4 ms·
> First, we do detect a small number of voter fraud cases. People have gone to prison for it. Fair enough, though now I'm wondering why I keep hearing "no shre
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> First, we do detect a small number of voter fraud cases. People have gone to prison for it.
Fair enough, though now I'm wondering why I keep hearing "no shred of evidence of voter fraud" from so many people.
> But voter fraud, on the "retail" level, is heavily penalized and extremely unlikely to impact outcomes.
There are currently four states (AZ, GA, PA, WI) with less than 1% margin between the candidates. Georgia is at 0.2%. It wouldn't take a high percentage of fraud to flip a state.
But let's suppose that retail voter fraud is rare. How are we even detecting wholesale voter fraud? What's the method to detect when someone with access to the voter rolls slips an extra crate of ballots into the count, or fills out and mails in thousands of ballots in the names of people who never asked them to?
- tptacek 6y agoHalf a percentage of the AZ vote is over 16,000 votes. See why this crime doesn't make sense?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago16,000 votes is only a half a percentage of people in AZ committing voter fraud, and that's assuming they each only submit one fraudulent ballot. Apparently people have been caught submitting dozens of ballots in the names of people they didn't have any right to. If 0.02% of people did that, it flips the state. You can also make the "doesn't make sense" argument about voting itself, since exactly zero of the states will be decided by a single vote with extremely high probability, but lots of people still voted. It's not much of a stretch to expect that a fraction of people smaller than the lizardman constant are not doing a diligent cost benefit analysis.
- adjkant 6y ago> Apparently people have been caught submitting dozens of ballots in the names of people they didn't have any right to. You'd think there'd be evidence for that somewhere, but you're just parroting die-hard Trump supporter talking points now off Twitter with no evidence. It's very clear you are not talking about any of this with good faith.
- tptacek 6y agoWhat do you think a fraudulent ballot is? You can't just make a person up; there are voter rolls. Whatever means you find of coming up with a name and address that will be accepted as a vote, you have to do it (here, hypothetically) 16,000 times. If you use real people's names, which you have to because, again, voter rolls, many of them have already shown up to vote. The epollbook shows that on the screen, and you're standing there being asked for ID by a suspicious poll worker. Meanwhile, you would need thousands of coconspirators, and count on none of them ever leaking. You face the prison sentence to end all prison sentences (we put someone in prison in TX for years for casting an invalid vote accidentally) and, if you pull it off, you have... a chance? of altering the outcome if the election is very close? There's a reason this just doesn't happen, and it's because it doesn't make sense. As a prediction: America is not going to spend a lot of time and energy making you feel safer about it. My advice to you is, next cycle, sign up as a pollworker. It's so much more of a shitshow than you can possibly imagine, but I came away from it feeling paradoxically better about the process.
- matwood 6y agoIt's unfortunate that people will simply not listen to reason. You have gone above and beyond explaining the realities of mass voter fraud, but it goes against the outcome people are searching so they ignore you. You have more patience than I have. > It's so much more of a shitshow than you can possibly imagine, but I came away from it feeling paradoxically better about the process. This is the first time I really dug into the process, and I agree. I voted absentee, and that process plus what I saw on TV around the counting process made me much more confident in how things work.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The epollbook shows that on the screen, and you're standing there being asked for ID by a suspicious poll worker. Meanwhile, you would need thousands of coconspirators, and count on none of them ever leaking. You're talking about someone showing up at the polls to commit voter fraud in person, when the contention here is primarily about mail-in ballots. If someone has access to the voter rolls from the previous election, how do you detect if they've submitted mail-in ballots for people who were registered but didn't vote last time, on the theory that most of them still won't? Or who registers new people without their request and then submits ballots in their names? That entire process would be taking place outside of the polling location.
- alphabettsy 6y agoThere is no evidence of widespread voter fraud is what’s being said. It’s on the accusing party to provide that evidence and they haven’t. It also strikes me as strange that they’re targeting only the cities that they are. Detroit for example when it was actually Oakland and Kent Counties that most altered the outcome in Michigan for Trump. Election officials have many ways to audit elections for example knowing exactly who voted in an election how and where. To fill out and mail thousands of ballots you’d need to have them in the first place. Ballots are tracked from mailing to receipt and processing. How would you know who to pick so that there’s no conflict if they show up at the precinct to vote in person?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> It’s on the accusing party to provide that evidence and they haven’t. But that's what I'm saying. What measures can we put into place to allow them to do that if it's actually true, or rule it out if it isn't? I'm asking for a good way that someone could find evidence that someone else e.g. mailed in a large number of ballots fraudulently, and you're telling me that there is no evidence of that happening. Well yeah, that's the issue. What I want is a way to distinguish the case where there isn't evidence because it isn't happening from the case where there isn't evidence because we don't have a good system in place for detecting it. I want the ability to show conclusively that this isn't happening if it isn't happening, not just a lawyer's argument that absence of evidence is evidence of absence.
