18 ms·
Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording
- terramex 6y agoTitle is a bit misleading - while he did attach watercooler to R5 to unlock unlimited 8K, later in the video he achieved the same thing by using custom internal copper heatspreader and small fan attached to bottom of the camera body in 3D printed enclosure - that is much more useful and less "gimmicky" solution. Even with just custom heatspreader and without fan he was getting 40 minutes of recording, then had to take 5 minutes of break and could record another 40 minutes, as opposed to 25 minutes with hour long breaks before modification.
- m463 6y agoI think he probably went for watercooling first because it has the promise of silence. A fan on a video rig sounds horrible, and probably sounds horrible too. :) It's funny how all the pc watercooling awareness is spreading. There are lots of videos about the controversial process of applying thermal paste.
- terramex 6y agoFan on video rig is a fairly standard solution, used by both Blackmagic and RED cameras.
- CarVac 6y agoAs far as I know, fans like that are used to run between takes, not during them.
- geerlingguy 6y agoCinema cameras are also very rarely used very close to an omnidirectional microphone—a slightly audible fan would not be picked up by the external lav and shotgun mics recording the talent / action. Some people recording with the R5 or other more compact systems might rely on internal mics or a shotgun mounted atop the camera for audio, and that definitely picks up sound emanating from the body, at least a little. Many lenses' focus motors are loud enough to be annoying in onboard video.
- nottorp 6y ago"The promise of silence" is well said. It may be better than tiny fans, but for pcs you basically add pump noise and move the fan's location a bit. You can obtain the same effect with 12cm+ fans in a well designed case without the risk of leaking.
- philjohn 6y agoA good D5 will emit hardly any noise when running at 30-50%, and you can have 140mm fans on 140mm wide rads running very slowly (400-600rpm) and keep everything very cool. I've done both air only, with high quality fans, and now have. custom loop - the custom loop is far quieter, even at load. And it was fun to do.
- ashtonkem 6y agoPCs also live in cases, and can be moved a non-trivial distance away from the peripherals they drive. Not so much for cameras, whose placement is driven by other factors
- alisonkisk 6y agoMicrophones can be moved away from the camera.
- nitrogen 6y agoVery true, though a bit more difficult for a one-person team if they need to move around.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoWell for filming people you can use a wireless lav.
- im3w1l 6y agoI wonder if the processor (which was the hotspot) couldn't be moved from the rest of the camera though.
- nicoburns 6y agoI think he went with watercooling first to simplify his testing and make sure that his fixes weren't failing due to inadequate cooling power.
- IgorPartola 6y agoHell we are now seeing water cooled 3D printer kits.
- bufferoverflow 6y agoMany cinema cameras have fans in them.
- codeulike 6y agoThe hacked-together watercooling was the experiment that proved that a better heat solution would lead to unlimited filming.
- swiley 6y agoActive cooling in handheld devices is really underrated. I understand not having it if they're water proof but most aren't.
- rtkwe 6y agoA big issue is most handheld devices are already packed to the brim with battery filling most of the space left over after the electronics are laid out so there's no space left for meaningful active cooling. There was a teardown of a Red camera on Linus techtips to add watercooling and the contortions required to pack everything in with the cooling was amazing.
- _visgean 6y agoNot sure how active cooling plays with image stabilization but my guess would be that not very well - or rather it takes quite some engineering to make it play nicely. Also battery life...
- Slartie 6y agoIf I were Canon, I would make this guy a generous job offer to integrate a better stock heat spreading solution and optional external cooling into future camera models.
- robin_reala 6y agoWhy? He’s just hacked on an external cooling system that is in no way meeting the basic quality requirements of a production device. For that you’d want to hire a heat transfer engineer with experience of designing small-sized passive solutions, and with both a valid work visa for Japan and fluency in Japanese. Kudos to the guy for debugging his particular problem, but that doesn’t make a product.
- grenoire 6y agoHis practical business solution to it is quite sensible and likely overlooked: "Matt also believes that Canon could have designed the camera to dump the heat toward the bottom of the camera and then sold a separate base attachment for videographers that provides vastly extended recording times." In the video he more specifically describes how it could be possible to use the mounting point's metal base to transmit heat to a mounted cooling attachment.
