11 ms·
Primary energy vs final energy: why replacing fossil fuels may not be so hard
- dudus 6y agoThe article tries to explain the difference between primary, final and useful energy to justify why moving to renewables would be easier than at first glance. But I just don't feel like I got convinced in the end. If anything I'm more confused now than before. In special this part about air conditioners being 300% efficient sounds to me like maybe they don't know what they are talking about. “Electrical devices can sometimes offer higher than 100% efficiency,” said BNEF analyst Matthias Kimmel. That might seem odd. How can there be more energy as output than input? But that’s exactly what heat pumps and air conditioners do. They use electricity to shift heat from the outside to inside, or vice-versa, and typically provide three units of energy service for one unit of energy input, meaning an efficiency of 300%.
- dboreham 6y agoThat was easy. Just put a few of them back-to-back and you'll have 10X as much energy.
- sounds 6y agoBecause this doesn't violate the second law of thermodynamics it is impossible to get to 10X - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance
- akshatrathi 6y agoI wrote the story. The efficiency here isn't breaking the first law of thermodynamics. It's just the industry's way of measuring how much work gets done for a certain amount of input. If the work is heating or cooling, then shifting heat from in one direction or another can be done using heat pumps, which move three units of thermal energy for every unit of electrical energy consumed. Might that explain the conundrum?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dudus 6y agoBut then aren't you comparing apples and oranges when you call both that and the loss as heat and noise from coal as "efficiency"?
- renewiltord 6y agoWell, we're not interested in a thermodynamic comparison. We're interested in a useful-energy-obtained for useful-energy-spent comparison. For instance, if I leave a block in the sun and then bring it inside, I have only expended the energy to move the block out and then move the block in. It doesn't make sense for me to include the sun's contribution to the system because that's not a cost I incur. The actual apples to apples comparison in efficiency _is_ the heat emitted by the block in my house divided by the cost of moving the block.
- foldingmoney 6y agoThis is a property of _what the device is doing_ (moving heat from one place to another) as opposed to being a property of how it's powered, though.
- goodcanadian 6y agoAir conditioners move heat from inside the house to outside. So, they can provide more cooling (move more heat) than the equivalent input energy. That is how you come up with greater than 100% efficiency.
- jcampbell1 6y agoWhat is wrong with the concept of a heat pump? A resistor converts electricity into heat 100% efficiently, and a heat pump is often 3x as efficient at heating a house vs electric baseboards.
- dudus 6y agoOk then the electric baseboard is 30% efficient vs the heatpump which is 100% efficient.
- nickff 6y agoHow are you calculating efficiency? It's usually: efficiency = useful work / energy input Efficiency is not calculated relative to the best performing machine.
- thatcherc 6y agoBut a resistor converts 100% of the electrical energy it consumes into heat. So if you were to take the same amount of electrical energy and run a heat pump, you could get 3x more heat into a room. In that sense, the heatpump is 300% efficient.
- Gibbon1 6y agoYeah one can argue semantics all one wants but you still get 3 to 4 times more low grade heat per kwh from a heat pump than a resistive heater. And that's what you actually care about.
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoNo; you're missing the point - 100% of the energy in an electric baseboard system is converted into heat. It's 100% efficient. There is no more effective way to turn electricity into heat than resistively. A heat pump doesn't turn electricity into heat. It moves heat from one place (outside) to another place (inside); and can seem more efficient because the system isn't closed.
- 6y ago
- _Microft 6y agoHeat pumps move more heat (which has the same unit as energy, that's why you can put the numbers in a ratio and get a unitless number) than they use energy for the process. This is the crucial point for heating with them, otherwise they would make little sense (except for using them for cooling) over having an electric heater instead. Here is something to read on this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance Jump to "Examples" if you like concrete examples.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bungle 6y agoAnother example is to light up a candle, then use a peltier element and a heatsink to generate electricity. Then use that electricity to power a led. The outcome is that you have some of the candle light, but you will have a much more light from the led.
- ActionPlankton 6y agoThis discussion of heat pumps makes me want to add that we may also ignore cogeneration too much. We just don't think about heat flows and temperature enough. There is, of course, the communal thing, done in Sweden and Russia and college campuses, with a power plant and steam pipes going to apartments. But what about an appliance for suburban America? Like, combine a gas turbine generator with an HVAC system and hot water tank (pretty sure you can buy things like this in Germany). No unsolved technical problems here. You generate electricity for your home, heat it with waste heat, and absorb temporary excesses in capacity by usefully heating water. You could imagine integrating other things too: If you need more heat than you use electricity, then you might as well use the electricity to do something high-value (cryptocurrency is a crime against the environment, but you might as well compute some hashes in your resistive heater). All this becomes an elaborate way to burn natural gas to make heat, but you get a bunch of other things out besides. The "smart controller" aspect then becomes interesting -- but even that is "just simple automation", not super-difficult AI. Maybe logistically, the "everything is electric; electricity comes from renewables/nuclear; and heat comes from heat pumps" solution is easier in the long run? But this more "decentralized heat engines" solution has the "advantage"(?) that it could run on biomass, which is easy to store (however, I am aware of the problems of wood pellets and deforestation).
