9 ms·
I live in the UK and I'm 100% for it in theory, but 100% against it in practice. I currently have an electric vehicle - the only kind of usage scenario where i
by gambiting 6y ago
I live in the UK and I'm 100% for it in theory, but 100% against it in practice.
I currently have an electric vehicle - the only kind of usage scenario where it works and is absolutely brilliant is charging at home. That's about it. Public charging is a joke, vast majority of stations either don't work, are occupied most of the time, or cost so much money to use that it would literally be cheaper to drive a diesel car.
We visited our friends some time ago in London for a few days(before lockdown). They live in an apartment so no way I could run a cable to the parking space. No problem I thought - there's a Shell station nearby with a charging point, several ChargeYourCar points at car park not far away, and I could see on ZapMap that there were two charging points on the street - and worst case scenario there are rapid chargers along the way at few motorway stops.
We got there and basically - all ChargeYourCar points were out of order for 3 days we were there, the 2 charging points on the street were only for permit holders(something that ZapMap didn't mention), and the one single charging point at the Shell station nearby was occupied every single time I checked. So we stopped at the motorway services in the end, where they had 4 rapid charging points - all taken. We waited 30 minutes for someone to leave, once they left the car wouldn't connect - had to ring up the number on the charger, finally the customer service advisor restarted the point for me and it started charging. Only another 45 minutes of waiting and we had enough charge to get home. Oh and the charge was literally £0.49/kWh(I pay £0.05/kWh at home on a night tariff) - I had a Qashqai 1.6dCi few years ago that I could fill up for that much and drive down to london and back.
Again, the car itself is brilliant. It is the future. I have no idea how people still drive around in cars that burn anything to move - they are loud, having to have gears is stupid, having to keep buying fuel is stupid.
And yet.
I can't imagine that the UK government and the private sector will get their act together and somehow, in 9 years, the infrastructure will be amazing, and they will find answers to questions like how do you charge at an apartment or a house with no dedicated parking space. I'm eagerly awaiting to hear about these solutions.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoHow do you expect this to change? Whatever the downsides of electric cars, rampant global warming is clearly much worse. (And yes, stopping it will require more than just switching to electric cars.) Perhaps if electric vehicles were mandated, fast charging stations would be more widely available...
- gambiting 6y agoBtw, that's not me arguing against electric vehicles. They are absolutely fantastic. I think in the next ~10 years everyone who can aford one and has a place to charge one should get one. There will be a massive shift towards them. I just don't see a total ban in 2030 to be necessary -the market will shift towards electric anyway, but if you are in a situation where an electric car just doesn't work for you for whatever reason, I don't see why you shouldn't be able to buy an ICE car. Especially since I imagine they will start being in minority by then, so their impact will be smaller and smaller every year. With a total ban you aren't solving the situation for people who can't work around the limits of an EV - you're just making them pay higher and higer prices on the second hand market for existing ICE cars(as pre-2030 cars are meant to be allowed for as long as they work).
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI would also prefer a very strong carbon tax (or something similar like cap-and-trade) over a blanket ban on specific products, but I'm not sure it makes much difference in practice. Isn't forcing people to pay more on the second hand market more-or-less equivalent to adding a tax? And, eventually, you'd need the number of ICE vehicles to be low enough that ubiquitous gas stations won't be economically viable anyway.
- saiya-jin 6y agoLook, we're all trying to do something for the future, we're on the same boat. But you can't just simply waltz to mankind and actively make their lives measurably more miserable 'because future and polar bears', suck it up. People will react very negatively and you will lose the cause, maybe for good. In next elections some populist will win and revert any progress (I believe I don't need to put names here, do I). It literally doesn't matter that everybody on Hacker News would agree with this, HN is definitely not a representative sample on many topics. If you think mankind is smarter, look at politics of lately, look at covid-related deniers, folks rejecting masks due to some wacky conspiracy, 5g/chipping and so on and on. Forcing folks like this while we give places like China, India or other polluters a free pass? Not only are people expected to pay the bill (research, transition), but it literally won't matter on global scale that they do.
- ip26 6y agoMaybe I'm engaging in magical thinking, but I can't help think after a policy like this is implemented, apartments without electrical service next to your parking spot will rapidly become virtually unlettable. Supply follows demand.
- xxpor 6y agoAnd following that assumption, the most recent version of the national electric code in the US calls for there to be a drop for a EVSE at every N parking spots in new apartment buildings (there's a formula based on how many spots). It doesn't require for an EVSE to actually be installed, but the building has to have the capacity for it. That's important because adding say 20 30 amp EVSEs is a non-trivial increase in the total capacity a building needs. BTW, even a 30 amp EVSE isn't great in an apartment. Because commercial service is almost always 3 phase, you'll only get 208v. That's 6.2 kW. In my townhouse, I have a 40A 240V circuit (50A at the breaker, but the 80% rule means the EVSE only puts out 40A). That's 10 kW. A 61% increase.
