13 ms·
Geometric Algebra (2012)
- jan_Inkepa 6y agoThere are good ideas that gain traction super quickly. GA is not that. Possibly because there's already an ok solution (dot/cross-products), the benefits of switching are pretty incremental (or negative in terms of net effort for people who use dot/cross products a few times a year). Category Theory is an example of a unifying theory that caught on. It took time, but my brain was able to assimilate to it quite quickly. With GA none of it sticks for me - I have other tools that suffice (I work on games and have reasonably regular 3D exposure, but the traditional tools of calculus textbooks mostly suffice, and if I need fancy concepts they tend to come from differential geometry). I remember another big war being to push gauge integrals into Calculus textbooks (as an alternative/augmentation to Riemann integrals that vastly increase the scope of what can be integrated). I assume that went nowhere, but that was a valiant struggle. My breakthrough with the cross product was coming to understand it as a weird but practical tool rather than representing some fundamentally beautiful geometrical concept. It might be one of the most well known weird mathematical tools. The cross product of two vectors has no real meaning to me intrinsically (I don't think it has or deserves a platonic identity) but it's useful for talking about orientations/picking right-angles/planarity. I can imagine at some point educators might become convinced about the utility of GA and things flipping, but it feels far from that tipping point still.
- gugagore 6y agoFrom your description, you have not experienced [what I consider] a breakthrough with the cross product. In 3D there is a one-to-one mapping between vectors and oriented areas (feel free to think of it as a plane along with scalar denoting an area of the plane). When I learned about vector calculus, this one-to-one mapping was used liberally and implicitly, even though the vector a×b behaves differently from the vector a and the vector b. Even if you take the magnitude of a×b to get a scalar |a×b|, that scalar does not behave the same as e.g. the scalar a ⋅ b. The SI system cannot distinguish between a scalar torque Newton-meters and scalar work Newton-meters, though they are different. Geometric Algebra makes the difference explicit. For me, it's not about giving a meaning to a×b after the fact, but rather to ensure it has meaning by construction. I think it's valid to assume the operation a×b and then figure out what it means (or doesn't mean, or call it a weird tool). But Geometric Algebra gives one way to think about it more clearly. It's not about fundamental beauty for me. It's about having a consistent and clear system to operate within.
- andi999 6y agoThe cross product is just an infinitesimal rotation. If you rotate b around the axis a, then the derivative of the new vector is axb. So the cross product is the product in the Lie Algebra of rotations. (Thats why you have the Jacobi identity). I find this gives much more insight than labeling it a bivector. Edit: also this view can generalize. You can ask what other reprensentation of the rotation Lie algebra exists and find e.g su(2), this leads you to spin-bundles then.
- gugagore 6y agoThis is not very clear to me. Can you be more precise? If we're talking about the Lie algebra of space rotations, then the elements of that are infinitesimal rotations. Those elements form a vector space, and there's also the Lie bracket, which is the cross product as you say. I don't see the sense in saying "rotate b about a" when both a and b are to represent infinitesimal rotations. If we're taking b to be a position in space, and a to be an infinitesimal rotation, then your explanation makes sense (though in a backwards way from how I think of it. a x b is the vector you rotate a about in order to get the derivative of the tip to be b). How do you reconcile that with the Lie Algebra? More importantly, what if your vectors don't model rotations to begin with? Then you still are left with giving a meaning to the cross product. How can you clarify anything by taking your vectors to be infinitesimal rotations, whose cross product gives a third infinitesimal rotation, which carries information about the non-commutativity of the [non-infinitesimal] rotations? It is one thing that the cross product does, but I don't see how it explains, for example, what the cross product has to do with calculating volumes of parallelepipeds, or torques.
- benrbray 6y agoGeometric Algebra is certainly not the only theory to make this distinction. Most treatments of tensor algebra will cover Hodge duality and emphasize the importance of ensuring all quantities have well-behaved "types". Category theory helps to organize everything a bit more neatly, too. Some good examples are [1] and [2]. [1] https://ccom.ucsd.edu/~ctiee/notes/tensors.pdf https://ccom.ucsd.edu/~ctiee/notes/tensors.pdf [2] https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~kmcrane/Projects/DDG/ https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~kmcrane/Projects/DDG/
- skybrian 6y agoFrom a brief skim, it looks like this introduction has the same problem as every other introduction to geometric algebra that I've seen: a complete lack of practical examples. Where is there an introduction that shows you how to use geometric algebra to write better code to perform calculations? Or maybe to do word problems, like when we teach kids algebra or calculus? Even in a supposedly practical book like Foundations of Game Engine Development, Volume 1, there are code examples throughout the book, except for the chapter about geometric algebra.