- Homunculiheaded 6y agoIt's too bad that reality doesn't really care if you have clever accounting tricks to show that "things aren't really as bad as they look!" The only number that matters at all is global green house gas emissions. We need to get that to zero, and it has continued to go up. Imagine you have a drinking problem and your doctor tells you you need to stop drinking alcohol or you will suffer liver failure. You can argue all day about what percentage of your drinks are alcoholic. "Doctor, I drink 3 cans of coke and only 12 G&Ts now, not 1 can of coke and 24 beers like I used to, I went from 4% of my drinks being non-alcoholic to 20%!" If your daily total alcohol consumed keep rising you have a problem. That's the situation we're in with co2 emissions. There are many clever ways to make it look like everything is fine, but reality doesn't care. If our global CO2 emissions continue to rise we have absolutely no hope.
- akshatrathi 6y agoTotally right that what matters is greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. Tackling them, however, is going to take all our muscles. Many climate deniers have used the 80% of primary energy from fossil fuel figure as a way to claim it's too hard to do anything about the problem or to say there's been little progress. That's misleading and I wrote the article to explain to correct that narrative.
- wnevets 6y ago>That's misleading and I wrote the article to explain to correct that narrative. There is your first mistake, you can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves in to. There are literally people denying covid is real/serious while they or their love ones drown in their fluids.
- thinkharderdev 6y agoI don't think this is a useful way to think about it: 1. You don't need to convince literally everyone. There are still some people who believe the Earth is flat and probably always will be, but it is not super-relevant to collective actions because they are a tiny minority 2. People do in fact change their minds on things. It usually just happens on larger time scales so while one article isn't moving the needle, the accretion of many articles and arguments can change population-wide beliefs. 3. The population of people with an opinion on any given topic is not static. Even if any individual never changes their mind, the composition of the population can change if new people are forming opinions in one way more often. Science progresses one funeral at a time and all that....
- mcwone 6y agoI found this article interesting: https://media4.manhattan-institute.org/sites/default/files/R-0319-MM.pdf https://media4.manhattan-institute.org/sites/default/files/R...
- ardit33 6y agoThe guy that wrote is is a big Oil lobyist, and the Manhattan Institue is a conservative/big oil think tank It is like someone from the early 1900s saying: Combustion engines will never take over, steam is 98% of power... etc.. etc.. yet in 10 years they did take over, first cars, then larger vessels (trains and boats). Coal/Steam power generation for trains was seen as a super polluting thing and unwanted in cities anymore. Same thing is happening again, this time it is the combustion's engine turn to get replaced with something cleaner
- mcwone 6y agoWell, I sure hope you are correct on this and we will see a green utopian future. What concerns me is the finiteness of non-renewable resources both oil and the materials used to produce wind and solar power. Processing of ore to produce the rare metals used is very power intensive and polluting. What happens in say 2050 when all this green power tech needs to be replaced?? Is there enough raw materials left over to continue the production of green energy tech ??
- tertius 6y ago"That's like saying this other situation that we can look back at by analogy and overlay it on the future that hasn't yet played out." Nope.
- philipkglass 6y agoThat's a very deceptive article. It compares the levelized cost of electricity from wind and solar generation (using Lazard's LCOE numbers) against gas production cost from a shale well. You have to pay for the power plant construction, operation, and maintenance in addition to the fuel in order to get electricity from gas. And the well owner has to charge more than bare costs for the fuel in order to stay in business.
- robertlagrant 6y agoThe article seems incomplete. Sure we may be burning three times more coal than we'd have to if we could perfectly convert it to energy. That has literally never factored into an argument I've seen about renewables - it's always "we currently produce X GigaWatts 24x7, and renewables don't let us do that". Saying we burn coal at 30% efficiency isn't addressing anything useful. And it's one of those articles where many won't completely follow it, but they'll come out with an impression that the premise is true because of some "sciency bits", when with some more content they could've actually been educated in something useful. Or you could say, "nuclear power would solve this quicker than anything" and you'd be right :-)
- phkahler 6y agoRight. When people talk about what percent of our electricity comes from where, its always gigawatts from the power plants, not BTUs of coal.
- epistasis 6y agoThat's not been my experience. Usually when I hear people arguing the impossibility of renewables, they are taking the BTU numbers, not the kWh numbers of actual energy services.
- philipkglass 6y agoIt's a factor in arguments where people say "we don't need to just clean up electricity, we need to replace all fossil energy." They're usually referring to primary energy in these arguments. If you look at barrels of oil consumed per day in the US, then just plug the barrel-of-oil numbers into a unit converter to see how many terawatt hours it comes to, it looks hopeless to put a dent in oil consumption with electric vehicles and renewable electricity. But as the Bloomberg article points out, we don't need a 1:1 replacement of joules from fossil fuels with joules from non-fossil energy. If everyone currently driving a Toyota Corolla started driving a wind-charged battery electric vehicle instead, the total energy consumed would shrink dramatically without any behavioral changes. Most of the oil energy demanded by those Corollas is simply wasted as heat.
