8 ms·
I was recently met with a new popup in the Instagram app, asking me to allow it to track me across applications. I actually said yes, because I get great targe
by jedberg 6y ago
I was recently met with a new popup in the Instagram app, asking me to allow it to track me across applications. I actually said yes, because I get great targeted ads in Instagram and Facebook. I've clicked on multiple ads and actually even made purchases of things that I didn't know about that looked interesting.
But the important part is that I do it willingly. I'm glad they were forced to ask -- not everyone is ok with that kind of tracking, and that's the whole point. I'm totally with Apple on this one. Give people choice.
I made my choice, and everyone else should get to make theirs too.
- Despegar 6y agoI haven't gotten that popup. Are you sure that's actually a meaningful choice you can make and not just a test to see how many people are going to opt-in when this finally rolls out in iOS?
- jedberg 6y agoNo idea. Since I said yes my experience didn't change. Could be a test of some sort. I'm on the iOS beta so that might have something to do with it.
- monocularvision 6y agoHave you maybe turned off the ability for apps to ask at all? I have.
- overlordalex 6y agoI'm on Android and I get this popup in Instagram every few months (I'm assuming because I decline every time), so I doubt it's iOS related
- macjohnmcc 6y agoThe App showed a message asking if I would prefer targeted ads. It just asked me yesterday so there is hope for you!
- stingraycharles 6y agoYeah I’m honestly not sure how anyone can make a case against giving users a choice with a straight face. We’re already conditioned to all these annoying GDPR pop ups anyway, so it’s not like another one would disrupt the status quo. Besides, contrary to the GDPR “consent” pop-ups, this upcoming iOS one actually has a useful impact.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoWould you pay a small amount for those ads?
- jedberg 6y agoWhy would I pay for targeted ads? You mean because I find them useful? I assume they're more useful to the advertisers than to me. I am willing to not get paid by them since I find them useful.
- pinko 6y agoI think the parent question is interesting... you say you derive value from them, so it's somewhat conspicuous and seemingly arbitrary (rather than intentional, or calculated) that you've happened upon exactly $0.00 as the value to you, rather than negative (you'd like no ads unless you're being paid to compensate for the pain, loss of privacy, etc.) or positive (because you enjoy them and derive value out of them as a discovery service)...
- Zarel 6y agoI don't think jedberg said anything that implies the value is exactly $0.00. Rather, jedberg has already found way more suppliers than he needs, all willing to supply him ads at $0.00, which makes that the equilibrium price. Analogously, I would value oxygen basically infinitely high because I don't want to die. However, I would never pay for it because I can easily get it for free, and would laugh at anyone who tried to charge me for permission to breathe. I think it's difficult in general for people to put a price on most of the things they get for free, just because they're used to getting them for free, and build their price intuitions on being able to get them for free.
- jonas21 6y agoMany things end up at exactly $0.00 because the transaction costs (handling payments, dealing with refunds, reporting taxes, etc.) exceed whatever value the thing has. This is part of the reason why so many things are ad-supported to begin with -- even if someone is willing to pay $0.03 to read a random article, there's no effective way to collect that.
- OneTwoPetitFour 6y agoThanks for the perspective. I was an early Instagram user, but deleted my account not so long after they introduced stories. Recently, I registered a new account, and after a grace period without ads, I was surprised by just how drenched it has become in advertising. I used it to follow professional athletes. First of, many of the organic posts are themselves sponsored advertising, then the athletes share brand posts from their sponsors, and then between every story you get an actual ad. Of course, with more personal connections the trade of might be different, but for my use case described above Instagram seemed unsustainable.
- an_opabinia 6y ago> but for my use case described above Instagram seemed unsustainable. Which part? Another interpretation is, professional athletes don't really enrich your life at all. You have as big a problem with celebrity as you do with a piece of software.
