5 ms·
If Zoom made clear to users that connections were not secured to the same standards as competitors, and that potentially hundreds of employees could be silently
by londons_explore 6y ago
If Zoom made clear to users that connections were not secured to the same standards as competitors, and that potentially hundreds of employees could be silently listening in on any call, I think that would have prevented them becoming a leader in video conference tech.
So the right fine here is their entire market cap. That would put them back at square one, which is where an honest competitor would be right now.
- me_me_me 6y agoSure, that sounds like fair solution. But that's not how capitalism works. You can be honest business or you can steal billions, get caught and pay a millions in fines. I think everyone can see a problem here. You pay back less then you stole so this is an active encouragement to steal. Most recent example, morgan stanley fraud for bilions in profit pays fine of 1.5 mil [0]. Reality is borrowing from Kafka. [0] https://coinweek.com/bullion-report/morgan-stanley-mitsubishi-to-pay-almost-2-million-for-spoofing-precious-metals-futures/ https://coinweek.com/bullion-report/morgan-stanley-mitsubish...
- amelius 6y agoTotally agree, and this should hold for any kind of illegal growth hacking.
- johannes1234321 6y agoIs it really different from competitors like Cisco (webex, jabber, ...)? A big selling point of all those is phone dial in which can't be done with e2e encryption (the phone gateway run by the operator has to have the keys)
- thesimon 6y agoThe thing is: Our team doesn't use phone dial-in, haven't even seen the feature so I guess it's not enabled, but still we don't have e2e encryption. That doesn't make sense.
- johannes1234321 6y agoNo doubt their, but GP refered to competitors and in that segment e2e is rare.
- user5994461 6y agoPhone dial-in is always a paid addon. I guess it's the same on Zoom and your company doesn't pay for it.
- eddieoz 6y agoSome reports say the whole video conferencing market, being very optimistic, will reach $50B in 2026 (considering Covid-19 - https://www.gminsights.com/industry-analysis/video-conferencing-market https://www.gminsights.com/industry-analysis/video-conferenc...) But Zoom, alone, already has a marketcap of $117.534B (https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/ZM/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/ZM/) I really think there is an unsustainable distortion happening.
- clusterfish 6y agoWild optimism aside, you can sell one or even a thousand ZM shares at approximately the current market price, but you can't sell the entirety of the company at the same price. The pool of buyers is much smaller for such volumes.
- newh90 6y agoI don't really think so. I think we are just moving away from inefficient meetings that are IRL. I would love to see all meetings go remote for many reasons. I think this will stay even once Covid is gone.
- user5994461 6y agoThe market being $50B means there are $50B of sales to do per year. Market cap is a multiplier of revenues, easily 10 or 20 for a tech company, that means a $1T market cap to be taken across the videoconference companies. Wondering how numbers can be so high? Count $10 per month * 12 months in a year * 100 million employees in the US... that is $12B per year going to video software!
- vitus 6y agoActually, price / earnings (P/E ratio) is typically 10-20 for _any_ company in the S&P 500. When you look at big tech, the numbers are drastically higher: - AMZN: 92 - GOOG: 34 - FB: 33 - NFLX: 76 - AAPL: 35 - MSFT: 35 Compare this to, say, 3M, at 19, or GM with 17. edit: incidentally, apparently Zoom's P/E is... 527, which is grossly inflated even for a tech company. Tesla is also in the same category with a P/E of 834.
- velcro 6y agoNot defending them in any way - but don't think security was the primary reason for Zoom taking off. It was stability - it just worked and at the same time competitors didn't. Everybody used to have Skype and I would have gladly handed over my data to MS if only it would have been able to do stable video calls. It was often a disaster for just 2-way calls, let alone group.
- vaccinator 6y agoSkype was better before the MS aquisition... and it used to be P2P. It'd be nice if the pre-MS source would leak somehow.
- DangerousPie 6y agoI think you may be viewing history through slightly rose-tinted glasses there - I used pre-MS Skype a lot and it was never anywhere near as reliable as Zoom is and didn't support group video chat at all. And the fact that it was P2P meant that some features that everyone would expect to work these days (offline messages, mobile support) were simply not possible at all.
