18 ms·
> You should expect "equal pay for equal work" at your new remote job So naive. In an ideal, utopian world? Maybe it would work this way. Maybe. In reality,
by simonebrunozzi 6y ago
> You should expect "equal pay for equal work" at your new remote job
So naive.
In an ideal, utopian world? Maybe it would work this way. Maybe.
In reality, your compensation is a function of your negotiating power. Some people, in fact, manage to get the same pay even when working remote, because they're "highly employable". Others don't.
And let me add: I almost agree that remote work shouldn't necessarily command the same pay. A company's goal is to "extract" from each employee more value than his/her/their salary. If a company manages to save on a salary because the employee doesn't have much negotiating power, good for the company.
This is not to say that a company should do anything it wants, far from it. It simply means that if you accept that you live in a market-enabled society, your salary is at stake, too. You want to pay $2 dollars for milk, instead of $20? That's thanks to competition between companies. That's market forces at play. You want it there? Accept it on salary negotiation too.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y ago> > You should expect "equal pay for equal work" ... > So naive. > In an ideal, utopian world? Maybe it would work this way. Maybe. > In reality, your compensation is a function of your negotiating power. > ...if you accept that you live in a market-enabled society, your salary is at stake, too. This logic horrifies me because it applies equally well to wage disparities based on protected classes. We have collectively decided as a society that this argument is faulty and unethical. That doesn’t mean remote work should get equal pay. It just means that your argument doesn’t hold.
- leetcrew 6y ago> This logic horrifies me because it applies equally well to wage disparities based on protected classes. I dunno if GP meant to imply that, but this is kinda the key flaw with the "equal pay for equal work" thing. most engineers earn way more than the median income. this is a direct result of existing in a market-based economy where wages are determined by supply and demand rather than some abstract notion of fairness. you can't complain that the payscale is different for atlanta vs sf while maintaining that it's totally fine for you to make 5x as much as the cashier at 7-Eleven.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y ago> you can't complain that the payscale is different for atlanta vs sf while maintaining that it's totally fine for you to make 5x as much as the cashier at 7-Eleven. It's that the "equal work" part? Comparing one cashier to another cashier (assuming same hours, same responsibilities, etc) is equal work, so is part of an "equal pay for equal work" conversation. Comparing a cashier to a software dev is a wholly separate conversation.
- leetcrew 6y agotaken in isolation, sure, "equal pay for equal work" makes sense. but it sidesteps the question of why certain work commands higher pay in the first place. the answer lies in the balance between supply and demand. engineers were quite happy to accept the market equilibrium pay when it placed them near the top of the income food chain in their locale, but suddenly they are quite unhappy to see other engineers getting paid even more. maybe I'm not articulating this quite right, but there seems to be an inconsistency in here. it strikes me as similar to the type of feminism that only cares about seeing more women as CEOs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dwaltrip 6y agoIf a company is found to be discriminating by protected class, they are in big trouble. Sure, it can be difficult to catch. But what is your point exactly? Markets currently play a massive role in determining prices across our entire society. A wage is a price paid for an individual's labor. Labor markets are not perfect. No market is (despite the wailings of the ideologues). We try to fix these issues with specific policies and regulations. There is plenty more work to do here. But if you are advocating for the abolishment of labor markets entirely, I would love to see the details of your proposal. I don't know of any society today that has managed to do so.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoThe point is that “the markets don’t work that way” isn’t an argument that “society shouldn’t work that way.” We intercede in the case of protected classes because “economics therefore morality” isn’t a sound argument.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dwaltrip 6y agoOk fair enough. Do you grant that some interventions are more practical and cleanly implementable than others? Perhaps the assumption in the original comment is that legally restricting market discrimination for wages by region may not be practical and / or would have significant harmful side effects. I would need to give the idea more thought. It certainly seems a far more complex and less clear-cut matter than the existing protected classes.
- pc86 6y agoProtected classes are specifically excluded from market forces. That's why they're... protected.
