4 ms·
This is really cool from a tech perspective. I’m sure it’s a great product too. The thing that bothers me about e-bikes in the US specifically is that we seem
by mulmen 6y ago
This is really cool from a tech perspective. I’m sure it’s a great product too. The thing that bothers me about e-bikes in the US specifically is that we seem to be rediscovering scooters but worse.
Among other things I am a motorcycle rider. I took the class. Before the pandemic I commuted on a 1970 Honda CB450. I know the risks, and the rules.
These are mopeds at best. Electric motorcycles at worst. Europe and especially Asia already understand the benefits of scooters and traffic understands they exist. Taiepi even has special striping at lights to make scooter filtering safe and easy!
I am optimistic that these kinds of devices will get more people on two-wheeled personal transportation but I’m concerned about the people going 30mph on bike paths or riding in the road with no education.
Tangentially I’m disappointed that electric drive has translated to “no rules” on roads and bike paths. If I ride a 1980 Yamaha moped on a bike path people will look at me like I’m a maniac but I can go 50% faster on a bicycle and nobody seems to care.
- closeparen 6y agoClass 1 ebikes go no faster than an athletic cyclist would (20mph), and most bike lanes / paths are restricted to those. Another gambit I've seen that tends to moderate my speed on an ebike is a "green wave" tuned for 13mph. No point going any faster.
- mulmen 6y agoSure but where I live there is precisely zero enforcement of speed or capability. You also have to consider the effect of adding orders of magnitude more “athletic riders” to bike paths. Especially when the new riders are new to the speeds. And when pedestrians are used to having fast cyclists ride in the road, which is the norm here. Ebikes are nothing short of a menace on my local bike path.
- brudgers 6y agoIf the path is mixed with pedestrians, 20mph on a bicycle is irresponsible whether peddling or ebiking.
- closeparen 6y agoIf there are pedestrians it’s a sidewalk, not a bike path, and a bike should not be on it at all unless the rider has dismounted.
- ben-schaaf 6y agoAlmost all cycling paths around my area are mixed bicycle/pedestrian.
- closeparen 6y agoSo there are no cycling paths in your area.
- mulmen 6y agoThat's completely irrelevant. Some cycling paths in my area are mixed pedestrian and cycle. Mostly they are mixed car and cycle. There are a handful of dedicated bike paths but those often have pedestrians on them anyway. Good luck changing that. The semantics of "bike path" are not interesting here. I ride my bike at around 8mph. I don't pass many conventional bicycles. I don't get passed by conventional cycles much either. When I do it is often by someone on an e-bike going twice as fast.
- closeparen 6y agoI think we were raised in very different cycling cultures. I was taught to be embarrassed at much less than 15mph under my own power. Being lazy, I usually rode closer to 11-12 when alone, and the only slower bikes I encountered were small children. Many athletic cyclists zoomed by at 20-25. I was also taught to assert my right of way when I have it, and be deferential when I don’t. So the designation of the path does matter.
- t-writescode 6y agoIt also sounds like you guys exist in different areas. The situation you're completely against is the status quo in Seattle.
- jjav 6y ago> These are mopeds at best. Electric motorcycles at worst. These are very far from that. This LeMond ebike has a 250W motor. Any moderately strong cyclist can put out more than 250W. Very strong riders can do double that. And the motor assists cut off at 20mph. Even a weak cyclist like me (~180W FTP) can trivially do 20mph on a regular bike if the trail is flat so that's hardly a high speed.
- mulmen 6y agoEbikes are awesome. We need more of them. But we need to treat them like what they are, motorcycles. My first moped topped out at 25mph and that was only on flat ground. I never even considered riding it on a bike path. Most cyclists on bike paths are not going 20+ mph without breaking a sweat for 20-30 miles like these ebikes do. People are going to get hurt and it will do further damage to the already tarnished reputation of two wheeled personal transport in the US.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> I am optimistic that these kinds of devices will get more people on two-wheeled personal transportation but I’m concerned about the people going 30mph on bike paths or riding in the road with no education. At 20MPH your turbo assist turns off completely leaving the rider in this weird state where 1MPH slower is easy and 1MPH faster is brutal. If you are going 30MPH anywhere on this, it's because you are a world-class cyclist or are going downhill. People ride on roads with no education all the time, we call them drivers. People going 20MPH on a 30 pound bike aren't dangerous to others. People surfing the web while driving a 6 ton truck are dangerous to everyone. > Tangentially I’m disappointed that electric drive has translated to “no rules” on roads and bike paths. This is literally every form of transportation. There were no/ terrible rules around cars when they came out as well.
- mulmen 6y agoTwo stroke mopeds are not new but I do not see them on bike paths. I do see them in the road. e-bikes that comply with the existing laws have similar capabilities to mopeds yet people ride them on bike paths. Another dimension of this phenomenon is electric cars. Teslas are somehow synonymous with "self-driving" even though they could have the same capabilities with gas motors. Somehow electric motors are translating to "new rules" even though we have existing rules that apply. > At 20MPH your turbo assist turns off completely leaving the rider in this weird state where 1MPH slower is easy and 1MPH faster is brutal. If you are going 30MPH anywhere on this, it's because you are a world-class cyclist or are going downhill. A buddy of mine bought an e-bike this summer that can go 30mph for 30 miles. I see bikes like this on the local bike path regularly. > People ride on roads with no education all the time, we call them drivers. People going 20MPH on a 30 pound bike aren't dangerous to others. People surfing the web while driving a 6 ton truck are dangerous to everyone. What? Where can you drive a car without taking a driving test and getting a license? 30lb bikes going 20mph are absolutely a threat to pedestrians. Inattentive drivers are dangerous but that's entirely irrelevant to this conversation outside of it being a reason people are scared to ride their electric motorcycles in the road.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> What? Where can you drive a car without taking a driving test and getting a license? In the US, driving instruction is basic, and easy to pass and most people have long forgotten it. Trying to suggest they are "Educated" is ridiculous. > 30lb going 20mph bikes are absolutely a threat to pedestrians. Absolute nonsense. The number of pedestrians injured each year by cyclists is tiny, likely zero most years. eBikes don't change this because fundamentally. Cyclists (acoustic or electric) are much more alert than car drivers because if you aren't alert on a bike you get smashed by someone in a car. Cyclists don't hit pedestrians out of self preservation. Hit a pedestrian and it's going to fucking hurt. People in cars hit pedestrians without even noticing.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoEbikes in Europe are limited to 250W and electric power cuts off above 25km/h (15.5mph). Ebikes don't act differently than normal bikes on the road/path. They go the same type of speed, and they are silent. They're not scooters.
- mulmen 6y agoI don't live in Europe. My buddy has an ebike that can go 30mph for 30 miles. I see the same model on the bike path at least a few times a week, often at high speed. The rules are irrelevant to capability. I do own a European car, it is happy to go 120mph on the highway, even if that's not legal anywhere in my country.
- loeg 6y agoDifferent ebikes land in different regulatory classifications. Your buddy's "ebike" is legally a moped (US). Class 3 ebikes can only assist up to 28 mph. The people riding that model on bike paths that do not permit mopeds are breaking the law, just as if they rode any other moped on that path.