16 ms·
When tipping was considered un-American (2015)
- Ekaros 6y agoWhat makes restaurants and bars different from other service industry jobs? Like your local policeman, judge or border guard? Shouldn't those be tipped too? Or wait, isn't that a bribe?
- wyre 6y agoMy tip is paying a server at a restaurant to serve me. My taxes pay for the state to protect me. Also, none of those things are in the service industry.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoDoes a retail store employee serve you when they spend a few minutes to find something for you? Do you tip them also? How about a nursing assistant that changes your bedpans?
- Thiez 6y agoIt gets even more hilarious when you try to tip the teachers of your children, or perhaps police officers and a judge. Strange how bribing workers for better service can be expected, unexpected, or just plain illegal, depending on their profession.
- akiselev 6y agoYou don't tip them directly, you tip the Rotary Club or the local Police Officers Association.
- ingvul 6y agoDo you tip at McDonald's then?
- a5withtrrs 6y agoMy complaint (as an Australian) against tipping is that I have no idea what the cost of my meal ends up being. If I dine out here at say a pub, the price for a steak is $30 AUD and the price of a beer is $5. The total price I pay is $35 AUD. This includes tax. This includes the wage for the staff front and back of house. And if for some reason I'm feeling like tipping the staff because they went the 'extra mile', I can optionally do so. This is super confusing in the US (as a visitor) when the price of a meal is advertised as $xx and then you go to pay and it's actually $xx + tax + tip. If I'm paying a minimum price of $xx + tax + 10% tip, why not just make that the price of the item? It just makes no sense to me!
- sideshowb 6y agoBeing from a culture that usually tends to quote consumer prices all inclusive, I find the practice of doing otherwise outright slimy and deceptive. I admit this is irrationally emotional but it's one of those little details that somehow shapes my perception of the USA as a whole. *quoting b2b prices without vat is fair as whether or not tax is payable depends on the customer.
- pg_1234 6y agoYou're not being irrational ... Americans are just slimy and deceptive.
- dang 6y agoNationalistic flamewar will get you banned here. Please don't post like this again, regardless of which country you have a problem with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- cmdshiftf4 6y ago>why not just make that the price of the item? It just makes no sense to me! There's nothing stopping them from doing so but it benefits them by being deliberately opaque. Also, worth noting is that Americans consider 10% to be a stingy tip.
- b0rsuk 6y agoEven though I live in the fifth most round country in the world, I immediately guessed it was about skin color. I think lack of tipping and prejudice often come together. I observe the same thing here. Waiters with eastern accent get rude treatment.
- unwind 6y agoWhat is a "round country"?
- derwiki 6y agoIt apparently does mean something (TIL): https://gciruelos.com/what-is-the-roundest-country.html https://gciruelos.com/what-is-the-roundest-country.html But not sure this is what GP was referring to
- Nitrolo 6y agoI'm guessing they might mean the literal roundness of the country, i.e. how close the geographic borders are to a circle. Quick search suggests they might mean Poland.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sewer_bird 6y agoPresumably an obese one. https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-obese-countries https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-obes...
- curiousgeorgio 6y agoCount me as firmly in the anti-tipping camp. The article fails to mention the fact that tipping actually creates an environment where more prejudice (not less) can be exposed. If you aren't a stereotypical "good-looking" female server, you will statistically earn far fewer tips. The same goes for people working in the kitchen (as the article mentions). If your servers (or anyone working in the restaurant) demand higher wages, pay them the fair wage and charge what it costs to operate at that level. The expectation of a tip feels similar to the hidden fees charged by wireless carriers so they can advertise a much lower rate.
- projectileboy 6y agoI agree, but what is the best path to end this ridiculous custom? Simply not tipping is unethical, as tipped employees generally make less than minimum wage.
- airstrike 6y agoYou've answered it yourself > what is the best path to end this ridiculous custom? > minimum wage
- curiousgeorgio 6y agoDo you really think a higher minimum wage would end the expectation of tipping? Asking honestly, because I just don't see that as a solution to this problem. There's a discussion to be had around minimum wage, but that feels like an entirely separate issue.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoYes, it would. Civilized states have done away with tipped minimum wages, so employees can no longer complain about being taken advantage of by employers not paying them for tip totals not getting them to minimum wage limits.
- airstrike 6y ago
- ug02fast 6y agoI don't tip and never will.