- kome 6y ago> In reality, your compensation is a function of your negotiating power. Some people, in fact, manage to get the same pay even when working remote, because they're "highly employable". Others don't. OK, but if you go in front of the employers as individuals, 1 might gain, but everybody will lose. That's not how work relationship works. I get that on HN everybody feels like a genius and individualism is rampant. But that's a fertile ideological environment for mass exploitation. Tech workers are just workers first and foremost, and the same dynamic of the labor market are true for tech workers, as they are true for anybody else.
- da_big_ghey 6y ago> 1 might gain, but everybody will lose. Exactly. Based on talking with others about their salaries, I usually seem to be one who gains. So I will oppose efforts to normalize pay for a given role because I will lose and probably take a pay cut. There's also nothing wrong with paying more or less for a job. Some people are better workers, period. This is true even if they have the same job title.
- enriquto 6y ago> In reality, your compensation is a function of your negotiating power. This quickly falls down once salaries and payments become public. In economic parlance, when everybody has all the information and the job market becomes efficient.
- username90 6y agoYour negotiation power becomes even more important when everything is public, because then it gets harder for people to cheat you.
- jasonjayr 6y agoThen companies should have no problems whatsoever with Unions? I mean, if a group of employees want to get together to amplify their negotiating power, then they should not stop that?
- helen___keller 6y ago> then they should not stop that? The whole point of having negotiating power is they can't just "stop" it. Because you, as a union, collectively have enough power to force them to the table to negotiate. Whether or not the company has a problem with unions is basically irrelevant.
- plutonorm 6y agoIt is irrelevant. But somehow companies have convinced most that unions are a bad thing. They have leveraged their greater influence to further their power. They are now in an essentially unassailable position. For the great majority of the workforce they have no bargaining power. This toxic modern world should pop like the noxious little bubble it is. We need a new 60s only this time we need to win.
- yeetman21 6y agoI am only qualified to speak about the tech sector in which I work. All of my coworkers make above six figures. We have every sort of benefit that we could want. Why would we want a union? Our company has convinced us that unions are a bad thing by giving us basically anything that a union could have, and more. Why would we want to agitate for more when we already have so much, and risk what we currently have (which is more than adequate)
- bumby 6y agoUnions are meant to bring some balance to a very imbalanced power structure when that power structure lends itself to taking advantage of the employees. The fact that you and your fellow employees have it so well may indicate that isn't your case. Unions aren't necessary but can help. I've worked in positions where the courts provided the same benefit via a different mechanism. Edit: I accidently had "are" for "aren't"
- inquirerofsorts 6y agoWhy does this feel like one of these numerous HN posts that will not stand the test of time a few years later. I can do a better job than many in SF for half the price. Have already spent close to a decade waking up early for US west coast meetings. Get the feeling that a day of reckoning is coming for those clinging so dearly to their location based earnings. I've been saying it for years about Australia being so constrained with cities like Sydney and Melbourne which magically have some of the most expensive land prices on Earth. Getting away from these places and making your own digital way is truly a freedom to behold.
- zepto 6y agoCan explain where your feeling comes from?
- ghiculescu 6y agoI think what's more likely is a lot of overpaid people are about to move to Sydney and Melbourne because their pay isn't tied to their location (for now).
- runawaybottle 6y agoI’ll add that I once did more critical work as a part timer in college but never achieved equal hourly rate due to the class of worker I was (part time). It’s an age old battle, interns, part time, offshore, etc are always going to be second class citizens. Feel bad for the prop 22 stuff and gig economy, because they are part of the same struggle. It never ends.
- a_imho 6y agos/remote/female/g Or really, use any other marginalized group with limited negotiation power and see how your comment turns out. Only difference is remote is not protected class, but that is simply an implementation detail. Everybody argues this issue from the POV of their very own salary and it is understandable. It is fair to say you think you are at the good end of the deal and you like it there. But the moral argument about equal work should be equally compensated is nigh unchallengable. https://elsajohansson.wordpress.com/2017/09/13/what-does-a-wage-gap-look-like/ https://elsajohansson.wordpress.com/2017/09/13/what-does-a-w...
- zepto 6y agoExcept remote/female is not interchangeable. Remote = lower costs. Female ≠ lower costs. I’m not arguing against equal pay for equal work. I’m arguing that it’s a bad analogy to compare being remote with being female.
