6 ms·
> Nothing on the ARM, Qualcomm, or MediaTek roadmap is even close. Don't count on the Mediateks of the world to spend any time on this market. Most of the lic
by gumby 6y ago
> Nothing on the ARM, Qualcomm, or MediaTek roadmap is even close.
Don't count on the Mediateks of the world to spend any time on this market. Most of the licensees are focusing on high volume embedded cases where they an try to drag themselves above the commodity pricing floor by providing a package of SoC and (in my experience crappy) drivers and an android port. In fact "package" is the key word: they typically won't sell you the chip in a useful way (i.e. no data sheets) but instead want to sell you a reference board with ported software running on top.
Apple is unusual in that they have two value add products that matter and have managed to, over time, build the capability to handle it. The economic calculus for them is quite different from that of the merchant chip vendors.
There are a few possible alternatives like Qualcomm and Nvidia (!!) but the market dynamics aren't the same for them.
It is possible that an Nvidia/microsoft relationship could develop somewhat similar to the Intel/Mcrosoft partnership, but unlikely. The market is different and the regulatory environment may become different. Terminal devices (laptops, desktops, phones) aren't really where the money is any more (except for Apple, an exception on several dimensions) so the push for such a partnership is diminished.
More likely is a partnership addressing cloud datacenters between say MS or Amazon and Nvidia, but nobody is going to be willing to allow one chip vendor to have any say over their destiny. It would make sense for one of the top cloud vendors (AWS, Azure, IBM) to buy Nvidia but that would never be allowed.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoAnother option is AMD. Originally they were going to have a Zen variant that ran ARM. They shelved that plan once the x86 version of Zen showed promise, but there are rumours that the plan continues on the back burner. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD_K12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD_K12
- api 6y agoAMD, Nvidia, and Marvell after the Cavium acquisition could do it. Intel could too but wouldn’t unless the x86 market tanked badly.
- m_mueller 6y ago> unless the x86 market tanked badly That has always been a question of when, not if. And M1 shows that it is quickly approaching. In a market where physical limits have slowed down miniaturization, with just 5-10 years away from a standstill, a low efficiency instruction set focused on backwards binary compatibility is going to get washed out of most usecases very quickly. It's going the way of the IBM mainframe - still sold decades after its heyday, but marginalized to a niche (bunch of enterprise cloud instances for software that is too expensive to recompile/port).
- bryanlarsen 6y agoM1's awesomeness has almost nothing to do with the instruction set. AMD64 and ARM64 are very similar in terms of complexity. M1's awesomeness has to do with: - assembling a killer team - 5nm process - high speed, low latency DRAM - big-little The only substantive difference between the AMD64 and ARM64 instruction sets is that ARM64 has a more relaxed memory model.
- api 6y agoNot true from what I’ve read. The problem with x86 is not complexity but variable instruction lengths. This makes it hard to determine instruction boundaries, complicating decoders and making more than 4-way decode hard. M1 has 8 decoders for comparison, and it would be easy to have 100 with ARM if there were a benefit to that many.
- bryanlarsen 6y ago1. AMD64 is a lot easier to decode than the legacy i86 8/16/32 bit instruction set. 2. Decoding took a significant portion of the chip when they were a million transistors. The m1 has 16 billion resistors, decoding is a much less significant fraction of the chip.
- petra 6y ago
- ip26 6y agoDual ISA would be pretty cool. The more I learn about the differences between ARM and x86, the more it starts to seem like it really is not that much of a stretch. Just need the market for it.
- mschuster91 6y agoIn the server market that could actually work, there are virtually no constraints on power or die size there.
- egsmi 6y agoThere are plenty of constraints in the server markets. The primary ones are economic.
- ineedasername 6y agoAt this point it seems more and more that x86 is still around purely due to legacy reasons and path-dependency. Intel's failure to execute on mobile really opened the door for ARM to have tons of resources over a decade thrown into it's development as a platform, and now the M1 is and extremely solid proof of concept that tentative forways into ARM on desktops/laptops/servers will absolutely warrant the shift in platforms. A few years for software ports and an extra 2 generations of chip improvements, and I think Intel's failure to execute on it's fab processes will just become a moot point. I have more confidence in AMD to pivot, and they have their GPU business as well. Intel may be relegated to aging obsolescence the same way HP and IBM did with their "big iron".
- zinekeller 6y ago> Intel may be relegated to aging obsolescence the same way HP and IBM did with their "big iron". Cough cough Itanium is an Intel-HP collaboration cough cough
- ineedasername 6y agoHah, true. That was absolutely the wrong chip at the wrong time, poorly implemented and lacking the software base of other platforms. I have no idea why they built the thing rather than put more resources behind Xeon, which was basically the end result anyway.