- rdiddly 6y ago"...or as BloombergNEF’s Colin McKerracher puts it: 'just sound and fury, signifying nothing.'" Wow that Colin McKerracher is quite the wordsmith. Quite the bard. (i.e. it's Shakespeare)
- aardvarkr 6y agoIs no one pointing out that this isn’t the part that makes replacing fossil fuels hard? This is focusing on a completely irrelevant metric. It’s a great motivator for why we need to shift but it has no impact on how hard it will be to replace oil. There’s 100 practical reason for why it’s hard, namely that clean energy sources are not under our direct control to scale up and down as we need more/less. We can’t tell the sun to be strongest at 6pm when everyone gets off work so we’ll need more energy. You can force the wind to blow. The best way to solve this is improving battery tech but that’s a HUGE task. What we have currently is a focus on quickly growing increase in clean energy sources as a baseline energy source with a diversified mix of other sources along with natural gas peaking plants that are far cleaner than coal and provide near immediate response times to surges on energy demand which is incredible.
- ip26 6y agoFWIW long distance transmission lines work too. Solar peaks a few hours earlier than demand. So ship that power east two timezones.
- kortilla 6y agoAnd which solar panels power California?
- epistasis 6y agoBatteries and hopefully offshore wind. And people will time shift energy consumption when incentivized. If we were able to charge cars at work, for example, that would shift massive amounts of load to peak solar hours, when electricity will be essentially free on the generation side, and transmission/congestion costs will be the major factor. We are well on our way to making enough batteries to replace our car fleet. If we do that, we will have already built the industrial manufacturing capacity to store several days worth of energy. I forget the numbers, but a huge proportion of wind and solar installs are planning foe good chunks of battery right now. The contracts I've seen indicate a storage cost of $80-$110/MWh, which is cheaper than new nuclear, and pretty much in coal territory. The future is one of super abundant renewable energy, with the huge fractions of it thrown away, unless somebody can figure out used for it or ways to transmit/store it.
- lake-effect 6y ago“Electrical devices can sometimes offer higher than 100% efficiency,” said BNEF analyst Matthias Kimmel. That might seem odd. How can there be more energy as output than input? But that’s exactly what heat pumps and air conditioners do. They use electricity to shift heat from the outside to inside, or vice-versa, and typically provide three units of energy service for one unit of energy input, meaning an efficiency of 300%." Article seems to arguing against basic thermodynamic laws. Air conditioners and heat pumps do not output more energy than they consume. You can't move heat around without expending lots of energy. I'm suspicious this is just uptalk trying convince people renewables can replace fossil fuels without any new data, just confusing lines of arguments.
- xboxnolifes 6y agoThis came up in the last hackernews post I've seen on the topic. It essentially boiled down to that air conditioner efficiency (and similar machines) is measured using a different formula than energy conversion efficiency.
- Gibbon1 6y agoIn one case your are calculating efficiency in terms of unit of work per unit of energy in. The other you are looking at the efficiency in term of unit of heat per unit of energy.
- serpix 6y agowell my 80m2 apartment is fully heated to about 22.5C with an air heat pump drawing about 600W with an outside temperature of 0C. So take from that what you will about efficiency.
- alacombe 6y agoThat's no particular feat, you can heat a forge to 1200C with enough insulation and just 600W. Also, this is just considering a limited referential, ie. the one impacting the most your wallet. If you consider a bigger referential, your efficiency will drop below 1 for sure. Not to mention that your system will leak refrigerant (it's really not a matter of "if" but "when"), which is likely to have greenhouse effects.
- hinkley 6y agoIn the spirit of Fermi’s paradox: So then why haven’t we?
- philipkglass 6y agoBecause there are multiple decades' worth of investment in fossil fuel assets that need replacing, and renewables started competing on price alone (ignoring global warming externalities) in just the past few years. That's also why Germans pay eye watering prices for renewable electricity; Germany installed renewables on a large scale before the costs came down.
- jxramos 6y agoSeems like a simplistic but a very conceivable short sighted overlooked detail in touting fossil fuel advantage to quote so called primary energy for fossil fuel, and yet it kinda feels like a straw man is hiding somewhere. Are there actual past articles and literature that conflates the two when speaking of fossil fuels? Setting the bar too high for renewables would be a big fallacy, but where has that happened exactly? It'll be cool to look back at old articles and twitter posts and spot this conflation or at least to ask for clarification.
- jxramos 6y agoHere's an example from the linked article @mcwone shared below that may present us with an opportunity to spot the fallacy in play: Meanwhile, with batteries, it costs roughly $200 to store the energy equivalent to one barrel of oil. Lazard, “Lazard’s Levelized Cost of Energy Analysis”; utility-scale lithium battery LCOE (levelized cost of energy) @ $108–$140/MWh converts to $180– $230/BOE (barrel of oil energy equivalent). We'll I'm struggling to track that quote in the article to its primary source assuming I landed on the right place https://www.lazard.com/media/451419/lazards-levelized-cost-of-energy-version-140.pdf https://www.lazard.com/media/451419/lazards-levelized-cost-o...