- adjkant 6y agoAnd until you have that, you're going to assuming the unlikely, unproven, and unprecedented side from a president literally known for lying and questioning the results of the past election baselessly, finding no evidence in 4 years of time to search and the DOJ at their disposal? You think the conspiracy is so widespread and perfect that there's no trail at all, not even to maybe 20% of the alleged fraud? C'mon now.
- tptacek 6y agoBefore you ask for people to help you preclude that anyone mailed in a large number of fraudulent ballots, I think it's fair to put to onus on you to describe how that actually could have happened. Start at step 1 and talk us through it: what does the "thousand ballot mail-in attack" look like? Bear in mind voters are registered with ID and proof of address into every state's voter rolls, states have records of when people die, and every election authority watches for duplicate votes; those are the table stakes mitigations you need to get past. Go ahead, I'm interested in hearing this out.
- pugworthy 6y agoKeep in mind there are two kinds of voter fraud: the ones that get caught (and never show up in vote data), and the ones that don't. There are always stories about the person dead for 10 years that gets a ballot that is maybe even turned in - but that vote isn't counted, precisely because it got caught.
- EricDeb 6y agoTrump also barely won MI, WI, and PA last time. No was nitpicking vote result curves at that time.. I'm sure they were equally as strange.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoYou were expecting Trump to question the results in states he won? An accusation of hypocrisy doesn't tell you which time they were wrong to do it.
- EricDeb 6y agoThey are wrong to do it because it convinces millions of uneducated Americans that it's all rigged and their vote doesn't matter. Here are investigators debunking most of the voter fraud allegations thus far. https://twitter.com/Ike_Saul/status/1324435797374808066 https://twitter.com/Ike_Saul/status/1324435797374808066 https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-fact-check-biden-vote-spikes-mi-wi/fact-check-biden-vote-spikes-and-county-recount-do-not-prove-democrats-are-trying-to-steal-the-election-in-michigan-and-wisconsin-idUSKBN27L2RL https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-fact-check-biden-vote-spi...
- gregmac 6y agoWhile I think you're arguing in bad faith, at least there's some interesting discussion in the replies. I think it's an interesting thought experiment to figure out how to do mass voter fraud though: > How are we even detecting wholesale voter fraud? What's the method to detect when someone with access to the voter rolls slips an extra crate of ballots into the count, or fills out and mails in thousands of ballots in the names of people who never asked them to? The mere act of bringing in a "create of ballots" is going to be incredibly tricky. You have to obtain the valid ballots somehow: steal them, get some printed, or print them yourself. If you print them, you have to perfectly replicate the design, type of paper, etc. Then you have to physically get the box into the building, into the right room, with the proper security seals or whatever is used. But let's pretend security is crazy lax, and/or several people are involved AND somehow not one of them is caught or a whistleblower. This is already a stretch -- as the number of people involved goes up, so do the chances one gets caught and/or one is a whistleblower. If we add the ballots without it adding up to the number of names crossed off the voter rolls list, that's going to be a giant red flag of voter fraud happening. Either this has happened and no one has noticed (one one has ever thought to check this?), or.. it hasn't happened. With access to the voter rolls we could inject names, but of course that leaves a paper trail. Thousands of names of people that don't exist or are deceased or are from the wrong place would appear and would have all voted. We could also figure out how many deceased people are on the list and have them vote, but this too leaves a paper trail. While there's some reporting of incidences of deceased people voting, it appears to mainly be clerical errors [1] and certainly doesn't appear to be at the scale of thousands needed to sway the vote, so likely this also hasn't happened. Casting any significant number of ballots for legitimate voters ahead of time would be likely to result in lots of people showing up to find out they've "already voted" and being turned away. Once again, this either has happened and thousands of people quietly walked away saying "oh well" and not going to the media.. or it hasn't happened. With access to the rolls, we could look up who didn't vote, and cast votes for them. We'd need to be able to cross out names after the polling has closed, then make sure our crate has a matching number of ballots to the people that didn't vote and physically get it in to the count room. And of course, this would show up in the type of analysis this article is doing: it would look exactly like the Russian election results at the start. This also doesn't appear to be the case, at least for 2016. All of this work would allow some fraction of voting fraud to happen at ONE polling station. If we pick the right station in the right district (where the security and scrutiny is likely to be higher) we could maybe even have a meaningful effect, but for all that work and risk (of jail time) there's no guarantees. We'd need to do it at multiple polling locations, but unfortunately most of the work involved doesn't really scale: we we just need more and more people involved in the conspiracy. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/08/tech/michigan-dead-voter-fact-debunking/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/08/tech/michigan-dead-voter-fact...