4 ms·
Whatever you think of it, it's not "terrorism" (the objective is presumably to deter a state nuclear weapons program and not specifically to frighten the masses
by throwaway894345 6y ago
Whatever you think of it, it's not "terrorism" (the objective is presumably to deter a state nuclear weapons program and not specifically to frighten the masses). While any loss of life is unfortunate, and while the US and Israel are not without blemish, this assassination was very targeted (no collateral) and it plausibly deters Iran from advancing (and thus using) its nuclear weapons program. This seems like a pretty good deal on balance, at least for those who can accept that the world is not perfect and very often the loss of a single life is the best one can hope for to prevent the losses of tens or hundreds of thousands of lives.
Anyway, I want to steer clear of the "which country is more evil?" question because it's so very unlikely to yield productive discourse (we can use enumeration fallacy to support whichever position we like even if we agree on core values).
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> it plausibly deters Iran from advancing (and thus using) its nuclear weapons program Having looked quite deeply into this, Iran does not currently have, nor peruses such a program. Meanwhile Israel not only does have a nuclear program, but refuses to sign any treaties regulating it.
- hnracer 6y agoWhat do you make of the Israeli's sharing of intel to the public regarding a purported illegal nuclear weapons research program currently ongoing inside Iran. Is that evidence fabricated, and if so how do we know that?
- AsyncAwait 6y agoBecause there wasn't any new credible intelligence in there even per the U.S., which is no friend of Iran [1] and because Israel has been rehashing the same shit forever now. > Is that evidence fabricated, and if so how do we know that? It is generally up to the party offering evidence to prove its authenticity, not the other way around. 1 - https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/netanyahu-s-info-iran-nukes-known-u-s-intelligence-years-n870456 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/netanyahu-s-info-iran-n...
- throwaway894345 6y agoThey don't have a public nuclear weapons program because they don't want to suffer the sanctions that would be imposed on them, but they have a long history of interest in and pursuit of such a program. As for Israel, I fail to see how that's anything but whataboutism.
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> As for Israel, I fail to see how that's anything but whataboutism. Has it ever occurred to you the Iranians might be interested in such a weapon because Israel already has one? This is not without precedent. We know for example that Pakistan developed its nukes to deter India when they demonstrated they have nuclear weapons.
- throwaway894345 6y agoLet me be clearer: I don’t see how Iran’s intent (or speculation there about) is relevant to the quoted portion of my post: > it plausibly deters Iran from advancing (and thus using) its nuclear weapons program As for Iranian intentions; they’ve been quite clear and consistent that they want to wipe out Israel, and I take them at their word about their motives. It seems unrealistic to me that they want nukes for purely defensive purposes (unrelated to their broader desire to wipe Israel off the map), i.e., they think (absent a nuclear Iran) Israel would without provocation initiate a nuclear attack on Iran. It seems obvious to me that Iran wants nuclear weapons as part of its broader desire to eradicate Israel, albeit probably not to launch nukes at Israel directly but rather to derisk a nuclear counterattack. In either case, a nuclear Iran brings us considerably closer to a violent humanitarian crisis.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoOxford Dictionary's definition of terrorism: the unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims. From Iran's perspective this is terrorism. From the US/Israel's that is probably not simply because I believe that there's probably a lawful mechanism for these governments to carry out this sort of action on foreign soil. For them it's "raison d'Etat".
- abnry 6y agoIs a scientist working on a nuclear bomb a civilian? In the strict sense, yes, but it is very close to not being one.
- e12e 6y agoFrom tfa: > But some American officials argued that the death of Mr. Fakhrizadeh, the latest in a string of such mysterious killings of Iran’s top nuclear scientists, would send a chilling message to the country’s other top scientists working on that program: If we can get him, we can get you, too.
- whimsicalism 6y agoIs a computer scientist working on AWS a civilian? The DoD uses AWS.
- abnry 6y agoA scientist leading the project of constructing a massive weapon does not compare to a scientist working as part of a cog in the wheel on a service that is used both by the government and other companies that is not related to weapon construction any more than a screw driver is related to weapon construction.
- throwaway894345 6y agoA couple issues with your interpretation: * Israel isn't subject to Iranian jurisdiction, so it can't be "illegal", at least not meaningfully. In other words, if we don't account for jurisdiction then any international conflict could be considered "terrorism", which doesn't pass a common sense test. * The Oxford definition stipulates "and intimidation", not "or intimidation". There's no indication that the aggressor's intent was to intimidate (rather, if they wanted to intimidate, they would have attacked the target's family or otherwise not been so surgical).
- kome 6y ago> This seems like a pretty good deal on balance, at least for those who can accept that the world is not perfect and very often the loss of a single life is the best one can hope for to prevent the losses of tens or hundreds of thousands of lives. There are plenty of assumptions here tho. Because I am not sure such an act "can save lifes", or in fact, it keeps reinforcing the hegemony of US, IL and SA in killing systematically and waging wars in the region... My point is: is murdering a top scientist/politician useful to save "tens or hundreds of thousands of lives" or is this facilitating the killing "tens or hundreds of thousands of lives" in Palestine, Yemen, Jordan, Lebanon, Iraq and destabilizing the region?
- throwaway894345 6y agoTo be clear about my assumptions, I don't trust the Iranian regime. They have been interested in nuclear weapons consistently for the last 70 years, and they've been rather explicit about their position with respect to Israel (it's a "cancerous tumor that must be uprooted and destroyed" or something to that effect). I think they pretty credibly want to wipe out Israel and emerge as the regional power. I'm also assuming that the US, IL, and SA are pretty interested in regional stability if only because stability favors their own interests. You have a few implicit assumptions of your own: 1. Keeping Iran in check "destabalizes the region" (and the corollary, that Iran's objective is stability in the region) How can you believe this in light of Iran's pretty explicit intent to wipe out Israel? Are Iranian officials merely posturing benignly? 2. The US, IL, SA objective is "systematically killing tens or hundreds of thousands of lives and waging wars in the region" (and not to stabilize the region) Of course, these countries aren't "systematically killing" anyone. You can criticize them for their actions, but they haven't been "systematically killing" anybody, nor expressed interest in the same. 3. There is a dichotomy between Iran killing tens or hundreds of thousands and the US/IL/SA killing tens or hundreds of thousands (i.e., if we prevent Iran from killing tens or hundreds of thousands then we implicitly allow its adversaries to kill tens or hundreds of thousands) Of course, there is no such dichotomy. Thwarting Iran's nuclear program and stabilizing the region are two sides of the same coin.
- captain_price7 6y ago
- cblconfederate 6y agoIt's highly unlikely he's irreplaceable