5 ms·
I recently watched an interesting talk[1] about the NANOGrav project which looks for extremely low-frequency gravitational waves. The sources for these would be
by magicalhippo 6y ago
I recently watched an interesting talk[1] about the NANOGrav project which looks for extremely low-frequency gravitational waves. The sources for these would be super-massive binary black holes, unlike the compact binaries ("regular" black holes and neutrons) that LIGO can observe.
They use radio telescopes to look for disturbances in the timing of millisecond pulsars due to gravitational waves, and they get about half of their data from Arecibo.
The project has been going for almost 15 years and they had just begun to see interesting stuff in their data. As the the project relies on continuous measurements of the pulsars, in order to detect variations in their timing, the presenter mentioned that more than six months of downtime would have a significant impact on the quality of their their overall data, and as mentioned on their page[2] many of the pulsars can only be measured by the Arecibo telescope due to its sensitivity.
[1]: http://pirsa.org/20100068/ http://pirsa.org/20100068/
[2]: http://nanograv.org/announcement/2020/08/20/Arecibo.html http://nanograv.org/announcement/2020/08/20/Arecibo.html
- toomuchtodo 6y agoObservatories come and observatories go [1]. It would be logical to have a transition plan to migrate science projects as old observatories are decommissioned and new ones turned up. Arecibo could go dark tomorrow due to disrepair (antenna assembly fails entirely, and 900 tons of suspended gear is going to do some serious damage upon failure) and the cost to repair and recommission is greater than available funds from UCF and NSF. Edit: dredmorbius mentions in a comment below China has built a better observatory for this type of science [2]. Retask remaining science to other assets, decommission Arecibo. [1] https://www.nsf.gov/news/special_reports/astronomy/facilities.jsp https://www.nsf.gov/news/special_reports/astronomy/facilitie... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25046772 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25046772
- sitkack 6y agoCould we have a building that is both a sports field and a device for doing cosmology? I would call it, "The Astro Dome"
- toomuchtodo 6y agoDo you need a building? Fully fund science, of course, but kill outdated platforms when resources can go to newer projects. I am very much in the support of science spend, but also very much for the efficient use of science dollars available. https://www.leolabs.space/radars/ https://www.leolabs.space/radars/ (private org operating a global network of phased array radar for space debris monitoring) https://public.nrao.edu/telescopes/vlba/ https://public.nrao.edu/telescopes/vlba/ (global network of rf observatories operating in concert) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_space_telescopes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_space_telescopes (space observatories)
- magicalhippo 6y agoNot a radio telescope like this, you want those in the middle of nowhere where there's as little stray radio signals as possible. The city next to Green Bank telescope, the other major telescope for NANOGrav, has banned[1] cell phones and similar in order for the telescope to not be drowned in noise. [1]: https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2015/07/us/quiet-town-american-story/ https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2015/07/us/quiet-town-am...
- magicalhippo 6y agoSure, though in this case the whole point of the study is to observe the same pulsars over a very long period of time, so switching observatories can be tricky. Does FAST cover most of the same pulsars Arecibo does?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mmoche 6y agoI am confused as to why "repair the thing before it catastrophically fails" is not the best of the available options. Decommissioning a facility like this is a loss for science globally, even if there are alternatives available. Telescope time is precious.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoYou would have to dig into who is providing funding and how the funds are being spent by UCF, Universidad Ana G. Méndez, and Yang Enterprises Inc (the loose consortium tasked with O&M of the facility). See the latest update on https://www.ucf.edu/news/update-on-arecibo-observatory-facility-after-telescope-damage/# https://www.ucf.edu/news/update-on-arecibo-observatory-facil.... Just a month ago, cable sag surveys and safety assessments were done, and a structural monitoring instrumentation system was installed. I'd be curious what those reports show, and if this most recent failure was anticipated. If it wasn't expected, what was the value of the work last month?
- gambiting 6y agoI'm not saying that he should, everyone can spend their money as they wish, but just as a fun thought exercise, could a private, extremely wealthy entity do it? Say, could Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk just say "yep, I'll pay for all the repairs from my own pocket"?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoAbsolutely, but then they should assume control of operations to ensure a tight ship is run. If efficient use of funds is demonstrated, further funding (whether private, public, or crowdsourced) should follow. You don't want to encourage mismanagement of limited funds. Edit: Upon further thought, I think it's an exceptional idea that SpaceX submit itself as an O&M vendor for NSF (and perhaps even NASA) RF/observatory facilities. Between launches and StarLink, they have demonstrated lean execution. @ISL: Your point is noted, but SpaceX has a $50-100 billion valuation, access to capital markets, and StarLink is likely to be very profitable. I don't think it's fair to paint them to be in financial peril as they were during their earlier years. UCF's entire budget is $2 billion, and they can't scrap together a few millions dollars to properly care for Arecibo. UCF and SpaceX have each demonstrated their level of capability.
- leephillips 6y agoArecibo is more important than the data it collects. If you are born on the island, it is perhaps the most conspicuous and inspiring scientific installation there. It’s a fascinating place to visit, beautiful and iconic. Its loss would be a loss for the children and aspiring scientists of Puerto Rico.
- rovr138 6y agoI was very interested in astronomy as a kid. I remember my mom taking me to visit the observatory as a kid. Somehow she got in contact with people there and I was able to tour other places. While now I’m just a developer, it definitely sparked my curiosity and my like for science. I have very fond memories of it.
- kitd 6y ago... the presenter mentioned that more than six months of downtime would have a significant impact on the quality of their their overall data Worse than that, the article mentions this telescope is one of the few that can emit radar and is used to track nearby asteroids. That function will need replacing too.
- Frost1x 6y agoI worked with some astrophysicists awhile back looking at these pulsar timing arrays[1] using Arecibo and Greenbank as data sources. Pretty fascinating stuff how you can identify strategic pulsars with desired frequencies and at positions where you can detect certain ranges of gravitational waves (typically super massive blackhole mergers). Prior to LIGO's detections, they were hoping to be the first to detect and confirm the existence of gravitational waves but LIGO beat them to the punch. They were already concerned about defunding of efforts in radio astronomy and fighting to keep some of this hardware operational. These Arecibo hits are probably not a great addition. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulsar_timing_array https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulsar_timing_array