8 ms·
In addition to this request, we have filed a separate Sensitive Data takedown request of this file: /widevine-l3-decryptor as it contains the secret Widevine RS
by userbinator 6y ago
In addition to this request, we have filed a separate Sensitive Data takedown request of this file: /widevine-l3-decryptor as it contains the secret Widevine RSA private key, which was extracted from the Widevine CDM and can be used in other circumvention technologies
They are practically asking for Streisand Effect... if you distribute your key with the software, then whatever form it is in, I would not consider it "private" at all!
- R0b0t1 6y agoThis is DeCSS all over again. Was that ever resolved? It seems to me the original DeCSS complaints were more or less dropped because technology moved on and they couldn't mount a defense in a real court, and had to rely on bluffing.
- freeone3000 6y agoCase was dropped by the DVD CCA in Norway because the number was no longer secret. That isn't relevant for section 1201 of the DMCA. It cares only if the program's intent was to bypass copy protection. DeCSS, and even libdvdcss, are absolutely infringing on this, and can't be hosted in USA repositories.
- akersten 6y agoHow is one supposed to exercise their right to Fair Use without "bypassing" technological measures via tools like these? I think there is solid legal DMCA ground for them to remain hosted in the US, without even needing to reach for the whole "freedom of speech" thing. I won't even get into how I think GitHub is being overly courteous to media companies by extending takedown ability for alleged Section 1201 violations. I'm firmly convinced the only remedy the DMCA offers for that is via the courts, and that the takedown process explicitly requires the identification of infringing material, not circumvention tools.
- roywiggins 6y agoFair use is about copyright. The DMCAs anti-circumvention section means you can't distribute software designed to circumvent DRM, even if that software isn't itself infringing. So I don't see how fair use could apply.
- akersten 6y agoAt a minimum, Google's counsel testified under penalty of perjury in this takedown letter that they took Fair Use into consideration, so there must be at least some application here. (And if there isn't, that sure is a strange sentence to have in the letter - almost as if they are misusing this takedown letter template after all!) Fair Use is about using copyrighted content, which is widely shackled behind DRM. Any court can easily see that in order to exercise your right to use that content in a Fair Use sort of way, you must break the DRM. Therefore, the existence and availability of DRM-breaking tools is a necessary condition for Fair Use to be exercised at all in conjunction with the modern media landscape.
- bawolff 6y agoDMCA does not include fair use as an allowable reason to circumvent DRM. That is one of the reasons why DRM sometimes shows up in weird places because it effectively limits fair use rights (see also all the right to repair stuff that people have been talking sbout lately) IANAL
- pbhjpbhj 6y ago>DMCA does not include fair use as an allowable reason to circumvent DRM. // Could you cite the law you're referring to here please? The UK CDPA as amended to follow the EU's Marrakech directive seems to say anything that prevents you from exercising your Fair Dealing rights to make content accessible for disabled people is void if it contradicts these rights. This seems necessarily to allow for circumvention of DRM (for people with disabilities and specific registered companies) but that also appears to mean production of circumvention means needs to be legal otherwise such accessibility will be impossible.
- R0b0t1 6y agoYou're wrong: You can break copy protection if you own the rights to a work. This means you can e.g. circumvent Window's license checking if you own a copy of it already. The DMCA does not criminalize that, nor could it, and this is probably why py-kms is still up on github after a copyright challenge. This was a change that I am assuming was added before any complaint could be mounted about this use case for fear of striking more of the DMCA down than just that provision that was modified.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tbodt 6y agoThe only difference between Widevine and DeCSS is you can rotate the Widevine key.
- kzrdude 6y agoThat should be a big difference. Have they made sure that all the netflix boxes out there support this?
- floatboth 6y agoBoxes are unlikely to use this key. The letter implies that this key is for the weakest (software-only) level of protection, used on generic PCs.
- kzrdude 6y agoWhat do smart tvs and tv boxes use?
- nyuszika7h 6y agoEach device usually has its own unique Widevine L1 keybox, with a separate intermediate key for each model.
- bawolff 6y agoCSS only used 40 bit keys to comply with US export controls, so with modern computers you can just bruteforce it without knowing the key, so the key is very much a moot point at this point.
- anthk 6y agoNot even modern, my athlon did that under 20 minutes, mplayer cached the key once it decrypted the DVDs.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoIt was "resolved" by new laws being introduced almost globally that make development, distribution etc. and potentially even possession of "circumvention devices" illegal, making it possible to do such takedown requests in most countries that provide infrastructure.
- ObsoleteNerd 6y agoTime for some DeCSS-style t-shirts/stickers again... maybe something like this[0]? ;) [0] https://imgur.com/a/ajKeDfp https://imgur.com/a/ajKeDfp
- cryptonek 6y agoJust in case someone is looking for editable version: https://pastebin.com/Rbj6nd3q https://pastebin.com/Rbj6nd3q
- Closi 6y agoIt would be great, although the real difference here is that the DeCSS key was almost impossible to change once it was leaked, while the Youtube key is comparatively trivial to change.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago42 ways to share code https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://decss.zoy.org https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http:/... Predates so-called "Streisand Effect"
- Hitton 6y agoI see that what you posted is on google's servers. Doesn't that mean they are effectively distributing it themselves?
- fnord123 6y ago> Predates so-called "Streisand Effect" DeCSS was released in 1999; Mecha Streisand episode of South Park was 1998.
- happymellon 6y agoWhat has South Park got to do with it? The "Streisand Effect" was because of Streisand suing a photographer in 2003 causing people to realise where she lived and getting photos of her house, and the phrase was coined in 2005 by Techdirt.
- fnord123 6y agoThere must be some kind of Mandela effect going on since I feel quite sure I was using this in 1998 after Streisand voiced distaste at the South Park episode.
- GauntletWizard 6y agoMecha-Streisand re-appeared in South Park’s 200th’s episode in 2010; Perhaps that’s what you were thinking of?
- Closi 6y agoIt's not an issue to them in this case, as presumably they can just change the key once the DMCA is successful and they have set precedent.
- kaszanka 6y ago"secret" when it's distributed with every installation of Google Chrome. This is your brain on DRM.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoSimilarly to the youtube-dl case. Maybe Google was indeed behind it ?
- shiado 6y agoI thought copyrights on numbers were deemed invalid? Copyright applies to data as it appears right? You can encode a number in any base, the idea that a company has copyright on every base encoding is equivalent to me saying I have copyright on every key because I wrote a program that enumerates all keys.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> I thought copyrights on numbers were deemed invalid? They are invalid. It's interesting since it implies copyright itself must be invalid. All intellectual property is data, information, a collection of bits... Also known as a number. Copyrighted works are actually just numbers. Really big numbers. Creators are just trying to discover those numbers through their labor.
- userbinator 6y agoIt also means such a program would be illegal, since it would also necessarily involve the creation of numbers that can be interpreted as truly illegal content.