- Rillen 6y agoIts quite clear that canon engineeres or managers are aware how to build it like this. I haven't even started watching this video and had the same thought of transporting the heat through the bottom. Whatever made canon made it like this, was on purpose. Either the concentrated on picture for the most time and realized to late and it would have required rebuilding core parts and not getting it out in time or they will bring out a camera/pro version to this with unlimited 8k recording and with a higher price. The assumption that a hobby engineer can solve this issue while canon can't, is not realistic. Based alone on the original firmware approach, i would argue that time or priority was the issue.
- 6y ago
- Triv888 6y agorecall coming up for this $4,000 camera?
- cghendrix 6y agoYeah I’m in awe that this is considered acceptable that the camera just can’t record video more than 20 minutes for all the money you pay.
- chrismorgan 6y ago20 minutes at 8K. At lower sizes, it’s not such a problem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_EOS_R5#Overheating_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_EOS_R5#Overheating_issue...
- Triv888 6y agobut you probably can get a $100 camera that can do 4k videos (I got a 1080p video camera for $30 5 years ago)... I would expect a $4,000 camera to be able to do 8k reliably...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lhoff 6y agoThe resolution is not everything. Compression and bitrate matters as well. No $100 Camera is able to handle that bitrate. Raw 8k results in 2.6 Gbps. That is not something that a small and low prower CPU can process. And thats what causing the heat. I checked for a 100€ 4k action cam and tried to find out the bitrate they use. I found none where it was specified but this one https://www.goxtreme-action-cams.com/de/goxtreme-manta-4k/ https://www.goxtreme-action-cams.com/de/goxtreme-manta-4k/ requires at least a U3 class SD card. That means 30MB/s so 240mbps. And thats what causing the heat. Canon could of course but a better cooler into the camera but that was either a economic decision to protect their professional camera gear, a a design decision to keep the case small or a mix of both.
- lhoff 6y agoThe guys a linustechtips watercooled one of their Red Helium 8k Cameras. And the actually did cool the sensor itself and not the processor. Its a video series but the final assembly and test is shown here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEUCNh5g-2I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEUCNh5g-2I
- eru 6y agoWith that name, they should have liquid-helium-cooled them.
- nvahalik 6y agoIIRC, they had to be careful not to _overcool_ the sensor because the sensors have an acceptable range in which they work. Anyway, the entire series of videos is pretty fun to watch.
- CrazyStat 6y agoI have a friend who does amateur astrophotography and talks a lot about modifying DSLRs to cool the sensor and things like that. I never listen very carefully because I'm never going to devote the time and money the hobby requires, but I take it there's a dedicated community that does this kind of thing.
- codeulike 6y agoActual hacker news. This is really interesting though, in the context of Camera companies like Canon having to adapt to the digital age, and users expectations of what digital devices should be capable of.
- Jnr 6y agoCanon is well adapted to digital age. They simply sell much much more expensive professional gear that can do the unlimited 8K recording. If they were to add this feature to R5 out of the box, they could see reduced pro gear sales.
- Exmoor 6y agoThey don't, actually. The R5 is the first, and currently only, Canon camera that records in 8k. They do have a line of cinema cameras, but all max out at 4K currently. Likely because they use the smaller Super 35mm sensor to match the film size film folks are familiar with.
- Nexxxeh 6y agoThis whole human malware business meant getting decent webcams and Camlinks (HDMI capture devices) extremely difficult and/or expensive for a while. Logitech C920 were particularly difficult and expensive to get, which long lead times. So in April, Canon came out with a utility enabling use of many EOS (and three Powershot) cameras as high quality USB webcams.
- Agentlien 6y agoThis reminds me of a loosely related tale. In 2008 I was hired by a game studio to build a HW/SW system for synchronizing a Canon EOS 1D Mark III and a series of studio flashes. The idea was to use its ability to take ten pictures a second to take a rapid succession of images with very different lighting. The images were then processed by a series of tools I'd helped develop the previous year. The timeline was pretty tight, so I had to begin development before I had the camera. I contacted Canon support to confirm that the 10 pics per second was only when given a continuous signal and to ask which speeds it could reach when taking separate pictures via remote trigger. Their support tech insisted it was irrelevant since I couldn't possibly press the button that fast. I tried, to no avail, to explain that it was a computer sending the signal and it could do so (with the hardware I had) a thousand times per second. Reluctantly, he forwarded the question to their technical support, who never answered. I ended up using a continuous signal and having my program listen to the remote flash connector. It worked splendidly.
