2 ms·
Has there been any retrospectives or published thoughts around why OpenID failed? Ideally a extensive, impartial report would be nice to read through. While it
by diggan 6y ago
Has there been any retrospectives or published thoughts around why OpenID failed? Ideally a extensive, impartial report would be nice to read through.
While it's easy to blame big technology companies for the failure of open standards, there might be other reasons behind it (as well as companies trying to prevent it from succeeding)
- IshKebab 6y agoOpenID failed because you had to sign up to an OpenID provider and then copy and paste some weird URL from there into websites you wanted to use. Why would anyone bother with that hassle when you can just put in your email address (that you already have & know) and a password. In contrast, OAuth succeeded because most people already have a Facebook / Gmail / Github account, which meant that sign up just becomes clicking a single button which is easier than email signup. OpenID was more difficult than email signup, whereas OAuth is easier.
- robertlagrant 6y agoHaving a DNS-like system that resolved an individual's email address to an OpenID provider (or more than one?) might've been a good idea.