- a_imho 6y agoIf you are not arguing against equal pay for equal work Remote = lower costs does not hold. It also depends on what you think about wage gaps and why do we need equal employment laws in the first place?
- zepto 6y agoFacts don’t depend on what I’m arguing for. I’m arguing against comparing remote work to the gender pay gap. Being female is not comparable to being remote. Most people have more choice about where they live than their sex or gender, for example. I assume you are not arguing that sex and gender are just preferences.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- a_imho 6y agoLet's agree to disagree. Imo it is very much comparable from a negotiation power point. The fact that it is not something you can change easily is orthogonal. If you want to be pedantic you can use religion as an example.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway2245 6y ago> your compensation is a function of your negotiating power That's right, I suppose: But, why do I have more negotiating power, if I can sufficiently fake an address in San Francisco? This is just a way for employers to exert their power and reduce salaries across the board. It should be resisted.
- boc 6y agoFaking an address would work until you are expected to meet up with your team in person. If it turns out that you actually live in Bend, the gig will be up pretty quickly.
- pc86 6y agoThere is no scenario where you can be a remote employee and still be reasonably expected to meet in person with such short notice that you couldn't make the trip if it's actually worth the pay differential.
- zerr 6y agoYes, that is the theory, but in practice - the word always gets out, teammates find out each others' salaries and that's it... If there is a disparity, consider that team is broken - many would fly away, most of them will hate the employer.
- tekno45 6y agoMilk prices are regulated, thats why we don't pay 20 dollars a gallon.
- coward8675309 6y agoNo. If milk prices were unregulated you'd pay less, at least in the US and I believe Europe. https://www.fb.org/market-intel/how-milk-is-really-priced-in-the-u.s https://www.fb.org/market-intel/how-milk-is-really-priced-in...
- mgh2 6y agoIt is funny how tech employees complain about this when it hits them personally, while employers have been discriminating for eternity. That clause at the bottom of a job page: "no discrimination based on citizenship, origin, etc..."? Just corporate/legal mumbo jumbo. This is how it feels for the non-elite, non-American. In a weird way, the pandemic is leveling the playing field. Democratize opportunities, increase competition, decrease wages- plain supply and demand.
- ethanbond 6y agoThe pandemic is not at all leveling the playing field except maybe between the elite of one country and the elite of another. The non-elites everywhere are getting hosed.
- mgh2 6y agoI agree, maybe I meant non-US tech jobs.
- jimbokun 6y ago> It is funny how tech employees complain about this when it hits them personally That's a good point, because no other groups of people only complain about issues when they start to affect them personally.
- ethanbond 6y agoTech workers do make a unique show about caring, though. Think about all the social good branding surrounding massive advertising panopticons.
- claudiulodro 6y ago> You want to pay $2 dollars for milk, instead of $20? That's thanks to competition between companies. It's not though. "The support granted to U.S dairy producers represented approximately [...] 73% of the farmers' marketplace revenue. USDA data also reveals that US dairy farmers operate at a loss, and have a cost of production that is higher than what they earn from the marketplace."[1] We're subsidizing the low cost of milk via taxes because the marketplace failed to provide both affordable milk and the ability for dairy farmers to make a living. [1] https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/american-dairy-farmers-depend-on-government-subsidies-1015126442 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/american-dai...
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIt's sort of the opposite here in Canada, where dairy production is managed on a quota system (you need quota to produce and sell) and the quota is regulated such that the price remains stable (and more expensive than in the US) for the benefit of the farmers who have quota and in theory the public, who has a reliable "reasonable" price. It's dubious on many levels, but has its defenders.
- R0b0t1 6y agoEnd result of this being if I want to produce milk with dairy cows I can't?
- winstonewert 6y agoCorrect. (There are exemptions for farms with a small number of cows)
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoYes, similar systems are also in place for eggs and poultry. And yes in all cases there are exemptions in place for very small farms, but not enough to make much of a difference. "Alternative" products like duck eggs, water buffalo or goat's milk, etc. do not count, so there is some room for market diversification there, I guess. It has the net effect of keeping dairy prices at what's seen as an acceptable stable level that also keeps dairy farmer's in business, at the expense of diversity in the marketplace and access to new farmers.
