3 ms·
“ Nature’s agonizingly slow process of discovery, driven by cosmological and biological evolution on time scales of millions and billions of years, is accelerat
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
“ Nature’s agonizingly slow process of discovery, driven by cosmological and biological evolution on time scales of millions and billions of years, is accelerated to breakneck speeds in the laboratory.”
The slow process is not quite true.
For example, humans have about a half a million polypeptide machines (proteins, etc.) that make up the human body.
They are made of 20 amino acids in sequence and can be 10s to 100000s units in length.
If you calculate amount of polypeptides ribosomes could make given the base 4 DNA string and the choice of 20 amino acids, you will find there are not enough planck voxels in the observable universe to digitally represent them. I.e. the fact that nature found 500k to use for humans to be constructed in only a handful of billion years is profound.
It would have made more sense had the universe just been existing forever with no beginning.
- willis936 6y agoGenesis may be profound, but evolution is not. Humans didn’t appear out of a void of randomness
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThe universe has precise laws. Changes in physical constants to the 31st decile would negate the possibility of life. Genesis occurred through time+statistics (=evolution) just as evolution does.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoActually we did. We just did it in stages.
- jariel 6y ago"Humans didn’t appear out of a void of randomness" They did though, at least according to the materialist position which we now mostly accept as being 'science'. We basically define the universe 'as having a bunch of rules, which can be modelled' - in which case ... there literally is no life or rather a 'bag of random particles' (you) in a random environment, interacting according to some rules ... which is just net randomness. A researcher once said that evolution is no more interesting than a rock rolling down a hill - and he's right, from a materialist perspective. Nothing is 'evolving' any more than the ball of wax in a lava lamp lumping together and apart - it's just 'stuff happening randomly'. The problem with this materialist view when taken to it's full extent, is that it completely denies the most important reality to us - that we are 'life'. What we care about is the expression of life, we don't write laws to protect 'random bags of talking jelly' - our entire cultural foundation surrounds this notion of our being alive. And FYI - most common definitions of life exhibit this 'consciousness' problem, in that they may use biological terms, reproduction, all of that, but it's ultimately mechanical and materialist. So scientific materialism essentially denies the existence life as we commonly understand it preemptively, causing some deep existential problems. 'The Problem With Physics' I think is not 'Dark Matter' - it's the fact that it really hasn't brought us any closer to understanding what we actually are, which is the big question. There is a movement called 'emergence' which starts to move the needle on this, starting from a fairly material perspective but is ultimately metaphysical, at least it's a start.
- imtringued 6y ago>The problem with this materialist view when taken to it's full extent, is that it completely denies the most important reality to us - that we are 'life'. What we care about is the expression of life, we don't write laws to protect 'random bags of talking jelly' - our entire cultural foundation surrounds this notion of our being alive. And FYI - most common definitions of life exhibit this 'consciousness' problem, in that they may use biological terms, reproduction, all of that, but it's ultimately mechanical and materialist. Valuing life is a purely emotional and cultural thing. We care more about the lives of our relatives and friends than random strangers but we also care more about random strangers because they are the same species as us than we care about the lives of other species. Sometimes humans (by that I mean the Nazis) think other humans (e.g. Jews) are "inhuman" and deserve death as a punishment. (e.g. Holocaust) There is obviously no scientific basis in valuing life. It's a choice everyone makes for themselves. The HN submission about male chicks being shredded or even gassed is basically the same thing as the Holocaust but for chicken. Industrial killing of life, yet we don't care as long as we get our eggs. Thousands of years ago the world used to be lawless even for humans. Tribes were constantly engaging in violent conflicts. They didn't care one bit about the life of someone or something they deemed unimportant. We care about life because we are selfish and if someone takes a life away that we care about we want to satisfy our selfishness and engage in revenge against the killer.
