4 ms·
Whenever you watch a video you are downloading it. youtube-dl merely gives you control over where that stream goes, whether it's to a hard disk or to a media pl
by globular-toast 6y ago
Whenever you watch a video you are downloading it. youtube-dl merely gives you control over where that stream goes, whether it's to a hard disk or to a media player like the regular Youtube.
- bigbubba 6y agoThe point is that youtube-dl does more than just download videos. It can also be used for downloading metadata. I use -J to download metadata formatted as JSON.
- boogies 6y agoHow much of that metadata is not normally downloaded alongside the video?
- bigbubba 6y agoPlenty of it? I regularly download the metadata and subtitles of entire channels or playlists so that I can search for specific words or phrases in thousands of hours of video. I know of no other way to accomplish this.
- boogies 6y agoSubtitles are a perfect example of data that any normal browser downloads if you click CC, and can even be ^F'd if you click ‘Show Transcript’ on YouTube, but just happen to be orders of magnitude more useful if you control where they download to. I think you’re proving globular-toast’s point.
- bigbubba 6y agoSubtitles are not video, so no. And I'd like to see you visit a thousand video pages with an RIAA approved browser and ^F on each of them. Nice joke!
- hunter2_ 6y agoWhy should subtitles and video be considered so discretely? Are subtitles not copyrighted the same way as the audio and video portions of the work?
- cosmie 6y agoThank you so much for writing this comment! I've been in several situations where this would have been incredibly handy, but never realized it was possible.
- bigbubba 6y ago`youtube-dl --write-sub --write-auto-sub --sub-lang en --skip-download [URL]` (Then just use grep) There's all kinds of cool stuff you can do with youtube-dl. For example 'ytsearch20:kittens' will get a playlist of the first 20 search results for 'kittens'.
- andrei_says_ 6y agoThis sounds incredibly powerful. Wondering if c-span is on youtube and properly close captioned.
- bigbubba 6y agoAccording to their FAQ, c-span.org's search uses closed captioning to facilitate search (but they don't provide copies of those transcripts.) Perhaps that might suite your needs though.
- lostcolony 6y agoIs that metadata protected by some sort of mechanism? Or is it just not queried by default using one's browser? I.e., is youtube-dl calling a public, unsecured API, or is it circumventing some sort of copy protection? Because if it's just querying for metadata that anyone can already query for...your point seems immaterial as to the legality of the tool?
- robertlagrant 6y agoThey're saying that sure, the name youtube-dl might well imply it's specifically for downloading things from YouTube, but that doesn't mean it's specifically for downloading video from YouTube.
- baobabKoodaa 6y ago> Whenever you watch a video you are downloading it. Why is this comment downvoted? It's highlighting one of the most common misunderstandings that laypersons have regarding video download/streaming. Most people think that you can "view" content on the internet without downloading it. In this context, a tool which purports to "download" content, you know... sounds like it's nefariously doing something that the "viewing" tool (like a web browser) doesn't do.
- MauranKilom 6y agoThis may be completely true in a technical sense, but that's not how the law works (see https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23). And while the same bits pass through your connection, this equivalence already breaks down right away: There is clearly a difference between persisting a media file to disk vs having it ephemeral in browser memory.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- leetcrew 6y ago> There is clearly a difference between persisting a media file to disk vs having it ephemeral in browser memory. yes, at some point actual human intentions must come into play. you can't defend stuff like CP by saying "it's just some EM pulses, what's the big deal?". or "no I'm not invading your privacy with my IR camera, you are broadcasting in the IR spectrum!". in this case the implementation does blur the line a little bit. what if the browser's memory gets swapped out to a page file on a (spinning) hard drive? even if the cache gets "deleted" after closing the tab, it might be quite a while before the sectors containing that protected sequence of bits get overwritten. is this infringement?
- nobody9999 6y ago>There is clearly a difference between persisting a media file to disk vs having it ephemeral in browser memory. Is there? When "streaming" video, there most certainly is a copy of the bits being stored on a disk to ensure that the video "stream" plays cleanly and without interruption. Are you making the claim that "streamed" video is never buffered/stored on disk? That's an odd claim to make. I'm no expert on video streaming, but I would be very surprised to find that all video streams are only stored in RAM and not on disk. I may well be wrong about that. Perhaps someone more knowledgeable could chime in.