32 ms·
Electrified wingsuit from BMW reaches 186MPH on first flight
- sys_64738 6y agoStill not up to King of the Rocket Men standard. I think take off has to be included in these 'first flights'.
- grenoire 6y agoI mean... It's only like, really cool. On a side note, I think it's going to be an interesting decade for all sorts of sports. Different variants enabled by technology, and every-improving athletes and engineers are going to be working on very interesting demonstrations I bet.
- Retric 6y agoAmusingly that’s actually much slower than the world record for unpowered wingsuit horizontal speed of 246.6 mph.
- freeflight 6y agoTho that was not what was tested, this is about having additional thrust to regain altitude and fly longer distances: > “I found the idea of being able to jump from my local mountain wearing the wingsuit and land in my garden fascinating.”
- Retric 6y agoSure, I just find it funny how in most cases 180MPH is fast, but that’s about the minimum speed for horizontal wingsuit flight. You really can strap a get engine to a brick and get it to fly, but you can’t stick a jet engine to a brick and get it to fly slowly. EX: F-15 landed safely with just one wing. A little cough propaganda, but still interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M359poNjvVA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M359poNjvVA.
- freeflight 6y agoI don't fly wingsuits, but from a bit of quick research it seems that 180 MPH is fast even for a wingsuit. The article itself mentions typical horizontal speeds of around 62 mph. The Wikipedia article on wingsuit flying says: > A typical skydiver's terminal velocity in belly to earth orientation ranges from 180 to 225 km/h (110 to 140 mph). A wingsuit can reduce these speeds dramatically. A vertical instantaneous velocity of 40 km/h (25 mph) has been recorded. However the speed at which the body advances forward through the air is still much higher (up to 100 km/h [62 mph]). Even mentions another jetpowered attempt with hydrogen peroxide rockets reaching a horizontal speed of 160 mph, back in 2007. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wingsuit_flying https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wingsuit_flying
- Retric 6y agoMinimum level flight speed is called an aircraft’s stall speeds, which is different than their ideal glide speeds. Wingsuits have a glide ratio of ~2.5:1 (horizontal:vertical) which is not that much better than just falling as a normal skydiver can hit 1:1. To maintain level flight they need to generate a lot more lift, while carrying the extra weight of an engine. By comparison a 747 has a glide ratio of 15:1 and depending on specific model and how much weight it has onboard it will stall in level flight around 180MPH. While many aircraft can fly at much lower speeds, a wingsuit is a terrible aircraft.
- mdorazio 6y agoHorizontal speed =/= level. The average wingsuit with a forward velocity component of 62mph is still dropping in altitude quite fast.
- brendanw 6y agoI run a small site/app where wingsuit pilots upload gps tracks for analysis. 180mph is fast but can be achieved/sustained without a jet. In practice that is difficult to do on most BASE jumps as you need to sustain a steep angle for 10-15 seconds to hit that speed. Density altitude will greatly affect performance as well. What's cool is being able to sustain 180mph while not losing altitude, which it sounds like BMW+Salzmann have accomplished. From the article: "While Salzmann’s first flight was a resounding success, it appears he’s not resting on his laurels. According to BMW, the daredevil wants to fly between the skyscrapers of South Korea next." I've dreamed of being able to zigzag through downtown skyscrapers for more than 10-15 seconds. The Jetman project is astounding. From a friend who is working on a copycat, the costs are close to 100k to replicate. Eager to see experimentation+progress on any projects with the promise of making hybrid human+wing flight more accessible (cheaper).
- generalizations 6y ago> BMW says the electric wingsuit enabled Salzmann to accelerate faster than his mates at a peak speed of 186 mph. (Normal wingsuit operators typically reach horizontal speeds around 62 mph.) Very cool; it appears to be an assist, however, without the power to actually do a takeoff.
- MiguelHudnandez 6y ago15kW should be enough to easily lift an adult human, but the stability implications are a good reason this is an assisted wingsuit and not a jetpack. Another thing to consider is that saying it has 15kW motors and 5 minutes of thrust does not necessarily mean 5 minutes at 15Kw. That would work out to 1.2kWH weighing what I guess to be about 40 pounds in batteries alone. I'm really impressed by wingsuits, and strapping a motor onto one just makes it that much cooler.
