4 ms·
> Greenpeace's comment is pretty disappointing. But completely unsurprising. Greenpeace pivoted from an anti-military nuclear to an anti-civilian nuclear stanc
by masklinn 6y ago
> Greenpeace's comment is pretty disappointing.
But completely unsurprising. Greenpeace pivoted from an anti-military nuclear to an anti-civilian nuclear stance to try and remain relevant, they've been a negative force in the world ever since.
They've been raising awareness about AGW while actively fighting one of the best tools to mitigate it for more than 30 years.
- gmac 6y agoDon't mention nuclear on HN if you value your karma ... but in the UK, at least, civilian and military nuclear have never really been independent. See, for example, the UK government's otherwise incomprehensible willingness to pay extraordinary sums for new nuclear capacity such as Hinkley C[1]: "it is difficult fully to comprehend the persistent intensity of official UK attachments to nuclear power, without also considering aims to maintain nuclear submarine capabilities". [2] [1] https://www.theguardian.com/news/2017/dec/21/hinkley-point-c-dreadful-deal-behind-worlds-most-expensive-power-plant https://www.theguardian.com/news/2017/dec/21/hinkley-point-c... [2] https://www.sussex.ac.uk/webteam/gateway/file.php?name=2016-16-swps-cox-et-al.pdf&site=25 https://www.sussex.ac.uk/webteam/gateway/file.php?name=2016-...
- masklinn 6y ago> Don't mention nuclear on HN if you value your karma ... but in the UK, at least, civilian and military nuclear have never really been independent. By "military nuclear" what is meant is mostly "nuclear arsenal". Hence the peace part of Greenpeace.
- fuoqi 6y agoI don't think the military angle plays a big role in the British case. Hinkley C uses mostly foreign technologies and expertise, not domestic one. There were even talks about building a plant using Chinese technologies! Also submarine and power plant reactors are two very different beasts, so building the latter does not help much with maintaining expertise for the former. Plus Britain is quite dependent on the US help to maintain its nuclear capabilities. But I think it's true for Russia, maintaining full nuclear cycle does help with supporting its military nuclear capabilities. Thus the substantial political support which the industry gets there. For example the floating plant [0] is based on reactors used in icebreakers, which in turn have roots in submarine reactors. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_floating_nuclear_power_station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_floating_nuclear_power...
- sgt101 6y agoI think that doesn't explain Hinkley, but it does explain the Rolls Royce initiative. These modular nukes are much more like the zip it up and leave it for 25 year nuclear powerplants that they make for subs.
- Arnt 6y ago"One of the best" assumes that nuclear power generators are competently run and fuel competently disposed of. Which organisations do you trust more to be more competent than the Japanese (Fukushima) and Germans (who ditched unknown, unrecorded, probably large quantities of nuclear waste in an incompletely built facility)? We have better, anyway. The combination of wind, power, burning things that have grown in our lifetime and time-shifting power usage seems to be good enough AFAICT. By the latter I mean that a lot of big power users don't really need to run all the time. A company like BMW needs a lot of electricity to produce a car, but the factories are built with capacity to spare (building extra capacity while building is cheaper than adding if a car sells well) and most the power-hungry bits can be shut down for a while if the power grid really needs it. Unless a car model is really, really popular and the factory runs at full capacity, but in the case competing factories don't.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI think this is a pipe-dream. There is no energy grid anywhere in the world t1hat has ever run only on intermittent power sources. As for the hypothetical BMW factory, what are the workers meant to do while the power is low? You have to be honest that cost of such setup would be significantly higher because you need huge amount of storage, or large overcapacity, or both. Lastly, zero people died from radiation at Fukushima - the tsunami killed 15,000. Why is anyone surprised that a natural disaster can damage a building? Do we have tsunamis in UK and Germany? The story is completely overblown.
- telchar 6y ago150 years ago there was no energy grid anywhere in the world. We've come a long way since then. You seem really confident that a renewable grid will never happen. Do you have credible projections on storage and deployment costs that indicate asymptotic bounds on cost that are above the cost of similar projections for comparable nuclear?
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI am not saying it won't happen. You are free to argue we should be paying more for energy so its sustainable, but unless you are going to bring some serious evidence you can't just claim the problem is easilly sorted and wind + solar grid would be cheaper than nuclear. Current and projected cost of storage is relatively high, the most cost efficient storage is hydro and compressed air, they are not showing any kind of fast decrease in cost. Maybe there is potential in energy grids that span continents and have large over-capacity - then you dont need much storage. I am assuming we are talking about imminent future, in 50 years maybe math is different, but thats too late for climate change.