7 ms·
Because Apple decided that only software they approve of can be used on machines they sell unless the user explicitly allows software Apple hasn't accepted (via
by judge2020 6y ago
Because Apple decided that only software they approve of can be used on machines they sell unless the user explicitly allows software Apple hasn't accepted (via ctrl-click). On iOS, Apple decided that users can't allow untrusted software at all. Users still end up paying $400-$1400 for phones that run this software, so the 'free market' has decided that users want a software model like this (otherwise Android would be an even bigger player in the US than it is now).
- zeusk 6y agoPeople still paid $1400 for PCs in 1999, nothing stopped US govt from suing Microsoft for bundling IE - let alone not allowing users to run "unapproved" software.
- zaroth 6y agoMicrosoft had 90% market share. And in the end they settled.
- zeusk 6y agoBy offering the user a choice for the browser, which is exactly what I want from Apple - a choice for app store, or the default maps app.
- tesmar2 6y agoPetition them or switch to Android. No one’s forcing you to buy it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- slivanes 6y agoAnd yet Apple is forcing the lack of choice in an app store.
- tesmar2 6y agoSo? It’s their platform.
- itismetheidiot 6y agofrom a European point of view, the market belongs to the people, not Apple and thus they must play by the rules the State set, for and on the behalf of the people.
- valparaiso 6y agoApp Store is not a separate market. It's separate business as stated by Apple lawyers and judge agreed on September 28th. EU judges need to firstly define this as a "new market", which will shock the whole industry.
- zaroth 6y agoBut don’t you think — it’s their phone, they have spent billions of dollars developing it, shouldn’t they get the choice of how their own product should work? It’s not like the user doesn’t know what they are buying. It’s not like Apple doesn’t have strong competitors. It’s not like the app developers are like, “Oh, 30%?! I didn’t know!” People want the product that Apple is making. They buy it knowingly and willingly in droves. Look at the M1, the culmination of decades of hard R&D, beating Intel at their own game. You want to tell this company — which is absolutely killing it and creating absolutely tremendous value for consumers the world over — you want to tell them how their own device should work?! Explain to me why the free market has not spoken, and spoken clearly in favor of the products that Apple has brought to market for their customers. Why in the world should the US Government say that what this truly amazing company should do in their own code and product roadmap. Honestly, it’s a travesty in the making. What Apple has accomplished — coming back from the brink — is one of the greatest success stories in the history of capitalism. Why, why in the world should the US Government — a true paragon of incompetence — dictate terms on how they should run their lawful, competitive business.
- R0b0t1 6y ago>But don’t you think — it’s their phone, they have spent billions of dollars developing it, shouldn’t they get the choice of how their own product should work? Maybe? But then they're not selling it, they're leasing it, and they need to say that.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 6y ago>> But don’t you think — it’s their phone, they have spent billions of dollars developing it, shouldn’t they get the choice of how their own product should work? No. Its MY phone from the moment I bought it. If I want to change some aspect of how it works that's up to me.
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoOn the other hand, you knew these restrictions before purchasing it and still continued with the transaction. I understand both perspectives here but I don't think one is objectively right.
- heavyset_go 6y agoAnd quite literally a choice for a browser, because Apple mandates that all browsers on the App Store use Safari on the backend, which means that Chrome and Firefox are just skins over Safari on iOS.
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoThis would be huge because Safari is missing so many APIs and leaves users on an unusable browser when they stop getting OS updates.
- Bud 6y agoThis would not be huge, because iOS devices don't stop getting updates for 6-8 years, by which time it is very unlikely that third parties would bother making a special browser app just for that unprofitable 0.1% slice of the market.
- tesmar2 6y agoA mistake then as well. Buy a Mac if you don’t like Microsoft’s approach.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoApple has nothing like the MS market share, though.
- zeusk 6y agoIn US phone market, they do and this isn't just about monopoly per-say but what it means to "own" a computing device if you can only run manufacturer approved applications on it.
- tesmar2 6y agoIf you don’t like the way they sell you a device, start a company that sells the kind of device you want. Or buy a pine phone.
- zeusk 6y agoNot sure if you're trolling, but that's not a rational option for most. I've described elsewhere in thread why switching is not an option for me; Apple has slowly trapped me in their ecosystem of Apple TV, Apple Watch, Macbook, Homepod, my BMW which will only talk to an iOS device, iMessage, HomeKit They don't provide any external APIs to interact with these products so other platforms/systems could make such a switch less painful.
- tesmar2 6y agoI’m certainly not trolling. You’re not trapped. Over time switch to another provider. Or all at once. They sell you a service and device with terms. If you don’t like it, get out of that ecosystem. Certainly don’t use the power of the federal government. Do you like monopolies? Because that’s how you get monopolies.
- intricatedetail 6y ago"They sell you heroin if you don't like it - quit"
- ribosometronome 6y agoMicrosoft had a considerably larger share of the worldwide market.
- frandroid 6y agoWhat free market? It's a duopoly.
- mfcl 6y agoExactly! And it's a bad kind of duopoly. It's not like I'm customer and I only have two choices. Here, I only two choices and I pretty much to use them both since if I drop one I loose a lot of potential customers.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s a duopoly, where one of the players offers people the thing that people are asking for I.e sideloading and alternative app stores. Instead of choosing that product, many people here complain that the other company doesn’t give them what they want.
- on_and_off 6y agothat's a bit of a false dichotomy though. it is not like these 2 products were identical except for sideloading. They don't have the same hardware, Apple has an unlimited ad budget, if you want to chat with somebody using iMessages, you are pretty much limited to iOS, you can't transfer app purchases between platforms, etc
- zepto 6y agoGoogle has an unlimited as budget too. Indeed it has access to advertise on properties that Apple can never purchase access too.
- truyou 6y agoIf you go into subscription settings on iOS devices, they show a "try out apple music" ad -- you think this position is available to Spotify/others? They don't pay 30% on top of sales to boot. Same thing with Google, they cross promote their own new properties everywhere in Gmail (left pane) and Google.com but no one else has access to those locations, they can destroy thousands of small business through this practice.
- EE84M3i 6y agoSorry, I don't use a mac -- could you clarify about ctrl-click to accept? Can you bypass the approved developer check box in system preferences with a right click on the `.app` folder?
- spullara 6y agoOnce you launch an app around the restrictions you don't need to do it again.
- kstrauser 6y agoYes, you can.
- judge2020 6y agoEffectively - if you don't have "only app store" selected in gatekeeper, you can bypass the 'unidentified developer' option as well as the message when an app isn't notarized. https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/open-a-mac-app-from-an-unidentified-developer-mh40616/mac https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/open-a-mac-app-from...
- fennecfoxen 6y agoMacs famously only supply one button, so right click and control-click are two names for the same thing.
- Bud 6y agoMacs ceased to "famously supply" only one mouse button about a billion years ago.
- ddxxdd 6y agoI will believe that the market is truly free when I see multiple start-ups attempt to upend Apple's business model and fail to do so.
- tesmar2 6y agoWhat’s not free about it? Just because they are popular doesn’t mean the market’s not free.
- Siira 6y agoThere are lots of factors in choosing between Android and iOS. Besides, two choices don’t make a competitive market.