8 ms·
After botched child porn raid, judge sees the light on IP addresses
- pilom 16y agoTime to invest in a DD-WRT router to be sure there aren't any backdoors for ARP requests to map IP addresses to physical hardware.
- blhack 16y agoYou should elaborate on that so other people reading the discussion can get an idea what you're talking about.
- ramidarigaz 16y agoMy understanding is that proprietary router firmware may have unknown vulnerabilities that someone could use to discover the MAC addresses of computers making specific requests. That would allow, for instance, law enforcement to tie internet usage to specific computers. DD-WRT and other open source firmware should be a little more secure in this regard. The open source firmware out there is definitely more reliable over long periods of time than the stock firmware that comes on most routers, so I assume it's also more secure.
- pilom 16y agoCouldn't have said it better myself.
- yid 16y agoMAC addresses can be easily spoofed. For example, on some ethernet cards: sudo ifconfig eth0 hw ether 00:12:34:56:78:9A will change your hardware address.
- zcid 16y agoTrue but if your MAC just happened to match a MAC the litigating attorney had on file due to the exploits which ChuckMcM is referring, it would be much more difficult to claim innocence as you can do with a shared IP. MAC spoofing would only be relevant if you were regularly using random spoofed MACs on your own network.
- sigil 16y ago> MAC spoofing would only be relevant if you were regularly using random spoofed MACs on your own network. Or, if for some reason that practice was widespread enough that it provided plausible deniability.
- holdenk 16y agoThe case for MAC spoofing being common (at least with people "borrowing" your wi-fi) makes sense because some networks have MAC address based white lists, so this defense isn't quite as crazy as it sounds at first. IANAL etc.
- yid 16y agoNot necessary -- someone could spoof their MAC to match mine. IMO, this is more likely when there is already malicious intent, and it's almost trivial to do.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- epochwolf 16y agoI've used spoofing frequently on a local college's campus to get around blocks they've put on my system. Apparently some of the student use Ethernet jacks aren't for student use.
- sigil 16y agoYup. I've actually used this, to work around certain cable modems that only allow the mac address they were set up from.
- JonnieCache 16y agoJust use the DD-WRT feature that lets you have 2 APs, one encrypted and one open. Connect all your kit to the private one, and limit the outgoing bandwidth of the open one. This should surely give both security and plausible deniability?
- pilom 16y agoThey still break down your door though.
- zerosanity 16y agoAbout time. Identifying people by IP address is like identifying people that live in a certain house. A house can have many people living in it. It's not a one-to-one mapping.
- tzs 16y agoThe law already knows how to deal with that. It's called a search warrant. When many people are living in a house, and you have sufficient reason to believe that one of them has committed a crime, you can get a search warrant to do search the house. The case at hand is a civil case, where the option of a search warrant is not available. If it were a child porn case, the police would still be able to get a warrant to search the house where the IP address is assigned.
- ataggart 16y agoIt's not clear to me that armed men busting down people's doors at 3am is a preferable model.
- zcid 16y agoThat's exactly what this could be the precedent to prevent. The mistaken pornographer case showed that an IP is not necessarily evidence enough for a warrant, esp. a no-knock warrant. It will quite possibly lead to requiring more evidence than just an IP in the future.
- wtallis 16y agoNot all search warrants are no-knock warrants.
- varikin 16y agoI think is the right idea. An IP address is a piece in the puzzle of evidence. By itself, it should not be enough to prove guilt, but it might be enough for a search warrant. I hope is that as time goes on, the legal system (and hopefully all parts of the government) better learn how technologies work and don't work so they can make more informed decisions. Hopefully, as the younger generation start their careers in those fields, they bring better understanding of technologies with them. Though there is another article I read today that is an anecdotal story about someone my age that doesn't know difference between a web browser and search engine. After writing all this, it reminded me of a friend. He is now an IT manager and his wife is a lawyer (currently a judge's assistant I think). They were talking a couple years ago about the lack of credible expert witnesses in the IT field. She had seen that they are not staying current in the IT field, similarly what can happen with conference speakers. They spend all their time talking about technologies while not having the time to gain a deep knowledge of new technologies. I seem to taken a tangent towards the end (or maybe the beginning), but oh well.
- viraptor 16y ago> One obvious takeaway: letting total strangers use your Internet connection for any purpose comes with some risk. Really? My takeaway is: allow open access to anyone, but limit the bandwidth. This way nothing can be proven about my actions. (could be anyone) It actually reduces the risk for me if IP is not identifying people anymore.
- falcolas 16y agoIt's a great defense during a trial, but the cost would likely be associated with being arrested, loosing computer hardware to the local officers for an unknown amount of time, and the potential cost of mounting a legal defense in the first place.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- crikli 16y agoI've always wanted to mount a big electromagnet in my doorframe like in Cryptonomicon. The main reason I haven't is that there is a 100% chance I'd forget to deactivate it and fry my own hardware. Probably within a week of installing the magnet.
- maayank 16y agospoiler :( edit: the comment has its place, but I can only assume that an alert at the beginning would be highly appreciated by many.
- msg 16y agoWhat is the statute of limitations on spoiling? That is a twelve year old book. Serious question.
