10 ms·
Tiny bubbles under a ship may help reduce fuel consumption
- ColinWright 6y agoI remember reading about this 40 years ago, and have occasionally wondered why it hasn't been implemented. Then I'm reminded of the history of the "Bulbous bow"[0] on ships, and how long that took to be adopted. I've submitted the Wikipedia link[1] in case anyone wants to read about it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulbous_bow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulbous_bow [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25091997 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25091997
- worldsayshi 6y agoBulbous bows sounds hard or impossible to retrofit on an existing ship but this does sound fairly easy to add.
- hansvm 6y agoIt might be harder for larger ships but for anything under a couple hundred tons those are straightforward to retrofit in anything that doesn't have an exotic hull construction.
- worldsayshi 6y agoAre you referring to bows or bubbles?
- hansvm 6y agobows
- Already__Taken 6y agoIt isn't, but it also is not a fix-all. They work for a very specific, narrow range of speeds and wave conditions. If that's not in your shipping route it's not helpful.
- worldsayshi 6y agoAre you referring to bows or bubbles?
- Already__Taken 6y agoThe bulbous bow.
- jcims 6y agoI always wondered what that was for, cool!
- Balgair 6y agoFor anyone that didn't read the article: Without the bulb, the prow slices through the water and causes the water to ride up the sides of the ship. The bulb on the bow is under the waterline. This forces water up in front of the ship before the prow. The bulb is designed so that the bulb-rise of water cancels the prow-rise of water in destructive interference. The bulb design only works at certain speeds, water conditions, etc.
- app4soft 6y ago> have occasionally wondered why it hasn't been implemented. Because underwater hull part may be caused via cavitation erosion.[0,1,2] [0] https://www.iboats.com/propellers/what-prop-cavitation https://www.iboats.com/propellers/what-prop-cavitation [1] https://www.thoughtco.com/cavitation-causes-and-remedies-2293276 https://www.thoughtco.com/cavitation-causes-and-remedies-229... [2] https://www.southampton.ac.uk/engineering/research/projects/cavitation_erosion_corrosion_of_ship_propeller_materials.page https://www.southampton.ac.uk/engineering/research/projects/...
- bernulli 6y agoThose are two very different things. The OP article talks about introducing air bubbles into the stream along the hull, the articles you linked talk about cavitation bubbles, i.e. water that vaporizes when the pressure locally drops. The latter collapse spectacularly and do indeed damage to surfaces. The former don't. [edit: clarified which articles I mean]
- app4soft 6y ago> introducing air bubbles into the stream along the hull Placing air bubbles into the stream along the iron/steel hull in seawater... This is the worst idea as it would drastically increase oxidation.[0] [0] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/es0109242 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/es0109242
- loriverkutya 6y agoLet’s forget about the thick layer of paint between the steel and the water...
- app4soft 6y ago> Let’s forget about the thick layer of paint between the steel and the water... If seawater oxidation around the boat would be increased then thick layer of paint should be thinned to prevent steel corrosion, which also means increasing cost of the boat.
- verroq 6y agoRelated: Propellor Boss Cap Fins https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a8PjWSeLUzY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a8PjWSeLUzY
- PicassoCTs 6y agoShips are already risky & expensive projects, and to modify them experimentally can have large follow up costs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galvanic_anode https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galvanic_anode
- Groxx 6y ago>Large ships with bulbous bows generally have twelve to fifteen percent better fuel efficiency than similar vessels without them. Wow, that's a much larger effect than I expected.
- kumarvvr 6y agoSeems like a clear cut and solid idea. Any ideas on why it is not in widespread use?
- jacobush 6y agoLess stuff grows under the ship, too.
- btrettel 6y agoA similar technology was examined in a class I took back in 2016. As I recall, the ultimate reason why this and similar technologies are not in use has nothing to do with whether the technology works or not. Apparently there is fairly little interest at present from the market for these technologies. That doesn't make a lot of sense to me (these technologies can clearly save a lot of money in the long run) but this is what I recall from the class. I'd speculate that the people with the power to implement the retrofits needed are skeptical of the benefits.
- worldsayshi 6y agoI've heard a story from someone working in naval logistics that they often ship loads of empty containers around the world (and back) just to avoid some contract clause that switch up the storage cost of idle containers after a few months. The incentive structures seem quite perverse.
