6 ms·
Just the sheer number of people calling for Twitter, Youtube, Facebook, etc to censor others is remarkable to me. I came of age during a time when we on the le
by freedomben 6y ago
Just the sheer number of people calling for Twitter, Youtube, Facebook, etc to censor others is remarkable to me.
I came of age during a time when we on the left believed fiercely in personal freedoms, especially freedom of speech. We would blast music that would say things like, "F--k you I won't do what you tell me." [1]
Now the same left I loved can't erupt in protest fast enough when social media aren't censoring idiots. We used to all know that censoring of anybody was wrong, but also that it didn't work. Censoring was what corporations and authoritarian states did to people, and we hated it.
That's just one example of the change people have gone through.
[1] https://genius.com/Rage-against-the-machine-killing-in-the-name-lyrics https://genius.com/Rage-against-the-machine-killing-in-the-n...
- post_below 6y agoI see freedom of speech as a right that should be preserved at almost all costs. And also, step back a bit and look at the state of digitally distributed disinformation. We've elected politicians that look like characters from an absurdist satire, loony conspiracy theories are going mainstream, climate change isn't real, the pandemic is a lie, a significant percentage of the US population thinks the presidental election was completely fraudulent... and so on. Misinformation is a problem that genuinely threatens society. I'd love to think that if you let people figure things out for themselves they'll eventually manage it. That they'll eventually stop believing wild claims based on no evidence. But we don't have time to test that theory. Should the big platforms have the power over the digital public square that they do? Definitely not. But they do have it. Pressuring them to deal with misinformation is something I completely support. The alternative is tech illiterate legislation because the misinformation problem isn't going to go away on it's own.
- artificialLimbs 6y ago"Misinformation is a problem that genuinely threatens society." Misinformation is magnitudes of order less dangerous than restricting free speech. The antidote to bad speech is more (hopefully good) speech, not less speech. I like to be able to spot the idiots and know who they are and where they stand, not to put them underground where they inevitably fester into violence in their bubbles.
- XorNot 6y agoThis is laughable. If propaganda and advertising don't work, then why is everyone so invested in creating it?
- pitay 6y agoThis is laughable. If propaganda and advertising don't work, then why is everyone so invested in creating it? The people creating propaganda are also interested in enforcing censorship if they are in the position to do so. Propaganda and censorship work far better together than individually for groups that want to brainwash society into certain beliefs.
- XorNot 6y agoI guess we all imagined that multi-billion dollar advertising industry then...
- pitay 6y agoI need more context or detail to understand the point you a trying to get at. I really do, because otherwise I am just trying to guess what you mean, or even how it correlates to what I said at all. Without further clarification, it seems to be tangential to me.
- XorNot 6y agoWho is "they"? Who apparently represents all global advertising interests, and also represents all who desire to censorship for any reason?
- pitay 6y agoI still don't understand what you are saying. When you say "Who is "they"?". Are you saying Google and other tech giants? They have huge advertising networks. But that is a total guess since what you are saying is still very unclear. It looks like you don't want to be clear about this. I'd really prefer you to just say it, rather than all this cryptic stuff. But since you go on about advertising, that is a way for groups that want it, is to be able to force people to listen to their message. This robs people of their agency to listen to what they choose to. Censorship also doesn't allow people to listen to what they choose to. This makes advertising and censorship very alike. They both result in a persons loss of freedom to choose what information they get.
- lenkite 6y agoI don't trust the folks who tag information as "misinformation". I would rather that be left to my research and judgement.
- flippinburgers 6y agoGood luck holding this worldview on places like twitter. I feel like certain kinds of individuals think that they have social momentum on their "side" which brings out their true colors: they don't care. In other words they feel that they are "winning". They are the insufferable authoritarians that polluted the right many years ago in their rigid thinking but they are now a very vocal minority on the left. At least I hope they are a minority but I wonder. The internet has made outcomes immediate. The internet has also removed the human element of social interaction. I think these two mix in a terrible way. I have no idea what can or should be done about it though.
