5 ms·
The TL;DR is that around 200 content moderators, location unspecified, are protesting decisions to move them back into the office. It's not immediately clear f
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
The TL;DR is that around 200 content moderators, location unspecified, are protesting decisions to move them back into the office.
It's not immediately clear from the letter that this was Facebook's decision. In fact, it appears that Facebook subcontracts content moderation to Accenture and CPL, both of which are named in this letter.
The letter also takes shots at Mark Zuckerberg's growing wealth and attacks Facebook's attempts to augment the human content moderators with AI pre-filters to remove the worst content. The latter claim is strange, as the content moderators are the ones most likely to benefit from AI pre-filtering. They try to claim that Facebook "failed" to create a workable AI, but I seriously doubt that Facebook has given up on the project. More likely that they're still iterating. I suspect these people feel they need to attack the AI angle to protect their jobs.
The letter goes on to demand 50% higher hazard pay, demands that the subcontracted content moderators be hired directly into Facebook as full employees, out of their contracting jobs under consulting firms.
- satya71 6y agoFacebook should bear the brunt. In a more reasonable arrangement (in which, the generator of risk has to bear the liability), these people would be direct employees of Facebook.
- jefftk 6y ago> in which, the generator of risk has to bear the liability Do you think this in general, or just for content moderation? For example, is it reasonable that I can buy car insurance that covers me if I cause an accident?
- leetcrew 6y ago> For example, is it reasonable that I can buy car insurance that covers me if I cause an accident? did you mean to phrase this differently? isn't that the primary purpose of having car insurance?
- jefftk 6y agoMy parent was saying that the generator of risk should always bear the liability, which confused me because there are many situations in our society where a third-party agrees to take it on in exchange for a fee. I described car insurance, as one of those situations.
- pdonis 6y agoYou do bear the liability for the risks you create by driving your car. Paying your car insurance company premiums means they agree to pay up to a certain amount of money for you to cover damage, but that doesn't remove your liability. In addition to the fact that it's you paying the premiums, if you get a ticket, it's still you that gets points on your license; if you injure someone because you were driving recklessly, it's still you that gets sued (and if the damages awarded are more than your insurance covers, you're still on the hook for the rest); if you injure someone while driving under the influence, it's still you who gets charged with a crime.
- leetcrew 6y agoah I see. I don't view insurance as shifting the liability itself (more like a payment plan for the expected value of the liability), but I can see why you might look at it that way.
- arcticbull 6y ago> For example, is it reasonable that I can buy car insurance that covers me if I cause an accident? Reasonable? I’d describe it as mandatory, and not even a question in no-fault jurisdictions. It doesn’t exempt you from criminal charges if you did it, say, intentionally.
- gmadsen 6y agocar insurance doesn't remove liability, it will pay agreed upon sums of money to cover damages, but certainly anything criminal will still be pursued. And people can sue you for more than your insurance might cover.
- mcintyre1994 6y agoI’m not sure if this is what you meant, but in the UK you can buy comprehensive insurance that will cover damage to your car as well as the other person if you caused the accident.
- toyg 6y ago> It's clear that they want Facebook to bear the brunt of the bad PR That's the right thing to do, considering FB is the only entity with some power over their employers. Avoiding this kind of thing is exactly why brands outsource their dirty work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gtrhtrhtrhtr 6y agoI'm wondering if there is also an element of: you should be surveilled while you moderate content, as otherwise you could steal it. It's a hard problem as moderators have access to user data (I imagine).
- Karunamon 6y agoEven company-mandated spyware is superior to hauling everyone into an office in the middle of a pandemic.
- occamrazor 6y agoI imagine that a locked down laptop running just the moderation UI provides reasonable security. If not, the camera can ensure that the moderator doesn’t use the “analog hole” to copy video or image content. Forced use of headphones instead of speakers finally almost closes the gap for audio.
- gtrhtrhtrhtr 6y agothat sounds like bad opsec
- heleninboodler 6y agoVideo and audio too risky. We're gonna have to go with a neural interface and implanted DRM chips. I bet Time-Warner Media has patents they can license. :)
- sleepybrett 6y agoI imagine they are not, I imagine they are presented with a neverending series of captcha like screens. Content at the top, buttons down below to classify why it needs to be banned or if it's ok. If more context is needed i'd still be hiding user information from the moderators but maybe pulling up some number of posts 'around' the suspect post.
- zentiggr 6y agoIf part of someone's work responsibilities involves screening for child abuse and other direct violence, and every other depravity a user might try to post, that worker should be given the best possible mental health support, and be paid substantially more than any minimum wage. Like anyone serving in the military and possibly subject to all the PTSD and injury that combat can entail, these moderators are standing as a thin line against the worst things humanity can do to each other. They should be given respect and every possible consideration for their sacrifice. Their demands are merely a simple first step closer to the recognition they actually deserve. I would go much further.
- dbt00 6y ago> They try to claim that Facebook "failed" to create a workable AI, but I seriously doubt that Facebook has given up on the project. On the one hand, they probably haven't. On the other hand, they provably aren't as close as they thought they were, and may be very far away.
- banana_giraffe 6y agoThe cynic in me thinks they're still working on it, but the first test cases they're concerned with are about removing copyrighted content. Then they'll see how to apply it to other problems.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoMy understanding (from talking to FB employees over the years) is that they have been trying to do this for at least a decade (as have Google). The fact that they haven't fired all the moderators yet should give you an idea of how difficult it is.
- octoberfranklin 6y agoThis ought to be declared the one and only trustworthy measure of the AI/ML hype. How many human moderators does Facebook employ? Zero? AI lives up to the hype!
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoYeah, but it's AI-complete. Its an adversarial problem also, as people are really motivated to share their content. It reminds me of the filters on facebook that kept killing compliant nude pictures of larger people, because the model had obviously just learned to count pixels of skin. It'll be a long time before this work gets automated, and until then, they should support their moderators.