- sroussey 6y agoI’m curious to see what the visual effect ended up being. Any link to an example?
- numpad0 6y agoSounds like a 3D capture rig than visual effects.
- Agentlien 6y agoThat's correct. I can't say too much about the details. It ended up working really well but wasn't used in production for reasons of internal politics. The guy who had the original idea for the system, a former classmate of mine, later went on to start his own company, Quixel, based on similar ideas.
- cbozeman 6y ago> wasn't used in production for reasons of internal politics In other words, some insecure shithead's ego got stepped on and he couldn't handle it. I guess it could have been a woman, but since women are higher in trait agreeableness, I doubt it.
- tlb 6y agoAt least some such cameras were limited to less than 30 minutes, because EU tariffs classified something that could record for more than 30 minutes as a video camera, which had a higher import duty. Source: https://www.borrowlenses.com/blog/video-recording-limits-in-mirrorless-and-dslr-cameras/ https://www.borrowlenses.com/blog/video-recording-limits-in-... Having the camera overheat seems like a clumsy way to do it, though. The time limit would depend on ambient temperature and manufacturing variance in the heat sink.
- amiga-workbench 6y agoThis limitation applies to my Sony A6000 too, thankfully there is a software hack to unlock an unlimited recording time. https://github.com/ma1co/OpenMemories-Tweak https://github.com/ma1co/OpenMemories-Tweak
- spuz 6y agoThat EU tariff was scrapped some time in around July 2019. The R5 was never sold with such a recording limit (4k 30fps has always been unlimited even with the overheating issues and old firmware). Some new cameras are still being sold with the 30 minute limit so you have to watch out for that if you are looking at another camera.
- ekianjo 6y agoThis is not specific to Canon by the way, even smaller cameras like the newest RX-100s from Sony have limitations on taking high resolution videos because of overheating.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dbspin 6y agoWonder if you have a link to this. I've tried researching it before, and all I could find was internal discussions of the intention to remove the tariff, no codification into legislation.
- ehejsbbejsk 6y agoI would like to see a modular full frame sensor connected to iOS. Can I dream?
- jsjohnst 6y agoA friend of mine and I were working on building exactly that, but unfortunately he died last year and I don’t have the funding on my own to continue building it.
- ansgri 6y agoSony made steps in this direction with ILCE-QX1, and with their current compact full-frame ILC progress they could decide to reboot that product line. Would be interesting to have a compact photo/video powerhouse out of that lens-style camera with direct connection to iPad Pro. Though they are notoriously bad on the third-party integration side.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hourislate 6y agoThis was super interesting. I've torn apart some video cards and laptops (Mac/Intel) to redo the cooling assembly. Just simply applying better thermal paste makes things run a lot cooler. This example of a Camera was awesome and a great hack to unlock some serious value.
- cbanek 6y ago"Matt also believes that Canon could have designed the camera to dump the heat toward the bottom of the camera and then sold a separate base attachment for videographers that provides vastly extended recording times." Seriously, this. I wonder if they could make the area around threaded screw on the bottom for attaching to tripods a heat spreader. These are usually made out of metal already, and have to be structurally sound for the camera to be attached there. If the attached base was a block of aluminum or copper, it could probably suck the heat out of there.
- nabilhat 6y agoI had the same thought at the first picture. There's already a great big slab of metal visible at the base of the camera with what looks like an easy access path from the processor. If these easy DIY heat sinks catch on, someone's bound to make a longer heat sink, bend the end over in a vise, and tuck it in alongside that existing mass of metal to incorporate it into the heat sink mass. The copper alone doubled the time to overheat, adding that much mass should do substantially more, and almost certainly provide a heat path to tripod mounts.
- jdhn 6y agoWhenever I read something like this, I think how despite the rise of the smartphone camera that's good for 99.9% of people, it still seems like there's still a lot of opportunity to improve traditional point and shoot digital cameras. It almost makes you wish that some of these companies (Canon, Sony, etc) put some more research into some sort of skunkworks that could completely reimagine the form of the camera in a way that would greatly benefit the user.
