6 ms·
Comcast to impose home internet data cap of 1.2TB in more than a dozen US states
- ev1 6y agoThey've had a 1TB cap + pay per GB overages in basically everywhere they don't have competition already. For years. I've always hated looking at a several hundred dollar internet-only bill.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoVote with your wallet, switch providers if you can. If you can’t, put the time into spinning up a coop or muni fiber ISP in your community (or a locally owned for profit ISP even). Failing all else, StarLink. https://muninetworks.org/content/muni-fiber-models-fact-sheet https://muninetworks.org/content/muni-fiber-models-fact-shee... https://startyourownisp.com/ https://startyourownisp.com/ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24424910 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24424910
- ev1 6y agoI ran the second I could. Proper fiber is great. Sick of Comcast's 5 Mbps "up to" upload on their gigabit plan that they just use the word gigabit everywhere on but it takes 4 hours to upload a docker container.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sitzkrieg 6y agowell if its cable provisioned gigabit (docsis3) has limits on upload of 35Mbit. but i hear you, i pay for gigabit and get an average of 600mbps down for many months now
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI live in a city which ostensibly has ISP competition, but it’s basically a fiction. Most of the city is in an enclave where one of the two major cable providers has exclusive rights. The parts of the city that require both providers to compete are dense, mostly apartments, and the providers get exclusive rights to each building. In most cases, the only other option is extremely slow DSL. I’ve researched my options at every place I’ve lived and I’ve consistently been stuck with Comcast. It’s really a shame.
- Beached 6y agoI wish I could get starlink. :( it will likely be 2+ years until it would be available to anyone
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gruez 6y ago>Failing all else, StarLink. This doesn't make any sense. A Starlink satellite's bandwidth is shared with everyone under its radius, so any throttling/bandwidth caps is going to be even worse. A quick search says that each starlink satellite provides 20 Gbps each, which works out to 6.57PB per month, or around 5000 1.2TB/month users. This is the best case scenario, assuming that their usage is uniformly distributed per month. Most bandwidth use is bursty (think netflix in the evening), so in reality it's actually going to be much worse. Assuming a 4K stream at 25 Mb/s, one satellite would only service 800 users. Given comcasts' statistics (5% of users use more than 1.2TB/month), that would mean you need dozens of satellites to service all the heavy users in even a small town.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- junar 6y agoI mean, I'm not a fan of the charge either, but proactively buying the unlimited data plan is only dozens of dollars more, not hundreds. https://www.xfinity.com/learn/internet-service/data https://www.xfinity.com/learn/internet-service/data
- ev1 6y agoThis was actually not an option in the past. In one of those pre-existing markets you'd basically just purchase from Comcast Business instead for something like 100M down, same 2-5M up on coax for a few hundred a month w/o cap (and with mildly better support but still absolutely no help and will just hang up on you if you say you use Linux or your own router or modem). That page is new, and it is particularly obnoxious and sickening that the only way to get an unnecessary, arbitrary cap removed - the cheapest option is to use their hardware that you are not permitted to control, that emits Wifi hotspots that you cannot control, and remotely-controlled passwords. It's pretty much a Meraki rental that isn't yours. It's bordering on AT&T home internet's equivalence of "if you don't want us to sell all of your detailed DPI'd browsing history, add $50/m to your plan cost".
- ratsmack 6y agoInternet usage should be based on a standard connection charge and then a per GB usage charge... this is generally how power companies charge for their service. If you think about it, the average users are subsidizing the minority that have multi-TB monthly usage.
- ev1 6y agoThey should also charge reasonable wholesale rates in that case if you remove the monopolization of the last mile. In other countries this is actually how it works already, the underlying cabling is municipal, you just pick an ISP to transit over it. Comcast charges $0.20/GB for coaxial. Verizon charges $10/GB for LTE. My actual cost for hosting side projects is below $0.50 per 1 TB. It is unreasonable if they are going to fuck with your traffic, tamper with your HTTP payloads and inject scripts into them, deprioritize certain data and still charge multiple orders of magnitude more per GB.
- zamadatix 6y agoIt seems like you're comparing the cost of serving data out of a purpose built location to the cost of transporting it to and from an individual person. Not saying Comcast or Verizon are offering good or bad per GB prices just that it seems you're comparing the cost of your apples (unless your side project is a LOT larger than I'm assuming) and then saying the oranges are mispriced as a result.
- ev1 6y agoI am, but this was with the implication that the last mile fiber was already built out, city/municipality-owned and you are already paying an access fee to use the cabling, therefore you are effectively just transporting packets to/from your own core anyway.
- qeternity 6y agoThe variable cost of bandwidth is orders of magnitude lower than electricity. I suspect this subsidy is much lower than you might think.