- alimw 6y agoLooks like there's barely any tax on fuel for ships and planes. I guess it's tricky to raise such a tax unilaterally... "The extreme example of this price sensitivity was California’s 1991 decision to lift the fuel tax exemption and to tax interstate bunker fuel sales. Within a year, Californian bunker sales had collapsed as ships bunkered elsewhere especially Panama. The decision to impose a tax was reversed but California’s bunker business never recovered. " https://ec.europa.eu/clima/sites/clima/files/docs/0036/taxation_en.pdf https://ec.europa.eu/clima/sites/clima/files/docs/0036/taxat...
- 6y ago
- mrfusion 6y agoWould this work on a kayak? Anyone want to team up and try it?
- Kaibeezy 6y agoSeems like there would be a surface interface area versus propulsion force calc in there somewhere. Guessing the result wouldn’t be very significant for a tiny vessel.
- jcims 6y agoIt would likely have some effect but you'd have to pack and power the air supply. Might be something you could just do with compressed air and have a little foot pedal to turn it on when you want it.
- catherd 6y agoSome whitewater playboats have a concave chine that I was told makes bubbles that have this effect, but intended to make turning the boat easier. No idea if it was the bubbles that actually helped, but I've been in a boat that had them and it was noticeably easier than normal to spin it around. You can see the inverted chine here (the line running along the underside of the boat, at the edge of the flat bottom): https://825355.smushcdn.com/1645402/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/7-Embarrassing-Whitewater-Crafts4.jpg?lossy=0&strip=1&webp=1 https://825355.smushcdn.com/1645402/wp-content/uploads/2019/...
- TheRealPomax 6y agoYou want to haul an air compressor with you in a kayak? O_o
- Gravityloss 6y agoIt could be a foot pumped bellows. Release the bubbles when you really want to go fast...
- willvarfar 6y agoRussian high-speed torpedos have used super cavitation to envelop the torpedo in a steam of bubbles in order to go much faster: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercavitating_torpedo https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercavitating_torpedo It has trade offs for torpedos which is why the Russians and other nations continue to develop and deploy conventional designs.
- magicsmoke 6y agoAll the noise from the bubbles and rocket engine prevents the torpedo from listening to and tracking its target. Point, shoot, and hope the torpedo gets there before the target moves too far.
- TheRealPomax 6y agoYes, but torpedoes are meant to blow up after firing. Ships aren't. The torpedoes don't have to withstand 60 years of supercavitation damage (unlike ship propellers do, which already can't, and need frequent maintenance and replacement) (also this has nothing to do with supercavitation, it's just a regular bubbler at the bottom of the ship that lets air rush to the surface around the hull)
- hasperdi 6y agoI know some ships have them, including Diamond Princess, aka. The COVID-19 ship. Look for Mitsubishi Air Lubrication System, if you’re looking for more information
- Kaibeezy 6y agoAnyone know how this compares to the turbulent boundary layer “sharkskin” swimsuit concept that made a big splash at the Olympics a while back?
- samvher 6y agoOne is about turbulence (i.e. structure of the flow of the liquid) while the other actually relies on there being something other than liquid water in the flow (air or in the case of super cavitation vapor). Not sure if that answers your question - maybe you wanted to know about differences in performance (don’t know about that).
- gpsx 6y agoI'm not an expert but I can make an educated guess. They put dimples on golf balls to create turbulence, which gives less drag than laminar flow over the ball. I assume that is the same thing happening in the sharkskin swimsuit. For the ship hull I have another guess (sorry). In fluids, you can't reduce "friction" by having a "slipperier" surface. The rule is (for laminar flow) the speed of water at the surface, relative to the surface, is 0. That determines the velocity field around the object, which in turn determines the drag. My guess is that when the air is between the ship and the water, the air has 0 velocity at the surface of the ship. The air also has a 0 velocity relative to the water at that boundary. But the air has a velocity gradient so the net effect is that the surface of the water if now in motion relative to the ship, meaning the ship can cause a smaller velocity profile of the water.
- munchausen007 6y agoNot very good if you are operating echosounders.
- bufferoverflow 6y agoHydrofoils is another way. https://vimeo.com/358872215 https://vimeo.com/358872215
- dredmorbius 6y agoHydrofoiling most cargo vessels tends to be impractical. Bubble systems can (in theory) be applied to any existing design.
- Cactus2018 6y agoSpeaking of foils, there is active development in commercial and DIY personal electric foil boards. Check YouTube or a build forum like https://foil.zone/ https://foil.zone/
- Someone1234 6y agoHydrofoils cannot deal with rough weather/strong winds, what shipping routes is this practical for (where it is far enough to compete with air, but short enough to not have weather conditions)? Plus that video seemed very disingenuous, given the lack of hard data/facts and instead just vagueness on top of vagueness and a shiny demo. I wouldn't touch that company.