- Balgair 6y agoIn the end, it comes down to the optics. The (incredible) tiny sensors in smartphones aren't big enough to get past a certain fidelity. Combined with very small working ranges on the lenses and the limits are pretty hard. Hence the three lens set-ups now on the newer models. Granted, the optics here are just the coolest things. 'Digital' lenses are some very slick stuff and the engineering is the best you can get. But in the end, you just need longer working distances and bigger lenses. The optical physics are just the laws you have to deal with, same as Newton had to. No amount of engineering can get past them. One thing they could do is to put a 'periscope'-like mount on the side, have the sensors slide up and down inside, and slot in a few lenses based on the optics. But the mechanics and likely slow speed of such a device would wear-out very fast and would be very susceptible to drops and dings.
- nippoo 6y agoDespite this being uncommon in consumer video cameras, it's pretty standard to see this in long-exposure astrophotography setups - not to prevent overheating, but to reduce sensor noise. Some setups use Peltier or even cryocoolers to get to very low temperatures, but plenty of commercial CCD modules have water-cooling loops built in, eg https://www.atik-cameras.com/product/atik-11000/ https://www.atik-cameras.com/product/atik-11000/
- robin_reala 6y agoHow do you stop condensation on the sensor? Sealed chambers?
- JonathonW 6y agoThat particular model says it uses heater elements to prevent condensation on the outside glass, and a high-efficiency desiccant to prevent condensation internally on the sensor itself.
- minimalc 6y agoYes, I work with CCD and SCMOS cameras and many of our sensors are cooled via Peltier cooling in a vacuum sealed chamber[1]. I have seen condensation on the sensor window due to vacuum failure before. [1] https://andor.oxinst.com/learning/view/article/ultravac https://andor.oxinst.com/learning/view/article/ultravac
- voldacar 6y agoAbout how much does a CCD like that cost?
- bufferoverflow 6y agoHe is not cooling the sensor though. He is cooling the CPU.
- dukeofdoom 6y agoI have the compact g7x mark iii, and its terrible at overheating when shooting 4k. After 4-7 minutes of shooting 4k 24p, it overheats. Its terrible at autofocus, and exposure too. And its not even cheap, $700 latest Canon compact camera. They need to do something about the overheating issues, because much smaller phones don't have these problems. And apple can now do 4k 60p, and colors are pretty good.
- arriu 6y agoFor anyone interested, the astrophotography guys on centralds.net have been doing similar things for a while now. If you're looking to accomplish something similar, they might be able to help you out. Additionally, there are lots of people doing similar diy mods to DSLR cameras on youtube for astrophotography, usually with sub-zero cooling capabilities.
- perardi 6y agoI am generally not of a conspiratorial mindset, but in the very particular case of these photography-centric cameras, I can’t help but wonder if these video features are purposefully subpar so as to not steal market share away from their more expensive cinema cameras. The real reason is probably much more along the lines of “oh, that’ll be a nice bullet point to have on the marketing site, let’s throw it in and not really test it that much in the field”, but still, leaves a bad taste in the customer’s mouth.
- tgb 6y agoApparently at least some of the limitations are actually due to an EU import tax on video recorders but not on cameras. [1] Though this also says that that will be fixed in 2019, so I don't know what the current situation is. [1] https://www.borrowlenses.com/blog/video-recording-limits-in-mirrorless-and-dslr-cameras/ https://www.borrowlenses.com/blog/video-recording-limits-in-...
- sschueller 6y agoManufacturers usually just disable or limit features to get around this in markets like the EU. For example you can not sell a new device that has FM only radio without support for DAB. So many manufacturers of mp3 players etc. disable the FM radio feature firmware for those markets.
- perardi 6y agoThat’s well known, and not what I am thinking about. More like… • Dumb frame rates. • Lack of good flat color profiles. • Lack of clean HDMI output. • Dumb codecs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 6y agoThere are so many things about a photo camera that can record video that makes a a workflow PITA for video only shoots. The small form factor alone makes these cameras difficult. There's no rooms for buttons to easily adjust settings. You get at best a single micro-HDMI port. Yes, it is getting better with all of the 3rd party devices that have been created to specifically address the fact that the form factor is so small it would be impossible to use without them. These cameras and their smaller form factor do lend to some very interesting things though, so please don't think I'm crapping on them. Their prices also make them nearly disposable for decent budget shoots meaning much more interesting shots can be captured. TL;DR Big video cameras have their places that smaller photo-centric cameras can't replace.