- tacitusarc 6y agoIt's not a right or left thing. The natural human tendency, the base state, is fundamentally tribal in nature and the objective is to win, to beat the other tribes. The recent push to censor and silence dissent isn't an anomaly: the several hundreds years post enlightenment that gave us the ideas of individual rights and freedoms were the anomaly. I also do not believe anyone advocating the censoring of others has been themselves censored, or put in a minority position where they were afraid to express dissent. Because if you have that experience, it tends to give one a dim view of censorship.
- atq2119 6y agoThe natural human tendency, the base state, is fundamentally tribal in nature [citation needed] The problem with your statement isn't the claim that tribal behaviours are a natural tendency in humans. Of course they are. The problem is your claim that they are somehow primary. There are many other tendencies of comparable weight, and how strongly they are expressed relative to each other depends very much on the individual. Not to mention that when it comes to tribal instincts, there's a huge difference between individuals as to what they perceive their tribe to be. Their nuclear family? Their town/state/country? Their profession? Participants in their hobby? Their "race"? All of humanity?
- tomnipotent 6y ago
- cycomanic 6y agoI think it's not so easy. I think it's first important to remember that the concept of freedom of speech is not an end goal by itself. It was always just a tool for people to be able to point out unfairness/wrong things in society. It was deemed necessary for criticism to be able to done freely for improvements to society to be possible. Now what we are seeing with social media platforms (and I ould argue it started already earlier with the raise of fox news) at the moment is that we see that there are elements of society who found that facts and truth don't matter and freedom of speech doesn't matter if you have big enough pockets and use the right psychological strategies. Essentially the way society and particulary social media is set up is, that the richest voice gets heard (at least by some people) and the truth of what is being said is not important anymore. In other words the platform are used for controlling us (not by the government, but vested interests) and destroying society, freedom of speech is not helping against this if anything it's a hindrance because it assumes all speech is equal, which it isn't. I don't have a solution and I would like a way to defend us without destroying freedom of speech, but I don't have a good solution. Also these platforms have been "censoring" for a long time, nobody was batting an eyelid when Isis accounts and videos were removed. In fact many of the outlets who are now screaming about censorship were shouting that twitter et al. were not doing enough. That tells you a lot about howmuch they care about freedom of speech.
- michaelmrose 6y agoWe didn't censor the peddlers of not so much alternative opinions as elaborate hate fueled fantasies in which real people feature as alternative versions of themselves dressed in pedophile drag which are conspiring against the rest of us and if you visit the places where these degenerates congregate they happily talk about how people guilty of imaginary crimes ought to be imprisoned or murdered. Some of them have taken the cues and actually committed such murders. The problem is there is money and importance to be earned by trivial to construct lies that a functioning marketplace of ideas would trivially discard but it turns out ours really doesn't work so well and freedom without responsibility is a clusterfuck. We let the liars run wild and ended up with a reality TV star killing hundreds of thousands of people with his incompetence and working hard to start a war that would kill hundreds of thousands more in the last days of his regime. Perhaps visualize every one of those corpses stacked one in a reeking pile and realize that censorship may be the lesser of two evils.
- freedomben 6y agoThere is far more censoring of much more mainstream opinions than you seem to realize. If it was just the crazies you are talking about I would mostly agree. It's not.
- michaelmrose 6y agoCan you give me an example please?
- freedomben 6y agoYes definitely, I was on mobile earlier otherwise I would have. The New York Post had a major story censored a few weeks ago. I have no love for the NYP (I think they sensationalize news), but they are not some scummy right wing conspiracy machine. I pretty much agree with Glenn Greenwald here: https://theintercept.com/2020/10/15/facebook-and-twitter-cross-a-line-far-more-dangerous-than-what-they-censor/ https://theintercept.com/2020/10/15/facebook-and-twitter-cro... They also suspended an account of a sitting state senator in Pennsylvania who was holding a hearing on alleged election fraud: https://www.ntd.com/twitter-suspends-account-of-state-senator-who-called-pennsylvania-election-hearing_533067.html https://www.ntd.com/twitter-suspends-account-of-state-senato...