5 ms·
Japan’s GDP per capita which is arguably the most relevant economic statistic was higher in 1995. That’s got nothing to do with the stock market. People call J
by Retric 6y ago
Japan’s GDP per capita which is arguably the most relevant economic statistic was higher in 1995. That’s got nothing to do with the stock market. People call Japan’s economy stagnant, because it is. https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/JPN/japan/gdp-per-capita https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/JPN/japan/gdp-per-capi...
That said, for a country with limited natural resources and a rapidly aging population their economy is arguably reasonably healthy. If anything it shows what happens to a modern western economy when you don’t adjust for very low birth rates with immigration.
- harpratap 6y agoGDP per capita fails to take in account purchasing power parity and deflation of currency.
- Retric 6y agoReal GDP does take into account inflation or deflation. PPP is tricky as it depends on a specific basket of goods. It does seem to paint Japan in a better light, but digging into things it’s not quite that simple. For example Japan’s housing is treated as more disposable than most of the world which makes direct comparisons difficult. PS: Deflation is also a very very bad thing economically, trying to gloss over it is a very bad idea.
- benrbray 6y ago> Deflation is also a very very bad thing economically Why? I'd be interested in reading more if you have sources. Genuinely asking, I know almost nothing about deflation other than what I just read on Wikipedia [1]. My generation has had to grapple with the negative effects of inflation combined with low interest rates and wage stagnation, so I'm genuinely curious to hear about a different time/place where long-term deflation caused problems. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation
- barry-cotter 6y agoDeflation causes the economy to seize up as borrower’s debts grow in real terms even as they pay off the nominal balance and consumers put off consumption in the expectation things will be cheaper later. Demand collapses and the economy goes into a recession. It’s bad monetary policy. If you have deflation you should print more money until you don’t. https://www.thebalance.com/what-is-deflation-definition-causes-and-why-it-s-bad-3306169 https://www.thebalance.com/what-is-deflation-definition-caus... > Deflation occurs when asset and consumer prices fall over time. While this may seem like a great thing for shoppers, the actual cause of widespread deflation is a long-term drop in demand. > Deflation often signals an impending recession. With a recession comes declining wages, job losses, and big hits to most investment portfolios. As a recession worsens, so does deflation. Businesses hawk ever-lower prices in desperate attempts to get consumers to buy their products and services.
- gumby 6y agoAnd fixed-volume currencies are inherently deflationary (e.g. gold, Bitcoin, etc). Actually gold is worse; back in the gold standard days economies suffered deflationary squeezes bunctuated by boom/bust as new goldfield strikes occurred and the supply suddenly shot up (California, Yukon, Victoria, etc just to look at the mid-late 1800s). You end up with a liquidity trap in the amount of money doesn’t increase/decrease roughly in proportion to the size of economic activity. Fortunately “roughly” as it’s hard to measure.
- imtringued 6y agoYou have to know the definition of inflation. Central bankers generally refer to consumer inflation as the measure of inflation they target. It's based on a basket of consumer goods. According to that definition we don't have inflation. I tend to say consumer inflation in my comments to make it less ambiguous. By that logic asset inflation can actually act as a deflationary force because the relative value of consumer goods shrinks compared to the rest of the economy and the surplus can be used to provide an excess of consumer goods which further drives down prices. Of course this assumes that asset holders are not planning on spending their capital gains domestically. Considering current demographics (the retired own houses but don't spend as much) and globalization (Chinese workers can do your job) it is pretty much assured though. Anyway. The reason why deflation is bad is highly obvious. Imagine a highly simplified economy consisting of one factory. Some initial event happened that caused demand to go down. The factory has trouble selling its inventory. It lowers its prices over time to attract more customers. People looking to buy the latest gadget just put it off because they can buy it later for even less money. At some point the factory has to close because nobody is buying. Then suddenly everyone wants a gadget but there is no factory. If you want a business to operate in 2025 then it has to also operate in the years before that. Deflation sets up the exact opposite incentive. It makes sure everything you did in the past cannot be topped in the future without extreme effort. It means your best years are already behind you because there is less money to be made in 2021 than in 2020. It tends to reward hoarders, those who don't need to be productive. Inflation is the opposite. It makes sure that the future is always brighter than the past. There is more money to be made in 2021 than in 2020. It tends to reward workers, those who do productive work. The answer to deflationary problems? Give people a reason to work. It's why we have so many "gig economy" companies. It's nothing new. It's just day labor with some software lipstick applied to it. There is an overabundance of unskilled workers so there must be some way to economically deploy that workforce even if its not enough for a full time position. Converting unskilled workers into skilled workers would be even better but it would mean the government or the employer has to foot the bill. It's just not going to happen even though there is plenty of money around to fund education.
- harpratap 6y agoCouldn't find any authoritative data on real GDP figures but this - https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/JPNRGDPEXP https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/JPNRGDPEXP shows a good upward trend since 1995, and considering the population has been going downwards, real GDP per capita is going up by your metrics.
- benrbray 6y agoSorry, I just don't buy that you can summarize the life satisfaction & economic output of 140 million people with a single number, not to mention that GDP is a pretty bad measurement as far as single numbers go [1]. It's much, much, much more complicated than that. Anecdotally, my experience living in Japan vs the United States is that it's much better to be poor in Japan than poor in the United States, for various social / economic reasons (for instance, national healthcare in Japan, car culture in USA). At least before COVID-19, small businesses in Japan seemed to be doing pretty well, compared to the United States. [1] https://www.ft.com/content/765781fe-f136-11e7-b220-857e26d1aca4 https://www.ft.com/content/765781fe-f136-11e7-b220-857e26d1a...
- andi999 6y agoFor working poor yes. Government handouts are extremely difficult to get in Japan though.