5 ms·
That's a bit like saying addictive drugs themselves aren't a problem. Technology is designed to trick humans into engaging with it. They use us for profit. It
by echelon 6y ago
That's a bit like saying addictive drugs themselves aren't a problem.
Technology is designed to trick humans into engaging with it. They use us for profit.
It's asymmetric warfare. One or two parents, with jobs and responsibilities, against kids with peer pressure and billion dollar industries hawking them on, claws in their back and brain.
- minusthebrandon 6y agoMy wife and I both work full-time and we still stick to my daughter's iPad restrictions: only an hour a day, no Instagram or TikTok or YouTube at all, and she only gets it after homework and chores and other things are done. We never take it anywhere. It's important that parents set AND KEEP boundaries. My daughter now knows not to expect to be able to Snapchat her friends or anyone else because she's never been able to. When she mentions that her friends all have it, we remind her that our house is not their house and we have our rules in place for a reason, which we are always willing to explain. While I agree that screens and TV ARE very addicting, that doesn't mean that parents are powerless or that the majority of the problems brought up in this article are not the fault of the parents.
- _zamorano_ 6y agoYeah, it's doable and congratulations for achieving. But anyway, he is right. For most parents is an uphill battle against tech and social media they're bound to lose due to mostly exhaustion.
- londons_explore 6y agoLack of ability to snapchat friends might not seem important... But communication is key to nearly everything in life, and not being part of those snapchat rumours, disputes and controversies now will probably mean your daughter doesn't get as good at the skills to interact with her peers in 20 years time.
- minusthebrandon 6y agoShe interacts with her peers at school and with her family... by that same token, ANYONE who grew up before Snapchat or the Internet had or has lacking social skills. Also, she CAN FaceTime. I would not consider Snapchat or TikTok to be "socializing with friends" for an 8 year old.
- NegativeLatency 6y agoI missed out on texting because of similar choices by my parents, at the time it was not fun
- jjk166 6y ago> She interacts with her peers at school and with her family... by that same token, ANYONE who grew up before Snapchat or the Internet had or has lacking social skills. You know how we don't really get this whole social media thing the kids are into these days? That's because we lack those social skills. Just like how your parents' generation struggles with E-mail despite it being so simple, because you grew up with that. It might not bother you that you're bad at Telegram or whatever because none of your peers use it either. But her peers do.
- minusthebrandon 6y agoMy parents struggling with e-mail is no way the same thing as lacking social skills. That just seems a lack of technology skills. My point was that saying Snapchat or social media leads to greater social skills than what previous generations had is very hard for me to believe.
- jjk166 6y agoTomato tomato You can communicate via a method your parents can't because you used it extensively in your prime while they didn't. Your grandparents probably had the same issue with fax machines and your grandchildren will probably have the same problem with neural-messaging. Every generation thinks "but this time it's different" and every generation is wrong.
- ccleve 6y agoHow old is your child? Whether you can get away with this very much depends on the child.
- minusthebrandon 6y agoShe's 8. I'll grant that this works for us now. As she ages, we'll give her more responsibility for handling boundaries on her own.
- jjk166 6y agoYou clearly didn't read the article. Phones certainly can be a problem, but the problem here has nothing to do with the phone.
- echelon 6y agoI did read the article and saw the author blaming themselves and calling themselves bad parents. It's not all their fault. They're fighting an asymmetric war. Millions of parents are.
- jjk166 6y agoOh, you read the article where a mother repeatedly says her 11 year old daughter is just like a crack addict because she prefers being on her phone to making her bed? The article where the mother admits to going into fits of rage and punishes the 11 year old child for doing nothing that isn't normally tolerated even in this already very strict household? The article where this mother of an 11 year old blames nothing but the phone for the fact that this girl entering into adolescence behaves differently than when she was a child? No, this article was written by a narcissist who can't handle her little girl growing up and rather than dealing with it in a healthy way is instead raging against an inanimate object.
- goatlover 6y agoNine hours on a phone during the day is normal for an eleven year old? That sounds like a problem.
- jjk166 6y agoHaving never been an 11 year old girl in a pandemic, I can't really speak to what "normal" is. Based on the the girl's behavior as described in the article, it certainly has had no noticeable negative effects.
- onemoresoop 6y ago
- justforyou 6y ago>> That's a bit like saying addictive drugs themselves aren't a problem. You clearly feel that statement is false but don't provide any support for your strange point of view.
- dijksterhuis 6y ago> That's a bit like saying addictive drugs themselves aren't a problem. I mean... They're not. They're inanimate f----- objects. They've never maliciously set out to cause someone harm because they're inanimate f----- objects. They don't have an understanding of the concept of morals or ethics because they're inanimate f----- objects. When I ingest them into my body -- that's when all hell breaks loose. They become a problem for me when I use them. > Technology is designed to trick humans into engaging with it. They use us for profit. Who is this mythical "they"? Technology is designed to do many jobs. Some of them include gamification to "maximise engagement" or some other cringeworthy buzzword. Some of them are literally as simple as "turn the lights off at 10pm" or "wake me up at 10am". It's how we, as a collective species, implement and use technology that's usually the problem. "technology" itself is, again, an inanimate f----- object. > It's asymmetric warfare. One or two parents, with jobs and responsibilities, against kids with peer pressure and billion dollar industries hawking them on, claws in their back and brain. I think this is called life? Yes, lots of things all happen at the same time and there's alway societal pressures one way or another. But calling it warfare is pretty extreme and may be something useful to reflect on.
- michaelt 6y ago> They're not. They're inanimate f----- objects. [...] They become a problem for me when I use them. In common usage of the english language, a thing can be a 'problem' without being sentient or unavoidable. A pothole in the highway can be a problem if it's damaging people's cars - even if they could avoid it by driving more cautiously.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoI see what you're getting, and I like the pothole analogy. I agree with the fact that it can be used like that in the English language, but I disagree with the idea behind it. In the pothole analogy - it's like saying potholes are the reason for all these people's cars being damaged. If no cars were driving over the pothole then the pothole wouldn't be a problem as no damage would ever be caused! It's an inanimate f----- object. It's just there. It's the fact that people are driving cars on a road that has potholes that causes their cars to be damaged. It's some action that was taken that causes an effect to occur. Then we get into the murky world of who is actually responsible and what is the solution. Which I don't have an answer for.