4 ms·
No, no, not humans. The we that have dominion are certain genes, for which the humans are mere vehicles. These genes are just as old as the mushroom genes. And
by renewiltord 6y ago
No, no, not humans. The we that have dominion are certain genes, for which the humans are mere vehicles. These genes are just as old as the mushroom genes.
And this gene cluster is aiming to master the rock that is the Earth through modifying other gene clusters. And you can't stop it. Because through modification it grows stronger and more able. And it has rallied the memome and the hologenome to its cause. This cause requires no convincing because only winners get to play the next round. Change is inevitable. Understanding is overrated. Control does not require it.
Transformation Theology has subsumed this world. You live in an ether floating in it. You cannot choose the path of no change. No such path exists.
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoYeah, we’ve read The Selfish Gene, too.
- renewiltord 6y agoNaturally, it's 50 years old and one of the most influential science books of all time. If you hadn't, then the reference wouldn't work as well.
- ben_w 6y agoWhat it’s worth I haven’t read that book (or seen that passage before) and I still understood.
- renewiltord 6y agoRichard Dawkins did do very well with the way he expressed the concept. It is quite intuitive for something of such great significance. Easy to forget, I suppose for me, how intuitive it is.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> is aiming to master the rock that is the Earth Genes aren't goal directed towards something higher. > This cause requires no convincing because only winners get to play the next round The 'winners', us humans, are literally destroying the ecosphere which supports our life. > Understanding is overrated. That's an appeal to ignorance. > Control does not require it [understanding] We can control something without understanding it? Most of science would disagree.
- renewiltord 6y ago> Genes aren't goal directed towards something higher. No, but "this gene cluster" is me - and I am goal-directed. > We can control something without understanding it? Most of science would disagree. No, they wouldn't. Epistemology has progressed beyond this. Models have various levels of fidelity. And 'understanding' is a colloquial term that refers to a higher standard of fidelity than that required for control. Few drivers know how their cars work. Most drivers can drive their cars. But I do enjoy the amusing attempt at cutting out the sentence to create damning gotchas. Here, I mimicked your style and made one from your comment: > We can control something without understanding it Why, thank you for agreeing with me! Quite gratifying to receive such support.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> and I am goal-directed. OK, straight questiom goal directed towards what? > And 'understanding' is a colloquial term that refers to a higher standard of fidelity than that required for control Don't agree - further > Few drivers know how their cars work. Most drivers can drive their cars. Understanding is about understanding of aspects. They may well not understand the engine aspect (how it works precisely) but "Most drivers can drive their cars" means they control their cars, which means they understand what happens when a steering wheel is turned, and how not to grind the gears, and not to hit accelerator and brake together. They model it. That is the embodiment of their understanding. Without that they could not control a car. > Why, thank you for... Quite clearly there was a question mark at the end it to indicate my implied doubt. Science seeks better understanding of x so it can manipulate x more precisely. Please give me a couple of examples of complex systems which we don't understand but can control, so I can understand you better.
- imtringued 6y agoThat's a pretty stupid take because the combination of genes is unique for each life form so those genes are just as trapped in our bodies as the bodies are trapped in themselves. If you want to talk about genes as an immortalizing life form then those genes are just as prone to natural selection as the carrier. Some genes are old, some are new. New genes have an incredibly high attrition rate. Not much different from nature. Genes are suckers and losers just like their carriers.