13 ms·
NYC pilot tries mental health responders in place of police
- mixmastamyk 6y agoThis sounds fine with a few caveats, less ill people dead. But unless there’s long-term supervision available for these folks, it is only a 72-hour band aid. In our neighborhood they are back on the streets in a few days after getting naked in front of and screaming at girl scouts.
- andrew311 6y agoDid anyone else read this title as “NYC Pilot (that flies planes) Tries Mental Health Responders in Place of Police” instead of “NYC Tries Mental Health Responders in Place of Police”?
- asquabventured 6y agoYes! I thought it was going to be a story about a pilot's first hand experience!
- mrmrcoleman 6y agoYes.
- sgerenser 6y agoLiterally read the headline 3 times before realizing it wasn’t related to an Airline pilot.
- technofiend 6y agoThat's exactly how I read it and was envisioning a pilot calling mental health workers to get an unruly passenger off their plane.
- kylecazar 6y agoIndeed.. maybe 'pilot program' would help.
- IgorPartola 6y agoThis was definitely a bit of a Foot Heads Arms Body moment.
- tuna-piano 6y agoTrying new ideas in low-risk ways is generally a good idea. Government is generally incentivized to keep the status-quo and not take many risks. Your political position shouldn't affect your view of this effort, so long as it's novel, low risk and follows the data.
- collyw 6y agoLow risk until a mental health professional gets shot.
- aiisjustanif 6y agoWould you rather try it out on an entire state first? It is low risk compared to the alternative options to experiment.
- jnwatson 6y agoThe net deaths might still be lower. 978 people have been shot by police in the US in the past year. * https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/investigations/police-shootings-database/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/investigations/polic...
- syrrim 6y agoExchanging a larger number of deaths of civilians for a smaller number of civil worker deaths is a good trade. Dead civil workers mean less people willing to do that work, which means less help available to people overall.
- salamimonger 6y agoThat's a very hot take. But I'm inclined to appreciate it.
- briandear 6y agoOut of how many police-citizen interactions? The raw number is meaningless without context.
- SethMurphy 6y agoThis is what "Defund the Police" means in practice and hopefully this could lead to meaningful and positive changes. I recently witnessed an encounter in NYC involving paramedics and police interrogating an individual who did not want medical care, and any involvement with police. The paramedic was definitely using deescalation skills that I would usually equate with police work, as the police took a stand back and see attitude. I didn't see the outcome, but it seemed there was no one size fits all solution for this particular situation and the skills needed by both professions had a large overlap. The problem seems to be about eroding trust in the police relationship with communities. The solution being proposed is creating new trust relationship with another public organization. Either way we need trust with every public organization/community interaction in the end and moves like this, if successful, are still just solving half the problem.
- vangelis 6y agoA big step would be making police live where they work. There's a lot of talk about warriors coming in from outside to pacify an unruly populace.
- jelling 6y agoChicago, which has a long history of police abuse, has had residency requirement for police officers for years. What tends to happen is that officers live in one or two specific neighborhoods, far far away from the heavily policed neighborhoods. I believe it’s the same in St. Louis and other cities. This is just to say that a residency requirement is not a panacea by any means.
- mdorazio 6y agoI think this is a great idea and aligns well with what the general public wants. However, I'm afraid it might lead to injuries or even deaths of health responders if the encounters turn violent due to mental illness, drug abuse, or general fear of authorities + concealed weapons. This would end up swinging public opinion right back to the other side again. Like most issues in America, this one is complicated.
- goodells 6y agoI work as an EMT for a 911 service. The general attitude that I have and other EMS providers I’ve talked with seem to share is that this won’t end well. The first thing we’re taught is that the scene must be safe. If it’s not safe, we stage nearby until law enforcement or fire tell us to come in. The 911 dispatch is notorious for misevaluating the nature and severity of a situation, and generally we are toned out to an address and keep getting updates with call details as we are driving there. In this country where anyone can have a gun on them, there is no way in hell that I and my partner are approaching an emotionally disturbed person with no way to defend ourselves. If something goes wrong, the most effective weapon we have is an oxygen tank. And now the public’s perception of drugs like ketamine for chemical restraint is souring, so the message seems to be “Go deal with the worst our society has to offer, with no backup in case they try to hurt you, no not even safe chemical restraints. And no sorry we can’t pay you more than a cashier at WalMart... but you’re heroes!” Just last year a firefighter paramedic in my state was shot dead after administering naloxone to a man and saving his life. Part of it is the compensation. Law enforcement officers are paid substantially more than the EMS folks here with the understanding that they take on more risk. We make $12 hourly... not enough to accept drastically increasing our chances of being hurt or killed.
