4 ms·
Lots to unpack here: > It discourages exactly the kind of behavior it pretends to want to see Assuming cartoonish levels of bad faith and asserting a contradi
by refulgentis 6y ago
Lots to unpack here:
> It discourages exactly the kind of behavior it pretends to want to see
Assuming cartoonish levels of bad faith and asserting a contradiction in terms becomes the foundation for a lot of what follows
> Dads are disadvantaged in the same way Moms are, but then they're screwed over at work more (since expectations are set by articles like this one that it's the mom's duty).
As you noted above, the article advocates for the opposite of what you're asserting here.
> They're screwed over a third time in custody battles, when thanks to stereotypes like these, they will invariably get the short stick on custody. Best a Dad primary caretaker can hope for, unless the Mom is a drunk psychotic, is 50/50. Typical is Mom gets custody.
This simply isn't true, 2 of the 3 cases I know the dad got 80/20, primarily because he had a more stable situation, such as a full time job as a nurse, and/or owning a house.
> It's perfectly possible to write an article like this in neutral terms "primary caretaker," and point out the majority are women, and there's a disparate gender impact. It's an article about primary caretakers. By implying by correlation that it's 100% women, it does a ton of harm.
As you noted, you believe this was _implied_ - as a neutral reader, I'm not inclined to just agree with your assertion that it was implied, you actively threw away that opportunity by opening strong with the claim that the article is "pretending" to "want to see" things - you can intro people with a strong take, in fact, I need to do that more in my writing. But, you can't be three paragraphs in reasserting your strong claim, at this point we should have some discussion of evidence.
> As a footnote, that problem is pretty common. We don't have domestic violence laws. We have a "violence against women act." I'm not even sure how that's constitutional, but the result is that law enforcement ignores domestic violence against men.
You are asserting that the marketing name for one piece of legislation 24 years ago means that everyone only uses violence against women against preferring the general neutral. There's plenty of laws against "domestic violence" specifically, that's how it's referred to in law, and domestic violence is used _much_ more frequently - 22x as many, in fact.
> That's not to speak of the whole LGBTQ community, whom the author thinks it's okay to f- over by assuming a family is a husband and a wife.
All of your observations through this point were about how men are unfairly treated compared to women. This gives the reader absolute whiplash, because now you're claiming it's offensive to _talk about gender at all_ in relation to this.
- musingsole 6y ago> This simply isn't true, 2 of the 3 cases I know the dad got 80/20, primarily because he had a more stable situation, such as a full time job as a nurse, and/or owning a house. I like my refutations with sources.
- refulgentis 6y agoIt's extremely disproportionate to take a magnifying glass to evidence that _has_ to be anecdotal, by definition, when my interlocutor didn't even try including an anecdote. It's so disproportionate that I believe you're piling on bad-faith snark, not looking for me to post family court paperwork
- woofie11 6y agohttp://realworlddivorce.com/ http://realworlddivorce.com/ has in-depth state-by-state statistics, interviews with lawyers (who see many cases), and is incredibly well-researched. TL;DR: Dads very rarely get more than 50/50 custody in most states. If parents play equal roles, states range from 50/50, to primary custody to the Mom. For Mom to get less than 50/50, she's probably on drugs, in prison, or actively abusive, and even in some of those cases, Mom gets pretty significant custody.
- refulgentis 6y agoUnfortunately, I'm also familiar with real world divorce, and there's no universal claims like that in the text. I'm glad you've moved on to engaging on facts, can you point me to where on the site you found this data?
- woofie11 6y agoIt's all over. Here's an example: Massachusetts does not have a statutory presumption regarding physical custody following a trial, though lawyers told us that courts have strong biases. "The adage is that unless the woman has a hypodermic needle sticking out of her arm when she comes into the courtroom, she is getting sole physical custody and the father will be a visitor," said one attorney. Given the unofficial "mom wins" rule, it is surprising how many custody fights that there actually are. Part of the answer may be that the one-page official complaint form that is used to start divorce lawsuits has a checkbox to ask for sole legal and physical custody of minor children but no checkbox for seeking joint legal or physical custody. (The same one-page form that invites a divorce plaintiff also to start a custody lawsuit has a checkbox for starting a domestic violence lawsuit as well; the plaintiff can ask the judge to "prohibit defendant from imposing any restraint on plaintiff's personal liberty," i.e., issue a restraining order against the defendant.) To see if the attorneys we contacted were exaggerating and/or if the bias towards sole custody indicated by the official state form did not reflect outcomes, we hired an attorney to pull and analyze all of the cases for one judge, Maureen Monks in Middlesex County, for 2009, 2010, and 2011 (approximately 350 cases per year, though not all of them involved disputed custody). Judge Monks awarded custody via temporary order to the mother in nearly all of the cases examined except for one case where the mother was a drug addict and another where the mother was in a mental hospital (and as soon as the mother was released from the mental hospital, Judge Monks awarded custody of the children back to her). During the three-year study period no father was successful in going to trial and obtaining a 50/50 shared physical custody situation from Judge Monks in the cases that our attorney-analyst examined. Our attorney-analyst for the May 2011 study concluded that one plaintiff mother was "objectively unfit" due to alcoholism; Judge Monks awarded her sole physical custody of three children. The record of Judge Monks is consistent with March 2014 U.S. Census Current Population Survey data suggesting that over 90 percent of custody lawsuits in Massachusetts are won by women (Census data doesn't track the lawsuits themselves, but shared parenting is uncommon in Massachusetts and the Census found that 97 percent of the Massachusetts residents collecting child support are women). This is consistent with our May 2011 analysis, which found that roughly 91 percent of the "primary parent" winners were women and only 7.5 percent of children were assigned to shared parenting. source: http://www.realworlddivorce.com/Massachusetts http://www.realworlddivorce.com/Massachusetts