- mastazi 6y agoI'm not parent but I follow many professional athletes as well and in my case Instagram is very useful! In fact it's the one social media account I didn't get rid of. For two reasons mainly: * Announcements - Some of the sports I follow don't have a "regular season" like e.g. Basketball or American Football, they are organised more like boxing where an athlete may compete for one federation or another, and the events don't follow a pre-determined schedule: so you need to keep up with the news if you want to be able to watch them at all. * Instructionals - athletes often will publish instructional videos and when that happens they advertise them on their channels. Those are usually an order of magnitude more in-depth than anything you can find for free (e.g. Youtube) - I was never very athletic but I'm finally trying to get better so those are very helpful for me. (Edit: Of course this is a form of advertising but I'm very disciplined and avoid overspending at all costs, I buy instructionals once in a blue moon).
- jedberg 6y agoMost of the people I follow are friends with kids. It's how we swap pictures of our kids. The rest of my follows are web comics. I follow a couple of "famous" people, but they are mostly people with compelling content and not vapid influencer content. My experience seems to be that I see a whole bunch of fresh updates from friends, and then ads. If I'm looking when there are few updates, it's mostly ads. If I see mostly ads I know that I should put the phone down and come back in a few hours. :)
- eitland 6y agoI get another popup in Facebook that only has an opt-in no opt out. I've screenshottet it and it might very well become my second actual gdpr complaint. My first was a few days ago when "HP smart" demanded with no workaround that I hand over my email address to print on my own old printer.
- Spooky23 6y agoAre you ok? I’ve never heard any anyone this thrilled about an ad experience in my life.
- na85 6y agoJedberg was (is?) an administrator at reddit which is an ad-supported business. He has a financial incentive to like advertising.
- jedberg 6y agoHeh, it's funny you mention that. For the longest time I refused to run Adblock because it felt hypocritical. But eventually the experience got so bad I relented. I wouldn't say I have an incentive for internet ads to be successful. From the very beginning I advocated for revenue streams other than ads. And reddit is fairly diversified. I don't work there anymore anyway. I guess I just don't mind advertising if done well and is relevant.
- na85 6y agoI guess I just can't, no matter how hard I try, imagine why a person would think ads are good, especially targeted ads. The only reason I can come up with is that a person would willingly look past how odious advertising is because it pays their bills. If as you say that's not the case then can you help me understand why?
- jedberg 6y agoTL;DR: It gives me ideas of ways to spend money I was already going to spend, but now I have a place to start my research with some concrete ideas. Well, I've given the example of live shows a couple of times. I've been to a few live shows that I learned about from targeted ads. Those were experiences I enjoyed and would not have learned about otherwise. I'll pull up my Insta feed right now and list the targeted ads: Osmo -- This is a game system for my kids that I already own. The ad isn't super useful, except I just learned about a new game they're releasing that I might want to get for my daughter. I may have eventually seen this elsewhere, but this is the first I'm seeing it. Osmo again. But from a different vendor. Lego -- They have some new sets that I didn't know about. I enjoy building legos with my kids, so now I know about a few new sets we might enjoy together. Something called Soundbrenner. It's a gadget for musicians. I'm not a musician so this doesn't interest me. None the less, I am glad I know about this because I have musician friends who might be interested in something like this, so maybe the next time I talk to them I'll mention it, and they may be appreciative of me telling them because it can give them an idea of a new way to improve their play. Maybe they'll buy the gadget, maybe they'll find something similar, maybe they'll build something similar. A charity for helping teachers during Christmas. This interests me. I support education and there is a good chance I'll make a donation to this cause. Now I'm happy that I found out about this charity. An ad for a service that turns pictures of your pets into hand done oil paintings. I don't have pets, but one of my best friends does as do my parents, so there is a possibility I'll use this service as a Christmas gift. A contest to win a Lamborghini featured in a lady gaga video. This is mistargeted and I have no interest. A food sealing kitchen gadget. I'm going to forward this to my wife, who loves cooking gadgets, and then she'll check her cooking forums for someone who had a DIY version, but now she has a new idea to ask about. Bed Bath and Beyond. Meh, don't really care. A clothing company that follows the Tom's model of buy one give one. I don't like the clothes, but if I did, this is the kind of thing I might support if I need new clothes. Some sort of prescription drug. The ad doesn't even say what it cures. So I have no interest in this. However, if it happened to be for an ailment that I actually have, I'd probably click through to find out more and be a jumping point for my own research. Quicken Loans. I actually hate this ad because it encourages people to refinance their 30 year mortgage into a 15 year mortgage which is a terrible idea. Another ad for musicians, this time an app. Same comment as above -- not interested but I may mention to a friend. An ad for a new star wars game in VR. As it turns out, I recently bought an Occulus (from someone on HN actually) so this might be a game I would be interested in. I probably would have found out about this later when looking for new games, but this is the first I've heard of this game. Another Lego ad, this time a different set. Anyway, I could keep going, as the ads are endless (although they start to repeat). The point is, in most of these cases, I learned something new that I didn't know before. Yes, in every case, they are trying to get me to spend money. But it's money I probably would have been spending anyway (Christmas presents, games my kids and I can play together, games I can play alone, charity donations). So I'm glad that I now have some ideas and places to start looking. In a lot of cases, the ads are just jumping off points for research, but they give me new ideas I wouldn't have thought of.