- jariel 6y agoSo your comment misses two important points I'm trying to convey: 1) "It's a choice everyone makes for themselves." You cannot make a choice (According to Materialist Physics) You are nothing but random noise. A random equation cannot 'make' choices, it cannot 'make' anything there is nothing being 'made'. There is no such thing as 'intelligence' in random noise. So take a moment to grasp that for a second, because it reveals something about the first part of your statement: 2) "There is obviously no scientific basis in valuing life." What you mean to say is maybe there is no 'Materialist Scientific Basis' for valuing life. Because according to physics, why should we? But again from (1) there is no such thing as 'value' or 'emotion' or even 'choice' in random noise - you can see they hypocrisy of the statement. You're caught in a 'Chinese Finger Trap' of Scientific Materialism. You cannot on one hand talk about 'choice' 'values' because physics says those would be 'emotional' choices, when at the same time, materialist physics also tells us that there is no choice, emotion, intelligence, consciousness to begin with. Physics is telling us that you and I are just rocks rolling down a hill. We hit a bump, we go one way or another. That's it. No choice, no intelligence, no science, no discoveries, nothing is 'evolving' - just pure random noise like the fuzzy screen on the old TV sets. Remember that physics has not proven that the universe exists according to a certain set of rules. Physics is postulating that. We assume the Universe can be described as a set of equations, so we go about trying to describe things using equations. Because these equations have been very objectively helpful to us over the last few hundred years, and using them we can get rid of a bunch of fairy tales and ridiculous ideas ... we've come to believe that Physics itself is the search for truth. But it's not - Physics is only the search for material truth within the constraints that it's set for itself. By definition, physics may not be able to help us understand the meaning of life because they've resigned themselves to studying the lego blocks of life. Now consider an alternative: the perspective of 'the observer' and that Science is merely a tool for understanding the Universe around is - that Science is not a 'Truth' but a 'Tool'. That 'life' is the basis of our existence, and that it expresses itself via materialism, but is not entirely constructed of that materialism. The only reason we take any real interest in Materialist Science, ironically, is because of our creative impulses. Obviously - it's abstract, and not prone to equations, and can easily devolve into 'magical thinking' but that doesn't invalidate the ultimate premise of non-materialist thinking. Below the 'tree trunk' of Physics is 'Metaphysics' and it's worth remember that physics at any given time is only one way of interpreting the universe.
- Chris2048 6y agoIs it? You are talking about total combinations though, and nature doesn't brute-force every possible combination, but builds upon valid sequences.
- COGlory 6y agoYour numbers appear to be off. There are about 25k unique protein coding genes in the human genome, not 500k. Additionally, there appears to be a size limit to proteins. The largest human protein, titin, is about 40k amino acids. No larger protein has ever been discovered. Obviously 20^40000 is an incomprehensible coding space, but we can with a few broad strokes narrow that number down immensely. For starters, Eugene Koonin argues in The Logic of Chance, and elsewhere, that the evolution of proteins is limited by the amount of stable folds available in cell-like aqueous conditions. It's an impossible number to quantify but we do know that even most cellular proteins will naturally misfold coming off the ribosome unless aided by chaperones, so we can assume that coding space is drastically decreased. Furthermore, because of inertia, there are many combinations evolution simply will not sample. Most genes evolve by genome duplication events. The conclusion of the process is that youre never going to get too far away from what you stated with, and indeed we see this is the case with there only being a handful of true, conserved orthogonal genes (these number in the hundreds). Obviously, n = 1, but I guess the point I'm trying to make is that once you have stable structure/function chemistry, there's probably many many routes to "humans" or something else able to be self aware. We just see one of them because of we were guided here by earth chemistry and inertia. What is far more confusing is how the ribosome evolved in the first place, because that's the true de novo lynchpin of cellular life.
- tgb 6y agoMost protein coding genes produce multiple proteins, through having multiple isoforms, and proteins are modified post-translationally. 500,000 is on the higher end of estimates I've heard, but hundreds of thousands is the right order of magnitude.
- COGlory 6y agoYeah, splicing gets weird but the biggest estimate I've ever heard is 100k, and again, that's an estimate, not something we have determined empirically. However, I don't believe it impacts the coding space problem to the same degree. For starters, isoforms tend to have the same fold and similar, but modulated function, and plenty of life exists without them. They aren't randomly sampled the way that is suggested in the OP. Again, truly orthogonal genes number in the hundreds in all the known genome of all known life. If you start to add PTMs to the mix, then the truth is that we have no idea. A single protein will produce dozens of visible PTMs, probably thousands of invisible ones since even our most sensitive methods detect only population averages. On that vein, any individual protein also has a number of defects from translation, allosteric modification, etc. Proteins are obviously dynamic molecules, but those dynamics are of limited genetic tractability and are significantly different from environment to environment. I think I'm still going to stick to my initial argument which is that amino acid combinations are substantially more constrained than is being suggested.