- eisa01 6y agoNorwegian experience is that you only need on average 1-2 kW on a load balanced system (individual chargers are 22 kW). I hope the regulation allows for that?
- pmontra 6y agoHouses could have their own charging stations. I guess all the cars will need to be charged during the night, in parallel. Parking garages could add charging stations for all their customers and get paid for that. Parking places on the streets could be equipped with charging stations, one per place. It's going to be more complicated than laying fiber optics but doable. It's a new grid as big as the current one and for higher wattage. Finally, if you have to park where there are no charging stations, oops. Gas stations that can refill N cars per hour will be able to recharge a fraction of them, bad news for those businesses. Of course this is true only if we'll have to charge. If battery swap becomes common then the problem will be solved. Yet, the volume and the weight of a battery is still greater than the volume and weight of the gasoline storing the equivalent energy. The logistics will be more complicated. I expect to see power plants dedicated to charging: charge batteries -> load them on a truck -> deliver to "EV stations" -> bring back the exhausted batteries -> check if they're still OK -> loop again.
- oivey 6y agoI don’t disagree with your pessimism, but at the same time 9 years is an eternity to just install electrical infrastructure. Hopefully laws like this will put a fire under people’s asses.
- pmontra 6y agoOn the other side, would anyone start a business to lay power cables under the sidewalks of a city and create tens of thousands of charging points and be able to start selling it fully only in 2030? Probably not unless countries, states or cities pay for the setup. Will they start doing it closer to 2030 if they see that the adoption of EV is ramping up? More likely.
- grecy 6y ago> and somehow, in 9 years, the infrastructure will be amazing... It doesn't have to magically be "perfect" on Jan 1, 2030. In the UK around 2.3 million vehicles are sold per year[1]. Which means in 2030 about that many electric cars will be sold, and so on for each year. The ICE vehicles that were sold in 2029 won't magically stop being used, they'll just slowly fade out. So in reality they have until well into the 2030s (even 2040s) before the very vast majority of vehicles will be all electric. Of course this is a big challenge, and it will require effort. Anything worth doing is difficult. The other choice is we sit around and do nothing. I know which option I prefer. And at 38 years old, it isn't up to me. Talk to people who are 15-25 and ask what kind of air they want to breath and what kind of world they want to live in. This is a decision for them, not for us. [1] https://www.marklines.com/en/statistics/flash_sales/salesfig_uk_2019 https://www.marklines.com/en/statistics/flash_sales/salesfig...
- romanoderoma 6y ago> and ask what kind of air they want to brea I don't know what kind of air they want, but it doesn't look like they are doing much to stop polluting. If they wanted to, they could stop buying so many clothes or wear them for more than a season... https://indigohoneycomb.files.wordpress.com/2017/03/fash.png https://indigohoneycomb.files.wordpress.com/2017/03/fash.png https://assets.weforum.org/editor/4DxwPKr6vDnGTAjAheQiVQrcrv8O8Y5iD3H6WMt6zmI.png https://assets.weforum.org/editor/4DxwPKr6vDnGTAjAheQiVQrcrv... See? Nobody likes a bit of truth People only want to believed the stories they already believe in. As I've written in another comment "Praise EV and you'll look cool, blame fast fashion and they'll hate you" Point proven.
- tjoff 6y agoWhile I fully agree with your points and I truly have set my expectations for long-distance EV-travel to be as cumbersome as yours (you have to plan for that, because you can't know in advance). Still, I don't think that is enough to be against it. I live in an apartment and charging an EV would cost way more than gas. Even the cost of having a charging pole would be more expensive per month than I pay for gas (charging not included and likely also expensive). And, as you mentioned, be way more inconvenient in some situations. But can't it still be worth it? It is just one, very minor, out of countless sacrifices we will undoubtedly have to make. Why fight this one?
- romanoderoma 6y ago> they are loud, having to have gears is stupid, It's the beauty of driving I'm all in favour for people to stop driving if they don't like it, I can't wait for the day where I can be among the few owners of a mechanical car that I drive when I need to relax, outside of the cities, just don't call what other people enjoy stupid, please Before anybody jumps at me, I quit driving for commute or day by day activities 7 years ago and when I need a car now I use car sharing (I spent around 25-30 euros a month, it really is nothing compared to what I used to spend when I owned a car). But please don't tell me that one of those electric smart is a real car The feeling is just not there
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gambiting 6y ago>>just don't call what other people enjoy stupid, please I enjoy it too, my last car was a Mercedes AMG with a modified exhaust and a tune map. I loved it. But no, it was stupid. The climate is fucked and I literally had a car where the ECU would inject fuel and cut ignition just to produce the loud BRAP BRAP BRAP noise when changing gears. Literally burning fuel to make a noise and not move the car forward. Like, these two are not mutually exclusive. It was incredibly awesome and incredibly stupid at the same time. For driving experience of course I would pick the AMG over my electric car. But it's not a sustainable position to be in.