- ghaff 6y agoI hope you don't use any services where tipping is expected. Otherwise, you're just rude and taking advantage of people.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoThat goes to the heart of this argument: whose responsibility is it that the waiter is paid an acceptable wage, the patron or the manager?
- klodolph 6y agoYou can argue about how the system should work until you are blue in the face, but the fact is that if you show up at a restaurant and don’t tip, then you are making your waiter have a bad day.
- CamelCaseName 6y agoI would like to set the expectation now that I expect to be compensated 15% of your hourly wage every time you read one of my HN comments. I assure you that I will have a bad day if you visit HN and read one of my comments without paying. You can argue that HN should be free to read until you are blue in the face, but the fact is that if you show up in this thread and read my comment and don't pay me, then you are making me have a bad day.
- klodolph 6y agoYou can like to set any expectation you want, but the expectation to tip waiters is an actual, real expectation and not some kind of fabrication for a thought experiment. You could also argue that “driving on the right side of the road” is nothing more than an American social convention and choose to ignore it. Let’s face it—there is no logical justification for our society to choose driving on the right side of the road, versus the left.
- JackFr 6y agoI find anti-tipping crusaders amusing. If you don’t want to tip, don’t tip. Simple. Oh wait, I’ve got to listen to your 20 minute rant about inequality and racism and sexism and the violence inherent in the system because you don’t want ME to tip.
- Geminidog 6y agoIt's not that simple. People argue about it mainly because their's potential for not tipping to piss off your server. He could spit in your soup or smear your steak on the ground a couple of times before bringing it out to you. This expectation of tipping is forcing me to tip or I'm eating the saliva of a disgruntled server.
- vsskanth 6y agoTipping isn't the problem here. It's about establishing baseline pay. Restaurant staff shouldn't be paid lower than minimum wage, which is already pretty low and be expected to make it up with tips.
- Bostonian 6y agoIf an employer and employee agree on a wage rate, I don't think it's the government's business to intervene, regardless of the level. If you think someone is being underpaid at wage x, create a comparable job paying more than x.
- jgwil2 6y agoWe're not even discussing the minimum wage here; it already is a thing whether you agree with it or not. The question is whether there should be two different rates for positions that are customarily tipped, thus decreasing price transparency and shifting the responsibility of paying the employees from the employer to the customer.
- vsskanth 6y agoThis is a classic argument but it doesn't hold when one needs to work for their basic needs in order to survive (food, clothing, shelter, healthcare). If basic needs are gauranteed in some way for everyone, then yes, you don't need a minimum wage and can work for whatever wage rate you want.
- nicolas_t 6y agoThe problem I have with tipping in the US is that because of the judgement that prevents restaurants from forcing the waiters to share tips with the kitchen staff it means that Waiters end up being better paid and better compensated than kitchen staff in many cases (especially in upscale restaurants where the minimum accepted 20% tip is often a not insignificant amount of money). And, while good service is welcome, I never go to a restaurant for the waiters, I go there because of the food. I've eaten at restaurants with absolutely awful service and came back often because the food was amazing. I've never once came back to a restaurant where the food was mediocre but the service was amazing. So why should my tips go to the least important staff in the restaurant?
- learc83 6y agoI don't like the concept of tipping in the first place (although I make an effort to tip well anyway), but I definitely do not want tipping expanded any further than it already is. If restaurant owners can create an even more opaque pricing structure that shifts the rest of their employee costs onto customers they will.
- mbirth 6y agoThing is, it's not even the restaurant owners that are blocking a change to "all incl." prices - it's the waiters, too. Waiting is one of the very few jobs where an untrained person can earn lots of money just by doing their job and being nice.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoThis is one reason why turnover is so high in the back end. Not only are many overworked, but they also get bitched at by everybody in the restaurant if they don't do something right or have to make a change. Meanwhile waiters and expos don't have any actual skills.
- JackFr 6y agoIf you haven’t noticed turnover in the front of the house is also very high.
