6 ms·
Fits well with the current wave of authoritarianism/nationalism that has taken root all over the world. A free and open internet represents everything that a go
by paxys 6y ago
Fits well with the current wave of authoritarianism/nationalism that has taken root all over the world. A free and open internet represents everything that a government that wishes complete control over its people would be afraid of.
- mistermann 6y ago> Fits well with the current wave of authoritarianism/nationalism that has taken root all over the world. Autoritarianism often goes hand in hand with nationalism, but not always. In recent history, it is the non-nationalists who seem to be most pro-censorship, does it not? Unfortunately, due to the extremely dynamic and high velocity nature of current times, this article wasn't able to get into the new flavor of micro-censorship - hopefully they address that in the future.
- lainga 6y agoIndeed, in 1848 authoritarianism and nationalism were the two major opponents on the European political stage.
- mistermann 6y agoA lot of people would say the same thing is happening today.
- war1025 6y agoThe interesting thing about this is that nationalism is in general associated with right-leaning politics, and the censorship is far and away being applied more aggressively to those very same right-leaning nationalist groups. You would be hard pressed to find liberal / progressive content being censored online.
- artursapek 6y agoExactly. There's nothing "nationalist" about the type of censorship we're seeing on Twitter. If anything it's the opposite.
- leanstartupnoob 6y agoWhich government agency is censoring Twitter? Conservatives and libertarians LOVE to bleat about property rights, but they can't handle it when private parties won't provide free advertising for right-wing conspiracies.
- artursapek 6y agoI'm not aware of any govt agency censoring Twitter - only conservatives complaining that Twitter is censoring their tweets.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoJust wait until your favorite social media companies have their data centers raided by Trump for trying to overthrow the US government and are nationalized and converted into nonprofit taxpayer-funded instruments of the first amendment you little faggot. We’ll have your full name and address at that point too. Don’t worry, we won’t kill you, we have far worse plans for you than death.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lliamander 6y agoWhat we LOVE is a market free of force and fraud, and we love rule of law. Within that there are very nuanced conversations to be had about when the threshold for force or fraud has been reached. Enforcement of contracts is essential to a healthy society, but is it good to enforce a contract where one party either lied or coerced the other to sign? No, or at least not necessarily. The nature of the contract between social media platforms and their users (both explicit and implicit) has changed dramatically since the days that Twitter was "the free speech wing of the free speech party". Users have sacrificed a increasing amount of privacy for less and less obvious benefit. In the meantime, many people have come to depend upon these services for connecting with others, for their livelihoods, and for news independent of corporate media. Have the social media companies deceived their users? Or have they forced unconscionable terms upon their users? Have they violated consumer protection laws? I am not a lawyer. I don't know the answers to those questions. But I do know that there are some lawyers and judges who do think that some of these social media companies have overstepped. We don't necessarily need a civil rights case, or a constitutional amendment, or even to repeal Section 230. All I think is necessary is for existing contract and consumer protection laws be litigated and enforced. This kind of action would benefit both left and right, and I think is more constructive than opportunistically deciding that "businesses can do whatever they want" when you think it only hurts people on the right.
- r00fus 6y agoFrom the article: > "Poland blocked human rights sites; India same-sex dating sites" Clearly that's the wheelhouse of the right-leaning national groups, right? Oh, maybe not. Or maybe it's the rightwing nationalist governments cracking down on disadvantaged groups?
- war1025 6y agoI admit I didn't read the article before commenting. Really just seems like anyone that can get away with it is censoring people with differing opinions. Seems like something that will surely end well /s
- r00fus 6y agoAmusing how when it's aligned with your viewpoints (suppression of speech for rightwing groups), it's partisan. Otherwise, it's "anyone can get away with it". Hypocrisy on display
- war1025 6y agoYou misread my comment, which fair enough the wording wasn't great. What I actually said is "anyone who can get away with it" And obviously they would be doing it for partisan reasons.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> You would be hard pressed to find liberal / progressive content being censored online. No, I wouldn't. https://fair.org/home/that-facebook-will-turn-to-censoring-the-left-isnt-a-worry-its-a-reality/ https://fair.org/home/that-facebook-will-turn-to-censoring-t... I might have to work harder to find high-traffic social-media accounts peddling stories about the left being censored online than finding the same thing about the right. But, if so, would that really be evidence that the right was being censored more, or just that its complaints are being amplified more by the very same platforms they claim to be selectively censoring them?
- amznthrwaway 6y agoThe right is full of people who are free to use media to talk about how they can't use media. because the right is full of complete and total liars who lack even the tiniest shred of integrity.
- im3w1l 6y agoThe whole discussion is sapir-whorfed hard by the fake left-right nomenclature. Old-school-leftists, such as communists and socialists are catching ban-hammers, yes that's true. "Pronoun-left" on the other hand is not.
