3 ms·
Deadlifts are great for people who have taken the time to study and implement proper form as well as work their way up from lower weights over time. However, I
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Deadlifts are great for people who have taken the time to study and implement proper form as well as work their way up from lower weights over time.
However, I’m not sure how we arrived at a situation where people are recommending deadlifts as the go-to exercise for people who want to maintain fitness. Experienced weightlifters and coaches generally won’t recommend that beginners focus on deadlifts, like you said.
We shouldn’t be making fitness sound so complicated or setting the bar so high. No one needs to be doing deadlifts to get into shape. Frankly, most sedentary people need to focus on small, achievable, and enjoyable fitness goals to start. Simply going for a 15-minute walk every day is a step in the right direction for beginners. Going to the gym is great if that’s your thing, but doing a handful of push-ups and stretches at home is also great for someone looking to get started.
The Internet has been great for disseminating fitness information and generating enthusiasm for exercise, but this trend of recommending advanced exercises and over the top workout programs like CrossFit to beginners has probably done just as much harm as good. We shouldn’t be making fitness sound like some
complicated, difficult goal.
- amelius 6y agoAlso, it might be harmful to make people believe they can completely offset working 8 hours a day at a desk without breaks by spending 1 hour at the gym. By medical standards you still have a sedentary lifestyle.
- jonfw 6y agoIf you spent an hour at the gym every work day you would be in phenomenal shape- I absolutely do not agree that this is a harmful idea.
- roel_v 6y ago"By medical standards you still have a sedentary lifestyle" Is it? Is 1h of strenuous exercise at a time and sittimg the rest of the day not better than getting up every hour and doing some simple stretches or just walking around? Not trying to be argumentative, I honestly don't know.
- jen729w 6y ago> Simply going for a 15-minute walk every day is a step in the right direction for beginners. It is that, but that’s all. I’ve realised lately that it really isn’t enough. Until earlier this year I was cycling about 15kms a day in the natural course of going to work, and climbing perhaps 30 flights of stairs a day in the natural course of living on the 3rd floor. Then I moved house, and I no longer do either. I do, however, still walk a decent amount on the flat. My phone says I average about 7km/day (near enough 10,000 steps). It’s not enough. It’s taken me a while to realise it, but I’m pretty sure that my current lower back issues are basically a result of stopping the cycling & stairs. I can’t prove it of course, but it makes a lot of sense. All of my glute/hamstring strength has just gone. Starting tomorrow I’m forcing myself to ride about 15kms a day (~5 days/week), with some sort of an incline in there. I’m lucky that I enjoy this; I was luckier when it just happened as part of my day without me thinking about it. Making myself do it is going to be a lot harder. I need to figure out a way to “science the shit out of it” so I can at least gain motivation from the fact that it works (assuming that it does).
- quickthrower2 6y agoI’m not sure how cycling will help your lower back? Might make you fitter and lose weight. Have you tried seeing a physio?
- sethammons 6y agoLots of lower back pain is actually hip issues. Stretching and strength exercises for the win.
- djeiasbsbo 6y agoAccording to my physiotherapist, cycling (really any movement) is great but does not necessarily help with back problems and in some cases even make it worse (probably depends on bike, saddle, position etc.). What's important is consistently moving. That means getting up from the desk every hour for a 5 minute walk or some stretching. Switching between standing and sitting at a desk is a first step in the right direction but really we need to be moving. This gets almost completely ignored at most desk jobs but now that many people can work from home, the opportunity to get into the right routine presents itself.
- renke1 6y agoI am playing Badminton/Squash two times a week, not sure if that's enough to offset sitting all day, but it sure is fun and there is no lack of motivation to do it every week. Unfortunately, the place is currently closed due to the Corona virus.
- mbeex 6y agoI do calisthenics, aka body-weight training. Not the crazy crossfit incarnation, instead classic ladders, intervals of pushups, pullups and some variations. Additionally a plank before bedtime and some hiking (~2000km/year) + deep squats to counteract sitting. Most important is to find something you can make into a lasting habit (for years). Otherwise you will end like most people with dieting do.