4 ms·
>I think Apple brought this on themselves when they announced it would be faster than 98%[1] of the existing laptops on the market. They didn't caveat it with "
by Spooky23 6y ago
>I think Apple brought this on themselves when they announced it would be faster than 98%[1] of the existing laptops on the market. They didn't caveat it with "fanless laptops" or "laptops with 20hr of battery life", it's just supposedly faster than all but 2% of laptops you can buy today.
Exactly. It's a meaningless number.
They also conspicuously avoid posting any GHz information of any kind. My assumption is that it's a fine laptop, but a bullshit performance claim.
- matwood 6y agoWhat does ghz have to do with performance across chips? I’m reminded of the old days where AMD chips ran at a lower ghz and outperformed Intel chips running much faster. Intel had marketed that ghz === faster so AMD had to work to get around existing biases.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoEven Intel had to fight against it when they transitioned from the P4 designs to Core. They began releasing much lower clocked chips in the same product matrix and it took a while for people to finally accept that frequency is a poor metric for comparing across even the same company’s designs. And I think Apple also significantly contributed to this problem in the mid-late PPC days with “megahertz myth” marketing coupled with increasingly obvious misleading performance claims.
- crooked-v 6y ago> They also conspicuously avoid posting any GHz information of any kind Is that information actually of any real use when dealing with a machine with asymmetric cores plus various other bits on the chip dedicated to specific tasks [1]? [1]: https://images.anandtech.com/doci/16226/M1.png https://images.anandtech.com/doci/16226/M1.png
- bee_rider 6y agoIt is good to be skeptical of that "faster" and that 2% measurement, because there are lots of opportunities to make them ambiguous. But clock frequencies are hardly useful for comparisons between AMD and Intel. They'd be even more useless across architectures. Benchmarks are as good as it gets. Aggregate benchmarks used for marketing slides are less than ideal, but the problem with marketing is that it has to apply to everyone. Better workload focused benchmarks might come out later... In their defense most people won't look at these, because most people don't really stress their CPUs anyway.
- Spooky23 6y agoI agree, but it’s a weird measure to leave out when they advertise 16 “neural engine” cores. Understanding the clock difference between the low energy and performance cores might be an interesting comparator, for example.
- happymellon 6y ago> most people don't really stress their CPUs anyway. I find that Teams, Slack and VS Code running together stresses my 2019 Macbook Pro 16.
- theshrike79 6y ago> They also conspicuously avoid posting any GHz information of any kind. Comparing CPUs by GHz is like comparing cars by seeing which car can rev the hardest.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kllrnohj 6y agoThe frequency matters because it would give a far better insight into expected boost behavior & power consumption. For example when you look up the 15w i5-1035G1 and see 1ghz base, 3.6ghz boost, you can figure out that no, those geekbench results are not representative of the chip running at 15w. It's pulling way, way more because it's in the turbo window, and the gap between base & turbo is huuuuuge. So right now when Apple claims the M1 is 10w, we really have no context for that. Is it actually capped at 10w? Or is it 10w sustained like Intel's TDP measurements? How much faster is the M1 over the A14? How different is the M1's performance in the fanless Air vs. the fan MBP 13"? Frequency would give insights into most all of that. It's not useless.
- giantrobot 6y agoHere's the GeekBench scores for various iPhones [0] so you can answer for yourself. Here's the MacBook Air for comparison [1]. [0] https://browser.geekbench.com/ios_devices/iphone-12 https://browser.geekbench.com/ios_devices/iphone-12 [1] https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/4651056 https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/4651056
- adrian_b 6y agoThe GeekBench tests have revealed that the clock frequency of the M1 cores is 3.2 GHz, both in MB Air and in MB Pro. Therefore M1 succeeds to have a slightly higher single-thread performance (between 3% and 8%) than Intel Tiger Lake and AMD Zen 3 at only 2/3 of their clock frequency. The speed advantage of M1 in single-thread is not high enough to be noticeable in practice, but what counts is that reaching the same performance at high IPC and low frequency instead of low IPC and high frequency results in having the same performance as the competitors at a much lower power consumption. This is the real achievement of Apple and not the ridiculous claims about M1 being 3 times faster than obsolete and slow older products.
- giantrobot 6y agoThe clock speed of ARM chips that have big.LITTLE cores is not very meaningful. The LITTLE cores can run at lower frequencies than the big cores. The Apple A series (and M series I will say with some confidence) support heterogeneous operation so both sets of cores can be active at once. The big cores can also be powered off if there's no high priority/power tasks. The cores and frequency can scale up and down quickly so there's not a meaningful clock speed measure. The best number you'll get is the maximum frequency and that's still not useful for comparing ARM chips to x86. Even Intel's chips don't have frequency measures that are all that useful. Some workloads support TurboBoost but only within a certain thermal envelope. Even the max conventional clock for a chip is variable depending on thermals. I don't think it's worthwhile faulting Apple for not harping on the M series clock speeds since they're a vector instead of a scalar value.
- Spooky23 6y agoNobody is “faulting” Apple. They tend to avoid saying things for weird PR reasons. In this case, they make impressive sounding, but almost completely meaningless assertions about performance. If anything, they are underselling an impressive achievement. Intel does provide performance ranges in thermally constrained packages that are meaningful.
- quantummkv 6y agoGHz is also a fancy meaningless number that was spawned by Intel's marketing machine. The Ryzen 5000 chips cannot hit the 5GHz mark that Intel ones can, and yet the Ryzen 5000 chips thrashed the Intel ones in every benchmark done by everyone on youtube. And that's when both the chips are on the same x86 platform. Differences in architecture can never be compared or should be compared with GHz as any kind of basis. The only place where the GHz is useful for comparison is with products running the same chip
- headeffects 6y agoWhy is the clock speed relavant? Yes it lower than the highest end x86 chips, but the PPC is drastically higher. They don’t want clueless consumers thinking clock speed matters to performance.