4 ms·
One big issue I have with N95s is that there's no standardization in sizes. So, while I'm fit-tested for a particular manufacturer's model, it probably won't be
by Scoundreller 6y ago
One big issue I have with N95s is that there's no standardization in sizes. So, while I'm fit-tested for a particular manufacturer's model, it probably won't be available to the general public for a long time.
I found some other NIOSH N95s recently at a hardware store, but... they seem to be made with a contractor's facial structure in mind.
- codewithcheese 6y agoYep it seems the public did not understand people have different size and shape faces until we all started wearing masks. Just by looking at some masks you can guess which gender the were design by/for, but they are advertised as one size fits all.
- amf12 6y agoAgreed, but fit is more important for hospital and laboratory staff. For general public unfitted N95 like this is still better than some random cloth mask I think.
- clort 6y agoA ICU nurse I know says that every time a new brand/type of mask appears the whole hospital is fitted to ensure that they know who can wear which masks safely. If the mask does not seal, then it was probably a waste of time to have an N95 specification. Facial hair is not allowed; even stubble can interfere with the fit.
- burke 6y agoAnd this totally makes sense for people who are in known dangerous conditions and are relying on the mask operating at peak performance. Lots of people are in the situation of thinking of an N95 mask as an “upgrade” compared to a surgical or cloth mask for grocery shopping, etc. Early in the pandemic there was this line of thinking as if an N95 mask was 100% useless if it didn’t form a perfect seal. This is obviously untrue, and it’s clearly a step up from a surgical mask even with some minor facial hair! How much of a step up is a totally different question and like you touched on it’s quite possible that it’s not worth the extra hassle and discomfort.
- bmdavi3 6y agoDefinitely! I have a beard. A surgical mask fits only lightly over it, floating a half inch away from my face. That's better than nothing I suppose, but it really is only filtering big droplets. All the air is going in and out that half inch. An N95, with it's rigid faceplate and strong rubber bands pressing it against my face, crushes the beard and makes breathing more difficult so I can tell some air is being filtered. I'm not getting anywhere near the protection the n95 is designed to provide, it's still much better than what the surgical mask does, which is almost nothing. And I don't use the valve kind, so any filtering the n95 is doing, it's doing it in both directions. The surgical mask with a beard is kind of like walking around with my hand held a half inch away from my face.
- derefr 6y ago> The surgical mask with a beard is kind of like walking around with my hand held a half inch away from my face. Yeah, but that'd still be better than nothing, too. (As would be a face-shield worn without a mask.) In both cases, the main goal of getting regular people to wear masks isn't to contain exhaled droplets, but to lower the forward velocity of exhaled droplets, so they don't slam right into other people's mucous membranes, but rather have time to get caught in HVAC systems or dispersed into outdoor air. The faster the droplets are moving when they exit your mouth/nose (e.g. a sneeze or a cough), the less they're going to be able to "turn" to get out the sides of your mask. Masks are very good at stopping sneezes/coughs from contaminating the air, even when badly fit. That, and masks/face-shields/your own hand/etc. also protect you when someone sneezes or coughs directly "at" your face. Like the sneeze-guard at a buffet. It's not complete protection — the particles, once airborne, can drift "around" the barrier and come in — but it does appreciably lower contamination compared to having nothing there (presuming that people will be sneezing/coughing/breathing directly "at" your face/the buffet. Not a concern for most people; but this is why people in hospitality are wearing the face-shields.) > All the air is going in and out that half inch. Out, almost certainly (except for forceful expulsions, as above), but if you're breathing through your nose — and the mask is shaped to surround your nose — then even if it's a half-inch from your nose, at least some of your inhaled air will be coming in through the mask. Even if it feels like all of it's coming in through the gap in the mask. So there will be some fractional protection from that. Also, I believe high-grade masks are somewhat adsorbant — airborne droplets just like sticking to them if they rub up against them, rather than staying airborne. So a good mask can "passively" scrub the air you're breathing in, even if that air is coming in "around" the mask instead of "through" it! (This is only a small effect, though, and shouldn't be relied on. I'm trying to list the reasons mask-wearing is better than nothing, not trying to justify intentionally wearing your mask less-well-fitted than you could.)