- vaccinator 6y agoOr maybe your long term memory is corrupted?
- sunshinerag 6y agoAmen
- michaelmior 6y agoI'm not sure what would be accomplished if the source leaked. Someone would still need to maintain both the client and now a new set of servers. This would be difficult given that Microsoft would almost certainly use whatever means they could to stop this from happening.
- 6y ago
- viraptor 6y agoI wish that was true, but in practice I think it wouldn't matter. Zoom was the only one ready with infrastructure, multiple clients, automatic quality adjustment, screen sharing options, scheduling, and many other needed features. Otherwise we had hangouts/meet with very basic features and jet-taking-off Mac behaviour, chime which is really good but nobody heard of it (Amazon is not interested in that market apparently), Skype which aims for social chat consumers, slack which works only within the org, jitsi, and a thousand of me-too apps with very basic feature set. Zoom could kick your puppy at the end of each call, and it would likely still be the best choice at the time :-(
- newh90 6y agoSure, if you don't worry about privacy.
- jcims 6y agoYou can care about privacy yet still prioritize not killing your company in a pandemic. Very few things that are hosted are immune to employee buggery, that’s why companies invest in third party risk management; to assess those risks, which are always material and non-zero and determine if they are within the appetite of the organization.
- newh90 6y agotrue. one could just use onsite or p2p tech that avoids using servers beyond handshakes.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago"chime which is really good but nobody heard of it" So there was a competitor after all?
- viraptor 6y agoAmazon doesn't seem interested in that app being used by random consumers. There's very few accessible guides around it. It's technically good, but it's not even a competitor as such.
- sriku 6y agoIs this about the audio streams? I imagine that if at any time there are a million video streams happening, and zoom wanted to sneak into 1% of them, it would pretty much need 10000 vCPUs of compute to do that? The current tech scales affordably because only the encoded packets get transmitted between callers (via "selective forwarding units") without needing server-side re-encoding? edit: That was for video streams. For audio streams, certainly the cpus cost is lower - about 10%.
- cheschire 6y agoThe processing doesn't need to happen live. Bitstreams can be captured along with metadata for later searching, a la xkeyscore.
- pjc50 6y agoI don't think people would be calling for this level of punitive fines if Zoom were a Silicon Valley company making misleading claims.
- fakedang 6y agoFun fact, Zoom is a Silicon Valley company making misleading claims. It was started in California originally, not China.
- Spooky23 6y agoTheir competitors were using the same standard of security. FaceTime is the big E2E service. Most anything else allows dial in, and is not E2E. Zoom’s sin is bad marketing copy.
- jefftk 6y ago> the right fine here is their entire market cap. That would put them back at square one I don't think Zoom has transgressed anywhere nearly this badly, but even if I did it doesn't make sense to fine any company their entire value unless your goal is simply to destroy them. The company is only worth as much as it is because it is expected to continue as a company, and there would be no way for it to continue if it owed that much money to the government. Unless it was nationalized and run by the government, but I doubt you're proposing that? Which means instead the company liquidates, and its liquidation value is far less than it's value as a business.
- londons_explore 6y agoA good punishment is government nationalizes it, paying shareholders nothing, then immediately sells those shares back onto the public markets. The government would earn close-ish to the market cap. Effectively, allow the company to continue as before, but wipe out all shareholders. After all, they are the people who allowed this behaviour. They are the ultimate decision makers.
- yepguy 6y agoNo, abandoning property rights is not even close to an appropriate punishment, even for those directly responsible for the fraud, let alone for ignorant shareholders.
- ForHackernews 6y agoI don't think anyone except crypto-nerds cares about this. Normal people just assume everything can be wiretapped and Zuckerberg and friends are always listening.
- jrochkind1 6y ago> If Zoom made clear to users that connections were not secured to the same standards as competitors… Which competitors offered true E2E? I think mostly they were (misleadingly/lyingly) promissing something above what most of their competitors offered, no?