- aspyct 6y ago"made purchases of things that I didn't know about that looked interesting" Interestingly, that's precisely the reason I hate targeted ads. They just make me buy more things I didn't otherwise need. I see your main point though, it's nice to give the choice.
- ponker 6y agojedberg likely has a lot of cash to spend on random shit, he ran Site Reliability at Netflix which pays its entry level engineers $400K.
- obmelvin 6y agojust for other people's context: "entry level" in netflix is not the same as entry level even at other big companies (i.e. FB or Google), they only take experienced engineers
- bigbubba 6y agoFrivolous overconsumption is harmful to society and the environment, not just to your wallet.
- hated 6y agoThe large amount of debt ceded from society to jedberg in exchange for aiding and abetting the pollution of peoples' minds is morally reprehensible and disgusting to me
- foolfoolz 6y agothis is the weirdest take on ads i’ve ever heard. sounds like “i have too much money and enjoy when people show me new ways of spending it”
- FDSGSG 6y ago>i have too much money and enjoy when people show me new ways of spending it Is there something wrong with that?
- jedberg 6y agoThe purpose of ads is to inform people of things they wouldn't otherwise know about. In that regard, I appreciate good ads that tell me about things I would want to know about and didn't already.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThe purpose of ads is to get you to buy things you wouldn’t have otherwise. The vendors aren’t interested in you being informed, that would mean considering competitive products.
- throwaway2245 6y ago> The purpose of ads is to inform people of things they wouldn't otherwise know about. You keep saying that, but that is plainly a positive spin on the purpose and not completely truthful. If that were the purpose, why are there adverts for e.g. milk?
- cma 6y ago> The purpose of ads is to inform people of things they wouldn't otherwise know about. I don't see how this squares with things like blatant scare mongering smearing in political ads, and things like cowboys riding a truck up Mt. Everest to crack open a beer. Ads can be there just to associate emotional moods and undertones with a product or person, etc., and aren't only about surfacing unknown products.
- mcintyre1994 6y agoI wonder how you get into a useful ads category! Instagram usually wants to show me either absurdly expensive luxury property, student flats to rent near universities I’ve never been to, or luxury investment property in Dubai. They did at one point think I’d want to constantly see massively marked up dumbbells when they were sold out everywhere but when I didn’t bite they went back to showing me property I can’t afford in areas I don’t live.
- FDSGSG 6y agoIf you can work remotely or own your own business, luxury property in Dubai can actually be pretty interesting. It's not a bad place to live, no taxes and ridiculously low real estate prices make it a rather attractive proposal.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoI disagree. This cross-app tracking is an anti-trust concern. Plus, it's just fiscally irresponsible to give users choices. Facebook doesn't run a business in the real world, instead they play "games" which have optimal strategies and numbers to min/max. The more money they sink into surveillance-advertising, the more incentive they have to push users to actually use it. That incentive never goes away, it just builds pressure over time. This pressure inevitably manifests as lobbying money to rewrite the law in their own interest. There is a common saying in the U.S. with regards to business: "You are either growing or you are dying." We don't need to live inside of a panopticon in order to figure what shows are playing in town, what new items are down at the shops. Tell me what city you live in; I can help you find stuff around town at no cost and I don't even have to spy on you.