- mindslight 6y agoFor comparison this works out to 3.7 megabits/sec, which is less bandwidth than most DSL connections! That means if you're a heavy downloader, you should seriously consider switching to DSL. What I find especially galling is that the first 1.2TB costs half as much ($10 per 100GB, assuming a $120 monthly bill) than the subsequent data, even ignoring the fixed cost of the connection. I think if they merely charged a fair decreasing rate for usage, rather than trying to price gouge heavy users, they wouldn't be seen as such villains. Alas, muni fiber for the win. Gigabit symmetric and forget about it.
- gruez 6y ago>That means if you're a heavy downloader, you should seriously consider switching to DSL. Don't DSL connections also come with caps?
- mindslight 6y agoNot the few providers that I've had, as recently as several years ago. I believe cable caps arise from worries about last mile distribution segment capacity, and have less to do with actual Internet transit.
- LinuxBender 6y agoNorthern California has had the cap for a long time. I had to negotiate a plan for 45 minutes with them to remove the cap, which including going to 1gb/s which I don't need. I suspect this will be more common anywhere that does not have competition or where ISP's wink-wink agree not to step on each others territory.
- pridkett 6y agoIt’s not even a wink-wink. In many states, for example, Connecticut[1], the territory of each. cable provider is regulated by the state. There’s only a few tiny spots that have an overbuild of another provider. The state claims that DSL is competition, but let’s be real, 12mbps DSL is no longer competitive. [1]: https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/PURA/Cable/VideoProviderServiceAreapdf.pdf https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/PURA/Cable/VideoProviderServic...
- bdcravens 6y agoAs indicated in the article, this policy already exists for Comcast customers in other states.
- canada2us 6y ago"Only about 5% of our customers use that much." If only 5% uses 1.2TB each month, why would Comcast want to impose the cap to everyone? Comcast has already made enough money and this move has nothing but against social good. I am an international student from China in US. If you ever go to China, you will find how affordable Internet (or Phone Data plans) is. And it is even affordable in sparsely-populated rural areas, unlike the US rural areas I've heard of. These big private companies are just lagging US behind and the country cannot do anything with it.
- mkmk 6y agoPresumably they mean 5% of their customers use at least that much – some of them much more.
- bruceb 6y agoIf the hardware is made in china, the companies can get it for probably cheaper than anywhere in the world. Also the labor in china is dramatically cheaper. Is there a union of telecom workers in China? Of course China internet is going to be cheaper. That doesn't mean there should be such a difference between USA and China prices, but not surprised there is some, nor would I expect it to be the same or cheaper in the US. US has higher impute costs. As a pct of income of avg person what is internet access in China vs US? This of course leave aside the what constitutes the internet you get in China vs USA
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoSounds like a bit of an unpopular opinion in this thread but I think pay-for-what-you-use plans with reasonable per GB charge and a slightly higher per GB charge above a certain number seems reasonable, irrespective of your opinion of Comcast. Something like 30 dollars for a residential connection, followed by 2.5 cents per GB for the first 1024 GB, and then increased to say 4 cents per GB for another 1024 GB. If you use 1 TB, you pay 30+0.025*1024 ~ 55 dollars. Why should we subsidize those who download tens or hundreds of TBs? No one thinks this is unreasonable for electricity, why is it unreasonable for data? Bandwidth issues affect data too.
- charleslmunger 6y agoYou might find this comment thread, which discusses that same analogy, interesting: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17426607 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17426607
- gruez 6y agoThis comment was posted two minutes ago and it's already showing up as grey to me. It's a shame, because what was said has merit, even though the conclusion might not be appealing to the average HN reader. eg. >Why should we subsidize those who download tens or hundreds of TBs? Consumer internet is oversubscribed. By using 10x as much bandwidth as everyone else, you are effectively getting your internet connection subsidized by everyone else.
- RileyJames 6y agoA reasonably high cap like this doesn’t seem completely unreasonable. But where the cap is set, who it applies to, when it’s updated and when it comes into effect are more important than the number of TBs. For instance, setting it at 1.2 TB today seems fine, but in 10 years that won’t be nearly enough, but will Comcast update it? Or just push ‘heavy’ user to their ‘prosumer’ plans. It’s similar in financial regulation. Transactions over $10,000 must be reported for KYC/AML purposes. Sounds fine when it was implemented, but now it seems very low. It wouldn’t take much to future proof decisions like this, by default. Inflate by 10% per year, or some other metric. And the lack of such features hints at the fixed amount being the feature.
- m-p-3 6y agoSo if you play any game streaming platform like Google Stadia which at high quality and framerate use an average of 20GB/h, you'll bust that cap in little under 62h, and that's if you do nothing else.
- gnicholas 6y agoI'd feel better about this if they gave a discount (even a modest one) to all customers simultaneously. Then it would feel like the plan is revenue neutral and redistributive. They'd get some additional revenue from high-usage customers and give up some revenue from their other customers. Instead it feels like a heads-I-win-tails-nothing-changes situation.
- jm1234567890 6y agoAnyone use 5G mmwave home internet? Is it really unlimited download without throttling?
- sprite 6y agoComcast offers unlimited data for $30/month more.