- rmtech 6y ago> That's thanks to competition between companies. That's market forces at play. You want it there? Accept it on salary negotiation too. This is itself a bit naive. In a basic market with voluntary transactions the distribution of the gains from trade is undefined. If your labor sells for $100/hour and costs you $10/hour to produce (basic food, water and shelter) then it is a perfectly legitimate equilibrium for the company to pay you $10.01/hour and take the other %89.99 as profit. It's only through politics that we can make sure that the gains from trade are evenly split. The math of markets doesn't define it.
- wrkronmiller 6y ago> It's only through politics that we can make sure that the gains from trade are evenly split. The math of markets doesn't define it. That's clearly not the case since my employer could legally pay me $15/hour for my work, but pays significantly more. They do so, because they are competing with other employers for talent.
- rmtech 6y ago> They do so, because they are competing with other employers for talent. Yes, but the RESULT of the two-way competition where both employees and employers are competing is undefined in a simple model of the market. If you work as a cleaner or an uber driver, you may find that even though you generate some surplus, you don't actually get any of it (or you get almost none of it)
- josephcsible 6y ago> It's only through politics that we can make sure that the gains from trade are evenly split. False. Competition from other employers can do this too.
- rmtech 6y ago> can do this too. Yes, it CAN but whether it actually does depends on the details. If you are a cleaner or an uber driver, you might generate some surplus but you might see the other parties take all or almost all of that surplus.
- ouid 6y agoPerfect competition between laborers would lead to equal pay for equal work...
- gtsop 6y ago> In reality, your compensation is a function of your negotiating power. Ahhmm, no. Where does negotiation power stem from? Is it a skill? No. You are a product much like eveything else in this economy and you price is a function of how much you cost (living cost, heavily depedent on location) + supply/demand trends. Yes, your attitude and negotiation skills can impact your salary but only by a bit. You can't get your salary to tripple by negotiation. Why? What is the force that doesn't allow that? Supply and demand of other people who will do the same for less. Thus I argue the trend will be a big decline in salaries for remote jobs in places like SF or London, but a very slight increase in salaries in places like india. The market of remote workers is going global, thus the price for this product will adjust accordingly. There will still be some variation in the salary depending on where you are, but the global min-max difference will decrease
- golemotron 6y agoThe lesson is: don't be a commodity.
- gtsop 6y agoHonestly interested in hearing your opinion on how to do that.
- pc86 6y agoAddress business concerns, don't just write code. Almost anyone can write some spaghetti Java and get it to build, but most people who can do that can't operate well in a business environment dealing with executives and C-level people. If you can do both, you're no longer a commodity.
- gtsop 6y agoEven those people have specific salary ranges. They still are commodities or as the corp-speak put it: "assets". More expensive ones, for sure, but still the same rules apply. My living cost will be a hugr factor of my salary even in these positions. Speaking from experience. However, even if that wasn't the case, even if what you say is valid, these are inherently limited jobs so it's not a solution everyone can apply.
- neilwilson 6y ago"So naive." Depends on the law. If I'm female, and you're male, then equal pay laws may force it to be the same for equivalent work. Most of the rest of the world forces business to compete for labour - which is as it should be. Jobs, not people, should wait.
- throwaway3699 6y agoEnforcing this kind of equal pay law will result in a mass shifting of jobs to 3rd world countries the likes the world has never seen before.
- thedevilslawyer 6y ago"Enforcing of this kind of equal pay for women will result in mass entry of women into the workforce, the likes of which the world had never seen before. " It was the moral thing to do, and it happened despite the men it affected.
- neilwilson 6y agoGood. We can then live off their imports which they have to pay for by buying our exports because we have a floating rate exchange system, not a fixed one. If the rest of the world want to send us stuff, that's a benefit not a loss.
- ars 6y ago> Depends on the law. If I'm female, and you're male, then equal pay laws may force it to be the same for equivalent work. It already is, despite all the press claiming it isn't. In summary the difference in pay is caused by different choices men and women make in how much they value flexibility at work. See: https://harvardmagazine.com/2016/05/reassessing-the-gender-wage-gap https://harvardmagazine.com/2016/05/reassessing-the-gender-w...