- romanoderoma 6y ago> The climate is fucked Not because of manual gears... Or because people love to drive But because we move too many things burning fossil fuel Pleasure is never stupid, before considering driving stupid, there are many things I would call it first For example drinking beer, to quote you "you are literally burning fossil fuel to produce something that poison you" The war on ice is wrong in many ways similar to the war on drugs: it is punitive only for the final user. Do you really want people to stop using cars? Instead of putting public money in private companies to help people buy the expensive new electric cars, give the money directly to people to not use the car and see what they use the money for, so you can better understand what their needs are, instead of creating an artificial one.
- russli1993 6y agoNio's car is capable of battery swapping. There is a swap station and a robotic arm take out the battery from your car a change a new one in 3 mins. What is interesting is that they have this program where when you buy a car, you don't buy the battery, you pay a price for the car, then a subscription fee for the battery. And then you can do unlimited free changes at these battery stations. The idea is that you use the entire battery like "fuel". You don't care the ownership of a battery. They make sure the battery is always healthy and full of charge. It also allow you to upgrade to a bigger capacity battery on your car just buy changing a tier in the subscription. Back then nio cars were launched with 75kw battery. Now users can upgrade their car to a 100kw battery by changing a tier of the sub on their phone and pay more monthly fee. Oh you can also downgrade the tier too, say you don't need the single charge range of the 100kw, you can switch to the 75kw and have lower per month fee. China population mostly live in dense apartments, and many old apartments cannot be retrofited with car chargers. This is vastly different from the US where people live in houses. This system allow nio cars to be used like gas cars. And if your swap speed is fast, you don't need as many "energy refill" stations. The way I see it, it's really hard to get ev charging speed equal to gas refills. But it's not technically difficult to a build a robot that changes out battery fast. There was another car company that made a prototype battery change station that can swap battery in 1 mins. And you can always charge the battery as well. So fast charging, destination charging, at home charging for the capable. The combination is able to cover more scenarios and more flexibility. I think it will be interesting to see how this system gets developed in the future. See if it could work well. It will bring a new solution to this industry problem. So far, it seems to work well for both nio and consumers.
- jaharios 6y agoThis seems to me the only way possible to solve the charging problem. Not only it neutralizes the need for charging stations in your house but it makes the refill out of your house easy as gas one. The problem again is the adaptability and compatibility , if we can make smartphone companies use the same cable good luck making car manufacturers use a common battery type.
- slg 6y ago>I can't imagine that the UK government and the private sector will get their act together and somehow, in 9 years, the infrastructure will be amazing, and they will find answers to questions like how do you charge at an apartment or a house with no dedicated parking space. I'm eagerly awaiting to hear about these solutions. They have much longer than 9 years to get the infrastructure right. The average car age in the US is roughly 12 years old. I imagine is is roughly the same in the UK. That means even if they stop selling new ICE cars in 2030 the average car might still be an ICE into the 2040s. Assuming no further restrictions it probably wouldn't be until the 2050s that it would become truly difficult to find a used ICE car. Obviously the UK would need to improve in the meantime, but they would basically have 30 years to get their EV infrastructure into the position it works for every car owner.
- bobthepanda 6y ago> They have much longer than 9 years to get the infrastructure right. No, these seem like pretty solid questions to ask if you are going to be forced to buy an electric car, not just if society is going to go all electric. Unless we're trying to convince people to just stop buying cars altogether in 2030.
- slg 6y ago>if you are going to be forced to buy an electric car, That was my point. You aren't going to be forced to buy an EV. The used market for ICE vehicles can be expected to be robust for some 15-20 years after the ban on new cars goes into effect.
- bobthepanda 6y agoBeing forced to buy an old ICE car rather than a new one is still being forced to do something. Newer cars will have improvements in other things besides motive power, like safety features. Are we going to force people who are not in a situation where EVs are usable, to forgo safety measures as well?
- 6y ago
- marketgod 6y agoBuy a Tesla everything else is shit. Others need to catch up but it's going to take a while. If you buy a Nokia phone today it's not going to work as well as an iPhone. I'm presuming the electric car you have is from a company who isn't as good.
- gambiting 6y agoThat has nothing to do with my argument though, unless we're willing to assume that by 2030 people will be only buying Tesla vehicles.
- marketgod 6y agoTheir competitors aren't good enough. It's going to take them a while to catch up so yes, for the next decade, Tesla will have first-mover advantage. From what I can see in the market, Tesla and NIO are leading the charge, the rest of them should just file bankruptcy now. With all this said, I am presuming what you have. If you tell me the car you drive, I can look at their stock and give you a more informed statement.