- CivBase 6y ago> In 1942, the Supreme Court ruled that employees had an exclusive right to their tips and that their employers could not force them to share their tips with kitchen staff. What happened to that? What I really can't stand about tipping is that most of the time it goes to some dumb "tip share" scheme. My wife (then GF) worked at several restaurants in college and they all had tip shares. Even hosts and kitchen staff were included in the share. They were all payed under minimum wage, but the restaurant had to pay the difference if the tips alone didn't bring their wages up to the minimum (which happened more often than not). I realized that when I tip, I'm usually not rewarding the waiter/waitress. That reward usually gets split across dozens of people and my waiter/waitress likely sees none of it. Worse still, most of the time it isn't even a bonus to their wage. The $5/hr-ish is effectively deducted from their tips so I'm just paying their wages so the restaurant doesn't have to. What a scam. Regardless what you think of tipping, tip shares should absolutely be illegal.
- JackFr 6y agoIn my experience, the waiters tipped the bar staff and the busboys out of our own tips A our discretion. And in general the bar staff did a good job, but they absolutely knew which waiters tipped well and which tipped poorly.
- Nursie 6y agoThat seems absurd.
- mbirth 6y agoAlso I've heard in some places, the amount to share is calculated from the overall tips. So if you had a bad evening and made less than your colleagues, you're actually paying part of the share out of your own pocket. But still, there seem to be lots of people willing to do these jobs.
- CivBase 6y ago> But still, there seem to be lots of people willing to do these jobs. You mean the students, fresh grads, and otherwise-unemployed who basically have no other choice? I'm not sure them being "willing to do these jobs" is a great defense for the practice considering their alternative.
- pmoriarty 6y agoAnother interesting reversal is that boy's clothes used to be pink, and girl's clothes used to be blue.. the opposite of what they are today.
- Izkata 6y agoI think I remember reading, some years ago, that although it was pink the past "boy pink" was darker than modern "girl pink" - somewhere closer to light red...
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoMy problem with tipping is that we’ve carved up a small section of America and said “for these employees, it’s the responsibility of the patrons to make sure the staff are paid” Combine that with the fact that food value is a poor indicator of work. Someone who delivers a $100 bottle of wine should not be paid the same as someone who flips $100 worth of hamburgers.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoAnd that section gets bigger and bigger every year. Tip for drivers, delivery, movers, cashiers, barbers, doormen. But not the janitors, nursing assistants, cooks, non food establishment cashiers, retail workers, etc.
- longtimegoogler 6y agoIn some parts of Asia, tipping isn't a thing. So much nicer than agonizing over a tip. Just charge what something is worth. As a former waiter, I realize the importance of tips for them, but it seems like the system is broken. I remember where I worked, waiters would avoid servicing a table where. They new the customer was a poor tipper and force the new guy to take their order. It always seemed shitty.
- katbyte 6y agoIn canada and there is a restaurant near me that doesn't prompt for tip on the machine when paying - i go there more often the other places for this reason.
- alkonaut 6y agoHow close is legislation to make restaurants pay minimum wages before tip? If it’s not close, why? It seems that would solve a lot of the problems surrounding tipping and the employee situation in restaurants in general.
- qppo 6y agoIt's already the case in several places. The people most opposed to that legislation are the bar/waitstaff. Anecdotally, I know bartenders with take home pay close to engineers. They don't want tipping to go away.
- learc83 6y agoTipping isn't going away just because waitstaff make minimum wage. It's too ingrained in the culture. As evidence tipping still exists and hasn't declined in the areas where those laws are already in effect. I'm sure there are bartenders making 6 figures, but according to the BLS, the 90th percentile make $40k with tips. The median pay is $10. That's lower than minimum wage in a lot of places, so I doubt that many bartenders are against minimum wage before tips (none of the ones I know are).
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI can see a reason why receivers of cash tips would not be honest with how much they earn, especially to the government.
- learc83 6y agoI'm sure that makes a small difference, but I doubt it's enough to meaningfully change the conclusion. 1. The BLS knows this, so they get their data from multiple services--not just government agencies. 2. The IRS knows this, so are more likely to audit people who work in industries that receive tip income. 3. If the BLS numbers were vastly underestimating bartender income because of unreported cash tips, you would expect bartender income to have risen much faster than other similar low wage jobs over the last 20 years as cash has become less common. This hasn't happened.
- keiferski 6y agoI have a pet theory on why tipping remains popular in America. It goes something like this: Americans want the illusion of choice, even if they repeatedly make the same predictable choices. So, even if most people just add 15-20% (whatever the local norm is), they, in theory, have the ability to pay more or less, depending on the service. If the tip was factored into the price, the customer would lose that ability, even if they don’t actually use it very often, if at all.