- flubert 6y ago>lack of practical examples Maybe check out: Geometric Algebra For Computer Science https://geometricalgebra.org/ https://geometricalgebra.org/ ...there's at least a chapter on a ray tracer, if that is practical enough.
- pvg 6y agoThere's a subsection section called Simple Applications at the very beginning and a toplevel section Applications at the end.
- Gene_Parmesan 6y agoI share your pain, as someone who messes around with game engine dev as a hobby and has also read through that book. He sure made geometric algebra sound like it _should_ be useful, but man is it clear as mud to me. Of course in general I'm not surprised; for instance I'm not surprised that this paper doesn't have many practical examples. It's higher level math, of course, and for people in that space, showing a small example where you use the geometric product to solve an abstract linear algebra problem is about as close to 'practical' as you are going to get. But I found it much more aggravating in that book. It's specifically a practical book after all, meant to help lay foundations for renderer and physics engine dev -- but as you said, that section is completely devoid of any real examples of how you could integrate it to make Problem A or B easier, or how it simplifies your transform code, or literally anything. The complete lack of code examples or any such real-world applications make the chapter feel a bit out of place, maybe even tacked on or gratuitous. (Which is a shame because he kind of builds up to that chapter, dropping hints here and there about how it will fundamentally shift our understanding.)
- TheMightyLlama 6y agoI’m someone who never really internalised nor had use for any arithmetic, let alone mathematics, at all in life. And yet I see mathematics like this and I’m blown away at the apparent beauty of it. I look at equations I just _want_ to understand and navigate in my mind. But without knowing the path to get there I’m stuck at zero. Take the Riemann hypothesis for example. I wouldn’t mind understanding all the notation with examples and exercises for each part of the notation so I could bring it back together myself. There’s beauty here and I want it in my head.
- flubert 6y ago>Riemann hypothesis for example I'll recommend reading the chapter on the Riemann Hypothesis from the book: The Millennium Problems by Keith Devlin. https://www.amazon.com/Millennium-Problems-Greatest-Unsolved-Mathematical/dp/0465017304/ https://www.amazon.com/Millennium-Problems-Greatest-Unsolved... That has about 42 pages of prose describing the problem in layman terms. I'd think someone who tackled high school math should be able to follow it. Dr. Devlin also has a good Coursera course on an introduction to mathematics.
- solotronics 6y agoThis is a pretty good resource! https://math.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Calculus/Book%3A_Calculus_(Apex)/05%3A_Integration/5.03%3A_Riemann_Sums https://math.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Calculus/Book%3A_Cal...
- Enginerrrd 6y agoRiemann Sums != Riemann Hypothesis. That said, there is a decent book for the layman on RH: "Prime Obsession: Bernhard Riemann and the Greatest Unsolved Problem in Mathematics" https://www.amazon.com/Prime-Obsession-Bernhard-Greatest-Mathematics/dp/0452285259 https://www.amazon.com/Prime-Obsession-Bernhard-Greatest-Mat...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- adamnemecek 6y agoYou should check out the bivector community https://bivector.net/ https://bivector.net/ dedicated to Geometric algebra. Join the discord https://discord.gg/vGY6pPk https://discord.gg/vGY6pPk. Check out a demo https://observablehq.com/@enkimute/animated-orbits https://observablehq.com/@enkimute/animated-orbits Automatic differentiation that’s all the rage is based on geometric algebra, namely dual numbers. I wonder if automatic integration is possible. I have a hunch it is.
- eutectic 6y agoAren't dual numbers only useful for forward-mode AD, and not the more useful reverse-mode?
- canjobear 6y agoI highly recommend the video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60z_hpEAtD8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60z_hpEAtD8 linked from the site above ~40 minutes, and I get the point of geometric algebra now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyAguirre 6y agoFor those who happen to like both geometric algebra and general relativity, my former student Joey Schindler wrote this quite beautiful paper extending geometric algebra to calculus on manifolds. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1911.07145.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1911.07145.pdf
- sgdpk 6y agoI will read this a bit later, but is the idea to extended the structure of the tangent space and make it a full geometric algebra?
- siliconmountain 6y agoThanks for sharing. At what point does something like this become a PhD thesis level topic and not "just" a paper quality topic?
