4 ms·
Buying one. Citizenship is something that ought to be earned and given to people who show that they want to live in and contribute to a country. People like Sch
by Barrin92 6y ago
Buying one. Citizenship is something that ought to be earned and given to people who show that they want to live in and contribute to a country. People like Schmidt purchase themselves a tax excemption or freedom of movement in a world where ordinary people right now lose their jobs and are locked into their country.
- FDSGSG 6y agoThis feels like suggesting that it's immoral to buy a car because someone else might not be able to. >People like Schmidt purchase themselves [...] freedom of movement This is not immoral. >where ordinary people [...] are locked into their country This is
- esarbe 6y agoNo. Buying a car is not necessarily parasitic behavior. Bailing on your taxes is.
- eatmyshorts 6y agoAmerican citizens living and working abroad still must pay taxes to the US Government. As far as I am aware, the US is the only country in the world with this requirement. There is a reason the FBAR requirement is often called the "fubar" requirement.
- prewett 6y agoYou get a pretty high exemption for salary earned abroad if you paid local taxes on it and the country has a tax agreement with the US, which most do. You're still taxed on income earned within the US normally, but it seems reasonable that if you earned income from rent from a US property, or received dividends from a US company, that you should pay taxes on it even if you are not in the country.
- eatmyshorts 6y agoYou are taxed on income you make abroad, even if you never set foot in the country. I'm not talking about capital gains. I'm talking about income. Yes, up to a certain amount, you can deduct dollar-for-dollar taxes paid in the foreign country, but you are still taxed on that income. It's the only country in the world that does this. Because of this, among other bits, I do not think it is reasonable.
- nso 6y agoNorway has the same.
- Semaphor 6y agoLooking it up, it has the same rule as Germany: If your "center of life" is in Norway (roughly: spending more than 6 months out of a year there), then you have to pay your taxes. That is not what the US does which is "We don’t care what you do and where you live, if you have citizenship you better file your taxes"
- lb1lf 6y agoNo, we don't. If you spend more than half the year in Norway, you are considered a resident for tax purposes, and chances are you will have to pay some tax. However, income is not subject to double taxation; if you've already paid taxes in another jurisdiction, Norwegian authorities are not going to tax the same income again. As opposed to the US.
- eins1234 6y ago
- kylebenzle 6y agoHow can you argue that Eric hasn't "earned" citizenship anywhere he wants. I have a buddy from India who has worked hard in the tech industry and is applying for US citizenship and I hope he gets it. Its not like he just inherited his wealth and is now skipping out ASAP.
- 1024core 6y agoAs long as he remains a USC, he will have to pay US tax. Don't get me wrong: I don't like the idea of buying a citizenship at all. But this won't let him escape taxes, if you think that was his intention.
- coliveira 6y agoFor someone like Eric S., it must be very easy to get a new citizenship, and this will help him to setup some of the schemes that, while legal, will allow him to evade billions of dollars in taxes over his lifetime. I believe this is just a way to simplify his tax dodging schemes.
- ryanlol 6y agoCan you give an example of a scheme that this might help him set up? I believe that there are none, unless he pays a significant exit tax to give up his US citizenship.
- coliveira 6y agoThere are all kinds of schemes, but the main vehicle used is to put all assets in something called a trust. Do your research. With a trust you can move your assets around without other people knowing where they are invested. While the US laws applies to all citizens, a trust is not a citizen of the US so according to international laws there is nothing the US can do about it. If Eric has another citizenship, this becomes even easier.
- magicalist 6y ago> Citizenship is something that ought to be earned and given to people who show that they want to live in and contribute to a country. I mean, first, citizenship is made up. Many people have dual citizenship, and many countries will give you citizenship for ancestorship. And, of course, most countries offer citizenship to newborns who aren't contributing much and don't currently care about the country they're living in (and some countries, like the US, do so for babies born in the US to people who aren't citizens).
- lutorm 6y agoIs it really so different from the "EB-5" immigrant investor visa, which gives a citizenship path to foreigners who invest at least $1.8M in the US?
- sjg007 6y agoNope, but it's basically a faster path.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cblconfederate 6y agoI would love to be able to buy and sell citizenship. It would greatly incentivize governments to be responsible.
- kalonis 6y agoNo, it won't. It will incentivize governments to help rich people from all over the world avoid taxes.
- cblconfederate 6y agowhy? what s the use of having them as citizens if they won't pay taxes
- kalonis 6y agoThe sum they pay for the citizenship. Just look at some of the Caribbean islands. Selling citizenship can be quite lucrative.
- threatofrain 6y agoWhy ought citizenship be earned? A nation may structure it’s politics however it wishes...
- pembrook 6y agoThere are no tax benefits to be had for US citizens trying to hide money abroad post-FATCA. None. The US has the most draconian global tax system of any country in the world, and has the unique position of being able to actually enforce it due to the fact the USD is the reserve currency of the world and every country needs to stay on the good side of the US Treasury to transact in the global economy. In fact, the laws are so strict, they make living abroad as an honest middle-class expat a total nightmare. I have friends who cannot find a single bank in their country that will work with them because of the reporting requirements of working with US citizens. They cannot save in foreign banks and they cannot invest either due to the US penalizing foreign Mutual fund/ETF purchases by private citizens.
- alexashka 6y ago> Citizenship is something that ought to be earned and given to people who show that they want to live in and contribute to a country Says who? You? The beauty of people is we have different opinions. If Cyprus wants to sell their citizenship for a dollar each, that's their right. > People like Schmidt purchase themselves a... Yes, that's one of the motivating factors for being rich, is being able to purchase things afterwards. There's a child dying somewhere on this planet right now and here you are moralizing on HackerNews - people like you purchase themselves an internet connection and talk about blah blah, while a child is dying.
- dcolkitt 6y agoI guess it really comes down to how you conceptualize the nation-state. I think most people view a nation as a community, a body politic, maybe even an extended family. Buying citizenship is just as tawdry as paying for a mail-order bride. But I’m sorry. Me and many others see the nation state as a service provider. An institution that enforces the rule of law, furnishes protection from invaders and criminals, and provides large-scale public goods in exchange for some slice of tax revenue and a code of conduct. But if I’m unhappy with a service provider, then I should be free to change vendors to whomever meets my need. No different than the freedom to pay for a new phone plan or new gym membership. You complain that ordinary people don’t have the same consumer choice as the ultra-wealthy. If so, the focus should be on how to make the global market for nation-states more competitive for a wider range of consumers. I agree that many are locked into a shitty service provider. But if anything, the tiny slice of people who can exercise a choice almost certainly makes this market more, not less, competitive.
- zajio1am 6y ago> Buying one. Citizenship is something that ought to be earned and given to people who show that they want to live in and contribute to a country. Citizenship is just a legal relation between a person and a country. If both sides want that relationship, then it is perfectly moral to start such relationship.
- Nasrudith 6y agoYou don't get to decide that about citizenship - Cyprus does. There are consequences to whatever they decide but "ought" in itself is meaningless as an argument.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Citizenship is something that ought to be earned and given to people who show that they want to live in and contribute to a country. But, by buying the citizenship, they are not just showing in some vague indirect way that they "want to" contribute to the country, they are actually, directly, palpably contributing to the country. > People like Schmidt purchase themselves a tax excemption or freedom of movement in a world where ordinary people right now lose their jobs and are locked into their country. I'm confused, is your complaint that Schmidt hasn't done enough to "earn" citizenship, or that people that don't have less capacity to contribute should also enjoy what Schmidt does.