3 ms·
> Yes, the Intel policy to intentionally cripple their cheaper SKUs, hoping to extort money from customers by pushing them to buy more expensive SKUs, is extrem
by mschuster91 6y ago
> Yes, the Intel policy to intentionally cripple their cheaper SKUs, hoping to extort money from customers by pushing them to buy more expensive SKUs, is extremely annoying.
I agree that this practice sucks, but to play devils advocate - is it possible that this is due to binning / yield maximization?
- temac 6y agoI would think that maybe they can save a very low proportion of chips with ECC not-working, but the large majority would be completely arbitrary market segmentation: handling of ECC is going to be limited to a small relative surface area of the die. Now Intel 10nm still seems to be so bad that maybe it is interesting enough to bin on that, and maybe that's the cause Tiger Lake is even more limited on ECC capabilities than before in the various SKU. Although we already saw a restrictive move on Comet Lake. Instead of continuing to multiply their SKU (I think they had enough even 5 or 10 years ago), Intel should go back to the drawing board and ship interesting microarch on better nodes...
- Dylan16807 6y ago> I agree that this practice sucks, but to play devils advocate - is it possible that this is due to binning / yield maximization? Oh definitely not. They disable all kinds of arbitrary features that are totally unrelated to yield.
- rcxdude 6y agoYup. Number of cores, cache size, and clock speed are things which make sense for binning to improve yield. Most other features do not (ECC memory support does not require much silicon, the odds of it being damaged while the rest of the chip is OK are too slim for binning to make sense).