- oddthink 6y agoThis gets directly to my main question each time I see geometric algebra show up: how does it fit in with the "normal" notation of differential geometry? What assumptions does it make for a metric, what is the equivalent of parallel transport, Lie brackets, how does it represent gradients (and other things that are naturally 1-forms), etc., etc.? All the treatments I've seen jump in to manipulation without really going in to the axioms used. That paper seems to do a lot better at fitting it together, so I'll certainly read it, thanks.
- greatgoat420 6y agoI think there are two main reasons why we don't see more of the applications of Geometric Algebra. One is that most people who would be using it are already satisfied with Differential Geometry and the coordinate-free formulations of physical laws we have there already. Having done some work in computational GR, I haven't seen anyone mention it and none of the texts I have read do. I think for people advanced enough in their field they are already past any pain points that this solves, so they don't learn it and don't teach it to their students. Two I think that the people who this is most useful for, students just starting out in physics, aren't really in a position to go out and learn a new representation for doing their problems in. Especially when they are struggling enough with the basic concepts and their instructor is highly unlikely to be familiar with it. Because of those two things and the cycles they mutually perpetuate, without a huge PR campaign or some well known teacher using it at a big name school for an introductory class I don't think we will ever see this become popular
- hohohmm 6y agoThe main problem with GA is if you want a unified transformation hiearchy, geometric algebra could quickly get very complicated, as it requires projective GA to handle translation and dual-quaternion to handle non-uniform scaling. Geometry algebra appears beautiful to simple rotation cases and explains very well concepts that feel incomplete in simple vector math, but in real application for genric game engine, you can't really code up a scene graph with unified transforms in like 2 hours. Not to mention that even the GA people do not all agree with each other how to do the more advanced GA stuff(strange inversions and ext). Surprisingly very few people talk about this on Youtube with all those GA tutorial videos, and you can find scant information on the bivector site forum. In comparison, despite matrix represetntion's weaker mappng to geometric concepts, it handles everything in a more unified interface without too much complications. For that matter the GA math feels much to be desired. There probably exists a undiscovered better version of GA that handles translation and scaling better and everybody could instantly agree on. Until that day GA probably won't see much general usage.
- enkimute 6y agoOk, standard 4x4 matrices also implement a projective (aka d+1) model. (the 'w' coordinate is just the projective coordinate). So no difference with GA in that respect. Setting up a unified transformation hierarchy is actually very easy, and again not really different from how you would approach it with matrices. (plus, its more performant). Simply swap the matrix with the appropriate versor. Which (versors or matrices) are appropriate depends on the symmetry group you are interested in : Orthogonal Group (just rotations : distance + origin preserving) in d dimensions -> use the geometric algebra R_d. (classically : complex numbers, quaternions) Lorentz Group (rotations + boosts : spacetime distance + origin preserving) in d space dimensions and 1 time dimension -> use the geometric algebra R_{d,1}. (classically : Lorentz transformations) Euclidean Group (translations + rotations : distance preserving) in d dimensions -> use the geometric algebra R_{d,0,1}. (classically : planar quaternions, dual quaternions) Conformal Group (translations + rotations + dilations : angle preserving) -> use the geometric algebra R_{d+1,1}. (classically : linear fractional transformations) General Linear Group (translations + rotations + sheering + ... : preserves parallelism/incidence) : use d+1 x d+1 matrices. Working in a symmetry group that is 'to big' comes at a cost - both in algorithmic complexity as well as numerical precision. If you only want translations/rotations, but are using matrices you'll have to resort to things like Gramm-Shmidt or SVD to re-orthogonalize your matrices after doing numerical calculations. (you have to project it back to the solution manifold in math terms - this is almost never trivial and often impossible). (for those interested, I explain this in-depth in my GAME2020 talk : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ichOiuBoBoQ&ab_channel=Bivector https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ichOiuBoBoQ&ab_channel=Bivec... )
- publicola1990 6y agoWhile not specifically related to Geometric Algebra, much of even simple vector algebra itself is usually taught and presented in a confusing manner, is what I think. Elementary questions like whether a vector has a start and end point, has it got an orientation along its own axis, is it possible to determine if two given vectors are in the same frame of reference, etc are simply not obvious from most treatments of vector algebra I have seen. I do see a pressing need for a full treatment of the topic without notational or conceptual ambiguities. Atleast mathematics owes it to the other sciences that much, is what I feel.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]