- cmdshiftf4 6y agoAmericans also use tipping as a status signal, despite it being socially grotesque. Even here on HN we'll regularly witness people proudly proclaiming that they've tipped 50% or more for "good" service. Not content with showing off their status to whoever had the poor fortune to be dining with them, and the waiter/waitress that served the group, they also relish in the opportunity of soaking randoms online in their lavishness post-factum.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThe amazing thing I’ve seen is tipping makes people feel better just like charity makes them feel better. The little aspect of having the power to treat someone with your funds is a nice ego boost. Paying more in taxes or increasing the minimum wage doesn’t have the same effect, even though it would result in a more egalitarian society. The power to select who received the benefit from you is important.
- cmwelsh 6y agoIs there something wrong with tipping 50%? I didn’t realize my actions could be considered “socially grotesque”. Hospitality staff absolutely don’t mind extra money - I know from experience.
- Dayshine 6y agoIf you have the money to give away, perhaps use it more efficiently and give it to charity. Deliberately overpaying is a bad thing when you're either feeding a company or gifting a stranger, neither of which need the money anywhere near as much.
- Bostonian 6y agoThere is much anti-tipping sentiment in this thread, but customers have information about the quality of service that restaurant managers do not, so the ability to leave a large tip, small tip, or no tip at all should improve service on average.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoIt improves service if people who look like you tip a lot. If people who look like you don’t tip, it makes it worse.
- mplanchard 6y agoOr it breeds a horrific culture of obsequious, servile service, where you’re bothered every five minutes during your meal so that your server can ask if everything is still okay. I’ll take European style service any day of the week. Sure you have to get their attention when you need it, but they don’t rush you out and they only bother you when you want them to do so.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoThe waiter bothering you is not about trying to seem helpful in pursuit of more tips. It is because they want to nudge you to free up the table for the next customers. Sadly, this same culture of asking you every five minutes "Is everything OK/Can I get you something else" is spreading in Europe, because the business owner wants to boost turnover, ambience be damned. The centuries-old concept of the intellectual cafe in Central Europe where you could order just a coffee and then spend two hours at the table talking with your peers, is now dying out: the proprietor wants you to drink your coffee quickly and then either order more or get out. Sometimes the business owner intentionally plays bad pop music loudly, so that it becomes uncomfortable to maintain a conversation in the long term.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoAs rent prices increase, I can imagine it’s the only possibility. Merchant A calculated they can earn $x from y customers in a hours, so they can afford rent accordingly. Merchant B calculates they can earn more than $x by increasing the number of customers, therefore merchant B offers to pay a higher rent. Now they have to make sure sufficient customers (or sufficient revenue per customer per hour) is being met to afford the rent. Only solution would be to move to a place with lower rents, I think. Or start explicitly paying rent for your table at the cafe per unit of time, but that might be unsavory to most people.
- k33n 6y agoThe extreme authoritarian left truly believes that the best way to improve society, is to first drive it into the ground by making everything worse.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI think it would be better for society to codify living wages and better working conditions, and provide education for all as a means for advancement rather than tell poor, underprivileged people to grovel at the feet of a benevolent rich person who can help them move up the hierarchy. Of course, that solution would make rich people less rich and less “powerful” by not subjecting those with less to their charity, so I can see why some would oppose it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- beever 6y agoTipping is out of control in The US. Everyday it seems we're being asked to tip in new situations where there never was such an expectation before. This is really just employers passing their staff costs on to customers. Also, if you have a "tip" jar on the counter at a takeout joint or convenience store you're not asking for a tip, you're panhandling at work. I really don't appreciate the attempt to guilt me into paying extra for a gallon of milk or whatever.
- Geminidog 6y agoI only tip because I'm afraid of what they will do to my food if I don't. https://www.menshealth.com/trending-news/a19547701/how-restaurant-servers-mess-with-your-food/ https://www.menshealth.com/trending-news/a19547701/how-resta...
- ufmace 6y agoThe real thing with tipping IMO is the unknown of where and when it's expected. At least at restaurants, it's pretty standard that you're supposed to tip and roughly how much. It's like, there's some mysterious unknown correct tip amount. If you don't just automatically know this amount and don't tip at all or too little, then you're a jerk. If you tip too much, then you're a sucker or trying to get some other kind of favor. How about if you want to make a particular amount of money for doing some job, you just tell me how much you want? I can either agree and pay it and we're both happy, or not do it at all and at least nobody feels ripped off.