- hwillis 6y ago> That would work out to 1.2kWH weighing what I guess to be about 40 pounds in batteries alone. Absolutely not. Sony VTC4s are early 2010s cells that do 30 amps continuous with 2000 mAh capacity[1]. 172 cells weigh in at 17 lbs, 1.2 kWh, and a whopping 16.5 kW continuous rated output. For lower power applications, higher-capacity cells like the NCR18650G[2] weigh below 10 lbs per kWh. [1]: https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0674/3651/files/Sony_VTC4.pdf?838 https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0674/3651/files/Sony_VTC4.... [2]: https://www.imrbatteries.com/content/panasonic_ncr18650g.pdf https://www.imrbatteries.com/content/panasonic_ncr18650g.pdf
- shi 6y ago> Normal wingsuit operators typically reach horizontal speeds around 62 mph. Normal wingsuits can easily reach ground speeds up to 250kmh/155mph. Source: https://ppc.paralog.net/listtracks.php?sort=Speed&record=C https://ppc.paralog.net/listtracks.php?sort=Speed&record=C
- wiradikusuma 6y agoDoes anyone know why it's not strapped at the back like a jetpack?
- Retric 6y agoMost obvious is parachute goes on the back, and you really don’t want to mess with that. But, you’re also going to get a lot more turbulence on someone’s back.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- weddpros 6y agoI guess extrados is much more important than intrados in terms of aerodynamics (planes "never" carry anything above their wings, only below them)
- njharman 6y agoInteresting. But propulsion is strapped to his body (fuselage) and not his wings. Planes have things attached above fuselage AWACS have huge dish. The Space Shuttle transporter too. A-10's have engines above wings (although they are not attached to them).
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoNo, that's not even remotely some sort of design rule. Business jets commonly have their engines mounted above the wings. Doing so can enhance lift in some situations. Here's one of Boeing's models using this idea to enhance the lift of a blended wing body: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=28blrKKg0Uo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=28blrKKg0Uo
- topynate 6y agoIt says something about wingsuit flying that strapping a 25,000 rpm motor to one's chest and pointing it only slightly away from one's groin isn't even close to the biggest risk factor in this activity.
- intricatedetail 6y agoIt takes balls to fly it... I'll show myself out
- potatochup 6y agoI guess his arms are fixed into the suit, but it still looks like if you relaxed your arms a little too much you could get your hands into the turbine...
- ipnon 6y agoMy first thought is that this would plausibly explain the recent appearances of mid-altitude jetpack sightings by airline pilots around LAX.
- Robotbeat 6y agoLithium-based batteries (and associated tech) are to the 21st century what the internal combustion engine was to the 20th century and what the steam engine was to the 19th century. There’s a ~90% chance you’re using a device powered by a lithium chemistry battery to read this right now (laptop or tablet or phone). The smartphone alone (enabled by lithium based batteries) has transformed the world. Lithium-based batteries have impacted public health & healthcare (e-cigs vs conventional, medical devices like insulin pump, etc), micromobility (e-scooters, e-bikes, electric wheelchairs, etc), countless accessories (smart watches, smart speakers, wireless earbuds), grid storage, electric cars, electric buses, electric trucks, electric ferries, electric rocket pumps (RocketLab), satellites, submarines, civil drones (like Zipline), and a whole bunch of things that have not yet been invented and perhaps require improved chemistry like lithium metal anode or lithium sulfur or eventually lithium-air (enabling long-haul electric flight, even supersonic flight). For things like this article described, it will enable more expansion of form factors and reduce costs. Jet suits have been done before but equivalently-specked electric motors are much cheaper than the small, micro turbines used for projects like this. And micro turbines have such atrocious efficiency (about 4.4% for hobby turbine engines... meaning their fuel supply only has a useful specific energy of about 1.9MJ/kg or 525Wh/kg, compared to 0.5 MJ/kg for high-C-rate LiPo, 1MJ/kg for really good production Li-ion and 2MJ/kg for low C rate lithium metal anode cells and lithium sulfur) that after another few decades of battery chemistry improvement, electric microturbines not only will have punchier power but also longer duration. There’s a ton of undeveloped opportunities out there that will be enabled by the efficiency, convenience, low-cost, high reliability, and oxygen-independence of lithium chemistry batteries.
- CrazyCatDog 6y agoLithium ion cannot output enough (low C) to make this feasible (yet). Much more likely using Li-Po cells, which are far more adept at emptying themselves at high load—but thermal runaway (eg insanely hot fires) is all too real with Li-Po, though less so today than say 6 years ago!
- nikda 6y agoFrom Wikipedia: A lithium polymer battery, or more correctly lithium-ion polymer battery (abbreviated as LiPo, LIP, Li-poly, lithium-poly and others), is a rechargeable battery of lithium-ion technology using a polymer electrolyte instead of a liquid electrolyte.
