7 ms·
> With no shred evidence of voter fraud at any level I feel like this is actually the most suspicious thing here. In a country of over 300 million, in one of t
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> With no shred evidence of voter fraud at any level
I feel like this is actually the most suspicious thing here. In a country of over 300 million, in one of the most contentious elections in living memory, not one person was found to have committed voter fraud? It seems more likely that we're just terrible at detecting voter fraud rather than that there were literally zero instances of voter fraud anywhere.
Which implies we might need some better measures to detect it. The thing they were trying to do with dead voters is promising but has the obvious problem that there could have been legitimate ballots submitted, or unintentionally illegitimate ballots, if the death was recent etc. But the general idea seems to hold. Maybe we should add a few percent fictitious entries to the voter rolls and then see if any of them votes next time.
Anybody have any good ideas for how we could be detecting this, if it's happening?
If it isn't happening then having some measures in place like this would be good to point to as affirmative evidence that it isn't rather than merely the absence of evidence that it is. And if it is happening, it would be good to know that too.
- tptacek 6y agoFirst, we do detect a small number of voter fraud cases. People have gone to prison for it. But your premise is also broken. You assume we should see regular attempts at voter fraud, given our enormous sample size. But voter fraud, on the "retail" level, is heavily penalized and extremely unlikely to impact outcomes. There are all sorts of crimes that could occur, but don't, because there's no point.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> First, we do detect a small number of voter fraud cases. People have gone to prison for it. Fair enough, though now I'm wondering why I keep hearing "no shred of evidence of voter fraud" from so many people. > But voter fraud, on the "retail" level, is heavily penalized and extremely unlikely to impact outcomes. There are currently four states (AZ, GA, PA, WI) with less than 1% margin between the candidates. Georgia is at 0.2%. It wouldn't take a high percentage of fraud to flip a state. But let's suppose that retail voter fraud is rare. How are we even detecting wholesale voter fraud? What's the method to detect when someone with access to the voter rolls slips an extra crate of ballots into the count, or fills out and mails in thousands of ballots in the names of people who never asked them to?
- tptacek 6y agoHalf a percentage of the AZ vote is over 16,000 votes. See why this crime doesn't make sense?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago16,000 votes is only a half a percentage of people in AZ committing voter fraud, and that's assuming they each only submit one fraudulent ballot. Apparently people have been caught submitting dozens of ballots in the names of people they didn't have any right to. If 0.02% of people did that, it flips the state. You can also make the "doesn't make sense" argument about voting itself, since exactly zero of the states will be decided by a single vote with extremely high probability, but lots of people still voted. It's not much of a stretch to expect that a fraction of people smaller than the lizardman constant are not doing a diligent cost benefit analysis.
- adjkant 6y ago> Apparently people have been caught submitting dozens of ballots in the names of people they didn't have any right to. You'd think there'd be evidence for that somewhere, but you're just parroting die-hard Trump supporter talking points now off Twitter with no evidence. It's very clear you are not talking about any of this with good faith.
- tptacek 6y agoWhat do you think a fraudulent ballot is? You can't just make a person up; there are voter rolls. Whatever means you find of coming up with a name and address that will be accepted as a vote, you have to do it (here, hypothetically) 16,000 times. If you use real people's names, which you have to because, again, voter rolls, many of them have already shown up to vote. The epollbook shows that on the screen, and you're standing there being asked for ID by a suspicious poll worker. Meanwhile, you would need thousands of coconspirators, and count on none of them ever leaking. You face the prison sentence to end all prison sentences (we put someone in prison in TX for years for casting an invalid vote accidentally) and, if you pull it off, you have... a chance? of altering the outcome if the election is very close? There's a reason this just doesn't happen, and it's because it doesn't make sense. As a prediction: America is not going to spend a lot of time and energy making you feel safer about it. My advice to you is, next cycle, sign up as a pollworker. It's so much more of a shitshow than you can possibly imagine, but I came away from it feeling paradoxically better about the process.
- guscost 6y agoWell for example there are a more than a few definitely dead people who vote each election, that's pretty easy to show. But finding the, uh, living person who did the fraud is not always easy.