- mattnewton 6y ago> You would be hard pressed to find liberal / progressive content being censored online. I think this is a false dichotomy. Whenever speech calls for violence that upsets the current social-political order in the US, it is censored regardless of being "left" or "right;" one example being the very-left chapo trap house crowd on reddit. My understanding that there is less violent content coming from voices identified as "progressives" that tend to value other more acceptable* methods for social change. * Acceptable meaning something different per platform, but if we are being honest seems to usually mean "can sell mainstream ads space alongside them"
- paxys 6y agoHuh? It's the exact opposite. In the US sites like Facebook & Twitter routinely refuse to censor conservative content even if it is against their policies because they are afraid of pissing off Republicans in Congress. A "liberal" on Facebook calling for the beheading of a conservative politican would be banned (possibly even arrested) immediately. The opposite can and does happen every day, with no penalty. And all this still isn't relevant because we are talking about government censorship.
- war1025 6y agoSince my experience is the complete political reverse of what you describe (liberals getting away with things that conservatives assume they never could), I think the real answer is that probably there is less censorship in general than people assume. And I suppose that's probably a good thing. > And all this still isn't relevant because we are talking about government censorship. Agreed that the article is about government censorship, and I commented before I read the article. However, given that the US government at least has shown very little backbone in its threats to regulate social media companies, their tendency toward more censorship also seems concerning.
- EasyTiger_ 6y agoAre you intentionally trying to gaslight people? This is just straight up false. See Kathy Griffin holding a bloody Trump - a tweet which she’s retweeted multiple times.
- ojbyrne 6y agoI think that the right has moved the Overton Window so much to the right that they see things that most of the world would see as mainstream (Black Lives Matter, Abortion, Medicare for All, Defund the Police, Anti-Fascism etc) as extreme.
- lliamander 6y agoNone of those things, properly understood[1], were in any way mainstream until very recently. And arguably still aren't mainstream. [1] Obviously, black lives do matter and fascism is bad, but as slogans "Black Lives Matter" and "Anti-Fascism" represent very radical political programs. You should be as suspicious of these slogans as I assume you are of slogans like "All Lives Matter" and "Anti-Communism".
- Fauntleroy 6y agoI have no idea how you can keep telling yourself that when the top 10 shared links on Facebook have been nothing but conservative conspiracy theories for over 12 months straight.
- war1025 6y agoFacebook is taking a much more hands-off approach than Twitter.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoThat is irrelevant to the claim. Facebook doesn’t share links, the users do. The allegation of bias are associated with inconsistent and/or incorrect applications of their rules.
- amznthrwaway 6y agoFrom the article: > "Poland blocked human rights sites; India same-sex dating sites" What you are complaining about is that right-wingers are sometimes banned by private sites in the US because they advocate genocide and other contemptible actions.
- logicslave 6y ago"You would be hard pressed to find liberal / progressive content being censored online." You must be joking? Twitter, Google, FB, the blatantly partisan censorship?
- slg 6y agoA free and open internet also allows propaganda and hate to flourish which are two bedrocks of most authoritarian and nationalist regimes. It isn't as simple as ending censorship will allow everyone to be free.
- paxys 6y ago> A free and open internet also allows propaganda and hate to flourish I disagree. Sure there will always be some amount of misinformation on the internet, but a fully state-controlled media and internet (see - China) is far, far more effective at spreading propaganda and controlling the narrative.
- slg 6y agoThis isn't a binary choice between a fully state controlled internet and a fully free and open internet. There is a spectrum. I believe the ideal internet rests much closer to the free and open side than the state controlled side, but existing at the extreme of free and open would be come with its own set of problems. Just look at all the most popular places on the web that champion their lack of censorship or moderation. Most of them end up as cesspools.
- zests 6y agoNot disagreeing -- but what popular parts of the internet are not cesspools?
- galangalalgol 6y agoIs it possible that they become cesspools because poop isn't allowed to flow everywhere else? Is there a finite quantity of poop that could be diluted if it were spread out evenly, or is the supply unending?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoThe problem isn't quantity, but risk. There's a reason we restrict literal poop to a few designated places - while there's only a finite amount of excrement deposited any given time, you don't want every place you visit and interaction you're a part of to carry a chance of you witnessing someone defecating.
- elevenoh 6y agoHow about the wave of 'I won't change, I won't work on myself, so I'll change / sensor you under the pretense of virtue" that's taken hold in SV echochambers?
- konjin 6y agoJoe Biden wrote the original Patriot act. Lets not pretend that liberalism doesn't come with a jackboot on the neck of the people either.
- triceratops 6y agoTIL: Joe Biden represents liberalism.
- konjin 6y agoIf you look at his cabinet pick so far yes. I hope you're ready for Trump II the Trumpening.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Joe Biden wrote the original Patriot act. No, he didn't. USA PATRIOT Act was from Rep. Sensenbrenner (R-WI). It incorporated material from 3 earlier bills, one of which was also by Rep. Sensenbrenner (R-WI), the others by Sen. Daschle (D-SD) and Rep. Oxley (R-OH). https://www.congress.gov/bill/107th-congress/house-bill/3162/text/enr https://www.congress.gov/bill/107th-congress/house-bill/3162...
- konjin 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Counterterrorism_Act_of_1995 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Counterterrorism_Act_o... I should have said draft instead of original.
- dragonwriter 6y agoIt wasnt substantively similar to the USA PATRIOT Act, beyond being laws that have some relation to terrorism.
- raxxorrax 6y agoWeird is that in the US the liberals want to censor and the conservatives argue for free speech. They are at their throats so much that is probably doesn't really matter anymore.