- DCKing 6y ago> Originally they were going to have a Zen variant that ran ARM. Was AMD's K12 related to Zen in any way? AMD's predecessor to that, the Opteron A1100 series, was bog standard Cortex A57 cores. I figured K12 would be at best an evolution of a standard ARM design, but if it was more that would be very interesting. Would love to know more about this.
- deaddodo 6y agoIt wasn't a Zen variant; but the K12 was intended to be AMD's custom ARM uArch aimed at the server space. So there's a good chance it would have been focused on performance over power efficiency.
- bitcoinmoney 6y agoIt’s not the ISA that matters. But the execution of the project. Apple just showed it can make fast ARM. Is M1 faster than the latest zen?
- sudosysgen 6y agoNo, it isn't. It's toe-to-toe on single core performance, sometimes faster, but slower in multicore.
- socialdemocrat 6y agoYeah but zen3 only pulls off matching M1 Firestorm by using 60% higher clock frequency and thus running a lot hotter. At same clock frequency t he Zen3 would have been destroyed by the M1
- deeringc 6y agoYes, but Apple also used their financial muscle to secure all of the 5nm capacity from TSMC. We're not comparing apples with apples here.
- ksec 6y ago>Apple also used their financial muscle to secure all of the 5nm capacity from TSMC It would be more accurate to describe Apple was the only customer willing to pay and has enough volume.
- 29083011397778 6y agoIf you mean AMD couldn't match what Apple was willing to pay when you say "Apple was the only customer willing to pay", then absolutely. Otherwise, when push comes to shove in a bidding war with Apple, I don't think AMD really has a chance.
- starfallg 6y agoThat's grossly mis-characterising the relationship between clock speed, performance and power consumption/heat dissipation in chip design.
- kitsunesoba 6y ago> It is possible that an Nvidia/microsoft relationship could develop somewhat similar to the Intel/Mcrosoft partnership, but unlikely. The market is different and the regulatory environment may become different. In addition, I think Nvidia's tendency toward extreme secrecy would quickly become an obstacle.
- rjzzleep 6y agoOK, how is that different from Apple? They replaced all the protocols for keyboard/trackpad communication with their own at some point and it took forever for people to reverse engineer it. Same with the SSD and other components. M1 was shrouded in secrecy and apple tried to ditch all GPL software so that they wouldn't have to upstream anything if they don't want to. Let's at least compare apples to apples. Pun intended.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoThe difference is that Apple is a single company, so secrecy doesn't interfere with product development. Communication happens between the involved internal teams and the magic happens. In the case of collaborations between separate companies, secrecy becomes a problem because inevitably, details that are held close and not communicated turn into stumbling blocks. For a collaboration between Nvidia and Microsoft for instance, the teams at Microsoft involved with the project would need the same level of access to Nvidia's half as Nvidia's employees do in order to be as effective as Apple's internal teams have been. This isn't impossible of course, but historically Nvidia is not inclined to do things like this.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoFirm is NOT market. In fact fir property right economics why firm exist is a big study area. Why such contractual transaction is efficient compared with free market. (May be it is not as open source “economy” has organised transaction that is not possible with firms. And firms does cooperate.) The question further is this model extended to say china. Many things happened in china was closed to outside. Not much as a secret but more like a big firm operate cheaply in a world economy. Would others compete or like apple others have to follow inline to get the supply. One wonder.
- bredren 6y agoAll major tech has a new existential threat. Once Apple begins replacing its data centers with Apple Silicon chips it will create unbeatable economies in services. The rest of faang must find a way to catch up. They will already pay huge amounts in the meantime giving Apple even greater latitude to win coming new markets. There’s also clear opportunity for Apple to enable developers with cheaper services than other providers. This is a major issue for Amazon and Microsoft.
- GiorgioG 6y ago> Apple Silicon chips it will create unbeatable economies in services. Except Apple generally delivers subpar services. I say this as an iPhone/Mac user.
- GeekyBear 6y ago>Some of the world's best cloud talent is assembling in an unlikely place: Apple https://www.protocol.com/apple-hires-cloud-open-source-engineers https://www.protocol.com/apple-hires-cloud-open-source-engin...
- epall 6y agoI get the sense that hyperscalers don’t give Intel a ton of margin in negotiations, so they already have access to great server chips at competitive prices. And they’re bringing in AMD now to compete. Where M1 really shines is client-side applications like video handling, ML inference, and crazy branchy nearly single-threaded code. Servers can afford to run much lower clock speeds (see GCP n1 family, for example) because web serving is an embarrassingly parallel problem. Sure, some ARM might help lower costs of internal things like S3, but Graviton2 isn’t that incredible compared to the M1-vs-Coffee Lake comparisons going on in the laptop world.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- VRay 6y agoDoes MediaTek still send out Excel files full of register names/offsets instead of data sheets? Man..