6 ms·
There’s a cognitive bias where if you tell a certain kind of person a negative story about an environmental issue they will believe it, regardless of its conten
by colechristensen 6y ago
There’s a cognitive bias where if you tell a certain kind of person a negative story about an environmental issue they will believe it, regardless of its content.
If you read the article, none of the quoted sources say anything about depleted soil. It says it in the title, that’s it. Bait.
What it actually says is plant breeding and other agricultural practices caused the nutritional decline. You breed plants for storage, transport, and yield, this is what you get. Large woody or watery plants that don’t taste as good and are diluted. Fruits picked unripe and enormous vegetables that stay fresh for weeks means less value.
It doesn’t seem to have much at all to do with the soil quality going down over decades and more to do with industrial food distribution.
- Ensorceled 6y agoYeah, that was my first thought. The food is tasteless and less nutritious because of the cultivars the farmer chose, not soil quality.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- UweSchmidt 6y agoOn the other hand many plants aren't even getting in contact with soil any more and just get some liquid fertilizer in a greenhouse. That's the other cognitive bias: We still imagine old school farming, animals walking around the farm, happy farmers working outside. Advertisement and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ag-gag https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ag-gag hide the grim reality.
- colechristensen 6y agoVery few food crops are grown in hydroponics, and when they are, it's quite likely they have higher nutrition content than their conventional commercial crop counterparts. As one of the generational old school farmers in exile, I'm quite aware of how food is produced. Most of it that you eat in unpleasant industrial settings but not the hydroponic greenhouses you imagine, and if not, in a way that exploits extremely poorly compensated labourers to do things machines haven't been perfected for yet.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> There’s a cognitive bias where if you tell a certain kind of person a negative story about an environmental issue they will believe it, regardless of its content. Having been an environmentalist and activist this is contrary to about 18 years of personal experience. If anything it seems to be a mental manipulation that rationalizes such a claim as it somehow seems to not affect them personally 'right now' that it must not be so bad. > If you read the article, none of the quoted sources say anything about depleted soil. It says it in the title, that’s it. Bait. I read it, and this was actually about par-for-the-course type of 'journalism' of what was being written at the time--I spent much of my time trying to understand the correlations between diet and maladies like cancer, diabetes, and heart disease and found very little that went in depth as their simply wasn't much published research on the topic. It was also written several months before I personally would dive head-long (I did a horticulture apprenticeship in Europe, and went back to the Culinary industry focused on Farm to table concepts) into the DEEP implications of how a broken food supply has damaged Society after having spent time in diagnostics and completed an undergad in biology. > It doesn’t seem to have much at all to do with the soil quality going down over decades and more to do with industrial food distribution. Actually it does, albeit very superficially, and its advocating for organic practices as a way to overcome that. Selective breeding and hybridization is nothing new in Agriculture, what is new is this broken International food supply that can only exist because its highly subsidized which in turn suffocates the smaller more resilient system. It was the former's catastrophic failure under the logistical stress of COVID that many people suddenly saw the value of such a model in masse as CSA memberships sold out in record numbers all over the US, as did meat-shares. All while major Ag corps and Food Corps had to let fields rot and had their animals culled. I only wrote this because in my my other tab I was reading this article [0] about the decrease in the average height of school children Worldwide due to poor nutrition in school meals--a system where much of the government subsidized, poor nutrient food ends up, at a large markup no less. As the increase in obesity along side it, which is in part a byproduct of processed and nutrient deficient food that messes up with the body's innate satiation feedback system. The study also coincidences with the take-over of many small farms by large Agra/Pharma corps (1980s) and the wide usage of things like glyphosate resistant plants as staples in processed food. I highly recommend the book 'Harvest of Rage' as it explores much of what had become of Rural America since that take-over and the political climate that has come from it--crystallized by how demagogues like Trump come into office and have the ability to radicalize such a significant amount of people in the process. 0: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/11/201105183840.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/11/201105183840.h...
- rjzzleep 6y agoThere is a stats podcast from the BBC that examines some of these stats. In one of the episodes they look at the Tomatos in the UK. In short while things changed in that particular instance the previous numbers of certain nutrients were actually problematic to other factors(Sorry I'd have to listen again to remember what exactly. I believe it was either energy/coal or war related, but don't quote me on that). However, some of the nutrients in the things we eat actually come from the bacteria in the soil, so it stands to reason that both the killing of the soils as well as breeding more sugar rich fruits in general may ultimately have adverse effects to our health. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3csz3ry https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3csz3ry
- thdrdt 6y agoIn the Netherlands we grow a lot of bell peppers on 'water'. Those sweet pepers are much larger than the ones grown on soal. But the only difference is the taste and the thickness of the skin. They might even be a little more healthy because they were grown in a lab like controlled environment. Imho the taste is a big trade-off, but growing them on water takes way less space and also makes a failed harvest less likely.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoI am often shocked by the tastelessness of food in the Netherlands -- in contrast to anywhere I have ever lived. But the future is promising, as there is so much room for optimization.
- amelius 6y agoPromising? The Netherlands is a large exporter of plant breeding technology.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoIt's also the #2 agricultural exporter in the world. (Though I believe this figure includes agrotech exports) https://dutchreview.com/news/innovation/second-largest-agriculture-exporter/ https://dutchreview.com/news/innovation/second-largest-agric...
- barrenko 6y agoI come from a rural "wasteland" in Croatia. The soil is very infertile to say the least. Yet, the same plants that survive there taste much much better locally then the "same" ones from presumably better controlled environment. The older I get, you could blindfold me, and I could tell you I'm in my home area just by smell alone. It's almost like it's perfumed. In the plant, you can taste the struggle.
- philliphaydon 6y agoI didn’t read the article. But I’ve always been under the assumption because of being told all my child hood that frozen veggies are healthier because they are snap frozen. They ripen, then get picked and cleaned and frozen. While “fresh” is picked early and ripens on its way to the store.
- kickout 6y agoThe alternative is not much better. If we didn't breed those plant for transportability and storage, then <1% would get to enjoy them. I agree its a problem, but its clearly what is working in the market. If someone has excellent tasting fruit but can't store or transport it, its a business opportunity (if they can pull it off at scale). Most of the time you can't, hence the popularity of gardening and eating 'in-season' produce