- giantg2 6y agoMy thoughts exactly. Also, the success rate of calming down a mentally unstable person threatening violence to self or others is only about 33% for someone who is trained and knows the patient's history. That leaves a lot of risk for that other 67% of the time.
- cwhiz 6y agoI wish there were some service I could call in between 911 and... nothing. If I call 311 it almost always results in a call to 911, because they can’t do anything. However, I worry about the safety of these mental health workers. I don’t know how they are going to do this safely.
- giantg2 6y agoYou can call the relevant agency directly. Similar to calling the police station for non-emergency calls instead of 911. Of course it depends on the specifics of any given scenario.
- sigstoat 6y ago> You can call the relevant agency directly. Similar to calling the police station for non-emergency calls instead of 911. that's not a meaningful distinction in a lot of places. 911 and the "non-emergency" number around here go to exactly the same pool of people. there's maybe just some small difference in the prioritization of the calls. the only other published numbers are for administrative offices that are open 8-5, and rings the same desk you find yourself at if you walk into the lobby of the administrative building. they take lunch breaks, and there's usually just one person there working first-come first-serve.
- giantg2 6y agoSure, it depends on where you are, who you are trying to contact, and how urgent the situation is. I'm just saying it can be an option. I've done this.
- maxerickson 6y agoThe statistics are that most police officers never fire their weapon while on duty. I think there's a small portion of scenarios where the presence of the weapon suppresses violence.
- delecti 6y agoIsn't the point of 911 that they dispatch the appropriate service? It seems like the real problem is that there aren't less-extreme responders, which this initiative is trying to fix. I want there to be only 911, and I want them to figure out who to send. People shouldn't be second guessing who to call, they should call the "I need help" number. I could see where having something like a 311 might make sense, but it should just redirect to the same call center too. It'd help remove hesitation on calling.
- bogwog 6y agoIdea: disarm the police. In practice, very few police interactions require a firearm, so why have that as the default? If a police officer is working in a dangerous neighborhood, then they can exercise their right to carry a personal firearm at their own expense. However, any decision to use the gun would be 100% the individual’s risk as they won’t be able to hide behind their departments policies and procedures as an excuse to shoot people. So a police officer deciding to shoot someone is no different from your neighbor deciding to shoot someone. It might also incentivize individuals to seek out real firearms training on their own. EMS people might be trained in mental health, but police officers are better prepared to deal with aggressive people, defend themselves (with batons, pepper spray, tasers, etc), and make arrests. For dangerous situations that require firearms, you can call in a completely separate organization dedicated to that, like SWAT or whatever. Or is this too naive and/or stupid?
- leetcrew 6y agoI think there's something to this idea. even in the most dangerous places in the US, the vast majority of criminals are not likely to shoot at police on purpose. cop killers almost always get caught and convicted (if they survive long enough to get to court), while in some cities the odds of getting away with killing a civilian free and clear are over 50%. certainly there are some enforcement roles where weapons aren't needed. for instance, if you need a gun to feel safe confronting a driver over a broken brake light, maybe it's just not worth pulling them over to begin with? in general, I think there ought to be more parity between what cops are allowed to carry and do to defend themselves and what is available to civilians. if every patrol car needs an ar-15 in the trunk to safely traverse an area, shouldn't people who actually live there be allowed to at least carry a pistol? or alternatively, if it's not okay for a civilian to carry any sort of firearm, why should it be okay for police?
- giantg2 6y agoI generally agree with the bit about increasing parity. Some policies seem to relegate citizens to a lower class. The part about the brake light doesn't sound like a good idea. Police do encounter people with more serious warrants while responding to minor infractions or calls. Some of these individuals are dangerous. It's best to have the equipment needed to deal with those situations. I think the shortfall is that some people lack the training to go with it.
