7 ms·
The answer to OP's question is... why have software at all? Why not just paper? Why do you want a 'voting machine' at all? What's wrong with paper? The solutio
by chrisseaton 6y ago
The answer to OP's question is... why have software at all? Why not just paper? Why do you want a 'voting machine' at all? What's wrong with paper?
The solution to a problem that should not be solved with software is not to have different software.
- sebmellen 6y agoWe already have voting machines in use! That's the software that needs to be open-sourced.
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut why? What problem do they solve? Get rid of them. Don't convert them to open-source. This is the wrong argument to be making.
- sebmellen 6y agoWell, optimally, yes. But I don't see this happening. Ballot counting machines and software are really the only way elections can happen in a reasonable timeframe in the US, and even then with considerable delays, as evidenced by this year's election.
- heavyset_go 6y agoThe voting machines are already here and were in widespread use before the most recent election in the US. I agree that paper ballots are ideal, but the machines are already in use.
- sova 6y agoWe went from abacus to digital circuit painstakingly over thousands of years and you're using a compute-er with a screen to post this comment. There's nothing wrong with paper except its extreme inefficiency in the human realm. We could have audit-able ballots and public/private keys to check that our ballots have been counted and tabulated correctly. Is it the case, perhaps, that ballots are supposed to be "private" and therefore we have "private" software count them?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> There's nothing wrong with paper except its extreme inefficiency in the human realm. They aren't inefficient. In the UK (paper ballots) an accurate estimate is available when the polls close, and a certain result is available within a few hours before next morning. This is much faster than US voting machines.
- c0llision 6y agoTrue, but: 1. You didn't have to count 151 million votes in the UK election 2. You didn't have to wait a few days for mail-in ballots that were delayed in transit to arrive 3. You didn't have to do this in the middle of a global pandemic that required poll workers to stay 6 feet apart Generally the US election results can be predicted the same day, this year had additional challenges due to extremely high turn-out, high use of mail-in ballots, and limited number of pool workers due to pandemic. In my opinion, elections should be done using paper ballots, and those ballots are counted using electronic tabulation machines. After a batch of ballots are counted, a random sample of them are selected and manually counted. Should the results match, then you can have a high certainty of the accuracy of the count. Electronic tabulation machines are actually more accurate than hand-counting, and by hand counting again, you reduce the risk of the machines making "mistakes" due to technical glitches or malicious backdoors etc.
- brigandish 6y agoThere were 32,014,110 in the last UK general election, which is one fifth of the US total, but then the population is also (roughly) one fifth of the US’.
- throwaway2245 6y ago11 states including Alaska, Arizona, Nevada, and Michigan have a larger land area than the UK. [Edited to add: 46 states have a lower population density than the UK, adding further logistical consideration]
- 6y ago
- martimarkov 6y agoIt kills trees.
- robjan 6y agoAs long as they are replaced it's not too much of a problem.
- markdown 6y agoSpeed, I presume. With software, you can announce the results of an election the second after polling closes. The actual paper ballot count/verification might take a week, but that's one week of uncertainty you don't have to deal with.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIn the UK using paper a pretty certain estimate is available in zero seconds after polls close and accurate results are available within a few hours. Faster than the US using machines, which take a week.
- whimsicalism 6y agoAs long as pre-counting is banned in some states and mail-in ballots exist, this sort of timeliness will not be possible in the US.
- chrisseaton 6y agoPre-counting is banned in the UK. Mail-in ballots exist in the UK. How do you think we manage it?
- whimsicalism 6y agoPre-"opening" is banned in many states in the US but is legal in the UK. See page 12 of https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/sites/default/files/pdf_file/UKPE-Part-D-Absent-voting.pdf https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/sites/default/files/p... for instance or https://www.coventry.gov.uk/info/8/elections_and_voting/2434/working_at_the_election/4 https://www.coventry.gov.uk/info/8/elections_and_voting/2434..., to see how the United Kingdom pre-opens and sorts postal ballots.
- takeda 6y agoYour comment reminds me of this: https://politics.theonion.com/poll-94-of-nation-would-rather-live-in-authoritarian-1845532103 https://politics.theonion.com/poll-94-of-nation-would-rather...
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI believe strongly that all votes should be made on paper ballots. Some portion of these ballots should be audited to find irregularities, and hand recounts should be done in the event of an extremely close election. In the general case, however, tabulating ballots via a scantron machine or similar seems reasonable.
- dariusj18 6y agoAt some point in the process, vote information will be stored digitally. Whether it's posted to the SoE's website or during transmittal to the Federal or state governments. I'm also trying to imagine elections with the number of people we have and number of races being counted by hand from the beginning, with no digital storage or tabulation, and it is rife with errors and even harder to validate in a reasonable way.
- Closi 6y agoHand counting is how we do it in the U.K. It’s not actually that hard at all, including validation, through simple physical processes (that are incredibly tried and tested!). Write the contents of the vote totals on the outside of the box containing the ballots (total must reconcile to number of ballots placed in), then total all the box totals at the end for a single constituency. Constituencies then report back. We get results back within a day and the validity has never been seriously questioned. The process can easily scale linearly too.
