4 ms·
That's routine cost of business. Humble Bundle takes 25% of sale revenue, just for the distribution and marketing, and companies are queuing up to work with the
by simonh 6y ago
That's routine cost of business. Humble Bundle takes 25% of sale revenue, just for the distribution and marketing, and companies are queuing up to work with them. Steam also takes 30%. Both of these are for software you run on your computer.
In fact Steam kills the whole "Apple store is a gouge" premise stone dead. It literally is just a distribution mechanism on desktop computers, where you absolutely can side load apps and games as much as you like, and they're still considered very much worth 30% by the market.
There's a reasonable discussion to be had about side-loading on iOS, that's a separate issues, but the idea that the App Store cut is unreasonable in the market is clearly bogus.
- donmcronald 6y agoHumble Bundle seems like a good deal. They have a built in audience and you’re guaranteed visibility / promotion. The other 2 are a total scam unless you get put on a featured page. What’s the value of being alongside 1 million other apps with terrible discoverability? Developers still have to do all their own promotion and drive customers to the platform for purchase, but then Steam or Apple get 30 % for ringing through the transaction. IMO those 30% fees would drop to 10% very quickly if there were competition.
- simonh 6y agoIf Steam is a scam, why do developers choose to be on it, when PCs are an open platform?
- rimiform 6y agoBecause they're the best scam in town! I'm assuming it depends on the developer, though. Some are on Itch instead, mostly very indie devs.
- donmcronald 6y agoThey’re the victims of demand aggregation commoditizing the supply side of the market. It’s not so much a choice as it is a requirement to access the market. I think if developers set their price and Steam listed their 30% as a “Steam Fee” you’d see outraged gamers.
- dwild 6y agoThat's what happens when you get a huge portion of the market and get close to a monopoly. You could ask many Steam user what Steam got that others platforms doesn't, and most will say that it's because everything is on there. We prefer to use a single product instead of multiples, thus you choose Steam not because it's superior in any ways, simply because it's the default choice. Epic Store had to give games for free to start being considered.
- jldugger 6y ago> you choose Steam not because it's superior in any ways, simply because it's the default choice. Well, how many platforms even run on linux?
- PoignardAzur 6y agoIt's not just that everything is on there. There's also the review system, the workshops, automatic updates, easy browsing, communities, friend lists, customer service (getting refunds is easier than on any other platform) etc. The competing platforms biggest problems is that they assume that all they need to do is set up a HTTP server to download games from and add a few discounts/exclusives to get a customer base. But their UX is miles behind what Steam offers.
- ece 6y agoSteam doesn't force a payment provider for in-app purchases unless a user chooses to pay out of the Steam wallet and a developer has added support for it. Quite a few F2P games on Steam collect credit cards unlike what Apple/Google allow developers to do. Steam also has a ton of social network features like chat/communities/etc.. and they support multiple platforms. They also reduce their cut to 25% and 20% above $10 million and $50 million respectively. Developers and users are completely free to use or not use Steam, GoG, Epic, Itch.io, or others. Quite a few developers do pre-orders on Humble, and then sell on Steam, etc.. You're stuck with Apple/Google TOS for the vast majority of apps regardless if you're the developer or user. Epic couldn't possibly bring the same lawsuits against Steam, maybe the consoles, but even they allow different in-app purchase payment providers (F2P games collecting credit cards again) and subsidize the consoles quite a bit at the start of each cycle.
- iamacyborg 6y ago> In fact Steam kills the whole "Apple store is a gouge" premise stone dead. It literally is just a distribution mechanism on desktop computers, where you absolutely can side load apps and games as much as you like, and they're still considered very much worth 30% by the market. Are they? Look at how insane the backlash from the gaming community has been over Epic opening their own store, or how gamers acted when EA opened up Origin. Steam also provides significantly more for their 30% than Apple/Google do for their storefronts.
- ralfd 6y agoApple/Google are providing the whole operating system and API development and in Googles case access to billions of devices and in Apples case 250 MB cloud storage per app user for developers (up to 1 Petabyte) and piracy protection.
- ece 6y agoThe OS and APIs are part of the device users paid for. DRM for piracy protection can be had by any developer on any platform now a days, just look at Netflix. A person in charge of the Apple App Store told the US Congress it takes ~$100 million to run the App Store[1]. That's about $5/developer/year instead of $99/developer/year that Apple charges. [1] Page 345: https://judiciary.house.gov/uploadedfiles/competition_in_digital_markets.pdf https://judiciary.house.gov/uploadedfiles/competition_in_dig...
- votepaunchy 6y agoUsers don’t buy APIs. There are a small number of first party apps but iOS and Android provide considerable functionality specifically for developers.
- ece 6y agoThe User/Developer distinction is completely arbitrary. Any user can download Xcode/Android Studio and develop for their device which has the same libraries installed as an SDK including analytics/debugging/ads and such. Google used to charge developers a one time $25 fee, and Apple could charge as little as $5/developer/year to cover everything related to the App Store. The Swift compiler is common across a few Apple devices, and the device buyers are paying for that.
- danielrpa 6y agoIt's interesting that the top distribution channels charge exactly the same 30%. One would imagine that they would try to compete and start offering lower rates to undercut rivals like Epic (which is much smaller than Steam/Apple/Microsoft/Google as a distribution channel) is doing. The situation here is like all air major travel companies charging exactly the same for tickets for a given route and then justifying that by saying they offer a great value to customers.
- m4rtink 6y agoSounds like a cartel. ;-)
- gsich 6y agoNobody wants to change that, it's a hidden cartel.
- simonh 6y agoMaybe that exact competitive dynamic has driven prices down to 30%. After all, the dynamic you describe has to end somewhere. It can’t just keep pushing down to zero and all the competitors in the market need to be competitive on price.
- mrep 6y ago> In fact Steam kills the whole "Apple store is a gouge" premise stone dead. It literally is just a distribution mechanism on desktop computers, where you absolutely can side load apps and games as much as you like, and they're still considered very much worth 30% by the market. Except we also have off the top of my head / quick google search EA origin, bethesda game launcher, rockstar game launcher, ubisoft uplay, blizzard battlenet, and Epic game launcher all of which were almost certainly built because it is cheaper to just write your own distribution software and market your games yourself than give steam such a big cut once you reach a certain scale.
- pixel_fcker 6y agoAnd all of them are universally loathed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- m00x 6y agoIt's fair for Steam to charge that additional 25-30% since you have a choice to use it or not to reach that audience. If you become popular, you can de-list yourself off of Steam, and continue running on your website for free. The issue isn't that the app store takes 30% of your purchases to manage payments. If I'm a startup, I don't wanna deal with all of this complexity, so I'm all for it. What bothers me is that they control everything that's allowed on your phone. If you want to target iPhone users, you have no choice but to go through them. App stores are great, but forcing companies to go through them is bad. Allow people to plug in their phones and install apps from their computer. Easy solution, Google phones already allow this with some technical know-how. Allow other app stores on your phones.