3 ms·
That's kind of the idea, sort of, yeah. But what kind of limits does such an attempt run into? Can you just keep adding more and more dishes, as long as you pl
by rektide 6y ago
That's kind of the idea, sort of, yeah.
But what kind of limits does such an attempt run into? Can you just keep adding more and more dishes, as long as you please, each one pointing at one satellite, with zero interference from any other of your ground dishes? No, I rather suspect not. When you are uplinking, there's probably going to be other satellites also getting some of your signal, especially as we move from 1000, to 10,000, to beyond numbers of satellites. This is not my field, but I feel like there are some very interesting limits to uplinking, a lot of constraints, that the sky itself can only hold so much uplink capacity, and it'd be interesting to me at least to have some more back-of-napkin discussions on what those constraints really look like.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> When you are uplinking, there's probably going to be other satellites also getting some of your signal, especially as we move from 1000, to 10,000, to beyond numbers of satellites. Only starlink is going to be using this frequency band, so it doesn't matter if it hits anything else. And of the starlink sats, you're not going to have more than a handful in view at once, so aiming is easy. And as far as base stations go, you just need one every X hundred miles, with several dishes. The problems you're imagining could be real on a sufficiently dense constellation, but there is no reason to go anywhere near that density, so it's not a problem anyone has to worry about.
- rektide 6y agoEvery X hundred miles feels kind of like where I was going. Even then, there's a very active question of how many uplinks each given uplink ("gateway") would need to make, to provide the massive amounts of bandwidth required. Anyhow, I found a couple numbers on spectrum that are semi-interesting to me to assess what spectrum resources Starlink has purchased. According to this site[1], Starlink has: 27.5 – 29.1 GHz and 29.5 – 30.0 GHz and 47.2 – 50.2 GHz and 50.4 – 51.4 GHz = 6.1GHz of spectrum for uplink from base-stations ("gateways") to satellites 10.7 – 12.7 GHz and 37.5 – 42.5 GHz = 7GHz of spectrum for downlink from satellite to user "terminals". According to this page, a year ago they were authorized to run 6 gateways. I'm not sure how much throughput they can push to a satellite with 6.1GHz of total spectrum. It's still interesting to me to try to consider how even the current 893 satellites get anywhere near enough throughput up to them to be well utilizing their own downlink capabilities. I'm still only inuiting, but it still feels like something doesn't add up, I still don't see how the fleet is going to get enough bandwidth. My previous image of a data-center bristling with dozens & dozens of dishes pointing & tracking upwards indeed doesn't seem quite right (and the side-lobe interference question I was asking about), but the alternative, of a massive network of ground stations each boasting colossal connectivity, seems almost equally hard to imagine. [1] https://www.elonx.net/starlink-compendium/ https://www.elonx.net/starlink-compendium/
- Dylan16807 6y ago> I'm not sure how much throughput they can push to a satellite with 6.1GHz of total spectrum. The satellites are very far apart, so they can use the full 6.1GHz per satellite with near zero interference. At most you'll have two in the same part of the sky. The earth's surface area is about 200 million square miles. If you have 20 thousand satellites, that gives you ballpark 100x100 miles per satellite. Roughly 100 miles of separation, 350 miles of height, very easy to isolate just one. With this many satellites, if you had a ground station every 300 miles, it would have to connect to about 10 satellites. It would need 200Gbps of fiber, which isn't hard to do. You'd be using less than 25 terabits per second across the entire continental US. That's less than a single undersea cable. No colossal bandwidth necessary, even at unreasonable numbers of satellites.