- fastball 6y agoCool, I hope this works out for the best.
- qchris 6y agoHN has always seemed to me to be a community that is moved by data-driven approaches, and this topic has a pretty clear motivation to reduce police violence. As a result, I think some people may be interested in reading up on Comapign Zero's[1] 8Can'tWait initiative (https://8cantwait.org/ https://8cantwait.org/), which has identified, tracked [2], and advocated for 8 policy implementations across municipalities in the U.S. which meaningfully reduce instances of police violence. The policies include a Use of Force Continuum, Comprehensive Reporting requirements, De-escalation Requirements (which, here, in the context of mental health response is particularly valuable), and more. There are links at the bottom of their website which can help you dig more into their methods, if you're interested. [1] https://www.joincampaignzero.org/ https://www.joincampaignzero.org/ [2] https://useofforceproject.org/#review https://useofforceproject.org/#review
- nradov 6y agoSome of those proposals are good, others are terrible and totally unrealistic. In particular requiring law enforcement to always give a warning before using deadly force and ban shooting at moving vehicles will put them and the general public at greater risk. Sure police should issue a warning whenever possible but there are always going to be exceptional situations. For example terrorist attacks, mass shootings, and hostage situations.
- jhardy54 6y agoThen they can claim an exception to the rule caused by exceptional circumstances. The overwhelming supermajority of police activity doesn't require dealing with terrorists (including active shooters and hostage situations). Maybe SWAT can have slightly different rules regarding RoE, but those should be the exception.
- nradov 6y agoThat's the point. The #8CantWait proposal is problematic because it calls for strict bans without accounting for real world situations. As for active shooter situations, guidelines now call for the first responding officer to immediately move in and attempt to stop the shooter by any means necessary. They aren't supposed to wait for a SWAT team to respond. It's ridiculous to propose separate use of force rules for them.
- robomartin 6y agoI am all for the pilot program so long as the politicians pushing for this are charged as accessories to any crimes committed against the people they are going to put at risk. This is the very definition of insanity. In other words, ignoring reality and pretending that a fantasy in someone’s head is real. My father in law is a retired cop. One of the most harrowing stories he tells is about when he and his partner entered this four unit apartment building. The kind where you open the front door and there are four doors along a short hallway. The call was for yelling and screaming (a loud argument) from one of the units at 2:00 AM. They opened the front door (unlocked) and stepped into the hallway to look for the apartment. That’s when someone comes out of one of the apartments and immediately fires a gun towards them, emptying the entire clip. His partner got shot twice. He was grazed once. The guy ran off. Other cops arrested him later. The vast majority of people are good. We don’t have cops to hand lollipops to kids playing at the park. We send armed cops into the worst possible situations and expect them to be buddhist philosophers. Sorry, that’s not the real world. Not when your job requires you to engage with multiple people a day, any one of whom could kill you. Those of you who think you can philosophize with someone intent on killing you should take a weapons martial arts class to understand reality. Having done so myself for decades I can tell you I don’t want anyone with a knife any closer than 16 feet, maybe 20. Even someone relatively slow and without training can bridge a 20 foot gap and kill you with a knife before you know what happened. People (and politicians) love to voice opinions about this stuff and yet none of them are willing to put their lives on the line as part of the experiment they propose. I’ll have respect for them when, armed with a candy bar and good intentions, they go face someone who could potentially kill them. We’ll see how long their plans survive contact with reality.
- giantg2 6y agoThose politicians are on the same level of people protesting police shooting a suspect chasing them with a knife. Those are the same type of people saying "you should have shot him in the leg" and other crap.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- taway-predict 6y agoThis experiment will end as soon as one of them gets killed.
- rasz 6y ago"in place of police" >The mental health responders will be accompanied by a police officer uh oh
- kgin 6y agoA lot of people here rooting for their preexisting beliefs to be confirmed, rather than being happy that a city is experimenting and evaluating new ways of doing things. NYC didn't dig in and defend the status quo. They also didn't flip over the table and change everything across the city because of a new idea that sounded nice. They're testing it.
- hevelvarik 6y agoI did my part: I read the article. I still have zero clue as to how evaluate whether any particular call will warrant this new or the previous, alternative approach.