- OkGoDoIt 6y agoLike with Uber, one of the key features for a long time was there was no way to leave a tip, so there was no awkward question as to whether you should leave a tip. But now they ask for tips so prominently. Am I supposed to leave a tip? Uber is so expensive already, it’s not like adding a tip is something I’m willing to do unless I absolutely have to, like it’s understood I have to at a restaurant. It’s so frustrating.
- ziml77 6y agoLack of tips was the best thing about Uber. I've always found tipping to be absurd and actually hoped that Uber's popularity would help it set precedent in regards to tipping. It was disappointing to see them cave in to the complaints and add it in.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoThe worst part about mandatory tipping in the United States is that it does not improve service at all, and the service in American restaurants strikes me as poor and stuck in a rut: it is mainly in North America that waiters continually circle about back to the table uninvited, asking “Are you doing OK?” or “Can I get you anything else?” when you are just trying to have a private and leisurely conversation with your dinner companions. Sometimes this must be because their boss is telling them to gently push customers out the door to free up the table. Sometimes it might be because the waiter himself releases that by freeing up the table for another set of diners, he stands to get obligatory-tipped twice that evening instead of just once. But with a culture of obligatory tipping, customers have no way to penalize waiters for such over-intrusive behavior.
- Kinrany 6y agoTipping itself should be that mechanism. "You kept interrupting us after we asked you not to do so. No tip for you"
- Kinrany 6y agoI'd appreciate if someone who disagrees explained their point of view. Is that not why fixed tips exist? To reward good service? Everyone pays the same percentage, except when the service is exceptionally good or bad?
- bobbean 6y agoI've worked at a restaurant for years, same with my friends. Good servers know how to not be too pushy. You greet them when they sit down, ask for drinks. You drop off drinks, take an order for appetizers. When you drop off appetizers, you take their food order and look around to check to see if anyone needs refills. You come back with refills, and then bring over the food when it's done. You walk past the table to check if there is any empty dishes to grab, and ask if they need anything else when you do. Basically, my point is every trip that you need to make anyways, you check the table. If a table is hanging for too long, you start to get a little more pushy, because it's a business that's trying to make money. If it's a busy Saturday night and you have a table that doesn't want to leave, other people have to wait longer for that table, and also the restaurant makes less money. Imagine your annoyance if you make a reservation at a restaurant, and you get sat late because people are taking 3 hours to finish up. Your point about obligatory tipping and not being able to penalize servers doesn't make any sense. If service is that bad, you just don't tip. If a server yells at you, you talk to the manager or just walk out the door. I've put zero for a tip a few times and no one has given me a hard time, and if they do, your night was already ruined by awful service anyways. Also, if you make it out the door in time, the servers won't even see your check by the time you're gone. If you can't bring yourself not to tip someone, that's on you. It happens ALL THE TIME. Almost every other night a server will tell me that so and so didn't tip, or tipped a dollar, etc. By the way, none of this is for or against tipping, I'm just explaining my thoughts on the current system.
- cabite 6y agoReservoir Dog "I don't tip" scene: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4sbYy0WdGQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4sbYy0WdGQ
- difosfor 6y agoUnfortunately tipping is becoming more and more common in the Netherlands. Seems to be blowing (back?) over from the States. I wish places would just charge higher prices and pay decent wages and keep things simple.
- jb1991 6y agoA lot has to do with the blending of tourist-only places with more local places. In some countries, tourists typically tip, locals don't. But if you are a local and visit a touristy place, you'll see the tip expectation, and then this starts to permeate the culture.
- Symbiote 6y agoIn Denmark, I've had the waitress press "nej" to the tip on the card terminal once I brought out a Danish credit card. "Sorry, I didn't realise you were local."
- ht_th 6y agoIt is? I haven't tipped in years, whereas I did in the 1990s. Maybe because I never pay with cash anymore. Then it was common to round up to the next multiple of 5. Even so, I never have had wait staff asking for a tip.
- grecy 6y agoAs a non-American, tipping makes me feel disgusting(Footnote). Tipping is about waiving money around so other human beings literally cater to my every whim, on demand. IF I deem their service appropriate, and IF I'm in the right mood, I might give them some of my money. Or not, simply because. It's a disgusting way that rich people lord it over poor people, and every time I experience it my skin crawls. It's no surprise at all that rich people really like the idea of tipping, because it lets them flaunt their money, and people of lower classes will literally scramble to get some of it. What's the point in having a ton of money if other people aren't impressed/trying to impress you/make you happy. (Footnote) I still always tip, because the staff need it to survive.
