25 ms·
Manifesto of the Silent Minority
- henriquez 6y agoCute and disturbing, but reading the survey responses (there weren’t a whole lot), the piece seems highly embellished. It reads like a sociopathic mad-lib and I’m not sure there are any valuable takeaways here (particularly insights about a so-called Silent Majority)
- jstanley 6y agoThe piece never refers to a "so-called Silent Majority". It's called "Manifesto of the Silent Minority".
- spiralx 6y agoLess Wrong is a very opinionated site that should definitely be taken with a heavy dose of scepticism. Some of it is pretty out there. https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/LessWrong https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/LessWrong
- henryaj 6y agoRationalWiki should also be taken with a heavy dose of scepticism!
- gerikson 6y agoThe skepticism is included in RationalWiki.
- NateEag 6y agoI get that this is a joke, and I haven't spent much time on RationalWiki, but I feel compelled to point out that they aren't actually that skeptical. It seems to me to embody an unflinching, burning faith that using analytical tools and reason will always yield the right answers. The idea that the human mind might be too limited to understand everything seems like a foreign idea there. Ditto the idea that strict formal reasoning is not always the best approach to thinking. Don't get me wrong - I think logic is an invaluable tool, and I believe we should try to understand things beyond our current limits. I just also believe we need to admit what those limits are, and always remember our fallibility.
- dash2 6y agoThis may be unfair. As (I think) the Slatestarcodex guy put it, rationalists are one of the few groups where "Chesterton's Fence"[1] is a sufficient two-word rebuttal to many arguments. [1] https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Chesterton%27s_Fence https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Chesterton%27s_Fence
- NateEag 6y agoIt may be unfair. Chesterton's Fence asserts that the reason for the fence can be clearly known, though. I'm saying there are limits to what we can truly know or understand as humans. I don't think the rationalist community as a whole really accepts that, at least not to the extent I do. Chesterton's Fence isn't really relevant to that proposition, I think.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Havoc 6y agoPity about the redacted list. Would have liked to see the original
- ForHackernews 6y ago> If I cannot abolish democracy then I will repeal the 19th amendment and leave the rest to OpenAI. Is this a bad joke?
- winstonewert 6y agoyes
- narag 6y agoIt's a joke, somehow. There's a link in the article to the raw responses of every participant in the survey. Some of them are not so outrageous, many of them just make me sad. The joke is that, being from different persons, the article makes a mix of them that remarks the contrasts.
- rcruzeiro 6y agoNot really sure of the value of this is? Unless I am missing something, this reads like it was written by an "edgy teenager". Perhaps I am just missing some context.
- giantDinosaur 6y agoIt's the Thiel Question. The value in it is supposed to be that it generates thoughtful and insightful responses - if you are right and 99% of people are wrong then that is indeed impressive. Unfortunately, it selects purely from the extremes, where real insight is random. If it generated more concrete (i.e. scientific) responses that could be tested, it would be a much better question.
- loopz 6y agoUnfortunately, with today's standards of critical thinking and speaking, you get fired for speaking independently, this is more likely to spawn a new movement rather than provoke thoughtful responses.
- rusk 6y ago> today’s standards “Today’s”? There has never been a better time for freedom of speech. You can pretty much say whatever you want and nobody is going to put you in jail or burn you at the stake. Indeed you have tools like never before with which to promulgate your message. Even if your remarks are racist, xenophobic, misogynistic or some other kind of bigoted you can still pretty say much whatever you like and there’s even guys out there that will give you a platform. You might think that these rights extend to the workplace but you would be wrong. Leave religion and politics at the door and just do your job. I blame the culture of overwork that exists in the industry for many people not being able to know the difference between personal and professional.
- foxhop 6y agoThe workplace has become hostile against certain thought and has fully adopted another. You will get fired for speaking against the entrenched thought. This is exactly what was said in the above comment. If I said leave your politics and religion at the door and just do your job in a "safe space zoom call" or at a diversity committee, or at lunch, I'd be fired. The silent ones just want to do our jobs but increasingly the ones with political power inside institutions of work have the control to setup the stage for only one type of thought. I just want to do my job without going into these topics which occupy the majority of the companies all hands time and corporate communications.
- jevgeni 6y agoOne of the items on the list: > China wrote better philosophy 2000 years ago than the West writes today. What's "better philosophy"???
- TremendousJudge 6y agoAll the points in that list require a lot of justification
- jevgeni 6y agoWARNING: reading this article makes you roll your eyes so hard, they might just stay there.