- tptacek 6y agoDead people will vote in every election that allows absentee ballots, because people die after they mail their ballot but before election day. Atomicity. It's a bitch. Every state has an electronic pollbook that tracks voter eligibility. Votes for dead people will arrive, but they should not as a rule be counted.
- guscost 6y agoThere are definitely a few dead people who register to vote after dying, and successfully vote, in every election too.
- piva00 6y agoHow many on average?
- guscost 6y agoNot many, surely. Perhaps even single digits.
- chaz72 6y agoThen you can definitely name one.
- guscost 6y agoThe funniest one I’ve heard so far is Joe Frazier. The birthday apparently matches, but this may have to wait to be confirmed in court: https://www.bigtrial.net/2020/11/smokin-joe-frazier-among-22-dead-people.html https://www.bigtrial.net/2020/11/smokin-joe-frazier-among-22...
- benmmurphy 6y agoIt is very easy but more costly than a recount to verify the integrity of an election. Auditing relies on the assumption that real voters can be linked to attestations and the aggregate of attestations can be linked to the aggregate of votes. In Australia when you vote in person your named is checked off on the electoral roll. This is an attestations. When you submit an absentee ballot you also fill out a form. This is an attestation as well. The audit does a full recount of attestations and votes and verifies the totals are the same. Duplicate checking is also performed on attestations. Furthermore, the attestations are randomly sampled and the real voters are interviewed to check if they actually voted. In the case of absentee ballots the details on the form can be checked as well. The random sample is performed so you have an ‘acceptable’ level of fraud and then you sample enough ballots such that if you were higher than the acceptable level it would be likely to sample a fraudulent ballot. This process breaks down a bit at this point because of the issue of false positives where the voter cannot be contacted. However, with more work from the auditor it is often possible to distinguish between the voter being uncontactable and voting and the voter not existing, or being uncontactable and not voting. Because the audit process establishes a trail from real voters to real ballots it is very difficult to commit electoral fraud. There are some forms of electoral fraud this audit will not detect like bribery and coercion. It also doesn’t prevent substitution attacks where someone destroys real ballots and replaces them with dodgy ones.
- moduspol 6y agoIt might be tougher in my state because we allowed ballots that were received by mail on Election Day, but without a postmark. One of the accusations of voter fraud includes backdating the postmarks on some number of ballots so they would be counted. Obviously postmarks weren't created or intended to be cryptographic verification of when something was received anyway.
- moduspol 6y agoI'm absolutely willing to accept that very few people are (e.g.) voting twice in different states, filling out ballots mistakenly sent to their address, and similar small-scale stuff. But I do share your skepticism that when the stakes are this high, nobody's trying to meaningfully affect this. Especially this year when anyone could have told you the election will come down to the same small number of states waiting for days to count ballots in a small number of precincts. We know how well the TSA does because we actually try to send people through with weapons to see how often they get caught. In 2015, the answer is that 95% of weapons get through. I think we need the same kind of thing for elections. How tough is it to get / remove a few boxes of ballots overnight from wherever they're stored prior to being counted? When you do, is that immediately detected and reported, or is it presumed to be a mistake and just accepted? How many people does it take? [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/investigation-breaches-us-airports-allowed-weapons-through-n367851 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/investigation-breaches-...
- matwood 6y ago> But I do share your skepticism that when the stakes are this high, nobody's trying to meaningfully affect this. Thing is, it's much easier to impact the result legally through voter suppression. https://www.bbc.com/news/election-us-2020-54380684 https://www.bbc.com/news/election-us-2020-54380684 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-locations/southern-u-s-states-have-closed-1200-polling-places-in-recent-years-rights-group-idUSKCN1VV09J https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-locations/so...
- moduspol 6y agoThat's a separate conversation, though. I agree reducing poll locations can make some people less likely to vote, but it's not in the same category as fraud.
- matwood 6y agoTo commit fraud at the level required though just isn't plausible in a national election. Even in a close state like PA, we're going to end up talking about 45k+ votes. In MI, 100k+ votes, WI 20k+ votes, etc... All these states have mixes of R/Ds running things, and any fraud claims quickly ends up in grand conspiracy fallacy territory. This is not some 1000 vote situation like FL in 2000 (which was actually much more complicated than everyone paints it out to be).