- jeffbee 6y agoWhen is Apple going to buy one of these struggling camera makers? They could pick up Olympus for nothing and ship a camera with a real CPU in it, and maybe even software that doesn't make you cry.
- _fzslm 6y agothey -really- want to push iPhone (particularly Pro + Pro Max) as their camera. it even has Wi-Fi, mobile data and iMovie, so you can shoot video, edit it wherever you are, then push to Instagram/YouTube/whatever else. i say when pigs fly. (sadly.)
- samatman 6y agoThey really want to push AirPods too (to the point where even the iPads no longer have a headphone jack, which is absurd), but they also have Beats, because sometimes you need/want more sound than wee little earbuds can give you. Doing something analogous with cameras isn't an impossibility. It's not even going to cannibalize iPhone sales; the opposite if anything, although I'd imagine most people who are serious about shooting video on their phone have a 12 Pro in their pocket already. But mostly, it would give an obvious upgrade path to get into cinema-quality and real lenses, for customers who cut their teeth on what the iPhone has to offer. It's a natural fit for Apple, although I think I understand why they haven't: it's hard for that company to get out of bed for less than a million units sold, of anything.
- samatman 6y agoFrom your mouth to Tim's ear! I picked up a Sony this year, and I'm very pleased with the quality of the photos and video I'm able to achieve. The software is a constant, grating annoyance. It feels like being transported 15 years into the past, and (this one is Apple's fault), I have to pick my video format carefully if I want to import onto my iPad, which generally, I do. Everything, from the menu, to importing, remote control, all of it: it just doesn't work great, the ergonomics are terrible. Great camera though. Just a terrible computer.
- fomine3 6y agoApple made R&D facility on Tsunashima, Japan and they hiring engineers from camera industry.
- sneak 6y agoI have a Sony RX1r (have had both mk1 and mk2) and it does the same thing recording high bitrate 1080. How the hell are companies allowed to sell a video recording feature where it only records for a short period of time before just shutting down?! If you sold a car like this there would be lawsuits.
- lxe 6y agoI highly recommend DIY Perks YouTube channel. Check out other videos, like the artificial sun and the DIY projector.
- fomine3 6y agoDIY Perks is a channel what I love. I suggest to check other videos.
- jojobas 6y ago>Canon responded to the controversy by pushing out a firmware update that changes how the R5 monitors internal temperatures. This is the most spectacular part of the story. No marketing department could have come up with a better plot.
- causality0 6y agoCanon responded to the controversy by pushing out a firmware update that changes how the R5 monitors internal temperatures. -his R5 suddenly seemingly had no recording time limit This is the most impressive bit to me. If this were something like a smartphone I would expect the update to remove the ability to reset the timer, not change the whole scheme to be more user-friendly. It's refreshing to see a manufacturer who doesn't respond to hobbyists with outright hostility.
- jolux 6y agoThe R5 is a pro-tier camera, and Canon established its market-leading position through good technology and exceptional customer service. They would be throwing away a stellar reputation for little gain if they didn’t try to make the camera work the best that it possibly can within its limitations.
- chungus_khan 6y agoIt's an important distinction that is often obscured by the number of products that aren't professional equipment/software, and don't have this kind of attitude, but affix the word "Pro" to their consumer product line for marketing reasons.
- wooptoo 6y agoThis is the same chap who built Archimede's death ray in his bedroom. That video was even more impressive. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6bqBsHSwPgw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6bqBsHSwPgw
- tus88 6y ago> Matt decided to use a thin strip of copper to pull heat away from the processor Errr...this ain't watercooling man.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoIs the dark magic pocket camera is actually internal perri cool? And many astro as well.
- jacquesm 6y agoThe original video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X1u-9YqrIJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X1u-9YqrIJc
- aikinai 6y agoI've been using my mirrorless camera as a webcam while working from home and it overheats after a while. I solved the issue by laying an ice pack on top of it before long meetings.