- coldtea 6y agoI should read it then. Because such a facile dismissive comment makes me more interested in reading the article and less in what the commenter has to say. Without having read a line yet, I'm betting the article goes against "polite conversation", and ventures into trying to say something interesting, and this is the "pearl clutching" that usually accompanies such a thing. Let's see...
- simula67 6y agoWhat is your answer to the Thiel Question?
- praptak 6y agoThe Thiel question is stupid.
- reducesuffering 6y agoThis is not a statement few people agree with...
- fallingfrog 6y agoHa, I’ll get flagged as flamebait. Although, giving unsolicited answers to the Thiel question is perhaps the definition of flamebait.
- drewcon 6y agoIt feels like folks are missing the part where it’s a joke...
- tabob 6y agoWhat I get from this: The author decided to try and make an inciteful libertarian rant while smoking crystal meth. Is there something I’m missing as to why this is on HN? Was this written by an ai, or is it’s relevance that it name drops Peter Thiel?
- dash2 6y agoThe point is that it combines the responses from a survey of readers on "what they think that almost nobody agrees with".
- tabob 6y ago> Yesterday I asked readers the Thiel Question. 40 people responded. I have combined the responses into a single political platform. You can view the raw responses here. Whoa. Somehow my brain skipped over that 3rd sentence, and I read the whole thing 3 times. My bad.
- known 6y agoI suppose Capitalism/Socialism/Autocracy/Democracy/Religion/Atheism should lead to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Maslow%27s_Hierarchy_of_Needs2.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Maslow%27s_Hierarchy_of_N...
- eightysixfour 6y agoThis appears to be a direct response to the many recent articles stating that a large percentage of the US has political opinions they are afraid to express. So the author mined his blog readers for their answers to the Thiel question and then wrote a long form version of what those beliefs would mean. It is a satirical representation of how society often romanticizes beliefs outside of the Overton Window because they are signs of a “unique free-thinker” when most of the time they’re just poorly thought out hot takes.
- Arcorann 6y agoI remember reading a few years back an article about the most commonly shared views among voters (as in 90%+ agree rates), finishing with a political manifesto designed to incorporate as many of said views as possible (unfortunately I don't quite remember exactly where that article was from, or I would link it). This, being the opposite of that article, is certainly more thought-provoking for obvious reasons, and I note that while there are likely people who agree with every statement in the other manifesto, there is almost certainly no-one who agrees with every statement in this one.
- stickfigure 6y agoThere seems to be a lot of confusion about what this is. The author posted a survey of the Thiel Question, which asks "Tell me one or more things almost nobody agrees with you on." The motivation of the question is a belief that to build something revolutionary, you need to be able to think outside the box. "People would be willing to rent air mattresses in their living rooms like hotels" is the canonical example (from 2008). The problem is, most iconoclastic ideas tend to be... pretty outlandish. Also, people posting to anonymous web surveys (especially in the rationalist community) are probably tempted to exaggerate a little. So it's comedic to survey a group of people, collect the responses, and put them together as a hypothetical political platform. I found it hilarious.
- norswap 6y agoI'm getting a lock of kicks out of the comments here. Clearly, many people don't get it's a joke (but at the same time, based on a survey whose purpose is probably not to make that joke in the first place (1)). I'm considering using this as a filtering device. Misunderstanding this is a red flag for not trying to understand the context. And having a raging negative reaction to it is a red flag for temperament. (1) If you don't know about the Thiel question, here's the first google result for you: https://www.safegraph.com/blog/why-the-famous-peter-thiel-interview-question-is-so-predictive https://www.safegraph.com/blog/why-the-famous-peter-thiel-in...
- fallingfrog 6y agoHumorous but also pretty disturbing! Just by reading these survey responses, it seems that we humans are mostly a bunch of racists and pedophiles. I guess that dovetails nicely with the assertion that human life is worth less than 500$?
- iron0013 6y agoBut the survey wasn’t conducted among “we humans”, it was conducted among lesswrong readers. Lesswrong is normally pretty worthless, but this gentle lampoon if its own readership’s dumb opinions is actually pretty funny
- CrazyPyroLinux 6y agoThis reminds me of Paul Graham's 2004 essay "What You Can't Say"[0] which I think predates Thiel. "The Conformist Test Let's start with a test: Do you have any opinions that you would be reluctant to express in front of a group of your peers? If the answer is no, you might want to stop and think about that. If everything you believe is something you're supposed to believe, could that possibly be a coincidence?" [0] http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html