- sradman 6y agoThis appears to provide an additional 5 minutes of boost to traditional wingsuits [1], a specialized form of skydiving. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wingsuit_flying https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wingsuit_flying
- CrazyCatDog 6y agoAn electric ducted fan (EDF) is highly inefficient, had they put similar wattage through a gearbox to say a folding prop, efficiency may have doubled (albeit an admittedly more onerous form factor). This is just the beginning of electric assist single passenger flight! Reference: plenty of experience pushing 8KW+ through 2KG RC gliders (F5B) and far slower EDF models.
- patentatt 6y agoBit of an aside, but are you saying you are flying an EDF glider?
- CrazyCatDog 6y agoHaven’t bothered :) Only “toy” EDF models, performance from an 8KW system revving at 60K rpm at 10S (10 lipo cells in series) swinging a 19” folding prop is on par with a mini turbine in terms of performance (0-> 180mph+ in under 2 seconds). Granted this is for 2 meter gliders, but I would expect similar efficiencies in larger scale applications (the bmw EDF is not that much larger than RC).
- generalizations 6y agoThat's crazy. For a non-RC dude, how much thrust does that produce, and how much did it cost?
- CrazyCatDog 6y agoThe $ sounds high, but it’s nothing compared to the time that goes into building and preparing... https://youtu.be/oCS84I8vJK8 https://youtu.be/oCS84I8vJK8
- thimkerbell 6y agoIf someone wanted to learn all this stuff in a "for dummies" class, what course would they look for, among the MOOCs?
- demarq 6y agoSomething seems suspect here. There is just no way that small unit could generate near enough thrust to make a real difference. I think we need to look deeper into this claim
- kzrdude 6y agoHe's starting from a plane, so his flight is mostly powered by the fall and the updraft of the wingsuit. Additionally, it may look as if he's soaring when just gliding with a small change in perspective
- thdrdt 6y agoAre you sure? Those small EDFs can generate 12-25kg of thrust. The fastest wingsuit flight almost topped 400km/h so maybe the real question is how much extra speed was gained with those little EDFs.
- colesdefectum 6y agoEven without additional power it's possible to gain a small amount of altitude with a wingsuit[0]. Modern suits can be very powerful with proper technique. [0] https://squirrel.ws/learn/wingsuit-deployments https://squirrel.ws/learn/wingsuit-deployments
- hwillis 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxJJ17HV1yU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxJJ17HV1yU Fans that small put out enough force to literally push you straight up. Jetcat has an engine 23 cm wide which can pull 110 kg. For the same size an electric fan passes much more air. https://www.jetcat.de/en/productdetails/produkte/jetcat/produkte/Professionell/P1000 https://www.jetcat.de/en/productdetails/produkte/jetcat/prod...
- demarq 6y agothose are jets, not EDF
- dmje 6y agoI just need you all to pony up and buy me one. Presume that’s ok?
- okareaman 6y agoHumans are amazing animals
- blauditore 6y agoFor non-Americans, that's 300 km/h.
- thdrdt 6y agoAnd I just read on Wikipedia the fastest speed ever recorded was 396.86 km/h. And the fastest average horizontal speed over 1000m: 325.4 km/h. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wingsuit_flying https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wingsuit_flying
- Justin_K 6y agoDoes anybody else think it is way too small to produce any real thrust? If it put out serious thrust, I'd expect it to be less flimsy...the video made it look kind of floppy on the guy. I think BMW needs to publish the thrust produced vs use numbers that aren't truly comparable.
- CrazyCatDog 6y agoThis is why they cannot use the EDF for launch—nowhere near enough thrust. But thrust is far less important for sustained speed, where pitch speed becomes the critical element.
- spurgu 6y agoFor anyone interested in wingsuits in general, check out Jetman (Yves Rossy): https://www.jetman.com/en https://www.jetman.com/en https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yves_Rossy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yves_Rossy Obviously cool if you can do similar things with electric as well.
- peterwwillis 6y agoNice to see they aren't bothering with social distancing. I mean, sure, they might be spreading a deadly virus, but how else are they gonna talk about how bad-ass that wingsuit flight was? Totally worth killing immunocompromised people.
- anonytrary 6y agoThis sounds like a "Karen" comment. Do you really think a few guys flying in turbulent air will spread covid? Have you seen all of the people who gather in parks in San Fransisco? This flying experiment is not even comparable to other vectors of the virus that immunocompromised people are exposed to on a daily basis.