- Unseelie 16y agoChildren keep coming of age for specific media..I only read it last year. My dad read it this winter, my brother will probably read it this summer... I'd argue the statute of limitations on spoiling should be the same as murder. Not to suggest its quite as serious
- chopsueyar 16y agoThis is optimistic.
- ChuckMcM 16y ago"Steele's request was denied until he can name at least one specific person in the case over whom the court has personal jurisdiction—though it's not clear he can do this at all without going to the ISPs for help. But the judge doesn't care about Steele's problems." This is the correct result. I hope it is more broadly adopted by the courts. At the moment these seem primarily driven by legal firms using extortion as a business model, we should shut that down first and then go back to working through the issues of fair use and copyright.
- grellas 16y agoThe courts have long recognized that one can sue someone whose name is not known at the time of filing the action and then use the court's subpoena power to find out the person's name through an ISP. This practice has been in place since ISPs came into existence and it makes sense for the situation for which it was devised. The problem here is that the mass-infringement actions have twisted this otherwise legitimate process into something warped and grossly unfair by using the name-gathering process to target people who are then told, "pay up or you will be exposed as a downloader of porn" (or, in other cases, you will be subjected to a major infringement lawsuit that is not worth defending). Federal judges have enormous power and this judge (and many others) have simply said, "I won't let my court be used as an instrument for a shakedown," using legal niceties about jurisdiction to justify the matter formally. In effect, they are tossing the mass-infringement lawyers out the door, telling them their model won't work in their court. This is indeed the right outcome for this sort of abuse.
- roel_v 16y agoOK, so the alternative is that John Doe's get subpoena'd, and without room for settlement, a civil suit will be brought. How exactly is this better?
- tlrobinson 16y agoSo how long until we see legislation that a) makes open AP owners liable / accomplices in crimes committed on open APs b) requires open APs authenticate and log all user activity c) outright bans open APs?
- darklajid 16y agoWelcome to Germany, where this is already the case..
- roel_v 16y agoOf course, as it should be. When one speeds in a car, the owner of the car is liable for the ticket, no matter who the driver. When a dog bites somebody, the owner is liable, even when the owner could do nothing to prevent it. When a tile falls off a roof one somebodies head, the owner of the building is liable, even if he didn't know, had no reasons to suspect of even had no way to know that a tile could come off. All these situations are so-called risk-liabilities. How else would we solve situations like this?
- mustpax 16y agoNo, the owner of the car is not always liable for the ticket. Car rental companies will not pay fines you accrue just because they are the legal owners of the car. The dog ownership analogy has even less merit. A dog is not a sane person in the eyes of the law so as a guardian you are responsible for keeping your dog in line. On the other hand, a person who is using your WiFi for whatever illicit purposes is responsible for their own actions.
- roel_v 16y ago...because when you sign the car rental agreement, you agree to pay back any fines. Whoever cashes these fines will get their money from the rental agency, and they will then get it from you (or sue you for breach of contract if you don't pay them). I was not saying that the dog did anything consciously. The point is that there is a class of liabilities that do no depend on being 'factually responsible' for something. You can have no power whatsoever to prevent something, and still be liable for it. That makes the case for this wireless network even stronger - there is something you can do as an owner. You can take reasonable measures to stop others from using it. It makes perfect sense to hold people responsible for enabling the improper use by others. (note also that I'm not claiming that somebody who has an open access point will be jailed for child pornography; what I'm saying is that there is a very reasonable case to be made for holding people accountable for not taking proper care of their property (wifi network) that will enable others to use it illicitly).
- gtank 16y agoI'm surprised that IP address mappings still have the kind of legal weight that authorizes raids. Anyone can acquire a deniable IP by walking down the street to Starbucks (better yet, drive 15 minutes) or pointing a Pringles can at a distant neighbor. I assume anyone taking part in criminal content or actions on the internet would know this.
- nooneelse 16y agoPerhaps more judges would see this light were they the ones behind such ambiguous IP addresses. Surely some judges have open wireless networks at home. Would it be illegal to put a computer in range of a judge's house, have it search for child porn, and pipe anything it downloads straight to /dev/null so that it isn't actually stored?
- buckwild 16y agoI'm no networking expert, but don't they also note the mac addresses and generally use DHCP for open wifi? If so, they could totally identify folks with that info...
- steevdave 16y agoMost expire the mapping within a few days although AT&T Uverse routers default to ~30 days. Personally due to the fact that I tend to set up a lot of machines and want them available by hostname I set mine to ~30 minutes.
- andrewcooke 16y agothey don't have your mac address in most situations; they have the mac address of the router, which is not the same thing. hence the discussion above about being careful to avoid a router that might leak this information in some other way. dhcp gives addresses to the computers connected to the wifi. but those addresses are only used on the "user" side of the router. packets going out from the router to the internet do not contain those addresses (nor do they contain each user's mac address). as far as the rest of the internet goes, there's a single address, with multiple ports, which is your router. the nat (network address translation) in your router maps from the port used to the local mac/ip (dhcp) address. so someone "outside" does not know, without additional information, which user of the wifi is making a particular connection. hence this story.
- IgorPartola 16y agoI wonder how IPv6 adoption is going to affect this. NAT is still available under IPv6, but most won't use it and your MAC is by default a part of your address.