- 2Xheadpalm 6y agoIn general I agree with you. As you point out, the company is under no obligation to do what is 'fair' for my work and it is my negotiating skills/power that will dictate how much I get paid. Fine, I accept this. However, on the flip side, a company should not expect my undying loyalty, working for free after hours, or take one for the team to get that release out etc. And no I will not be joining them on those bonding, team-building zoom meetings and/or retreats (will they still be a thing in a post-covid world?). Sorry its just business, maybe if you paid me equally for my work I would be more open to the above.
- larrik 6y ago> Some people, in fact, manage to get the same pay even when working remote, because they're "highly employable". Others don't. When I took my remote job 8+ years ago, it was a big pay increase, plus my expenses went way down.
- paridhi7 6y ago>A company's goal is to "extract" from each employee more value than his/her/their salary. If a company manages to save on a salary because the employee doesn't have much negotiating power, good for the company. So, according to you, companies should have kept exploiting women and kept discriminating against under-represented groups by paying them less, because they didn't have "much negotiating power" and because it was "good for the company"? Equal pay shouldn't just work in an ideal, utopian world. It should work in all worlds because that is what is fair!
- JAlexoid 6y agoThey shouldn't.... But they shouldn't, because society should shun those companies.... not because government made it illegal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jstummbillig 6y ago> This is not to say that a company should do anything it wants, far from it. It simply means that if you accept that you live in a market-enabled society, your salary is at stake, too. You want to pay $2 dollars for milk, instead of $20? That's thanks to competition between companies. That's market forces at play. You want it there? Accept it on salary negotiation too. So, what exactly are you saying then? Should there be checks in place to ensure salary negotiations between an employer and employee be treated differently than two big companies hashing out milk prices or not? If not that would certainly be a very naive position which gets increasingly problematic, quickly, the more lopsided negotiation power and money is distributed between the two parties. A human centric society has to provide checks for that. An understanding of what we want can for example be driven by articles such as the one linked and is instrumental to the process.
- yibg 6y agoLocation also determines the costs of other things to a certain degree. Prices of gasoline, food, housing etc are all higher in high COL areas, so why is it surprising wages are too? I get the argument that "well I'm doing the same work here or there, why should I be paid differently?". But this is what things like outsourcing are intended to do isn't it? To get the same work done for cheaper.
- jimbokun 6y ago> Some people, in fact, manage to get the same pay even when working remote, because they're "highly employable". Some people, when working on site, make more than other on site employees because they're "highly employable". Bottom line is, being "highly employable" is the only relevant factor in negotiating, remote vs. on site is irrelevant, and you shouldn't let companies to bluff you otherwise. If they like you a lot more than the other candidate, who just happens to live in a high cost of living location, are they really going to pass you over to hire the other candidate, if you demand the same wage that candidate would receive? Capitalism isn't just for companies, you know. If you're not "highly employable", get highly employable and negotiate knowing your worth.
- raisedbyninjas 6y agoWhat you're leaving out is two candidates that have comparable qualifications. Thousands of positions that were once on-site only have expanded to the rest of the world. The candidate pool at every level just got increased. This can only drive wages down. Regardless if a company is targeting 99 percentile or 50 percentile developers, they will choose the candidate in the rural mid-west given equal qualifications. If there is ever a trend of a significant number of developers moving to low COL areas, then every recession, reorganization, merger, etc. becomes a potential situation for employers to threaten your job or relocating to Trumpville, Nebraska.
- Siira 6y agoEconomic efficiency has nothing to do with how the surplus is divided between parties. Powerful entities such as corporations can easily get most of the surplus their employees produce, and the market will not correct this. (I.e., you have no economical argument that non-protection of labor is needed for cheap commodities. Perhaps such an argument can be made, but yours doesn't cut it.)
- cratermoon 6y agohttps://bitworking.org/news/2008/01/the-free-market-fairy/ https://bitworking.org/news/2008/01/the-free-market-fairy/
- JAlexoid 6y agoYour whole comment is literally addressed in the article - and the author, without using the same terms, agrees with you. I don't understand why you think that you are in opposition to the author.