- tshaddox 6y ago> Tipping is about waiving money around so other human beings literally cater to my every whim, on demand. IF I deem their service appropriate, and IF I'm in the right mood, I might give them some of my money. The thing is, that’s isn’t even how it functions! It functions as a social norm with a very strong taboo against violating a customary minimum tip (often around 15-20% of the receipt).
- edmundsauto 6y agoI agree with your emotional reactions to people flaunting wealth. I also tip 25+% because I can afford to and I'm genuinely grateful for the services provided.
- Razengan 6y agoCustomers directly paying employees wages is one of the most bizarre things about America.
- Razengan 6y ago*giving
- jb1991 6y agoJust like in some parks you'll see signs "don't feed the birds," in Singapore at some places, you'll see signs "don't tip the waiters." In some cultures, it is considered rude if you tip.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoAlways tip (in the United States) because your server often makes depression-era wages and sometimes, in some establishments, your server also has to split that tip with the kitchen staff. The people who create your dining experience will be underpaid for their irreplaceable time if you do not tip. Consider tipping 30% for breakfast because customers tend to sit for longer, resulting in lower customer turnover and fewer tips than other times of day.
- gHosts 6y agoThat's because USA is broken. I went from a tipping + starvation wages culture to a no tipping + living wage culture. Soooooooooo much better. Sadly the push to deunionize and deregulate and zero hour contracts.... is pushing things towards starvation wages here. But the solution isn't tipping. The solution is to pay attention to complaints of worker abuse and the boycott such businesses. If that causes the business to die, we're all better off without it in the long run. Killing off non viable jobs is a mercy killing, it allows viable businesses to survive. Racing to the bottom is a loss for all.
- codegeek 6y agoBut why should I be forced to do what the employer should be doing in the first place ? Hear me out. I totally agree that waiters get paid like shit and their jobs are tough. I have sympathy for them but this culture of "oh poor waiters so we must tip" is basically encouraging bad practices. I would rather pay more for a meal while the waiter gets paid well by their employer. Why is it my job as a customer to worry about the waiter's financial well being ? Lets do free market. Raise prices, charge more and pay your waiters more. If no one eats at your restaurant, you know your food was shitty. People pay big bucks for good food, always.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoI choose to participate because I do not have the time or resources to make the necessary changes to labor laws and regulations.
- laegooose 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WXXPYxyn5mA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WXXPYxyn5mA brilliant dialogue about tipping from Tarantino's Reservoir Dogs. Steve Buscemi's character doesn't tip and a group of others try to convince him to do it
- JJMcJ 6y agoWas watching The Petrified Forest, a 1936 film starring Humphrey Bogart, and part of it takes place in a diner, and on the wall is a sign: Tipping is un-American Keep your change So the idea was alive in some sense even into the 30s.
- mrtweetyhack 6y agoI actually stopped eating out due to the tipping requirement
- addled 6y agoI was surprised when a Romanian friend told me tips were common in hospitals over there. The national healthcare system was "free", but a surgery might still cost a couple hundred in gifts to the surgeon, anesthesiologist, etc. A couple bucks to the nurses that check in on you during your stay. Good luck getting your bedding changed regularly if you're in a coma and don't have a family member around to dispense tips in your behalf. Sample size of 1 is pretty small. Anyone else from the region able to corroborate? Sometimes it is good to get a 2nd opinion.
- stephen_cagle 6y agoI wish we could get rid of tipping culture entirely. It is absurd that a business is allowed to pay less than minimum wage because they "make it up in tips". Also annoys me because I am never clear who I am punishing/rewarding with my tips. I can't think of a good way to undo tipping culture though. Best thought I have had is to have something like a 60% tax rate on tips. So you can tip, but you should know that 3/5 of it is just going to the Feds. Might disincentivize tipping to the point that it dies out. Other obvious thing is to remove the ability for anyone to be paying less than minimum wage; that is absurd.
- jalla 6y agoMandatory service charges are not the solution. It's equally disgusting. It just shows that business owners rely on a government controlled mandatory tipping system to pay its wages.