster. A year would be short though, unless you mean variants/mutations, which would really be reinfection, not with the same thing.
- Antimateri4 6y agoYes i read some interesting article aswell regarding mRNA vaccines, but from my understanting mRNA vaccine aren't yet tested in humans right? Only animals or am i mistaken? EDIT: what my question is: is there another mRNA type vaccine out there fully developed (i'm not suggesting that they are bad!)? EDIT2: Guys, i will never ask question again in here. Begin downvoted for a genuine question.
- inglor_cz 6y agoThey have already been tested on cancer patients, with some very promising results. https://acir.org/weekly-digests/2020/august/rna-vaccine-for-melanoma-shows-promise-in-early-clinical-trial https://acir.org/weekly-digests/2020/august/rna-vaccine-for-... https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/11/201110102550.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/11/201110102550.h... Some of the patients would probably already be dead if it wasn't for RNA vaccines.
- Antimateri4 6y agoYes, mRNA is pretty good and very promising (Moderna and BioNTech are mRNA based and they seems the most developed as for now)! My question was not asking if they are safe or not good (they have multiple points that make them probably the next big thing in vaccines and cancer treatments), i was asking if there are already mRNA vaccine type 100% developed and used as today.
- corin_ 6y agoThese Covid ones aren't the first that have been tested and shown safe in humans, but I believe they will be the first to be approved for release.
- Antimateri4 6y agoBioNTech one is also a 95% succesfull and mRNA based.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoYou're probably being downvoted because this information is easily looked up. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/RNA_vaccine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/RNA_vaccine
- delfinom 6y agoSadly from the manufacturing process description alone, we are going to be decades away from when it's actually ...not a few million dollars per individual to treat.
- faitswulff 6y agoAn individually tailored cancer treatment is already available in the form of the CAR-T therapies, which might give an indication of how expensive it’ll be - you were pretty much right on the dot, since each treatment in a course of treatments is estimated at $375,000.
- iguy 6y agoWhat is this money spent on? Is it a real cost per dose, or just a made-up number for something made in a research lab? Maybe another way to ask is: On the scale from 400k of white-shoe lawyer-hours, to 400k of custom 7nm silicon-etching, where should I mentally place this? The former isn't going to budge, the latter will cost pennies in a generation's time.
- seibelj 6y agoWhat they charge might be made up, but the costs of developing these drugs are astronomical. My wife is a cancer research scientist in immunotherapies and she can burn through tens of thousands of dollars in materials running a single experiment. And if she makes a mistake - the money is wasted!
- iguy 6y agoFor sure, I don't mean to suggest it's cheap research. But whether you charge a lot or nothing for the first few doses out of the lab, it seems like this won't really make a dent in the research cost. (I don't know if this $375,000 number is in that category, or not.)
- xorfish 6y agoIf the cost for every individual treatment is low, then the cost per treatment gets lower with more patients that can benefit from it.
- fullstackchris 6y agoHonest question here, is the mechanism in those mRNA treatments totally different? I can't imagine there is a 'spike protein' you can focus on with cancer - but perhaps I am totally wrong.