- peterwwillis 6y agoIt's not so much a 'Karen comment' as actually respecting human life. But sure, let's all spread the disease whenever we feel like it just because other people spread it worse. It's amazing how little morals people have nowadays when I have to defend not wanting people to die.
- anonytrary 6y agoCoughing at 10,000 feet is completely harmless. That sort of turbulence/condition is an unviable transmission vector for a virus as it reduces the PPM beyond effectiveness.
- FabHK 6y agoThey're outside and (in the last congratulatory shot) almost all wearing masks. I think that is defensible.
- peterwwillis 6y agoIt's not defensible, because you still have to social distance even when outside.
- sabujp 6y agonow just get me to flying altitude
- kylecazar 6y agoWow.. Some people have managed to build a seriously high tolerance for risk.
- CrazyCatDog 6y agoBoredom causes people (presumably not just me) to go to great lengths to feel alive again.
- rriepe 6y agoMinor headline nitpick: It should be electric-powered. An electrified wingsuit has electricity coursing through the whole thing. EDIT: More of a BMW PR nitpick I guess.
- reaperducer 6y agoI saw this on the news a couple of days ago. It stated that flight time is about five minutes before the battery runs out. That time in "flight" doesn't seem much different than the time it would take to plummet to your death. The only material difference seems to be the not dying part.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoYou could use these suits to help pilots who can’t land their plane - they literally only need a few moments of “burn” close to the surface
- colesdefectum 6y agoAs a wingsuit pilot I would disagree. Donning the suit is a little more complicated than just strapping on a skydiving rig and you need a fair amount of experience to successfully fly one to begin with. Your parachute system threads through the wingsuit, you still need to tighten leg straps inside the suit before zipping up, tighten a chest strap after zipping up, then zip the arm and leg wings and exit the aircraft with a correct body position and delay to avoid slamming into the tail depending on what type of aircraft it is. It takes a few minutes to put everything on while on the ground, I can't imagine trying to put everything on while a plane is out of control and get it all adjusted properly during an aircraft emergency. Wingsuiters suit up on the ground before boarding so all that's left is to zip up your arm wings and leave the aircraft.
- Toutouxc 6y agoWe already have those, they're called "parachutes". They're easier to operate, safer and don't require power.
- colesdefectum 6y ago5 minutes in addition to the normal time you get when flying a wingsuit would feel like forever. Even 2 minutes (my average) starts to feel strange towards the end after being used to a typical 60 second skydive.
- bloaf 6y agoBase jumping has a ridiculously high fatality rate (~1 in 60 people who try it die). I wonder if adding engines makes it safer or less safe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BASE_jumping#Safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BASE_jumping#Safety
- leeoniya 6y agoprobably depends on whether you're buzzing mountains and not deploying a chute till 1000ft. in this vid he's jumping out at 10k ft which makes it closer to skydiving.
- base698 6y agoIt's more active jumpers over their jumping career than just people who try it once. It varies wildly jumper to jumper based on the types of jumps done (cliffs are more deadly than bridges) and how often. Most people jump for a period of 3-6 years and quit. My wife and I were pretty active jumping in the era of wingsuit videos on YouTube. In her first year we had one good friend die and 9 people we'd met or hung out with a short time. It is basically comparable in danger to spaceflight.
- bjornedstrom 6y agoDidn't expect to find one here at Hacker News. 698... so you must have started around the early 00:s or thereabouts? Unfortunately I share your same statistics: I was very active in the early 2010:s and in that period I lost about 10 friends/acquaintances. Since then even more people I've hung out with are gone. So yeah: wingsuiting is dangerous. But BASE itself can be done "reasonably" safely I think: personally I was always more fond of slider down (low) stuff, like buildings, and in my mind that's a safer sport than wingsuit BASE.
- base698 6y agoYeah 2000 was first BASE jump. There are a few on here. Brendan W and a few others pop up on these threads.
- deleted 6y ago
- skizm 6y agoI'm genuinely wondering when I can buy a personal, commercially available, vehicle that will let me fly (or maybe sail) over the Hudson river on my commute into NYC. What are the stoppers for something like this? Landing? Economics? Regulation? I'd pay more money than a car for something like this.
- qppo 6y agoYou can buy a helicopter. They're expensive, loud, and dangerous. The noise is really bad and one of the reasons I'll vote against any local ordinance that would make heli-transit more available.
- dmurray 6y agoOr you can buy a canoe - GP was willing to sail instead of fly. Cheap, quiet, safe-ish - paddling across the shipping lanes of the Hudson is probably mostly fine, but if you do it every day you'll have some close calls. The Hudson River is less than a mile across at Manhattan. This could be faster than car/train/ferry/bike for some very specific commutes.