- godelski 6y agoThere are scaling issues though. The US is 5x the size of the UK. Counting is actually pretty hard and I'm not convinced it scales linearly. I'm also not convinced results are actually back in a day, but rather good estimates are given within a day.
- jen20 6y agoThe overall counting process in the UK scales horizontally rather well (it's a great example of map-reduce!), and it's close to unthinkable that the results affected by any given count would not be known on the evening of an election day, even if the shape of the resulting government were not known as in 2010. What is not reflected however is the sheer number of votes that people tend to cast in the US - often voting on dozens of different measures. The UK process does not have this aspect - at worst there may be a Westminster, country-specific parliament and city or town council on the same election day, and they are handled via separate ballot papers.
- godelski 6y agoI assume this is working under the presumption that we get rid of the voting software that already exists? This is a big part of OP's question, but I'll entertain it. You have to look at the 2000 election[0] where there was a switch to digital means. I don't have exact numbers, but I am under the impression that these machines are easier to use and are less error prone than the previous punch card methods. Your digital machines can also print you a receipt. So "why have a (digital) voting machine at all" is because it is easier and less error prone. Having election results going to the Supreme Court is a pretty big deal and should be avoided. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidential_election#Voting_machines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidentia...
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut yet again... you're talking about it relative to an alternative like punch machines... how about no machines.
- godelski 6y agoI mean if we're calling a punch ballot a machine then I think a check mark constitutes a machine. Pencil, pen, hole punch, what's the difference? It is a mark on a physical piece of paper. I think you're trying to work your solution into being correct rather than recognizing that the problem itself is extremely complicated. Given your other comments and our other conversations it is clear that you're overly simplifying the subject matter and frankly you are wrong about certain aspects of it (like that all votes are counted the night of rather than "enough"). If you flat out ignore these parts of the problem then you're going to get the wrong result. You should also not start with a solution and work towards an explanation, but rather work the other way around. These conversations feel really disingenuous to be honest. They feel more like they are based on how the UK is so much better without any real justification.
- ploika 6y ago> Pencil, pen, hole punch, what's the difference? It is a mark on a physical piece of paper Hanging chads? You even brought up the 2000 election in the US yourself. Pencil and paper (and no machines) would have avoided that mess.
- rdsubhas 6y agoWhat's wrong with paper? Single answer: Consistent recounts. For example, the US had two really high profile, narrow elections (2000 and 2020), and they still cannot figure out how many times to recount to believe the result. Best of 3 recounts? Best of 5? Keep recounting random places random times until the person you like wins? Does that even change or improve anything? With paper, it's 100% guaranteed that "No two recounts will ever be the same". It's a human process. Two humans verifying it will never come to the same conclusion. One will say the "ballot stamp was not in the right place", another will say "chad did not fall off the paper", someone else may just be tired in the night, so on and on. As a democratic society, we have had large cases of recounts that it's not even a surprise anymore. It has become the go to whining and agitation tool for losers. For the continued functioning of democracy, we have to put an end to this recount problem. If a winner wins by 1 vote, it should recount to the same 1 vote difference no matter how many times you do it. If not, elections are undermined (and thus democracy). As for the "voting machine", people in this forum are really not good for judging as they think in terms of "modern" tech software with C or Python with a running OS. Read this thread for more info [0]. A good way to describe the voting machine, is a dumb printer. It originally exists to print a proper valid ballot for the elector who then drops it off. The machine just so happens to also have a secondary counter in it while it prints, so it can be secondary verified for extra safety. The paper is what matters and it's still there. This is called VVPAT, Voter Verified Paper Audit Trail [1]. Over the course of time, after many many recounts, it becomes obvious that the machine-printed ballot and machine do not ever diverge. So it just so happens that for convenience, the machine has grown to get counted first. If anyone has a doubt, they can easily go back and verify the ballots which are stored forever. It has been proven over and over to give consistent recounts and restore trust in elections. Trivia: First time a Cabinet-rank senator in India lost election by 1 vote [2]. Recounts tallied down to 1. It has happened again. Chaos still did not break out. Candidates were not fighting over who was the winner. Reason? Voting machines and verified ballots. Recounts won't change reality. I'll finally leave you with the summary of an excellent video on elections in India before/after voting machines. Every loser will complain and blame something. Hacking the voting process, obstructionism, who's issued voter IDs, where and how many voting centers are placed, gerrymeandering, media, pre-mature leading polls, on and on and on. All this thing about Voting machines is a classic case of shooting the messenger. The voting machine only exists to give one less reason to blame on. Don't shoot the messenger [3]. 0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25106044 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25106044 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter-verified_paper_audit_tra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter-verified_paper_audit_tra... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C._P._Joshi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C._P._Joshi 3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zdo43a4JfYQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zdo43a4JfYQ