3 ms·
> Why does it feel like no other software company has these sort of branding issues? Google's internal incentive structure strongly favors shipping — at least,
by edouard-harris 6y ago
> Why does it feel like no other software company has these sort of branding issues?
Google's internal incentive structure strongly favors shipping — at least, it did back in the day, and I believe that's still true now to a great extent. Steve Yegge said it most concisely back in 2006 [1]: "At Google, projects launch because it's the least-energy state for the system."
The problem is that when one dedicates so much optimization power to shipping, there's less left over for things like maintenance and support. That might not be a huge deal for any individual product, but in the aggregate it sets a higher bar for keeping an initiative running — which presents externally as an excessive proclivity for killing products.
That perception, in turn, erodes user trust in the continuing existence of Google's portfolio of non-flagship products. And that leads to even fewer of those products clearing the bar for maintenance funding, because users are less willing to commit to using a product that may be discontinued.
Google's shipping-first bias was probably a huge advantage for them in the early days. But sometimes a company outgrows aspects of its culture.
[1] https://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/09/ https://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/09/
- telltruth 6y agoPart of the problem is also that lot of Google products are free. So there is no real way to measure bottom line impact when they mess with or kill things outright. Their current upper management is basically MBAs focused only on bottom line so birthing new free products and killing them is not something they care too much about. Birthing is driven by empire builders and killing is driven by Ruth Porat.
- mike_d 6y agoThings at Google aren't killed because they do or don't make money. Sure people have budget meetings and fight over hardware allocations, but things die because no engineers want to work on them. You don't get promoted for doing your job and maintaining things, you get promoted for inventing and doing new stuff.
- igetspam 6y agoThat's not entirely true. There have been plenty of shutdowns over the inability to monetize, either directly or via ads or data collection. Products have to have a value add for G or they don't survive. It's just that "money" isn't the only currency. The statement about promotion is spot on though.