- kerneis 6y agoIt's very much doable: https://edition.cnn.com/2016/11/01/americas/zach-schwitzky-canoe-commute/ https://edition.cnn.com/2016/11/01/americas/zach-schwitzky-c... "Living in Hoboken, New Jersey, the other side of the Hudson river to Manhattan, Schwitzky kayaks across the water in around 20 minutes."
- hwillis 6y agoa pilots license
- purplecats 6y agothat looks fun. is this something i can pay to do?
- bbojan 6y agoBatteries -> electric motors -> ducted fans seems inefficient to me. If I were building this myself I would go with a hybrid rocket engine.
- FabHK 6y agoThough electric motors are notoriously efficient (much more so than ICEs), and my understanding was that ducted fans are also efficient (particularly with 2 stacked counterrotating props).
- neolog 6y agoIs that exhaust smoke from an internal-combustion engine trailing behind them?
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoNo, they're just wearing smoke bombs/sticks so that you can see the trails in the footage.
- kleiba 6y agoFirst sentence in video: "What does it take to shape the future?" Me: turns off sound
- m0zg 6y agoMeanwhile, Tesla is gobbling up BMW's luxury car marketshare. I mean, this is exciting and all, but as a BMW owner with a 6 year old car, I'd appreciate if there were any non-dumb options in your lineup, BMW. Instead we're getting humongous grilles and wingsuits. How stupid do you think your customers are?
- Toutouxc 6y agoWhy does this, of all things, have to be electric? It's a wing suit. They're basically strap-on death. Their glide ratio is somewhere between a really bad plane and a brick, they're unusable in any shape or form for real transportation. They could've had gone with a jet or even a rocket engine and it wouldn't have made the thing more dangerous or less green or anything. Don't get me wrong, I love it, but I don't really see what they were seeing when they made this.
- usrusr 6y agoRockets or jets would limit your candidates for a sponsoring contract to Red Bull and Red Bull. If you are making a bit of a career out of BASE and/or wingsuit you are probably tired of them by now, or they are tired of you or both. It's a very small market and surely weird given that the buyer has a monopoly, whatever that means. With electric, apparently BMW becomes another candidate (who seem to be desperately looking for ways to get their name visible in a context that somehow combines "electric" and "exciting").
- duxup 6y agoAre these way safer than say the base jumping type wing suits? Obviously they're powered so they're different, but I remember a lot of wing suit debates where even professionals felt that the envelope between 'safe' and disaster on wing suits was way too small for even professionals to use. A lot of that seem to have to do with the jumper's sense of how stable they are / compared to how stable they actually are and how that could get way off at times and even pro's weren't able to manage them well enough.
- aeharding 6y agoJust to clarify, he's jumping a BASE rig with a wingsuit - albeit technically a skydive (jumping from a helicopter). It's a BASE rig since it only has one parachute, and the sole canopy is designed to deploy quickly and consistently. Another clarification - BASE rigs with wingsuits are not inherently dangerous. In fact, BASE/wingsuit gear failure as a cause of death is extremely low. It's correlation vs causation - BASE rigs are used almost always (except for certain stunts like this) used in a BASE environment flying close to land, where the margin of error (time to impact) is extremely low compared to a skydiving environment. In a skydiving environment, you can do everything wrong, even do nothing and likely live (automatic activation device triggered deployment of your reserve canopy). But with BASE, oftentimes you are flying so close to terrain that you cannot deploy your canopy and live, and your only option is to continue flying your wingsuit to a safe place to deploy - which is a problem if you stall, take a slightly wrong line down the mountain, etc. Source: I'm a parachute rigger and I wingsuit (in a skydiving environment).
- wombatmobile 6y agoLooks like a lot of fun. The cheesy music and SFX put me off.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ineedasername 6y agoI guess I can see military and extreme sports applications, but is there a mass market application I'm missing?
- pandaman 6y agoFor people wondering what is this for. BMW has just announced a new electric SUV (iNEXT) and started production on another one (iX3) so they are hyping their electric technology. In my opinion, they could do much better by just allowing their plugin hybrids to charge at the full rate of a lv2 charger. A PHEV X5 could be the killer product with the X5 already being one of the best selling cars in its segment except it takes 6 hours to charge on a lv2 for the full 30 miles range due to the current limitation. The battery itself seems to be able to handle much higher current when it charges off the engine so it seems like an artificial limitations to prevent the PHEVs from competing with the few BEVs they struggle to move.