- JeremyPOsborne 6y agoJeremy here from that Boundary Layer Technologies. That company building hydrofoil cargo ships. Hydrofoils are not new and have been working for half a century in harsh weather conditions. Please look up the Pegasus class ships from the US navy. Technology has changed in the last 50 years which means we can greatly improve efficiency and practicality of foiling ships especially in the world of airfreight. Foiling vessels can be built to handle any weather condition of a buoyancy based ship. And because we're at sea for no more than 6 days we have a much greater weather prediction to avoid storm swells compared to a tradition ship who might be at see for more than 30 days and cannot go around the storm. For 99% of the time, the ocean is pretty flat so we can still have 99% on time delivery. LOL, I appreciate your words about vagueness. We have not been specific about how we will achieve our goals, but watch out of the coming months for a lot more details. I do love a good hater, it's a promising sign.
- waste_monk 6y agoI couldn't find anything solid to back it up (although admittedly I didn't search very hard), but apparently this also reduces fouling of the hull. >air lubrication can reduce fuel consumption by five to 10 percent I wonder if this is just the air lubrications system, or if it also includes gains from the reduced fouling? Either way, it's an interesting technology and assuming it works anywhere near as well as the marketing suggest I'd expect it will become a standard feature on larger vessels.
- bunje 6y agoI've analyzed performance data from air lubrication vessels with some retrofits included. Frankly, never witnessed over 5% gain. At specific velocity range the gain could be 5% on average if the installation has been really successful. They might be better nowadays.
- fredophile 6y agoI'd imagine fuel costs are a big part of the cost of running a ship. Wouldn't a 5% gain be something ship owners would jump at? I realize it would be lower once you account for the added cost of the system and you may not always get 5% but even a savings of 1-2% of a big number is still a big number.
- zimpenfish 6y ago> I'd imagine fuel costs are a big part of the cost of running a ship. "A 12% reduction in at-sea average speed, known as “slow steaming,” led to an average reduction of 27% in daily fuel consumption and thus fewer greenhouse-gas emissions." Slowing down sounds a lot easier and cheaper than retrofitting bulbous bows or fancy new air lubrication systems. https://qz.com/1608527/the-shipping-industrys-emissions-could-be-cut-by-slow-steaming/ https://qz.com/1608527/the-shipping-industrys-emissions-coul...
- rsfern 6y agoI agree with the conclusion, but daily fuel consumption isn’t the right thing to track. I think this comes out to a 17% reduction in fuel use per unit distance, which still seems quite significant, but maybe changes the trade off point a bit.
- scottbucks 6y agoReally interesting article! I wasn’t aware of this technology to be honest, but seems very promising...
- dzhiurgis 6y agoAt 50km/h electric foiling boat uses comparable power per mile to an electric car (well something like 2-3x). See Candella’s boats videos.
- speedgoose 6y agoIs the electric car driving at 50km/h too?
- dzhiurgis 6y agoDon’t think so
- highenergystar 6y agoI wonder whether a somewhat scrubbed exhaust could be piped into the bubble system.
- wayanon 6y agoThe think the new Sir David Attenborough polar research ship has this feature (though I may be getting confused with a different vessel, an icebreaker I might have seen described on YouTube) https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-54597767 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-54597767
- Balgair 6y agoAside: The Sir David Attenborough carries the Boaty McBoatface AUV. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boaty_McBoatface https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boaty_McBoatface
- Gravityloss 6y agoI think bubblers are just common in icebreakers in general. It's because you want to reduce the friction between the ship and ice.
- totierne2 6y agoTiny bubbles on the propellor? (Rather than the whole hull.)
- ergwwrt 6y agoPropeller Cavitation. Friction reduction saves money on the glide not the drive
- bigmattystyles 6y agoSlight tangent but this BBC4 documentary about bubbles was great https://vimeo.com/213299679 https://vimeo.com/213299679
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ergwwrt 6y agoA airplane's wings allows flight not because of a negative pressure over the foil but because of repulsive electromagnetic charges in the air below foil (same force that allows capillary upward movement of water in tree trunks). Can an electrocharged hull repel electrocharged bubbles?
- zupa-hu 6y agoSounds like these bubbles are like little balls the ship is rolling on? Super interesting!